5 ms·
Rental America: Why the poor pay $4,150 for a $1,500 sofa (2014)
- w1ntermute 11y ago> Their decision to spring for a new sofa set was, if anything, a bet on the most optimistic arc for their family. Donald was getting regular work, sometimes making $500 in a week..The love seat and sofa retailed, together, for about $1,500. Why exactly is a family with a maximum of $25,000/year in (unreliable) income buying a new sofa that costs $1,500 upfront? I make more than 4x what they do in reliable income and have no dependents, yet I got my sofa $300 used on Craigslist. These people need to learn some basic personal finance.
- deleted 11y ago[deleted]
- devindotcom 11y agoNobody wants to buy items for amounts two or three times what they’d cost at a retail store. But when Abbott did her shopping in February, she didn’t have the money to make even a small lump-sum payment for anything of decent quality, even on Craigslist. She couldn’t buy via a layaway plan; Wal-Mart offers that option only during the holiday season. Perhaps she could have saved up the money on her own, but whenever she has tried to do so, her stash has been wiped out to handle daily needs. “Rent-to-own was basically all we could do,” Abbott, 33, said. Yeah, I wouldn't do it either, but I'm not in their shoes and I don't need that $150 this week to make rent. Meanwhile an entire industry is built that preys on people for whom this seems a good option. They're poor and they're misinformed - that sucks. And people make bad decisions all the time. But let's save our derision for the company gleefully charging a poor family four grand for a couch.
- baddox 11y agoI still don't get it. If they're paying $150 a week to finance the nice couch, why not stick it out for two weeks without a couch and buy the $300 one on craigslist?
- cbhl 11y agoMy parents just took old couches in off the street, for the cost of dragging it down the street and up the stairs. But when you're poor, you're more self-conscious about these things. What happens when your six-year-old son/daughter brings over their friends to play? Will they get made fun of for the old couch? What if there are hair lice in it? What if the kid gets hurt from it collapsing, and you have to take them to the doctor (which will cost hundreds out of pocket)? There are all sorts of irrational fears praying on the people in this situation.
- kubiiii 11y agoSpot on I think. But are those fears 100 % irrational? Weatlthy people can build their own furniture with old wood skids, their neighbours will never raise an eyebrow. Try doing that if you are poor. You'll get child protection in no time.
- steve19 11y ago"So Abbott and her husband walked into Buddy’s this past winter, hoping to replace the old sofa in their trailer, six years old, its wiring poking through the bottom, cutting gashes into the living room floor." The easy and cheap option if you have springs poking into the floor is buy a sheet of MDF for $9.25[0] and a 20" hand saw for $20 (or less) [1] and the spring-destroying-the-floor problem is fixed for under $30. It breaks my heart that these folks are so financially illiterate that they dig themselves into such terrible debt. [0] http://www.homedepot.com/p/Unbranded-1-8-in-x-4-ft-x-8-ft-S2S-MDF-Tempered-Hardboard-127320/202820158?N=5yc1vZbtn1 http://www.homedepot.com/p/Unbranded-1-8-in-x-4-ft-x-8-ft-S2... [1] http://www.homedepot.com/p/Stanley-20-in-Saw-20-029L/100243233 http://www.homedepot.com/p/Stanley-20-in-Saw-20-029L/1002432...
- brandonbloom 11y agoThese companies are despicable, for sure, but they couldn't exist without a long line of poor suckers. Both parties are clearly at fault in different ways, but we can fix the problem without ignoring the poor or inventing significant new and complex laws to clamp down on bad actors: We invest in education. When we have another sub-prime style meltdown we need to bail the economy out of, we're going to be wishing we invested in our schools and added basic life skills such as personal finance to the lesson plans. It's certainly cheaper to bailout schools than financial institutions. Anything else will fix a symptom, not cure the disease.
- nsxwolf 11y agoHow many times can someone make this mistake? It sounds like a good lesson the first time it happens. At some point, you learn to go on Craigslist and get a decent used couch (and fumigate it for bedbugs). Having classes to teach people this in public schools sounds really condescending. Poor people can't be so stupid that they can't even learn from their own mistakes.
- brandonbloom 11y agoMany people do learn from their first mistake like this, but 1) there are always more fools and 2) for many, it's unrecoverable As for the condescension: let kids test out. We really ought to abolish this entire notion of a class moving between grades together at the same pace, it's arcane.
- mc32 11y agoSometimes people get overexcited and only see the upside of things. I.e. I just got a job, hey, I got money, I can spend some. It's normal, albeit, shortsighted thinking. So, while I would scout for a used sofa, desk, etc... I'd splurge on a nice dinner with friends when I probably should have held back a bit. The other thing, is there is this psychological oppression where people feel obliged to act like others in society. So you think in relative terms rather than absolute. If Jane has a new computer, well, so should I --even if there is no reason the three year old system is insufficient. Keeping up appearances is a hell of a drug, to paraphrase.
