7 ms·
Bond crash across the world as deflation trade goes wrong
- w23j 11y agoLove that sentence: [...] 'narrow' M1 money in the eurozone has been growing at a rate of 16.2pc (annualized) over the last six months. You do not have to be monetarist expert to see the glaring anomaly. Even though you do not have to be a monetarist expert, it's probably easier to see the glaring anomaly, when you understand some of the concepts mentioned. :)
- phaemon 11y agoYou need the previous paragraph to see the anomaly: "a small army of hedge funds and 'prop desks' trying to squeeze a few last drops out of a spent deflation trade" You probably know about inflation (prices going up) and probably have heard of hyper-inflation, where the government just keeps printing more money, so there is too much money for the economy. As happened in the Weimer Republic or Zimbabwe. Perhaps you've heard the old joke of someone having to take a wheelbarrow full of money just to buy a loaf of bread, leaving it unattended for a moment, and returning to find someone had dumped out all the money and stolen the wheelbarrow. Deflation is the opposite, where there is a shortage of money. M1 money is the money you can spend. It's a subset of M2 money which is the money you can spend in a bit. Which is a subset of M3 money which is the money rich people can use without spending, plus all your money. So, the traders have been trying to make money from deflation, a shortage of money, when money has been growing at 16.2%. That's the glaring anomaly. The trader explains this as, "We're too dogmatic". This is trader talk for, "We're a bunch of barely numerate halfwits who have no idea what we're doing. None of us do. We're just trying to get out of this shitty business as multi-millionaires before we die of a heart-attack aged 40." Hope that explains it OK.
- semi-extrinsic 11y agoThank you, good sir, for elucidating.
- w23j 11y agoI see. Thank you for the explanation.
- lovemenot 11y agoHas the deflation dragon been Slain? Let's see. My perspective is that there have been many false dawns in Japan, even after more than 20 years there is still no clear way out. Of course Japan is a special case: as close as it is to China. As long as PRC growth slows, the developed world may get some respite from deflation. Which is intended as observation, not judgement. Good wishes to the Chinese economy.
- crdoconnor 11y agoJapan isn't special. Japan is a taste of what's to come.
- AnimalMuppet 11y agoWell, no, Japan is a taste of what's to come if we do what Japan did and if the circumstances are the same. To say that Japan is the inevitable end result, no matter what we do... I'll just say "Objection, your honor. Assumes facts not in evidence."
- toomuchtodo 11y ago> Well, no, Japan is a taste of what's to come if we do what Japan did and if the circumstances are the same. Have an aging population and birth rate contraction? Because that's the fate (which ISN'T A BAD THING) of all developed countries.
- AnimalMuppet 11y agoThat's the fate of all developed countries... except possibly the US. Immigration may save the US (or may not, depending on what happens with immigration policy...)
- hga 11y agoThat's a VERY BAD THING if your aging population can't be supported by a too small younger demographic. One of Japan's solutions has been in part to simply lose a lot of their old age pension records in a conveniently incompetent computerization effort for the less powerful, the ones in the high risk, low reward sector of the economy (not the salarymen). Another has been what sure looks like unsustainable borrowing. But eventually present consumption by definition has to come from present production, and that looks unsustainable, at least while keeping everyone at First World levels. Addressing AnimalMuppet's point a bit, a welfare state is incompatible with unrestricted immigration by people with low earning potential, as we're experiencing today. It makes the welfare state all the more unsustainable, and at least one side of the isle ought to be concerned that it noticeably strengthens capital's hand.
- jackgavigan 11y ago"They always thought there would be some other sucker to buy at an even higher price. Now we are returning to sanity." Great quote. It's interesting that stocks are up over the past couple of days, despite the fact that they're already at record highs. It'll be even more interesting to see what happens when the Fed starts unwinding its QE bond holdings.
- Hermel 11y agoRising interest rates make it unattractive to hold long-term bonds. For example, when interest rates jump from 3% to 4%, the net present value of 10-year bond drops by 10%. So as soon as investors believe that the turning point has come, the rational reaction is to sell bonds, amplifying the raise in interest rates even more. But where will they put that money instead? Letting it sit around in cash is not a wise idea because oftentimes, rising interest rates come hand in hand with inflation. Your best bet is to buy something of "real" value, be it gold, real estate, or stocks. In my opinion, this could explain the growing divergence between stocks and bonds. At least for a while, I would expect this to continue and stocks to go up with bonds falling, or at least stocks not fall as much as bonds. Then again, it is very hard to predict such things.
- mrfusion 11y agoBut according to the fed model [1] stock prices decline when interest rates rise. How do you account for that? [1] http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Fed_model http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Fed_model
- typedweb 11y agoPeople are less willing to borrow money to buy stocks at higher interest rates.
- blahblah3 11y agoIt depends on the real interest rate. Suppose you buy a long term bond yielding 5%, inflation was 2%. Now rates of bonds w/ comparable maturity and credit go up to 7% and inflation goes up to 4%. Your bond is going to be worth a lot less now, but stocks could be (in reality not necessarily...) more robust to this change.
- nhaehnle 11y agoNitpick: What's with those charts trying to predict economic quantities such as debt ratios for decades into the future (as the last chart in the article does)? Such predictions are entirely impossible, and their only conceivable purpose is to mislead the reader. There should be some kind of media best practices against that sort of thing. (Speculation about the far future is fine, but then your visualizations have to make it entirely obvious how uncertain the future is, by showing the full range of scenarios and how wildly they always differ.)
