6 ms·
I wish Europe weren't so nuke-averse. The lander should have been powered by a radioisotope thermoelectric generator (RTG), not solar panels. Then it would've
by CydeWeys 11y ago
I wish Europe weren't so nuke-averse. The lander should have been powered by a radioisotope thermoelectric generator (RTG), not solar panels. Then it would've had uninterrupted power for years and it could have been returning scientific data continuously since November.
Most of the US's long distance space probes have been powered with RTGs, which don't put nearly the same kinds of limitations on mission profiles. The New Horizons mission to Pluto, for example, is powered with 10.9 kg of plutonium that provides a steady 228 watts and enough heat to prevent the kind of cold-related damage we fear happened on Philae. That mission is so far from the Sun that it wouldn't even be possible with only solar panels.
- johansch 11y agoThe so-called "green parties" have caused a lot of environmental damage to Europe and the earth. Instead of relatively speaking quite safe nuclear power, in many places we are getting quite dangerous coal power. Pretty much just out of ignorance.
- rimantas 11y agoI think nuclear power is safest even in absolute terms not only relatively.
- dekhn 11y agosolar would seem to be safer, presuming you can manufacture the cells without causing environmental degradation.
- gjm11 11y agoNope, at least not according to the figures I've seen (e.g., http://www.forbes.com/sites/jamesconca/2012/06/10/energys-deathprint-a-price-always-paid/2/ http://www.forbes.com/sites/jamesconca/2012/06/10/energys-de...). I think the main reason is that installing solar panels isn't perfectly safe. Nuclear comes out a long way ahead of solar -- but both are vastly ahead of coal.
- witty_username 11y agoWhy? This cursory Google search https://www.google.co.in/search?q=death+per+terawatt https://www.google.co.in/search?q=death+per+terawatt seems to say nuclear has less kills per terawatt-hour than coal, though obviously quantifying deaths from all these power sources is hard.
- kuschku 11y agoThe issue with this is how it calculates deaths per terrawatt. Nuclear has the whole waste storage (and, in some places, drinking water contamination) issue, while coal has the whole climate change issue. Both are bad, but just saying that one of them has less short-term, but more long-term deaths isn’t a good argument.
- ethbro 11y agoImho, "the whole climate change issue" is a waste storage issue as well. Except it doesn't kill people quite as quickly, so we're okay with it just being released into our atmosphere.
- yellowapple 11y agoHave there been any documented cases of nuclear waste storage causing mortal danger, and if so, how do they compare to coal's waste storage (or, more precisely, the lack thereof)? I don't know any details on either, but I'd suspect that the latter is a much greater threat than the former, and that the more we transition from coal to nuclear fission (and, alongside that, the more we develop ways to use nuclear waste more productively), the better.
- pjc50 11y agoThe worst case is rather nasty though: the rendering of a large area uninhabitable and unusable for agriculture. There aren't a lot of sites in Europe where you can site a nuclear reactor far enough away to avoid either evacuating a major city or losing an agricultural region. There is no "away", as people like to say about rubbish.
- lmm 11y agoCompare that large area to that consumed by business-as-usual for the alternatives though. E.g. the area rendered uninhabitable/unusable for hydro power is larger (per kwh). (Of course many people find a reservoir more attractive than a radioactive zone, but both are equally unusable for habitation or agriculture)
- pjc50 11y agoarea rendered uninhabitable/unusable for hydro power is larger That can be true of reservoirs (Lake Mead is huge) but isn't necessarily. UK's largest reservoir is https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Kielder_Water https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Kielder_Water at a mere 2 miles by <6 miles, supporting a piddly 6MW (yes, megawatts not gigawatts, I had to double check that). But that's subject to planning permission in a way that radioactive exclusion zones aren't. The UK suffered from Chernobyl fallout for years: http://www.telegraph.co.uk/news/uknews/1514492/20-years-on-Britain-still-feels-the-effects-of-Chernobyl.html http://www.telegraph.co.uk/news/uknews/1514492/20-years-on-B... It's not that nuclear power is bad on average, it's just that the worst case scenarios affect potentially huge areas.
