11 ms·
To Lose Weight, Eating Less Is Far More Important Than Exercising More
- smcl 11y agoThis is one of the main themes of the documentary Fed Up - the food & beverage industry have sold us a lie about the US obesity crisis (people are obese because they don't exercise enough) - while downplaying their involvement (hiding\obfuscating sugar in the nutrition information of "healthy" options, lobbying to have Pizza classified as a "vegetable" portion in school meals, etc). It's worth checking out: http://fedupmovie.com/ http://fedupmovie.com/
- venomsnake 11y agoIsn't it obvious - you BMR is 2-3 times higher than your all other energy expenditures for the day. If you overeat nothing can save you ...
- vacri 11y agoA lot of people don't know that you base metabolic rate consumes a ton of energy. One prof told me that exercising merely doubled your energy requirements during the exercise - half for the BMR, half for the exercise. Taken in that light, exercise for an hour a day didn't do much to change your energy consumption overall. The numbers may be off, but the concept is there - it takes energy to maintain the billions of cells that make up your body. Even if they're 'doing nothing', they still live and excrete, for example.
- pizza234 11y agoIt's not obvious, actually; exercise also affects the BMR, as a matter of fact, according to some theories, certain types of exercise increase the BMR more than certain others (I don't express any support for this, just pointing out). Although we're not talking about huge amounts, when having a precise dieting regime, even a few hundred calories of "good weight loss" matter. Definitely nothing can save one from overeating, but that's why overeating itself it's a completely different matter. To wrap up, while of course in this field little or nothing is definitely proven, definitely no, this is not obvious :-)
- venomsnake 11y agoThe increase is 10% or so IIRC. So still not that significant. In our modern life most of the energy spent is to keep you alive. And you have upper limit on your BMR - you have to maintain a steady temp. We just cannot dissipate much more than currently before cooking ourselves medium rare.
- roel_v 11y ago"It's not obvious, actually" Yes it is. Changes in metabolism are a second-order effect, at most. There is only one first-order effect: fat = calories in - calories out. Once that equation is OK, one can go look at all the other factors - BMR, how macros are split, genetics, ...
- WildUtah 11y ago"you [sic] BMR[0] is 2-3 times higher than your all other energy expenditures" Maybe if you work sitting in an office and never go play outside or lift weights. Try lifting bricks or digging ditches or cutting wood all day and that BMR is just the beginning. Or climb a nice mountain or go on a hard bike ride or get nice and ripped and keep those muscles up. In the evolutionary environment where you were shaped everybody worked outdoors and sweated. If your BMR is most of your energy expenditure, you're not living the life you're adapted to. [0] Basal metabolic rate -- the energy you'd expend on the couch watching teevee all day.
- Robin_Message 11y ago<sarcasm>Yeah, I tried cutting trees down all day but then I got fired from my job as a software developer. I suggested that maybe we could turn the wood into paper to print the documentation on, but the documentation is all online, so they wouldn't give me a job. Then I climbed a mountain but there was no wifi up there so I missed my 3PM Skype interview for a new role. On the plus side, now the only job I can get is ditch-digger I am feeling much healthier.</sarcasm> People living standard western lives don't have a lot of time for exercise, so diet is going to have a much bigger impact on their calorific balance. That's the whole point of TFA. It would be great if we all had a better life-work balance and could climb more mountains, but that doesn't mean people can apply that advice to their lives right now. They can start doing some fork putdowns and head shakes.
- sdrothrock 11y agoThe phrase I always hear is that "abs are made in the kitchen." Edit: Or the variation: "Abs are made in the gym, revealed in the kitchen," which I always thought sounded kind of gruesome if you take it literally.
- peteretep 11y ago"Can't outrun a fork"
- rockdoe 11y ago"The best exercises for your abs are fork putdowns and head shakes"
- vidarh 11y agoAbs particularly because abs don't get very big no matter what you do, and so for most people abs won't really be very visible unless you dip below 10% body fat. No amount of crunches etc. will work around that. For larger muscle groups the body fat percentage matters much less.
- joelrunyon 11y agoStill amazed that people are still considering this a pure caloric issue and not a food quality issue. When you look at how various hormones (namely insulin) are affected by blood sugar & affect body composition, it seems you'd want to promote a method that bears that in mind. That said, I think the focus should be on "eating better" not just "eating less."