- mipapage 11y agoI would be grateful is someone could turn this into lower-level language!
- igravious 11y agoSeconded! Something bad is happening or is about to happen. But for the life of me I couldn't tell you what it is or what the ramifications both globally and locally are. Is he basically saying that the shit is about to get real? If so, what is the shit? edit: apologies for swearing, but I thought it was appropriate here given the _very_ strong language of the article. And I hate using/(being subjected to) aster*sks.
- Kluny 11y agoI am also waiting for a well informed adult to give us a summary. But from what I know of the bond market, bonds have been trading at an absurdly low rate for the past 20 years or so (please correct me if I'm wrong). This is an overdue correction, and is definitely bad for some people who have taken out an irresponsible number of bonds. But, possibly, will be very good for bond investors? I think?
- igravious 11y agoAnd please correct me if I am wrong but when you own a bond someone owes you money. Thus the low rate of interest. (Very low risk vouchsafed by nation states.) If bond rates start going up then...? Bad for governments looking to finance services? As you can see, I'm really trying to understand from whence the article's tone. Who's gonna get burnt? Probably Joe Schmoe again, huh.
- Kluny 11y agoCorrect, I should have said "issued an irresponsible number of bonds", not "taken out". And yes, I would also like to know who gets burnt. It isn't very clear.
- fauigerzigerk 11y ago
- tveita 11y agoStrong language for a piece of financial news. > ... crash ... horribly wrong ... clear warnings ... catching fire ... vengeance ... violent ... epicentre ... horribly wrong ... drama ... capitulation ... a lot of pain ... crash ... accident ... hammer ... crushing force ... shock ... vigilantes ... Looks well set up to trigger sentiment analysing trader bots.
- elcct 11y agoYour comment is even better set up. I can imagine in future articles will have "(bots ignore)" in the articles ;)
- hga 11y agoAmbrose Evans-Pritchard has been accurately described as "never the calmest man in a room", so the first cut of such a bot would be really simple ^_^. Seriously, he's been lots of fun to read since the start of the Clinton administration, but after a while you learn to apply a mental filter. For that matter, much of the British press is way more ... passionate than ours, that's one of its charming qualities. Along with oddities like the tabloid Daily Mail doing a lot of good reporting along with the celebrity articles, often better for US events than US media.
- crdoconnor 11y ago>the tabloid Daily Mail doing a lot of good reporting Pardon?
- hga 11y agoSeriously! In the example I'm best acquainted with, the 2011 Joplin, Missouri tornado, their early reporting was as good as anyone from the outside. In my personal photo gallery http://www.ancell-ent.com/1715_Rex_Ave_127B_Joplin/images/ http://www.ancell-ent.com/1715_Rex_Ave_127B_Joplin/images/ the before and after pictures of my apartment complex at the end were grabbed from the Daily Mail. (EDITED from Daily Mirror.) In general, in events where photos matter they're really good, and their copy, once you filter out the "passion" as I put it above is pretty good, especially since they don't overly try to force things into irrelevant narratives. More straight reporting than US we pretend to be objective "journalism". I suggest you try them a few times when a "breaking" event happens, e.g. a hostage situation.
- pjc50 11y agoA story about a global "bond crash" that only appears in the Telegraph? The Telegraph which is bought and paid for by HSBC?
- ExpiredLink 11y agoBen Bernanke: Why are interest rates so low? https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=9289612 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=9289612
- tootie 11y agoBad week to buy a mortgage.
- AnimalMuppet 11y agoIf you mean as an investor that you buy someone's existing mortgage, yes, it probably is a bad week to do so - unless you get it at a discount. If you mean, buy a house using a mortgage, though, it's a great week to have done so - if you had a lock on last week's or last month's rate. It still might be a good time to do so. And if you haven't refinanced and have a high rate, well, it looks like that ship is just about to sail. Do it now if it makes sense, because you won't have the opportunity to do so much longer...
- dpc_pw 11y agoRaising interest rate will limit number of people that can/are willing to take a mortgage, which will limit the demand, which will make house prices to go down. Raising interest rate will limit the investments, jobs, salaries, which will make more people default on their houses. Which will boost the above effect. So yeah, you can buy a house for X, with a nice tiny interest rate, but your house soon might be worth 3/4 * X or even 1/2 * X. The time to take mortgages is when rates are being lowered, not when their being raised. The rate itself is not very important. When interest rates are high, the prices are lower. When interest is lower the prices are higher. It's the dynamic (change in interest rate) that is important. You want the person you can sell the house to, be able to pay you more than you paid. * Note, I'm not an expert, I might be wrong. This is not a investment advise.
- AnimalMuppet 11y agoYeah, the effect you describe is very real. It's because the demand price curve for houses is set by the monthly payment, not by the total price, and the monthly payment depends on both the price and the interest rate. So what you ideally would like to do is buy when the interest rates are high (and prices low), then refinance as the rates drop, and get both lower payments and increased total value. But rates aren't going to drop for quite a while, so now what do you do? It seems to me that prices are low for how low the rates are, so buying is still (to me) a reasonable decision. > * Note, I'm not an expert, I might be wrong. This is not a investment advise. Ditto. Also note that I already own a house, so I'm not taking my own advice, either.