8 ms·
The world of threats to the US is an illusion
- neonhomer 11y agoThis article makes a small case about the military profit complex, but it's also ironic that according to the AP the "Chinese" have hacked their way into all federal employee's information: http://news.yahoo.com/union-hackers-personnel-data-every-us-govt-employee-195701976.html http://news.yahoo.com/union-hackers-personnel-data-every-us-.... So there are some real threats.
- erikpukinskis 11y agoHow is someone in China reading about some Americans a "real" threat? When I think of a real threat, I think of a person with an intent to harm a U.S. resident or citizen, a plan to do it, and the means to launch a plausibly realistic attempt.
- classicsnoot 11y ago...so your personal data being compromised by persons unknown is not something you would deem a problem?
- yyyyes 11y agoNot one worth going to war over.
- classicsnoot 11y ago"Going to war" was not a part of my question at all.
- zanny 11y agoIts framing in the context of threats to the US. The CIA can do their job and attempt to catch foreign hackers, you don't need 800 billion of army, navy, and marines sitting around to do that.
- classicsnoot 11y ago>the CIA is not responsible for "catching foreign hackers". That is the FBI. >the US military is roughly 1.5 million people. that is in total. .00375% of the US population I know it is easy to think that america has a huge military, and that the CIA is some massive organization that functions as an all knowing entity, and that they do nothing. But you need to expand your information sources. Watching the news and 0dark30 does not adequately prepare one to understand how international relations work. I know there is a tendency to think that the US overspends on defense (~22% of the total estimated budget) [http://www.usgovernmentspending.com/federal_budget_detail http://www.usgovernmentspending.com/federal_budget_detail]. To make a parallel, if there is some tech company that has a small, highly skilled staff, would it be silly for them to spend ~22% of their gross total budget on having the best gear and training? https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/United_States_Armed_Forces https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/United_States_Armed_Forces
- zanny 11y ago> the CIA is not responsible for "catching foreign hackers". That is the FBI. The CIA is foreign, the FBI is domestic. They are both investigative agencies. If the hackers are operating out of the US for a foreign interest, they are in the domain of the FBI. If they are attacking from China, thats the CIA's business. > I know it is easy to think that america has a huge military, and that the CIA is some massive organization that functions as an all knowing entity, and that they do nothing. It isn't "think". The US spends 4 times as much as the next largest military, China, while having the same land area and a quarter the population. We have treaties and agreements that make us the military defense force of a quarter of the world, and we do about a third of the spending. While being 4% of the global population. And of course the CIA is doing stuff. That is my point. You don't need the 800 billion dollar tumor to have a foreign investigations agency do their job protecting us from information threats. > To make a parallel, if there is some tech company that has a small, highly skilled staff, would it be silly for them to spend ~22% of their gross total budget on having the best gear and training? The staff you describe are only trained to stand in front of your competitors offices and block them from entering. They aren't adding value to the company, they are just eating its resources to threaten the competition. The 800 billion sunk into the DoD is producing a trickle of R&D results and innovation, but is not improving our GDP or producing goods or services of value to citizens. The bigger question is why when you have a small, highly skilled staff (NASA) you regularly cut its budget when it has at various points in history produced incredible R&D returns for its cost.
- facetube 11y agoIt is a problem, but the United States NSA is currently the biggest offender in that department. Let's start out by not doing it to ourselves.
- classicsnoot 11y agoThe US passively spying on 300,000,000 > China actively spying on [and suppressing] 1,300,000,000. What a wacky world.
- facetube 11y agoI was referring to China's efforts to compromise systems in the US, not their (dismal) domestic human-rights record. The point: we shouldn't be collecting and concentrating the private communications of American citizens in a giant data center – it's provided no proven protective value, and is a huge glowing target for foreign espionage (corporate and/or governmental).