- huehue 11y agoOver eating on high quality bacon won't stop you from being a lard-ass.
- paulojreis 11y agoHe mentioned "eating better". Eating "high quality bacon" isn't eating better.
- lubonay 11y agoHey, it's better compared to low quality bacon.
- paulojreis 11y agoI won't disagree with that - if I'm making wrong nutritional choices, let them be as tasty as possible!
- astrange 11y agoNothing wrong with bacon, fine source of macro calories. Maybe it's a little high in sodium.
- Stately 11y agoHave you tried that though? I'd say the reason why people associate bacon with being fat is because people that overeat bacon tend to overeat junk food, sugary snacks, industrial bakery and drink litres of sodas. Truth is though, that over the last few years more and more studies are disproving[0] the connection of saturated fat with obesity and heart disease. [0] - http://www.independent.co.uk/life-style/health-and-families/features/the-science-of-saturated-fat-a-big-fat-surprise-about-nutrition-9692121.html http://www.independent.co.uk/life-style/health-and-families/...
- atemerev 11y agoThis is obvious for anyone who tried both approaches and compared efforts/results ratio.
- rockdoe 11y agoOr just counted calories...
- mhd 11y agoThe problem here seems that discussions about this are sooo littered with personal biases. "Bro science" is just one aspect of this, far more common is expecting that one's personal achievement is universally reproducible. Yes, person A may eat all the burgers and twinkies, because he's going to the gym all the time and swimming laps like there's no tomorrow. But as a general rule to combat obesity, that's probably not the way to go (we often get the same personal non-exceptionalism in economic debates). So I hope we'll have less "But it worked for me!" in this thread and more thought about something a bit more universal and averaged out.
- learnstats2 11y ago> Yes, person A may eat all the burgers and twinkies, because he's going to the gym all the time One major problem with the standard BMI definitions is that any athlete in a sport that vaguely requires muscles will be classed as 'overweight' or 'obese'. Although there may be some justification for this categorisation, these are people we normally consider at the peak of fitness. One of the best things you can do for long-term health outcomes is to follow a strength training programme. For an average person, that may result in weight gain via muscle. This is not a bad thing.
- johnchristopher 11y ago> > > Yes, person A may eat all the burgers and twinkies, because he's going to the gym all the time > One major problem with the standard BMI definitions is that any athlete in a sport that vaguely requires muscles will be classed as 'overweight' or 'obese'. Oh, what a major problem it is for the vast majority of overweight people changing their diet and lifestyle. This really is the most important point they have to keep in mind: BMI don't apply to athletes who regularly train and practice. What a bummer. /s
- learnstats2 11y agoYou seem to have misunderstood my point. The general rule that muscle strength is positive for health applies to non-athletes just as well.
- mullingitover 11y agoI found it ridiculously easy to lose weight by eliminating refined sugar and alcohol from my diet. 'Don't drink calories' is a great rule of thumb, sugared beverages are a plague on society. Keep your sweet tooth happy by eating fresh fruit--I don't think it's even possible to get or stay fat if your main sugar source is fruit.
- empressplay 11y ago_especially_ alcohol -- there's huge calories in booze. It also promotes being sedentary, and also over-eating if you drink with dinner.
- joss82 11y agoIt's a bit oversimplified, because exercising increase your burn rate (your basal metabolic rate), even when you don't exercice. But anyway: eat food, not too much, mostly plants ;)
- snez 11y agoDid you not know that you can't outrun your mouth?
- lubonay 11y agoIt seems like the article downplays the role of exercise - maybe I'm nitpicking, but how is this a valid argument: "Over a six-month period, though, adding exercise made no difference." I mean who wants to lose weight over six months only to be more likely for them to gain it back? Also, looking at weight alone is misleading. All other factors being equal, a person burning 2500 kcal per day and consuming 2000 would be worse off than if they burn 3000 kcal and consume 2500. The latter case leads to better body composition (as in the ratio of body weight to fat) and better athletic qualities like strength and endurance. People doing regular exercise also report being more energetic than their sluggish 0-cals-per-day counterparts. On top of that, prolonged dieting regardless of exercise may lead to depression and moving around tends to alleviate that. Source: My Ph.D. in Broscience and Anecdotal Evidence :P
- roel_v 11y ago"All other factors being equal, a person burning 2500 kcal per day and consuming 2000 would be worse off than if they burn 3000 kcal and consume 2500." I have tried every possible generous interpretation of this that I can think of, but I just have to ask I guess: what's the idea behind this?