- NLips 11y agoA clarification to the point about Kielder's power generation: Kielder reservoir is primarily for regulating the water supply, rather than power generation. There are many hydro-electric plants in the UK generating much more power.
- EdwardDiego 11y agoGermany's wind turbines and solar farms disagree. 30% of its energy is renewable.
- areyousure 11y ago(This is not technically a reply to you, but just some context in case anyone else is interested.) For my own benefit, I have attempted to interpret the statistics in this relatively authoritative source: http://www.erneuerbare-energien.de/EE/Navigation/DE/Service/Erneuerbare_Energien_in_Zahlen/Zeitreihen/zeitreihen.html http://www.erneuerbare-energien.de/EE/Navigation/DE/Service/... As far as I can tell, for the year of 2014, Germany's primary energy consumption breaks down approximately 15/35/20/30 for electricity generation, heating, transportation, and other [p.10]. Approximately 30% of the electricity generation is from renewable sources [p.5], which is split approximately 35/25/20/20 between wind, biofuels, solar, and other (including hydro) [p.6]. Nearly all of the contribution of renewable sources to heating and transportation is from biofuels [p.8--9]. tl;dr: Renewable energy accounts for approximately 30% of electricity generation in Germany. Overall, renewable energy accounts for approximately 11% of primary energy consumption.
- ars 11y agoThat's a misleading number. Those devices embody a huge amount energy, which China supplied in the form of coal. It'll be decades before they pay it back, in the meantime they just caused more CO2 in the air. Nuclear would have been better.
- blkhawk 11y agoNot that again. No it does not take decades to pay back the energy cost of the production of Wind Turbines or Solar Panels. Win turbines have an average payback time of 2-8 Months. Solar panels are far worse but even there the payback time for the complete System (Panel, Inverter, Installation, Transport) is between 2.5 Years to 1 Year depending on the panel technology [1]. These numbers are from a Frauenhofer Study from 2009 so one can assume that today's payback times are better than that due to slightly increased efficiency. [1] http://c1cleantechnicacom.wpengine.netdna-cdn.com/files/2013/12/energy-payback-solar-germany.png http://c1cleantechnicacom.wpengine.netdna-cdn.com/files/2013...
- sschueller 11y agoIt is probably also a lot easier for the US to launch a space probe with a nuke power source than Europe. Regulatory requirements are very different and I am sure the US would not be too happy if Europe where to launch something with a nuke onboard without their approval.
- inanutshellus 11y agoI think putting a nuke on a rocket makes everyone nervous, not just the Americans...
- CydeWeys 11y agoIt's not "a nuke", it's a relatively small amount of radioactive material that is sealed inside a very strong capsule designed to survive almost any imaginable catastrophe during launch. The launches are from the coast out over the water. Yes there are still some risks, but in the grand scheme of things, the risks are nothing compared to the importance of exploring the universe.
- ridgeguy 11y agoNot so much easier. There were demonstrations in America against the launch of Cassini, which is a nuclear RTG-powered spacecraft in orbit around Saturn. http://www.cnn.com/TECH/9710/04/cassini/ http://www.cnn.com/TECH/9710/04/cassini/
- lmm 11y agoI remember the demonstrations, but they didn't stop it.
- dempseye 11y agoYou're blaming this on Europe being nuke averse, but Europe is not a homogenous area. While some European countries may be nuke averse, others have adopted nuclear power to a huge extent. There are other reasons why an RTG might not have been appropriate for Philae. They're pretty heavy, and the lander is pretty light. Also, it is wasteful to use an RTG that could last many years when the mission is only expected to last several months.
- delinka 11y agoPerhaps you have your causation backward: perhaps the mission was planned to last only months due to power limitations.
- dempseye 11y agoI was under the impression that they thought the lander would be blown off the comet when it starts to shed ice and debris in large amounts around perihelion.