- acveilleux 11y agoBecause they can't do any cash payments for any kind of sofa. But they just about thought they might be able to afford 40$ a week on this: http://www.buddyrents.com/linebacker-power-sofa-reclining-love.html http://www.buddyrents.com/linebacker-power-sofa-reclining-lo... Of course, that's with a 100 week term for a total of 4000$. America values material possessions a lot and when you're actually poor, you can't afford any. Places like this dangle small "affordable" amounts to people who can't do the math. And a big part of why they might not do that math is shame.
- leftnode 11y agoThey'll get right on that when they're barely getting by week by week. Between the mental exhaustion of crippling poverty combined with physical exhaustion from working incredibly demanding jobs, there's not a lot of time to learn personal finance. Not to mention, there's just not a lot of resources to do so for the poor. Wheres the disdain for predatory companies who prey on that susceptibility?
- rosser 11y agoThese people... In my experience, pretty much anything anyone ever has ever said that starts with those two words can be dismissed out of hand. EDIT: It's called hyperbole. But when you couple a "these people" with some sweeping, judgmental pronouncement about how the people in question are doing something stupid, wrong, immoral, &c, it becomes radically less so, and quickly.
- baddox 11y agoIt's two words of extremely basic English. How would you refer to a specific set of humans?
- sliverstorm 11y agoIn my experience, any statement that starts with "It's" can safely be ignored. ;)
- rosser 11y agoMaybe with a little bit less obvious disdain for the people you're talking about?
- chair6 11y agoSomewhat relevant, also on the subject of "These People"... http://m.youtube.com/watch?v=NBLUU42FW0E http://m.youtube.com/watch?v=NBLUU42FW0E
- msie 11y agoI "love" how a guy making 4x with no children is giving advice to people making a lot less WITH children. Completely different worlds.
- bliti 11y agoMy friend, I hope you never get dealt the same hand they got. It's not life, but merely surviving.
- mikekchar 11y ago> Normal families have sofas, she says, and you’ll do what it takes to feel normal. "Normal" families buy new things too. "Normal" families don't scrimp and save just so they can have chairs to sit on, and beds to sleep in. Interestingly, I neither have chairs in my apartment nor a bed. Nobody thinks I'm "abnormal" in this respect because I live in Japan. It is a bit strange that I work from home, program on an end table I borrowed from my mother-in-law and I sit on a stool that I bought for about $15 (admittedly new). But I started using that 6 months ago thinking I would upgrade when I needed to. Surprisingly I haven't needed to. The expectation of "normality" is what is killing the poor. This is based on your culture. You need a bed. You need a sofa. You need a kitchen table. You need an oven. You need a car. You need a sensible desk to work on. You need a special work chair. You need cable television. None of these things are actually needed in most cases. Possibly a person needs one or two of these things in specific cases, just like I need a computer to do my job. I don't have any of the things listed above and I'm not poor by any stretch of the imagination. My life seems perfectly "normal" to me. Without trying to sound superior (which is really difficult because probably I am unconsciously feeling that way), the skills you need to live happily on a very, very low income are probably the same skills you need to have to make (and keep) a lot of money.
- reagency 11y agoYour last sentence doesn't really make sense. Plenty of rich people buy plenty of frivolous things
- mikekchar 11y agoI had to think about your 2 sentences for a long time before I decided that you are right. The top 10% of income earners make $113,799 per year in the USA. The number of people I've seen who can earn that amount of money and burn through it all is astounding. I personally even know people who can spend that kind of money and even need to look for food handouts at the end of the month. I suppose what I meant is that if you can live happily on $10K per year, then probably it will be very easy for you to get and maintain employment for a lot more. As well as meeting people who can burn through money at a ferocious rate, I've met (much fewer) people who can live happily in what most Americans would call poverty. Those people always seem to have much more money than they need. It takes rare skills to live like that. The end result is that the poor have very little chance of bootstrapping themselves out of poverty (because if they could, they already would).
- Veratyr 11y agoIt gets worse: > They were perpetually behind with their Buddy’s installments and had taken to skipping one week and then catching up, with a $5 late fee rolled in. To make matters worse, those payment trips to Buddy’s put them eye to eye with more temptations. One week, they added a smartphone to their order. Another week, some Samsung speakers. And suddenly, the weekly payments to Buddy’s were $110. And more: > By midday that Thursday, $51 of the $230 had already vanished, used for gas and cigarettes They're already on the edge financially, to the point where even eating healthily is an issue yet they still buy cigarettes and add even more monthly payments for unnecessary technology. Basic life skills like budgeting, saving money, paying taxes and controlling your debt really need to be taught in schools. Maybe add it to math. Teaching math with practical lessons benefits everyone.