- lubonay 11y agoRegarding the 2500 vs 3000 kcal thing: move around, lift weights, knock uglies with your partner multiple times per day, do whatever floats your boat in order to increase your BMR by 500 kcal per day. Regarding the "worse off" part: I assume having less strength and endurance is worse for the average Joe compared to having more strength and endurance. Sorry that it wasn't clear in my post, I guess I assumed it was self-explanatory.
- roel_v 11y agoBut then all other factors aren't equal. I.e., person P with x% muscle and y% fat; eats 2500 and burns 2000; or that same person eating 3000 and burning 2500.
- joelrunyon 11y ago
- kfk 11y agoYeah, that is true, but I hold that being overweight and exercising (real exercise, not the fake gym training programs) is far better for your health and your well being overall. At least you keep a functional body - you can do long walks, runs, climbing, etc. - which is a much better life if you ask me, but that's only my opinion, I repeat, only an opinion. Edit. Just to be clear, of course being slim and exercising is a better option. I am just saying that for health I would prioritize exercise over weight.
- dylanjermiah 11y ago>but I hold that being overweight and exercising How is being overweight 'far better' for health or well being? (assuming you're talking about excess adipose tissue). Please define 'function' and how excess adipose increases ones ability to walk, run and climb.
- kfk 11y agoI have seen plenty of overweight people back in Italy that were able to do tough 10 hrs hikes or caving explorations with heavy loads or else. They looked far more healthy to me than slim people that do no exercise. I am just very skeptic of using weight as a measure of health or even as a universal goal. That said, being very overweight is a problem and being slim and doing exercise is a better option.
- dylanjermiah 11y ago>I have seen plenty of overweight people back in Italy that were able to do tough 10 hrs hikes or caving explorations with heavy loads or else. They looked far more healthy to me than slim people that do no exercise. What do you define as 'overweight'? How did they 'look far more healthy' than slim people? >I am just very skeptic of using weight as a measure of health or even as a universal goal. That said, being very overweight is a problem and being slim and doing exercise is a better option. It's not weight per se it's excess adipose tissue. Any where past 20% for males and 30% BF for females will generally decrease performance to a significant extent.
- farresito 11y agoAnd eating better is far more important than eating less.
- brohoolio 11y agoIt's tough to lose weight. I've had success lowering my calorie intake. I find that only implementing one change at a time conserves my willpower so that I'm more likely to succeed. I'll either up my exercise a couple weeks before I start cutting the calories or cut calories then wait a few weeks before introducing exercise. Controlling what I eat, for me at least, is easier than upping my exercise levels.
- haydenhall 11y agoFor myself at least its always been quite simple... If you want to lose weight and be healthy - eat little and eat healthy. If you want to lose weight and don't care too much for your health - eat little. If you want to be healthy - eat healthy. If you just don't care - eat whatever you like.
- kittiepryde 11y agoI was simplifying of it as: Calories --> Weight Food quality & exercise --> health
- dspillett 11y agoThat works in my head too, though I'd always add the caveat that you need both and should endeavour not to sacrifice one (even temporarily) in order to improve the other. Along that path (particularly compromising the health side in a pursuit of dramatic weight loss) fad diets and the like lie, and those things rarely work long term.
- dspillett 11y agoThat works in my head too, though I'd always add the caveat that you need both and should endeavour not to sacrifice one (even temporarily) in order to improve the other. Along that path (particularly compromising the health side in a pursuit of dramatic weight loss) fad diets and the like lie, and those things rarely work long term. One important factor that I've noticed (warning: anecdotal evidence approaching, be prepared to engage critical thinking) is that while exercise increases my appetite it doesn't seem to increase it as much as the extra I'm burning off. The difference isn't large but it is noticeable when watching closely and it seems to be relatively consistent: yes my body wants me to eat more when I exercise more, but it seems content with getting less extra in than the extra it has put out so if I just listened to my hunger I'd still slowly lose weight. This doesn't seem to be the case in periods when I do little or no exercise beyond my daily routine (walking to/from work and such) - I don't stop feeling hungry before I've eaten the right amount to stay at a stable weight.