- jerf 11y agoRemember when everyone was discussing how bad it is for the NSA to know everything, because they can do things like ride in at critical moments in someone's life, like a politician's, and blackmail them with releasing something unless it goes their way? Same argument holds with China, or anybody who gets the data. Plus, the ability of attackers is not bounded by your creativity or credulity, or mine. The question isn't whether you or I can come up with something interesting to do with the data, the question is whether anybody who gets their hands on it can. For the most part, the data really is mundane and irrelevant, sure. I know some government employees I went to college with, none of whom are in any position to do anything all that interesting at China's behest. But it's that .1% percent of data on the movers and shakers, and the people who will be tomorrow's movers and shakers, that is very valuable. (And I've got a bridge to sell you if you think the full range of the hacking has been revealed yet.) Edit: Oh, hey, look what I found in my newsfeeds literally one minute later: http://www.wired.com/2015/06/opm-breach-security-privacy-debacle/ http://www.wired.com/2015/06/opm-breach-security-privacy-deb... "Federal background checks, after all, are meant to suss out information that might be used by foreign enemies to blackmail a government staffer into turning over classified information. And that stolen information could be used for exactly that extortion purpose, says Chris Eng, a former NSA staffer and now VP of research at the security firm Veracode." They literally got their hands on the forms constructed to contain exactly the information we didn't want foreign governments could get.
- zac1944 11y agoSomebody forgot about Edward Snowden breach? Is that real threat to the world?
- skidoo 11y agoThe talk of need for separation of Church and State is one thing (and absolutely valid), but I think the largest threat to the world, indeed the largest threat the world has ever known, is the marriage between (American) State and (American) Industry. That's what the Snowden leaks have verified most.
- mark_l_watson 11y agoI wish that everyone in my country (the USA) would read this article. War is big business and throughout history war has been the means for the rich to get richer. Even if we have some economic malaise when the dollar becomes less relevant as the world's reserve currency, we have a lot going for us: geographic isolation and natural resources.
- zxcvcxz 11y agoI've come to the conclusion that multiple world governments --working together and against each other-- are attempting and in some cases are able to manipulate the narrative of conversations on the internet to further certain political agendas. I don't believe most of the crap I hear about teenagers leaving in droves to join ISIS all over the world, this is the red scare all over again. I'm also pretty sure twitter is one of the main social platforms used to manipulate the political/social narrative of the internet. More than half the accounts are probably fake, who knows how many fake "ISIS" accounts there are or even what countries government is making them. I also suspect twitter is being used as some kind of data hub for surveillance because of how fast it caught on in Arab countries and a lot of countries that aren't quite "western", then the western media started to push it in every news broadcast for a while as if anyone in America actually used it. Surprise surprise! all the terrorists always have twitter accounts. I wouldn't be surprised if the next "home-grown" terrorist has a twitter account.
- classicsnoot 11y ago@zxcvcxz, you have crossed the line into stupid. Your idea is reminiscent of AntiVax people or homeopaths. Here is some light reading for you to contemplate. http://bulletinoftheoppressionofwomen.com/category/acid-attacks-on-women-and-girls/ http://bulletinoftheoppressionofwomen.com/category/acid-atta...
- zxcvcxz 11y agoShouldn't we invade every country that oppresses women by your logic? The only reason ISIS exists is because we created it, and your solution is to go back and do what we just did again and create even more ISIS?
- classicsnoot 11y agoFirst off, at no point did i say we should repeat the mistakes of Gulf II. That was an intellectual leap made by you. Second, i was responding to how blase you seem to be about what ISIS is doing and what they are. I do not know what should be done. My inclination is for volunteers from any country be sent in to keep the peace and pursue these fucking monsters. Not nation states, not governments. Volunteers. And just to be clear. Smurf yes. The US should have a standing policy that if you melt people's faces or destroy priceless historical treasures because your stupid little book told you to, that we wreck shop. But that is childish and far fetched.
- r0naa 11y agoI think that this reasoning is completely flawed. Reading this article, I understand that the author's definition of threat is quite extreme. A threat is not something that "has the potential to annihilate" but is rather "a thing that has the potential to inflict damages". Dismissing any threats that has not a fully destructive potential as "not important" is sloppy, dangerous thinking. There is two extremes to this spectrum, you will notice that both have a characteristic in common, they fail to differentiate and nuance threats. From this fallacy, we can classify the two end of the spectrum as: - The "paranoid", who genuinely end-up thinking that "the end justify the means" and propagate their hysteria to the rest of the group, effectively becoming the biggest threat to what they were trying protect. - The "naive", who dismiss anything that has no fully destructive power as "trivial", effectively allowing threats to turn into actual damages, grow to become "fully destructive" (at which point it is too late) or cause a chain of events leading to destruction of what they were effectively trying to protect as well. Let's not be fooled for a second by the "alliances" and "historical relationships" between the US and its allies. Nation-States are engaged in a game for survival which is directly linked to growth and domination. A game-theoretic analogy would be the "non-cooperative" game, defined as "a game where players play independently and where any cooperation must be self-reinforcing". There is exceptions to that rule but they are such of limited scope and impact that we can safely consider them negligible. Since "Nation-States" lack a system of belief, they are free from the constraints that Humans self-impose onto themselves. A Nation-State will do anything to further its own interest, they are in essence, cold-blooded machines. The author of this article is forgetting about the 195 other countries in the world who are also playing this game. Obviously not all of them have credible chances to become big players but you can bet on the fact that all of them will fight tooth and nail for their part of the pie, no matter what it takes.
