4 ms·
We need some HN readers from the Netherlands to chime in here. "Although the Netherlands is probably the safest country in the world for cycling, helmet wearin
by joezydeco 11y ago
We need some HN readers from the Netherlands to chime in here.
"Although the Netherlands is probably the safest country in the world for cycling, helmet wearing among Dutch cyclists is rare. It has been estimated that only about 0.5 percent of cyclists in the Netherlands are helmeted"
Why are Dutch cyclists more likely to be injured if they wear helmets? - http://www.cyclehelmets.org/1261.html http://www.cyclehelmets.org/1261.html
- kuschku 11y agoNorthern German here: The reason is simple, the only people who wear helmets are the ones who know they are at risk anyway. Correlation != Causation. EDIT: Yup, article confirms it. In my city, the amount of trips taken by bike is over 26%, with another 12% public transport, and most younger people use bikes several times a day – but most don’t wear helmets, and most never had an issue with it, yet.
- KJasper 11y agoDutchie reporting in! Nobody wears a helmet here when they're riding their bike to work, schools, stores, etc. The average speed will be somewhere between 15-20 km/h and is relatively slow, next to that most bike paths are separated from the road so you'll only come in to contact with cars at crossings (and this is where most accidents probably occur). When people get on their MT/Racing bikes the speed increases dramatically to 30+ km/h (and most people wear a helmet) and other people on the road don't always expect those speeds coming from bike lanes so that's why you'll see more accidents. To summarize: Fix your infrastructure and you won't really need a helmet.
- elsjaako 11y agoWhat's there to say? Like the article you linked to said: almost no one but sport bikers and tourists wear helmets. I think the high safety in the Netherlands is mostly due to the driver education (In Holland, spending 40 hours training for your drivers license is not unusual, and you spend a lot of time in the most difficult situations around). Another reason is that if someone gets killed on an intersection, people will have a good look if the safety in that spot can be improved. So a lot of the most dangerous places have been changed to make it safer.
- otherusername2 11y agoDutch guy here. I haven't biked in the U.S, but from what I've seen, biking in the Netherlands is completely different. - Cars drive slower. 50 km/h in city zones, many places that are restricted to 30 km/h. - Our entire infrastructure is adapted to biking. Separate bike lanes, bikes get their own stoplights. We don't need to cut through four lanes of traffic just to make a left turn. We're not part of the normal car traffic on bigger roads. - Motorists are used to people on bikes. At the very least they don't hate them like they seem to do in the U.S. - Bikes are often considered equal to or even higher priority than cars. That means bikes get the right of way just as cars do. In many cases cars have to yield to bikes (roundabouts, etc). There's simply no comparison to be made between the U.S and the Netherlands when it comes to road conditions for bikes. Making any claim that "the Dutch don't wear helmets so I don't need to either" is ridiculous¹ Other than that, when I see U.S bikers in full gear on their bikes, I always have to laugh a little. Spendex shorts, special shoes, helmet, fancy racing bike. I've said this before on HN, but I think they take biking way too serious. And, but this is just a guess, I wouldn't be surprised if fancy bike makes you go a lot faster than the old dinky bikes we ride around on. And speed == danger, which is why your link points out that most Dutch people getting into accidents are wearing helmets: because they're doing recreational biking on fancy fast bikes. I don't think I'd ride a bike in a major U.S city. If I would, I'd wear a helmet. ¹) If my perception of biking in U.S cities is even slightly correct.
- panglott 11y agoFor a long time, you had to be pretty hardcore to cycle in traffic in the US. Politically radical, committed to fitness, whatever. Even 10 years ago, drivers would scream insults out the window, throw things at me from moving cars, and then there's the genuinely life-threatening harassment. Just for daring to be on the road at all, instead of the sidewalk. This has changed radically in the last decade, in my experience. On most roads at less than 30 mph, cycling at 10-15 mph is fine.
- mcv 11y ago> Even 10 years ago, drivers would scream insults out the window, throw things at me from moving cars, and then there's the genuinely life-threatening harassment. This is terrifying. I think removing idiot drivers from the road will do a lot more for bike safety than any helmet ever can.
- Roonerelli 11y agothat's probably because the streets in the Netherlands are much safer. they often have cycle lanes segregated from traffic. and there is less congestion than other major cities. so bikes come into direct contact with cars far less often
- joopxiv 11y agoBeing from The Netherlands, this article confirms my initial suspicion. Here, the only cyclists who wear a helmet are tourists (much more likely to get into an accident due to inexperience) and people riding a racing bike for exercise (much more likely to get into an accident due to high speed). Wearing a helmet while riding to work or something similar is completely unnecessary. I mostly agree with the OP, but there's one difference that might be important: we are raised to ride bicycles at a very young age. When I was in high school I was often trying to ride home without using my hands, through traffic, intersections etc., and I usually succeeded. I don't think I would ever be this comfortable on a bike if I learned riding it at a later age. I did ride a bike in New York a year ago and I didn't feel unsafe at all, but when I see tourists ride bikes through Amsterdam, that's a different story. For me, the experience of the cyclists is the most important factor for safety, and subsequently if wearing a helmet or not is warranted.