- agounaris 11y agoAs always, balance is the key!
- MrBuddyCasino 11y agoThis is true, but: when I exercise regularly, I find that I am less hungry and eat less. Anyone here made the same experience?
- daemonfire300 11y agoFor me it's quite the opposite. I do alot of exercise, and I am generally more hungry / in need of calories in comparison to a week when I did not so much excersise.
- jhh 11y agoIf I know I'll go for a run I am very hesistant to eat heavily, as I know I'll regret it. The more you exercise the more you push back heavy/unproductive meals in your schedule. You just know if you eat wrongly you won't be able to keep up with your own pace of execise. Eating and execise seem deeply connected to me. Certainly it is hard to put this kind of thinking into a controlled randomized trial.
- maknz 11y agoSo much this. If you include regular exercise you're way more motivated not to over-eat, you simply don't want to spoil the hard work you did since it's so easy to consume 500 cal but so much harder (relatively) to burn 500 cal. Combining both has certainly been effective for me.
- weavie 11y agoAfter a heavy weights session I am ravenous. It's not unknown for me to just give in and eat a whole tub of icecream before my proper post workout meal.
- curiousDog 11y agoSo true. I've found that Intermittent fasting + a 500cal deficit (below TDEE) is the easiest/most-effective way because it fits into my life-style as a programmer. I eat my last meal at 8PM and go to bed at 1-2AM. So not eating anything until 1PM the next day is a breeze (with a couple of cups of coffee in the morning). I've lost 20 pounds over the last 3 months with zero exercise.
- collyw 11y agoI like intermittent fasting, but I am already skinny, and I struggle to keep my weight up, despite having chocolate and crap beside me at work on my non fast days.
- jrapdx3 11y agoAfter years in the practice of obesity medicine, helping people lose excess weight, I'd say the thrust of the article is correct. The main key to successful (that is, sustained) weight loss is modifying food intake. Not for nothing do we call this "lifestyle modification", we should never underestimate the effort and courage it takes to adhere to the better plan. Thing is one can never exercise enough to "burn off" the tremendous calorie intake most people are subject to. After all around 75-80% of energy expenditure occurs in the resting state, only 20-25% is ordinarily attributable to physical activity. However I fully agree with the article that exercise is far from useless, certainly can contribute to well-being and has many indirect benefits that assist in long-term maintenance of decreased body fat content. Of course none of this is really new, it's been established wisdom in obesity treatment circles for a long time. "Getting in shape" is hardly a trivial project as it requires commitment, determination, knowledge and support. Maintaining the benefit of hard won weight loss is not free, the price is eternal vigilance.
- dylanjermiah 11y ago>the practice of obesity medicine Curious, what does that entail?
- jrapdx3 11y agoAmong other terms for it are "medical weight management" and "bariatric medicine". The idea is prescribing appropriate nutritional programs, behavioral approaches, and yes, exercise to assist people to reduce excess body fat content. Where indicated, medications can be prescribed to reduce appetite and satiety, perhaps increase metabolism in some instances. Probably obvious, but there are many other aspects to treatment of obesity, not the least of which is addressing other health conditions that contribute to excess adiposity. There is substantial medical/science literature on all these topics, really not too hard to find using search engines of choice.
- FranOntanaya 11y agoExercise and the lowered depression levels may be a good trigger for lowering the amount of confort food eaten and increasing diet discipline. The lower calorie intake still gets the credit, but many people may never get there without the exercise first.
- Htsthbjig 11y agoTo lose weight EATING WELL is the most important thing. For me it is shocking to watch the calories argument, and almost saying that you have to starve in order to lose weight. 40 years ago Americans, or most Europeans did not starve, and being overweight was rare. They ate lots of fat, for example with consumption of butter(calories) three times what it is today. Traveling around the world I see people that eat well(I have eaten their food) and nobody is fat there. They cook their food though. People in the Western world eat very badly. Most of their food is precooked, frozen and stored in plastic. That alone removes lots of necessary components of food, like vitamins or fiber, or degrade it making them not usable by the body. So when the body needs essential components, and could not get it the normal way, it enters panic mode and craves for more food. One of the most overweight people I have seen in my life were native Americans Indians in reserves and in Alaska or native people from Hawaii. They are so poor and eat so badly no matter how much they eat their body never says enough. People in Hawaii were known for being slender before colonization. There are natural limitations on industrial food, and we are paying for it. Industry instead of solving he problems(which is hard) has tricked be body into believing the food is totally ok, with things like artificial flavoring.
