6 ms·
If somebody wants to kill air travelers, TSA screening checkpoint line is the most attractive target. Just fill big suitcase with explosives and wait until you
by nabla9 11y ago
If somebody wants to kill air travelers, TSA screening checkpoint line is the most attractive target.
Just fill big suitcase with explosives and wait until you are middle of the TSA screening line during holiday season.
- Lawtonfogle 11y ago>If somebody wants to kill air travelers, TSA screening checkpoint line is the most attractive target. My other favorite example is that in a lot of buildings, including school buildings, the standard fire drill AND bomb evacuation drill has everyone move outside, often into a single area which is far less controlled than the building being evacuated.
- aetherson 11y agoOr, like, any other public transportation option. Busses and trains are not magically immune to explosives. Especially when they have literally zero security and you could easily bring an entire suitcase full of dynamite onto them. The fact is, there just aren't enough people interested in that who have the necessary skills to actually obtain explosives without alerting the FBI to their existence.
- jerf 11y agoIf you just want to blow something up there's nothing even all that special about "transportation". Planes are special, because they have an unusual characteristic; taking control of a plane gives you an extremely powerful weapon that you can point anywhere and deliver incredible destruction. There aren't very many other things that two or three people can do that will credibly take down a skyscraper. As it gets harder to deliberately crash a plane and there's ever more drive-by-wire, though, that threat diminishes, and the airport threat diminishes with it. Hypothetically if planes were completely ground-controlled, there would basically be no reason for airport security at all... blowing up planes isn't that intrinsically interesting, really. There'd be a certain amount of inertia to the concept, but that's it. (Yes, I know it used to be done, but post-9/11 I can't help but think that terrorists would view that as a pathetic second-best effort now.) (Though I'd appreciate some serious security around the ground control station, though. Taking over one plane is one thing... taking over "all the planes in the area" or even "all the planes in the sky" would be something else!)
- supergirl 11y agothere's also the fact that it's easier to blow up a plane. you need a big bomb to destroy a bus but only a small bomb to make a hole in the plane and kill everyone. and the plane has way more people on it than a bus.
- simoncion 11y agoA hole in a plane's fuselage or wing doesn't mean that everyone dies. You need a lot of power in order to take out a wing. Remember that wings on commercial jetliners are designed to eat an entire disintegrating jet engine in order to protect passengers in the fuselage. Additionally, a jetliner's fuselage can take a VERY large hit at cruising altitudes and speeds [0] and still leave the plane flightworthy. Planes are tougher (and their crews better prepared) than people think they are. [0] http://lessonslearned.faa.gov/ll_main.cfm?TabID=4&LLID=20&LLTypeID=2 http://lessonslearned.faa.gov/ll_main.cfm?TabID=4&LLID=20&LL... (Be patient. This might take a while to load, but it's worth the wait.)
- netfire 11y agoIs the TSA really doing anything to prevent someone from taking control of a plane though? Post-9/11, the cabin door is now shut and locked during most of the flight. I can't imagine a pilot or crew-member would open that door due to a terrorist threat, knowing what we do now (and that they would probably die anyway, if they opened the door)
- simoncion 11y agoThe door has also been substantially reinforced. It's probably safe to bet that anyone who tries to break through will not be successful for a variety of reasons. :)
- spacko 11y agoWhich again was a reason for why Germanwings pilot Andreas Lubitz could undisturbedly let the plane crash for committing suicide. (http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Germanwings_Flight_9525 http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Germanwings_Flight_9525)
- ehmorris 11y agoHere at least. Bus bombings are almost common in some places: https://www.google.com/webhp#q=bus+bombing&tbm=nws https://www.google.com/webhp#q=bus+bombing&tbm=nws
- pavel_lishin 11y agoTrue, however I would imagine that an attack on an airport would hurt more than an attack on a bus or train depot; I'd wager that flights might get grounded until everything is sorted out. Nobody's going to shut down New York's Penn Station if something happens in Chicago or San Francisco.