- Aloha 11y agoIf you don't live in a major city, a 300 dollar craigslist sofa is nearly a nonexistent thing.
- redblacktree 11y agoNonsense. If not craigslist, then a yard sale. If not that, a thrift store. You can certainly do better than buying new.
- x5n1 11y agoWhy do the rich get a better interest rate than the poor?
- NeutronBoy 11y agoInterest rate tends to reflect the risk of investment. Rich people are less risky to lend money to than poor people.
- x5n1 11y agoIt was meant to be a rhetorical question. But yes this is generally true. But they can afford the interest rate much less than rich people (poor people).
- NeutronBoy 11y agoAh, I wondered if you were serious or not. But yes, it's another one of life's cruel injustices that helps money beget money
- joevandyk 11y agoWhat someone can afford doesn't necessarily affect the price.
- Natsu 11y agoWhat really affects the price is what someone's best alternative is. If you have no alternatives, you get exploited.
- _nedR 11y agoThe power of compound interest works both ways. For the rich, It can mean a spiral upwards, as they can exploit the difference in interest rates of different investments to make profit. For the poor, it often means a spiral downwards into greater debt, more frequent defaults and ever higher interest rates.
- vecinu 11y ago
- bruceb 11y agoThese center have to deal with the risk of destruction, bed bugs, etc. They also allow renters to return an item. It's not surprising they have prices. I can't really fault them. Not sure whey these people just don't buy used furniture.
- bbcbasic 11y agoThe business model is aimed squarely at exploitation. It is a cynical way to make money. However perfectly legal and profitable, and they have expenses too so I guess we must say it is OK.
- acveilleux 11y agoIf they get more then 25 weeks of payments in the useful life of the object, they are ahead of the yuppy stores I sometime buy furniture on instalments from. The difference is that the yuppy store I buy from do 0% financing (by eating their own margin to cover the lender's take) and I do instalments strictly because I get the use of the money for free. Obviously, the difference is that my "hourly" wage is a lot better then minimum wages and I've demonstrated that I'm credit worthy over the last 16 years I've had access to credit.
- ComputerGuru 11y agoThese people are making 250-500/week/family, which isn't a lot obviously, but also isn't so little as to be permanently destitute - provided you're not signing away your income with stupid things like this run by dirtbags claiming to be serving the lower-income population. If you spend it right, you can get out of spiraling debt and save up for a better future, even with only 1000-2000 monthly income - but not while "lucrative" options like these tempt you into getting a new phone and a new tv when you really can't afford it. It's hard to resist pointing out the obvious without sounding cruel and harsh, but regardless of what's fair and what's not, it's never right to spend outside of your means. That 1500 sofa sure does look nice and comfy, but you're trading away any chance at escaping your life in a trailer park if you buy it on a 1000/month salary - and that's without the 300% interest rate. The problem is, stupidity in spending isn't restricted to a specific subset of the population. It's the reason why blue collar workers, white collar employees, lawyers, doctors, engineers, everyone can fall victim to credit card debt and wind up bankrupt and with nothing - even (or perhaps, especially) multimillionaire sports stars. You'll never have enough to own everything you see, but America makes it easy to obtain it anyway. A better car, a bigger house, a nicer education - just sign here, and it's yours! Edit: yes, it's really (technically) possible to persevere and save your way out of even the most meager of salaries, even when opportunities are withheld from those that need it most. This article, "only a constant factor worse than optimal," written by someone that I suspect might be the smartest person I've ever encountered, illustrates the secret: https://www.mail-archive.com/kragen-tol@canonical.org/msg00309.html https://www.mail-archive.com/kragen-tol@canonical.org/msg003...
- _nedR 11y agoThis sort of thing should be regulated. There is a line between healthy capitalism and crass exploitation of the poor by the rich. The poor and unaware need to be protected.
- bruceb 11y agoWhy does this need to be regulated? This isn't gouging on a need for medicine or food. Having is $1500 couch isn't a necessity. This business provides a good service. Decently nice furniture you can rent and return. It says how much the total cost is if you rent weekly until you own it.
- toomuchtodo 11y agoThey're essentially a payday lender for furniture. That's why they need to be regulated.
- bruceb 11y agoNot really. Pay day lenders lend money to people who are desperate as they need some money right now. These people are buying a $1500 sofa when there are used alternatives readily available.
- toomuchtodo 11y agoIf people don't need the furniture, then furniture rental stores should have no problem being regulated under the same usury laws that govern financial institutions, right?