- gitaarik 11y agoNobody says you need to be hungry to keep a healthy weight, but if you are overweight, and you want to lose that weight, there's no way around being hungry sometimes. You know why? Your fat cells only start giving off their fat to the blood when your blood sugar level is too low, and when that happens, your brain gets a signal you should eat, thus you're hungry.
- TheAceOfHearts 11y agoI lost 40lb, and the only exercise I do is walking / running occasionally around my apartment complex. My trick? I slowly reduced the size of my portions and I limited myself to eating only when I felt hungry. I didn't do any sort of strict calorie counting, I just tried to have a rough idea of how much food I was eating. Seriously. That's it. If you eat fewer calories, you will lose weight. It's that simple. At no point did I starve myself or force myself to undergo harsh dietary conditions. Here's the thing, I think a lot of people fail to lose weight because they try doing too many drastic changes all at once. This is REALLY difficult! But if you just do it really slowly... You don't even notice the change. Sure, the downside is that you won't see super fast changes, it'll take longer to manifest itself. On the other hand, this is probably the easiest possible way to lose weight, because it requires very little effort on your part (you just have to have enough self control to not stuff your face every day). Just serve yourself a smaller portions than you'd normally consume, eat it, and wait a few minutes. Then if you still felt hungry, go get some more. Otherwise, you've had enough and you're satisfied. At the beginning of this year I read an article that made me realize something. The article basically said "If you're fat, it means that you're eating like a fat person. You are a fat person." Maybe it seem stupid... But it's correct. If you're fat, it means that you have the eating habits and lifestyle of a fat person. Ask yourself, is that who you really want to be? For me the answer was "no". You can even cheat with your portions! Every time I go to a ramen shop I disregard all limits and just eat to my heart's content. Although doubtless it won't work very well if you do that every day.
- glandium 11y agoSomething related is that a lot of people are eating too quickly. I am guilty of this. And that doesn't leave time to the brain to get the satiety signals, leading to eat more than necessary. Eating more slowly can end up helping reduce portions. It's a difficult habit to overcome, though.
- glandium 11y ago"Far too many people, though, can manage to find an hour or more in their day to drive to the gym, exercise and then clean up afterward — but complain that there’s just no time to cook or prepare a healthful, home-cooked meal. If they would spend just half the time they do exercising trying to make a difference in the kitchen, they’d most likely see much better results." This. From my anecdotal evidence, weight loss is largely a commitment issue. So when you spend as much time going to the gym and back as you spend exercising there, motivation to continue the effort can disappear despite the reward. So it's just best to find your own right balance between (what kind of/how much) effort and reward.
- peteretep 11y ago> weight loss is largely a commitment issue Yes, but it's a "commitment issue" in the same class as "stopping drinking", "stopping smoking", and "getting out of debt" for a lot of people; there's a very large mental/compulsive/dependency component.
- moomin 11y agoTo the extent that scientists who've studied it reckon that only 5% of the population are _capable_ of keeping weight down long term through diet.
- antirez 11y agoEverybody in the fitness circles (see Reddit Fitness) knows this. It's just that normally doctors, TV & company misadvice you, telling something like "walk more, be more active" when the task at hand is to lose weight. Actually the exercise suggestion should be: do some strength training while seriously dieting in order to retain muscles. A 30 minutes run will burn ~400 calories. The same amount of calories can be eaten in 10 seconds. Do your math.
- gd1 11y agoYou do your math. Exercise isn't just about how many calories you burn during it. Add a kilo of muscle and it will be burning energy 24 hours a day, 365 days a year.
- empressplay 11y agoThis. Someone who is out of shape will typically have a slower metabolism than someone who is in shape. Also, in defensive situations the out-of-shape person's body can rely more on adrenaline-based fight-or-flight mechanisms potentially leading to anxiety, which can then encourage comfort-eating and lead to cyclic weight-gain. Once again, everyone wants to boil complex, intricate body and mind mechanisms down to "do this, don't do that." It's absurd. These are sophisticated systems full of roll-on cause and effect, tolerances, etc. not a toaster.