- freehunter 11y agoTo be honest, that's a huge fear of mine every time I'm waiting in a TSA line. What happens if they find a weapon and the person decides to use it right then and there? What happens if their equipment sets off a weapon? What happens if a domestic terrorist is trying to get back at the TSA directly? Most of my flights are what Delta or United call "connector" flights, so there are only 40-50 people on the plane anyway. Not an attractive target, I would think. But standing in line at O'Hare, there could be 100+ people there. I'm not afraid of the TSA. I'm afraid of the massive crowd of people they create.
- btbuildem 11y agoExactly. If you look at airports that face actual, active threats (israel) - you'll see they've minimized security lineups.
- thomas11 11y agoThe end-goal of terrorism is the psychological impact, not killing a few people more or less. And there's just something about airplanes that creates a larger psychological impact when they're hit. Maybe it's the thought of being stuck in one, helpless and with no way out. Or maybe they symbolize progress and freedom, making traveling the world so easy. Whatever it is, that's what the terrorist attacking airplanes are going for.
- beat 11y agoAnd 911 was tremendously successful in that regard. Americans more or less willingly gave up many freedoms and accepted a police state.
- __z 11y agoFrom the article: "The TSA is failing to defend us against the threat of terrorism. The only reason they've been able to get away with the scam for so long is that there isn't much of a threat of terrorism to defend against... Terrorists are much rarer than we think, and launching a terrorist plot is much more difficult than we think. I understand this conclusion is counterintuitive, and contrary to the fearmongering we hear every day from our political leaders. But it's what the data shows." You're much more likely to get killed on the car ride to the airport than at the airport.
- mikeash 11y agoI really wonder why this hasn't happened yet. I can only assume that either terrorists are maniacally fixated on the airplanes, or there are approximately zero intelligent terrorists.
- freehunter 11y agoOr option C, 9/11 was a one-off, special circumstance that was difficult to create in the first place and nearly impossible to replicate.
- mikeash 11y ago9/11 certainly was pretty unusual, but packing a suitcase with explosives and nails and hauling it into a crowd of civilians is the sort of thing that happens fairly regularly in some parts of the world.
- Someone1234 11y agoSee Boston marathon. I don't consider it a particularly sophisticated attack, but it was undeniably effective both at injuring people and at spreading FUD. Aircraft are an attractive target if you can cause the aircraft to crash, but most terrorist attacks on aircraft don't have that result.
- peteretep 11y ago> and at spreading FUD It was? Has the behaviour of Bostonians changed significantly? Were political goals achieved?
- dsr_ 11y agoBostonianish person here: it hasn't changed Boston. My brother-in-law was running the Marathon that day, he finished about 30 minutes before the explosions. Watertown residents' cars are no longer universally decorated with "W Strong" stickers. The feds had to strain mightily at the jury pool to get jurors willing to consider the death penalty -- sentiment in Massachusetts was 2:1 in favor of having Tsarnaev rot in prison. Insofar as the Tsarnaevs had a political goal, I don't think they achieved it.
- kgilpin 11y agoThe attackers objective is not blowing up a crowd of people. Their objective is a hijacked airplane; a dangerous weapon that can be used to attack strategic targets like the White House.
- simoncion 11y ago> ...a dangerous weapon that can be used to attack strategic targets... Do you honestly believe that Air Force hardware won't be used to destroy a hijacked passenger jet that appears to be in service as a weapon? I don't.
- tomjen3 11y agoAssuming they could get one there in time, no I wouldn't doubt it. Not sure how deliberately murdering hostages is constitutional but then neither is most of what the government is doing. How many jets patrol the US mainland now? What is their response time? I am assuming the white house has AA, but what about congress?
- simoncion 11y agoIf required, the murder of innocents strapped to or contained within a weapon of war is totally legal. It has been legal for hundreds of years. I can't speak authoritatively, but jet response time to a breach of a sensitive no-fly zone is in the single-digit minute range. [0] I would be shocked if every major government facility wasn't surrounded by a no-fly bubble. I would be surprised if we didn't have the capability to send fighters to anywhere in the CONUS within ten minutes. [0] Quite some time ago, I was living near Tacoma, WA when the POTUS was visiting. There was concern that an aircraft was going to enter the temporary no-fly zone around the POTUS, so a couple of jets from the nearby base were scrambled and cleared to go supersonic -maybe- 1,000 feet off the deck. The din and air pressure change was incredible; it was if a tremendously large bomb had gone off some distance away.