- arrrg 11y agoPhilae is a tiny little 100kg add on … 29 times heavier Rosetta (the orbiter) is the main course, Philae is this tiny little and quite experimental (though admittedly extremely cool – mostly because of exactly its novel mission) little hitchhiker. RTGs are heavy and consequently have pretty much only been used on much heavier spacecraft and even then mostly only when being solar powered just wasn’t an option. For Philae, besides it being very lightweight, being solar powered was and is an option and the only reason it didn’t work out is because things went wrong during the landing … How in the hell do you even get the idea that Nasa would have used an RTG in ESA’s place here?! They are not psychic. They couldn’t have predicted things going wrong during the landing … and why then put an RTG on this when that’s something Nasa themselves does only very, very rarely and only for very different missions with much more demanding payloads?! What is this insanity? Why the need to get onto this political pulpit and spew out some unrelated political propaganda because you feel like what? What’s the point of this deliberate and pointless provocation?! Huh? I’m confused and angry at this abundance of irrationality.
- herendin 11y agoMaybe some country, or company, could start a profitable business of launching RTGs and selling them to the ESA after they are safely in orbit?
- ajuc 11y agoI wonder how high insurance costs for "launching radioactive isotopes into orbit" are.
- gghh 11y agoHow about the PR strategy? "The lander wakes up, we get headlines again!" </sarcasm>
- platz 11y agohttp://www.popsci.com/nasa-can-make-3-more-nuclear-batteries-and-thats-it http://www.popsci.com/nasa-can-make-3-more-nuclear-batteries... http://www.space4peace.org/ianus/npsm2.htm#2_3 http://www.space4peace.org/ianus/npsm2.htm#2_3
- CydeWeys 11y agoYour links are out of date. The US has since resumed Pu 238 production for use in space-borne RTGs: http://www.economist.com/news/science-and-technology/21647585-america-resumes-production-plutonium-238-keep-space-within-reach-nasas-dark http://www.economist.com/news/science-and-technology/2164758... Even if we hadn't resumed production, I'd still be arguing that the simple fix is to resume production and continue using the proven technology, not to simply give up on it.
- duckmysick 11y agoThe European Space Agency together with the National Nuclear Laboratory are looking for a potential use of americium-241 in developing RTGs. So they aren't completely nuke-averse. http://www.nnl.co.uk/news-media-centre/news-archive/space-batteries-success/ http://www.nnl.co.uk/news-media-centre/news-archive/space-ba... http://www.quora.com/How-does-ESA-plan-to-power-its-future-space-missions-if-they-dont-want-to-use-RTGs http://www.quora.com/How-does-ESA-plan-to-power-its-future-s... Also, wasn't NASA's Advanced Stirling Radioisotope Generator canned in 2013 due to budget cuts? And recently there were problems with procuring plutonium-238. RTG isn't a silver bullet. http://www.economist.com/news/science-and-technology/21647585-america-resumes-production-plutonium-238-keep-space-within-reach-nasas-dark http://www.economist.com/news/science-and-technology/2164758...
- bitwize 11y ago"Europe" isn't nuke-averse; French nuclear plant designs are considered among the world's best, and Germany only backed off nuclear power when Fukushima happened. In light of Fukushima I wish EVERYONE were more nuke-averse...
- DasIch 11y agoGermany backed off nuclear power in the 90s long before Fukushima. That process was merely slowed down before Fukushima and set back on track afterward. This has to also be kept in mind when considering nuclear power in Germany. The nuclear plants in Germany are so old that whether you are pro or contra on nuclear power, shutting down the existing plants is more or less a non-issue.
- soperj 11y agoIn light of Fukushima, everyone should be more aware of what happens when you don't properly maintain, and update your nuclear power plants. In light of global warming, and carcenogens released caused by burning coal, I wish every one were more pro-nuclear.
- jschwartzi 11y agoI would add that I hope we all take flood control recommendations more seriously in light of Fukushima, too. I recall that TEPCO knew that it wouldn't withstand a tsunami of that magnitude, and they proceeded to ignore that risk.
- deleted 11y ago[deleted]
- kitd 11y ago> That mission is so far from the Sun that it wouldn't even be possible with only solar panels. Maybe there's your answer?