- Erwin 11y agoYou urged to do your math, but didn't present any of yours. Muscle burns an inconsequential amount of energy -- 6-10 per pound depending on sources. So if you were somehow to gain 10 pounds of pure muscle, you'd have enough calories for a small apple per day (60 cal). How fast can you gain 10 pounds of muscle? In an 18-week weight training programme, a group of men gained 4.6 pounds of muscle: http://jap.physiology.org/content/82/1/298 http://jap.physiology.org/content/82/1/298 -- most of the gain in 8 weeks. So I would imagine increasing your lean mass by 10 pounds (just to be able to eat an extra apple a day) would be quite an effort. One study: http://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pmc/articles/PMC3139779/ http://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pmc/articles/PMC3139779/ So considering SOLELY weight loss, ignoring calory deficits from diet changes and focusing on building up muscle mass does not seem effective. Instead of building up muscle mass for a 60Cal deficit via BMR increase, take a 600 Cal deficit via diet and lose the weight in 1/10th the time.
- vilmosi 11y agoWhat a load of rubbish. First of all, losing weight is not the goal itself, it's one of the means to the real goal, which is to be healthy. It's not about eating less, it's about eating healthy. Exercise is absolutely essential to be healthy, regardless of weight. Exercise is more important that eating less. What a dumb suggestion.
- gitaarik 11y agoBut it doesn't mean that when you're healthy your automatically not overweight. You can be pretty healthy having a lot of fat. The point is that in the past you gained the fat by eating too much, so if you want to lose that, you should eat too less.
- vilmosi 11y agoWho cares about overweight? It's about being healthy, but people forgot that. A lot of people from the gym are classified as overweight, with fat or not, but they are healthy as a horse and look good as well. This concern about losing weight has gone way too far.
- romanovcode 11y agoEvery person has its own goals.
- tjogin 11y agoBeing overweight is unhealthy, it can't be done in a healthy way; not in the long term. While it is possible for an overweight person to not have any of the common health problems associated with being overweight, that is temporary. If you are overweight, you will develop those health problems, it's just a matter of time. It's basically like smoking and cancer; not all smokers have cancer or get cancer, but there is no such thing as smoking in a healthy way, and if you do it, then the best way to get healthier and to prevent developing health problems in the future is to stop doing it. Some people can be overweight without developing health problems for a long time, even for a decade or two, but it's just a matter of time. Reducing your bodyweight is easily the best way to improve your health, and to make sure you don't develop health problems in the future. And, vice versa, many of the things we associate with bad health don't become health problems at all for people who stay lean. Food that we know to have strong correlations with bad health, like eating red meat, sodium, cholesterol, etc, are only really problematic if you also over eat. Exercise is great, it's terrific, but not over eating is much more important. The saying is true, "you can't outrun a bad diet".
- gadders 11y agoI think focussing on "weight loss" is the incorrect metric. They would be better off using "body fat %". It is possible to gain weight, and yet become more healthy. In addition, the metric most often used to work out whether are people are overweight, the BMI, is hopelessly inaccurate.
- deleted 11y ago[deleted]
- agentPrefect 11y agoI'm absolutely floored to see comments here still nit-picking at FOOD QUALITY vs FOOD QUANTITY vs WHAT DEFINES EXERCISE vs ETC. Whilst I fully enjoy reading some of the opinions on SOD, the myriad of needless front-end frameworks, etc. - this really is not subjective at all. Calories in, calories out. You eat 5000cal of the most nutritious, well balanced meal & run 10km - you will still put on weight (given you're not a giant). I'm not sure how this is so open to interpretation, it's rudimentary science at best.
- peteretep 11y agoDifferent foods cause different levels of satiation. Knowing that eating less will make you lose weight is not the same thing as overcoming feelings of hunger to actually eat less in practice.
- agentPrefect 11y agoAbsolutely agree with you, but that is an entirely different discussion. A good use case for the quality vs. quantity issue would be bodybuilders. Throughout a bulking cycle they make (or ... they should make) a concerted effort to do a "clean bulk" - which is healthy, good food. Ask any bodybuilder how difficult that is - which is exactly what you're saying. It's difficult because the food makes them full, satiated, etc. BUT - they still bulk. They still put on the excess weight regardless of how clean they eat. Calories in, calories out.
