4 ms·
Hasn't the luddite argument already been addressed by economists in general? Do we need to have it every time? Remember when a high percentage of humans worke
by melling 11y ago
Hasn't the luddite argument already been addressed by economists in general? Do we need to have it every time? Remember when a high percentage of humans worked in agricultural jobs?
- justonepost 11y agoThe argument is not luddite or the oppression of technology. The argument is that we need to revamp our economic system to allow for the displacement of workers. The reality is that more and more jobs are 'bullshit' jobs and more people are becoming rapidly economically irrelevant.
- adventured 11y agoWhere is this occurring exactly? In nearly every major economy, the people are better off today than they were 100 years ago, or 50 years ago. The US median may be the sole exception, due to having temporarily inherited the global manufacturing base all for itself after WW2. Germany, Canada, Australia, New Zealand, Sweden, Switzerland, Finland, Netherlands, Denmark, Norway, Austria, Czech, Slovakia, Ireland, Singapore, China, Hong Kong, Taiwan, South Korea, Poland, Russia, Colombia, Mexico, Brazil - the people in these countries, in median economic terms, are better off today than at any other time in world history. Even the French, whose economy has been stagnant for 20 years, are incredibly rich when it comes to median net wealth. In France it's $140,000 +/- median net wealth per adult, among the highest on earth. The Japanese are in all sorts of trouble economically, and their people, in median terms, are far better off today than they were in 1920 or in 1970.
- justonepost 11y agoWhat you see is people are working 'bullshit' jobs in order to keep up with consumption. Sure, these jobs exist, but they are mostly pointless. Our economic system is creating these jobs because of ZIRP. Witness the pointless startups getting funded (they're not ALL pointless, of course).. God forbid the fed ever increased interest rates and actually expected people to work in real jobs that produced something real.
- kevinskii 11y agoDo you work a 'bullshit' job?
- justonepost 11y agoThis fellow probably says it better than I: http://www.economist.com/blogs/freeexchange/2013/08/labour-markets-0 http://www.economist.com/blogs/freeexchange/2013/08/labour-m... If you take a moment and look at maslow's hierarchy of needs you have to ask yourself do we really need all these jobs at the top of the pyramid? Why can't we all just make sure the entire world has the bottom part covered and then just relax and enjoy each other's company / enjoy nature / read a book? Sure, I get why we have roomba the robot, but come on.... Luxury Yachts for millions of dollars? Mansions? Super cars? I mean, wtf.
- ChuckMcM 11y agoNo doubt Graeber would have considered the medicine man in the cave society as a 'bullshit' job. :-) The Luddite argument is almost exactly as you've framed it, "technology eats my job, 'they' fix it so most people don't notice, we should collectively outlaw technology." However, the Luddites, then and now, started from a fallacy that a 'job' was some sort of permanently defined thing, of which there was a finite supply. And sadly that is completely backwards. What there is, is capital, which is the output of an economy, which goes back into the economy to create more capital. Capital is not strictly 'money' which is a stand in for it at times, it is the potential to produce goods or services. That potential can be realized as $100 or it can be realized as someone who is not currently employed. The participants in the economy, people like you and me, make up new types of jobs all the time in order to convince some capital to flow your way. When we are successful we capture that capital, and then we reuse it to meet our own needs or goals. So when ever there is excess capital, there is job creation because everyone wants a piece of it.
- steve19 11y agocan you give some examples of these so called bullshit jobs? you might not agree that military jobs are useful (I think they serve a useful purpose) or the government in general (could be smaller, but it's not all bullshit in my opinion )... but many people would disagree with you.
- deleted 11y ago[deleted]
- melling 11y agoIt is the Luddite argument. What did they do when their jobs were replaced? https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Luddite https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Luddite Automating people out of work is not a new problem
- Klinky 11y agoNor is it a solved problem. You cannot point to any modern economy as an example of successfully avoiding this issue, since they all rely heavily on subsidy injections to maintain the economy(and for other reasons). A more modern example would be British coal. While people have moved on decades later, local economies were devastated. It can take generations to recover, while many fall through the cracks.
- slavik81 11y agoMy argument is that the government, as the owner of the resources being extracted, might have both motive and opportunity to raise their prices if extraction costs drop. Automation means we can do less work but still enjoy the fruits of our labour as if we did more work. I certainly wouldn't oppose that. The Luddites wanted to prevent automation but I don't, so you'll need to clarify if that's not what you meant.
- ticksoft 11y agoI often wonder if mental illness is a side effect of this shift from outdoor and natural forms of work, to indoor and stress driven types of work. People have to teach themselves all sorts of coping mechanisms to stop their minds going out of control with modern work (burnout being a vague example around here).
- iheartmemcache 11y agoLike all things its nature vs nurture. There are plenty of historical accounts of people being anti-social agoraphobes or autistic in the past. They were either labeled 'eccentric' if they were rich or crazy if they weren't. "Demon possession" during bible days was likely a form of mental illness, and those who genuinely heard "God" might have either been on psychedelics or had genuine conditions (schizophrenia comes to mind).
- anko 11y agoI think the argument is different today. It's not just one or two industries being replaced, and it's not just super skilled labour either. When computers replace our drivers, in australia, that's ~ 5% of people out of a job. That's just transport jobs, not including rental etc. The Australian government predicts a 10% growth in that industry in the next 5 years. http://lmip.gov.au/default.aspx?LMIP/EmploymentProjections http://lmip.gov.au/default.aspx?LMIP/EmploymentProjections Australia's unemployment rate is 6% - so that's basically a doubling of workers looking for jobs, from computerisation of one industry. Obviously 5 years is too short term for automation of transport, but projecting further than that is a fool's game. The fear is that automation will affect more and more industries at the same time, leading to structural unemployment. That's where a person's worth is less than minimum wage relative to the price of automation - people simply can't be trained fast enough because the industries are changing too fast and computer power is cheap.