- Zirro 11y ago"Saying that the US has no threats is forgetting about the 195 other countries in the world who are aspiring to be as much powerful as possible." I believe that this is exactly the way of thinking that is being criticized in the article. Very few of those 195 nations dream of removing the US from the position of world power, and even fewer are capable of it.
- classicsnoot 11y agoThis article is poorly written. It provides no background or supporting references to bolster its claim. I find it frustrating in the extreme. Threats do not have to be overtly threatening. A person in the room that dislikes you and has a lot of money and time can be just as threatening as a person in the room claiming to have a gun at home and an aversion towards your faith/gender/culture. I come from a place where people blindly believe the US is the best[sic] nation in the world. Anyone that disagrees is obviously some "egghead/pinko/etc" who can't appreciate the sacrifice of others. This, the opposite extreme, is a s frustrating as the words of the dullard who penned this piece. I confront it constantly in an attempt to represent the middle path. In my years of argument, discussion, and reassessment, i have come to realize that nothing is quite what it seems. To make absolute statements, for or against anything, is to place oneself in an inherently weak position intellectually. The author shrugs at Russia's expansionist aggression, pointing out their economic weakness as a reason they are no threat to the US. The approach to China and Venezuela is similarly misguided. Threats != weapons. Europe's relative peace since world war 2 is largely because of the US being extremely security minded. ...but who knows. Maybe Russia bullying its neighbors is just as symptom of it being misunderstood. Maybe China steals technology and data because they are just in that adolescent "acting out" phase. Maybe the world is really a nice place and the US is ruining the party for everyone. :|
- cyphunk 11y agoIt is an editorial in the opinion section. agreed references help but ive always assumed words in the opinions section of papers can be regarded as just that
- bane 11y agoThis is basically correct, but it's shaped by a few historic factors (note I don't necessarily agree with all of these, just putting them out there): 1 - The U.S. was almost constantly engaged in a domestic or near-territorial war of some kind from its founding until quite a few years into the 20th century. [1] During the time period the U.S. massively expanded, strengthened itself by defining borders and internally squashing various kinds of rebellions. Since then, the U.S. has basically been at war continuously. America is, believe it or not, a kind of warrior culture. 2 - The U.S. usually is able to claim some kind of victory out of most of its military endeavors. Thus military engagement is seen as a tempting, low risk, policy tool. The historic level of military success the U.S. enjoys is almost unprecedented in history. By selectively choosing engagements it knows it can win, the U.S. can continue the development of this legend. 3 - Domestically, Americans tend to think of our military actions as generally being benevolent in nature (e.g. stopping communism, fighting nazis, freeing subjugated peoples). The outstanding economic success of many countries who's soil we fought on and then built strong alliances with (Germany, Korea, Japan, France, etc.) feeds into this mythos. The post-war alliances we've formed help to "encourage us" to get involved. 4 - The modern state of the world's powers, an outcome of WWII, is one in which the U.S. is militarily uncontested by any power on the planet. The relatively few conflict deaths post-WW2 [2] seems to imply that U.S. military dominance brings peace, stability and prosperity and helps drive the notion of the Pax Americana [3] 5 - The failures and generally poor outcomes in countries under other major power's influences and policies feeds into this as well. For example, at one point a majority of the land-mass on the planet was engaged in Communism, under Russian control (as the U.S.S.R.) or influence. Despite access to tremendous natural resources (and short lived modernization programs), the Communist countries failed to produce economic successes and were often engaged in tremendously damaging internal conflicts. 6 - Pax Americana is viewed by Americans as a "good thing". Even though Americans don't view themselves as expansionist colonial powers, they view the expansion of the Pax via the export of American culture and influence as a good thing. This implies then that the current state of American dominance is a good thing, and that anything that even looks like it might be vectoring towards threatening that status quo (e.g. belligerent Russia, rising China, trouble on Allied borders etc.) needs to be aggressively halted or stopped. American policy is generally framed as #6, with 1-5 as a supporting framework. If thought of on purely military terms, American military expenditures and actions can't really be rationalized. If thought of on terms of #6 they make all the sense