- peteretep 11y ago> that is an entirely different discussion Surely it's a deeply related one. > Throughout a bulking cycle they make (or ... they should > make) a concerted effort to do a "clean bulk" - which is > healthy, good food For better or worse, most of the ones I know eat any old shit. Turns out supplemental testosterone is one helluva drug.
- pjc50 11y agoAt time of writing, this is RIGHT NEXT to a comment saying "Still amazed that people are still considering this a pure caloric issue and not a food quality issue."
- jensen123 11y agoI'm currently reading an interesting book - Food and Western Disease by Staffan Lindeberg. Among other things, it talks about how gluten might interfere with leptin (the hormone that makes us feel full). I don't think this has been proven 100% yet, but I've noticed that there seems to be far more fat people in the countries that eat lots of wheat, than in the countries that rely on rice.
- henrixd 11y agoMetabolism gets used to aerobic exercise quickly so it is not good for loosing fat. High intensity training (HIT) burns more fat overall. Timing on carbohydrates is important also. Eat them when you need them like around exercise, before work or in the morning. After your glucose storage is full extra energy will be stored as fat. How well fat will burn depends mostly how good shape your metabolism is. If your metabolism is slow when you start dieting it will only get slower and you really have to starve yourself to lose weight. Slowly increasing carbohydrates when not loosing weight and exercise is good way to speed up your metabolism so you are able to loose that fat after you gain some. Cardio exercises are last resort at the end of the diet when your metabolism is really slow and you want to eat something. So while eat less than you use is good starting point to loose weight. You can make it so much easier to your self with exercise and proper food.
- moomin 11y agoThe fundamental problem with the research he's quoting is that "long-term" means a year to him. Actual long-term, diets never ever ever work. http://www.washingtonpost.com/blogs/wonkblog/wp/2015/05/04/why-diets-dont-actually-work-according-to-a-researcher-who-has-studied-them-for-decades/ http://www.washingtonpost.com/blogs/wonkblog/wp/2015/05/04/w...
- franciscop 11y ago"statistically significant". I ak spoiled for life since reading https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=9714985 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=9714985
- KaiserPro 11y agoThere really isn't that much science to it. On paper its really really simple. To loose weight, you must expend more energy than you absorb. However, conversely to get fit, you will need to eat a balanced diet, with enough calories to replace damaged muscles. However on the weight loss front here are the golden rules: Some people exercise (exercise expends energy) Some people reduce energy consumption (eat less, or eat less calorific food) Some people combine both. There are no other options. Seriously, if you are on a diet and you are not loosing weight, its not because you are unlucky, its because you are still absorbing more energy than you are expending. Exercise more, or eat less. There is some evidence that efficiency can be altered by eating patterns, however that's not enough to over come eating an extra 300calories a day. Everything else, is literally junk science. The 4:2 only works if on arrogate you consume less calories. Atkins only works if you can't absorb the extra energy you have in fat and protein. Etc, etc, etc. This part is the easy part. Weight in 90% of cases is a symptom of one's environment. Changing environment is devilishly difficult.
- NLips 11y agoAssuming that by "4:2" you are talking about intermittent fasting, does anyone believe otherwise? Alternate-day fasting can help people lose weight not because there's any magical effect, but because a faster is unlikely to double their calorie intake the day after fasting - having fast days is just a simple/easy way to reduce overall calorie intake. Besides, the main benefits of alternate-day fasting are meant to be health related, not explicitly weight-loss. Is it a main-stream weight-loss method?
- Sammi 11y agoIntermittent fasting combined with weightlifting means you are more likely to loose fat and not muscles while fasting. The weightlifting will tell the body that the muscles are needed and it will then have less of a tendency to metabolize them for energy. Also muscles burn energy while you are sitting on your sofa. Increasing your muscles mass by weightlifting means you will burn more energy all the time. I think weightlifting is strongly overlooked for weight loss and especially for loosing fat when combined with intermittent fasting.
