4 ms·
Wow, they could complete their objective more quickly by taking a billion dollars in small denomination bills and putting it into a pile and lighting it on fire
by ChuckMcM 11y ago
Wow, they could complete their objective more quickly by taking a billion dollars in small denomination bills and putting it into a pile and lighting it on fire :-) Only slightly more seriously, it would be very impressive if they could pull it off, but having seen the deployment of Iridium (66), GPS (32), GLONASS (24) , and Galileo (30) it doesn't seem like we have a non-nation state that is up to the challenge of putting 600(!) satellites into orbit all at once.
If we assume the reporters got random factoids mixed up, 600 satellites? in 20 "planes" ? (lets assume they are somehow station keeping in the same orbital plane so 30 satellites each trying to stay 12 degrees away from the next satellite in the same plane, while trying to avoid the other 19 planes? One gets destroyed by space junk and you practically guarantee another 29 join it over the next 120 minutes or so? That is going to be quite the dance.
And what spectrum are they using for uplink/downlink? .5 Thz? Something they can get a license for all over the world presumably. That alone cost a billion dollars for Iridium.
I just can't imagine a scenario where this even works. Perhaps if they start with the old TeleDesic design or something.
- seany 11y agoKu band. They already own the spectrum.
- kbenson 11y agoUpon reading, I'm not sure if "planes" refers to aircraft, or surface, as in strata. I'm not sure how feasible that is, but in general the story itself seems light on technical details overall.
- ChuckMcM 11y agoMy guess was orbital plane (inclination with respect to the orientation of the earth. So everything in the same orbital plane is going round the same direction at the same speed and distance.
- yoha 11y agoIn this context, it refers to orbital plane. In this particular case, you can just substitute "orbit".
- stcredzero 11y agoIsn't SpaceX's plan to build a satellite Internet service essentially the same thing?
- dasmoth 11y agoYes (although with five or six times as many satellites).
- higherpurpose 11y agoAnd it will likely do it with reusable rockets.
- deleted 11y ago[deleted]
- maxerickson 11y agoSome answers here: http://www.oneweb.world/ http://www.oneweb.world/ (It's very promotional though, not very technical)
- ChuckMcM 11y agoThanks, so they are going to use Ku band and dodge and weave around the equator to avoid satellites in geosynchronous orbits. And from the animation on their technology page it really does look like they are going to have 30 satellites all in the same orbital plane following one after the other. They have set for themselves quite the challenge.
- Dylan16807 11y agoDodge and weave? They're just avoiding aiming down when they are at the equator. I really doubt they're going to hit anything, at least in a way that hurts more than one sat.
- mapt 11y agoGeosynchronous orbits? You mean, 35,000km away from LEO? Operating in a single orbital plane is really not as hard as you're imagining it to be. We do it all the time. And there are tens of thousands of large objects in Earth orbit, but we only detect collisions every several years.
- maxerickson 11y agoTheir spectrum license requires that they not create radio interference for geosynchronous satellites. How they plan to accomplish that is not clear to me.
- mapt 11y agoI interpreted him to mean physical collision risk. As for interference: They're planning on beaming signal to a wide swath of every plane for full-Earth coverage, not just at a narrow stretch near nadir. That means you'll have users acquiring a fix from a wide swath of sky; Let's say 45 degrees from zenith in various directions. That would make every user below 45 degrees latitude encounter fixes with OneWeb proximate to the geosynchronous belt on a regular basis. If spectral separation alone was insufficient to prevent interference, it's not something that would affect communications when a satellite is near the equator at all, it's something that would affect all the satellites nearly all the time. A 1200km orbit is 30x closer to Earth than the geosynchronous belt.
- throwaway_yy2Di 11y ago"Only slightly more seriously, it would be very impressive if they could pull it off, but having seen the deployment of Iridium (66), GPS (32), GLONASS (24) , and Galileo (30) it doesn't seem like we have a non-nation state that is up to the challenge of putting 600(!) satellites into orbit all at once." It looks like these satellites will be a lot smaller than Iridium ones -- from the BBC article, about 150 kg each, vs. ~689 kg [0] for Iridiums. The total orbiting mass is only twice that of the Iridium constellation. 600 * 150 kg = 90,000 kg 66 * 689 kg = 45,474 kg Naively, they could lift everything in maybe five Ariane V (ECA) launches, for ~$1 billion at market pricing [1]. That'd mean packing over a hundred microsats in one payload fairing. I'm not sure how close this is to reality: I'd guess there'd need to be a lot of structure overhead too. [0] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Iridium_satellite_constellation https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Iridium_satellite_constellatio... [1] http://www.spaceflight101.com/ariane-5-eca.html http://www.spaceflight101.com/ariane-5-eca.html ($200 MM/launch, 21,000 kg payload to LEO)
- ChuckMcM 11y agoWell for one the satellites wouldn't have enough fuel on board to do orbital plane changes, to at a minimum its going to be 20 launches if they want to hit 20 different orbital planes. I have yet to find out how they expect to do station keeping with that low mass.
- Dylan16807 11y agoShouldn't station-keeping be nearly independent of mass? Devote the same percentage to the fuel tank and use the tiniest working thruster available.
- TheLoneWolfling 11y agoUnfortunately, small thrusters are less efficient than large ones, overgeneralizing of course. There are a number of components that cannot be scaled down indefinitely. Although there are other potential options (EDTs, etc, etc) that don't have as much difficulty with scaling.
- mapt 11y agoI would like to inform you that the events of _Gravity_ were highly dramatized. Space is not so crowded, and most particles from a collision rapidly drift away. They chose a very high section of LEO, though, 1200km, where debris lasts millennia. Further populating high orbits like this without a solid plan for deorbit is problematic - not for OneWeb, but for the rest of us who don't want to see a Kessler Syndrome cascade thirty years down the road.
- jonah 11y agoFrom their site[1]: "End of Life Disposal When a OneWeb satellite nears the end of its intended service life, it will de-orbit automatically, ensuring that the space around our planet remains free and clear for future generations." So at least they've thought about that. [1] http://www.oneweb.world/#technologies http://www.oneweb.world/#technologies
- exDM69 11y agoIt should be noted that "de-orbit automatically" does not mean orbital decay here, but using thrusters to do a de-orbit burn. If the satellite malfunctions, it will become space junk.