in the world. There's a lot of self-filtering involved too. Americans ignore the failures and negatives surrounding military action, and the various excesses that come with pouring something like half of the government's discretionary funding into the DoD. But the illusion of continued threats is one that we've created in order to continue on justifying with what we generally believe is a better world under our influence than the one that existed before. You can hear most of this echoed when fairly sensible ideas like "maybe Americans should pull out of Europe and let the Europeans, who are economically and technologically able, to deal with defense needs for themselves" are floated. Responses (even from Europeans) are often along the lines of "no, European countries can't be trusted to cooperate well enough" or "remember the last time Europe was left to sort things out?" and so on. This also ignores entire continents like Africa, where Americans just simply can't figure out what to do at all. Our national notion towards Africa is basically to just ignore the continent and work on Middle-East containment instead. These days when Africa comes up at all, it's usually in terms of growing Chinese influence. 1 - https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/List_of_wars_involving_the_United_States https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/List_of_wars_involving_the_Uni... 2 - https://vimeo.com/128373915 https://vimeo.com/128373915 3 - https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Pax_Americana https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Pax_Americana
- vinceguidry 11y ago> Future peace requires taking [Russia's] security concerns seriously rather than treating the country as an enemy that is always seeking to best us. The problem with this is that Russia's security 'concerns' cannot be separated from their nefarious geopolitical ambitions. We can't win with Russia, give them an inch and they take a Crimea.
- tonypace 11y agoBut this article is straightforward isolationism, a very old current in American political thought. The implied answer to your question is, 'So what? America is safe, that's all that matters'.
- makeitsuckless 11y agoIsn't the same kind of thinking not just dominant in the US foreign policy, but also the same thing that explains much of it's internal issues? From militarized police, the massive prison population to the proliferation of fire arms, doesn't it all lead back to seeing the world in terms of "threats"?
- atorralb 11y agoThe last time the U.S was invaded was when Pancho Villa came from Mexico to the U.S to steal some horses from Texas. In, March 9, of 1916,Pancho Villa entered the U.S to kill some soldier in the city of Columbus and steal some horses, then in the next day Pancho Villa returned to Mexico to brag about it. That was the only time the U.S was actually invaded. Since 1947 the U.S "ministry of war" was renamed to "ministry of defense" and its "budget of war" was renamed to "budget of defense"... the name, is still a mistery to this day. What an irony, those countries that fear to be invaded, are actually the only ones that invade other countries. Regards
- classicsnoot 11y ago>War of 1812 was fabricated
- dataker 11y agoThe largest threat to America is America itself. For the past decades, America appears to be moving away from principles , objectiveness and liberty. More and more, we see a 'democracy' ran by delusional ideologies and even blind nationalism.
- classicsnoot 11y agoThe history of the US is not that rosy. We have always been a nation of criminals, robber barons, and capitalist mercenaries. It was only after WWII that the idea of being a benevolent super power came into being. After that war, the US stopped seizing territory and began to go about forming the structures of cooperative peace. The question, as i see it, is which is better: small, consistent conflicts lacing the developing sections of the world, or large, sporadic conflicts wrecking the developed sections of the world?
- douche 11y agoIn the nuclear age, full-out shooting wars between developed countries are a non-starter. Hence the 45 years of small-scale proxy wars between the U.S. and Soviet Union throughout Africa, Latin America and Asia.
- classicsnoot 11y agoThe idea that a large scale conflict will inevitably lead to nuclear exchange is so silly. Most nuclear weapons are not strategic, they are tactical. Regardless, no one would nuke the property they are trying to occupy. The reason their have been almost no real wars since the 1940s is because business interest has taken over control of every western government. I know people think there is a ton of profit to be made in war, but the damages so heavily outweigh the benefits that i have a hard time believing that is the sole motivation for hawkish policies.
- codecamper 11y agoGermany and Japan were able to become powerful again, post WW2 because they were not even allowed to spend money on any sort of army.
- classicsnoot 11y ago...which they could do because their territorial integrity was guaranteed by a country that spared no expense militarily.