- richardboegli 11y agoJust eat less. It is just that simple. <SHAMELESS SELF PROMOTION> My Weight Loss Story 40kg in 40 Weeks Without Exercise where I went from 120kg to 80kg (79.6kg) / 265lb to 175lb. http://40in40book.com/ http://40in40book.com/ This book was born out of the constant positive feedback and requests I received that my story needed to be shared with a wider audience. </SHAMELESS SELF PROMOTION> EDIT 1: I wanted to do this as a Show HN when I published, but I've been a longtime lurker without commenting and without an account with my real name. EDIT 2: I've read the article and the points raised are the same as what I noted when I lost my weight. Exercise can help, but you can lose the weight with diet alone.
- deleted 11y ago[deleted]
- spacko 11y agoJust watching documentation on people in none-1st-world-countries or even on wildlife animals clearly shows that we are eating wayyyyyyyyyyyy to much for the energy we are losing - that's one reason why I got into intermittent fasting (8/16). This hunger feeling we sense at times has nothing to do what so ever with actual hunger or nutrional depletion.
- nikiiv 11y agoAs someone who recently lost 40 lbs, I should say that it is generally true. A hard ergometer exercise can have a net effect of 240 kcal for one hour and gross effect of 320 assuming 80 kcal per hour body burn. 240 kcal is not much at all, provided that my body generally burns 2800 kcal a day. Not even 10% However limiting food intake reduces not only the calories, but vitamins and micronutrients plus minerals. Also not exercising at all means muscle loss and not so much fat loss, which can have severe effects in 3-6 months. So regular exercises are must, swimming for example 3 times a week plus some brisk walk in the park twice a week will do miracles. Not to forget proper feeding is it is as much important as reducing calories intake and creating calories deficiency. If one can't balance his food to have proper vitamins and minerals, one should resort to food supplements at least for calcium, potassium, magnesium, vitamins C, B6, B12 and E if you want to keep you heart and liver healthy during the process. Know what you eat and do the numbers. I started with 39% body fat and 33% muscle.. Now I am 30% body fat and 35% muscle with a lot of cardio. A close friend of mine reduced his food intake and albeit he achieved serious weigh loss, that was on the expense of muscle and tissue, rather then fat loss.. Personally I achieved my loss with the help of numbers and constant measures - get a proper scale that can report body fat/muscle/tissue, cross check with calipers, get a fitness tracker to track daily steps and calories, track you food, exercise, calories and progress.. There are so many sites and applications to do so.. And really important - do a blood work each 3 months for you heart and liver. A few drops of blood can give you so much intel Hope that helps
- ryandvm 11y agoThermodynamics saves the day...
- mikhailt 11y agoLosing weight is easy. Most people can do it by eating less without exercise. The biggest problem in weight loss (beside the fact that you shouldn't do any dieting as this should be a lifestyle change), is how to maintain the weight once you reach the healthy goal. I'm having a hard time figuring out how to keep the healthy weight and the best way for me is to exercise in addition to a strict cal limit. Exercise will increase your burning rate, and you have to figure how to balance it with your eating habits because you won't know how your body is burning while at rest for a while. This is the main issue, it is harder to maintain this fight than to lose weight on a simple low-cal limit. I met a lot of folks who successfully lost weight but gained it back and lost it again, it took them 3-4 times in a row to figure out how to maintain their healthy weight. I'm already in my second battle against this. I found the best method is 16/8 fasting method, eat 8 hours and 16 hours fasting and I already am losing far more weight than anything else. This is so much easy to maintain even when I'm reaching my goal. It's kind of like people winning the lottery and most of them just bankrupt themselves in a year. There's no real good educational program in US that teaches both kids and adult how to focus on what you eat and how to maintain the weight.
- boh 11y agoArticles like this are far too common, generic and pretty useless. X may be better than Y! Here's a study that proves it. Oh wait no, Y is better than X because this study proves it. Eat well and exercise. That's it.
- tjogin 11y agoI understand that from the zoomed out perspective, when you learn about advancements in the field from newspapers, magazines or blogs, it looks that way. But this is mostly the fault of various media sensationalizing findings, drawing their own conclusions and prioritizing shocking headlines over levelheaded critique of scientific study results as well as framing it in the proper context. The total body of scientific evidence is not really in such disarray as the reporting would have you believe. However, your conclusion still hits the mark; eat well and exercise.