- bane 11y agoAs I found out when I was poor, the $0 alternative is to just sit on the floor.
- _nedR 11y agoSo for corporate America, It's basically open season on the misinformed and undereducated poor? This sounds a lot like predatory lending - There is a good chance, the retailer is counting on these people to default so that they can sell the couch at 1000$ retail to the next gullible person who walks in. EDIT: I am not saying this should be illegal. Clearly, Buddy's is offering a useful service to people who are turned away by other establishments. But there needs to be some regulation. You shouldn't be able to charge $4500 for a 1500$ couch.
- joe_the_user 11y agoWell, As they say, it's a particular segment of poor. I personally shop at thrift stores and take hand-me-downs. I buy cheap laptops and load Linux. But all this takes time. The three-part-time job segment of workers can't do that and winds-up in the arms of these people. It almost makes that third job worthless - the problem is people want a lifestyle where they feel middle class.
- gscott 11y agoThere is a portion of the rich who do this too. When Michael Jackson died, his family came and went to take some of the furniture but had to bring it back. Apparently it was rented.
- sergiotapia 11y agoI'm sorry but I've been dirt broke, with family (wife n kids). I'm talking about making the choice between buying bubble gum and having enough to pay the bus fare home. Never in a million years would I buy brand new furniture, ipads, god damn -speakers-, if I were that broke again. Food, rent and utilities comes first. Priorities people. So these business are not really preying on desperate people, but stupid people with poor impulse control.
- Natsu 11y agoThe one tends to beget the other in a downward spiral, though. And usurious practices don't really help matters.
- anigbrowl 11y agoa used 32-gigabyte, early model iPad costs $1,439.28, paid over 72 weeks. As you say, a business like this preys on stupid people. They are trying to be thrifty but have no idea how much things should cost or how to handle more than minimal amounts of cash. It's pure exploitation.
- gatsby 11y agoPrevious discussion: https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=8471786 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=8471786 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=8473541 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=8473541
- mc32 11y agoThere should be greater regulation for what is essentially usury. Second, home economics needs to be drilled more throughout school. From elementary to highschool. Get kids versed in everyday economics. Many are practically illiterate with regard to home ec. Brainwash them, instill the notion of managing money more productively throughout schooling so it becomes second nature. The cold reality of economics could even have the secondary effect of 'scaring' (rather bring reality to light) into taking their education seriously. As opposed to, my parents make me go, I'd rather drop out, school isn't for me --a mentality I saw when growing up. Maybe kids are wiser these days.
- devindotcom 11y ago“The reason that the rich were so rich, Vimes reasoned, was because they managed to spend less money. Take boots, for example. He earned thirty-eight dollars a month plus allowances. A really good pair of leather boots cost fifty dollars. But an affordable pair of boots, which were sort of OK for a season or two and then leaked like hell when the cardboard gave out, cost about ten dollars. Those were the kind of boots Vimes always bought, and wore until the soles were so thin that he could tell where he was in Ankh-Morpork on a foggy night by the feel of the cobbles. But the thing was that good boots lasted for years and years. A man who could afford fifty dollars had a pair of boots that'd still be keeping his feet dry in ten years' time, while the poor man who could only afford cheap boots would have spent a hundred dollars on boots in the same time and would still have wet feet. This was the Captain Samuel Vimes 'Boots' theory of socioeconomic unfairness.” ― Terry Pratchett, Men at Arms: The Play
- mrmagooey 11y agoYou exploit peoples interest or addiction to various chemical substances and they devote entire government departments to chase you down, but you exploit peoples interest or addiction to the latest consumer products and you might get some tax breaks.
- xname 11y agoA month ago, I went into a furniture store, the salesman kept saying the store provide "financing" over and over, even I never asked him about "financing". I knew this is their way to trick stupid people, because many stupid people see a $1000 item (with a $100 payment per week) as a $100 item.
- cbhl 11y agoOne of the things that boggles my mind is the disparity between the following two scenarios: - when an American wins the lottery: they spend the money, get a temporary increase in happiness, then it drops back down - GiveDirectly gives an extremely poor person a few hundred dollars: they spend it on things that improve their earnings and reduce their hunger How can both of these things happen in the same world?
- sliverstorm 11y agoPerhaps few American lottery winners have been nearly as poor as GiveDirectly recipients? Many of the GiveDirectly recipients I've read about are so poor they spend the money on things like sheet metal roofs for their houses (to replace the thatch) so they don't leak and fall apart in a year. That's a level of poverty much of the American poor don't have to contend with- it's been a hundred years since many Americans had dirt floors, and many more than that since many American houses were thatchtops.
- dragonwriter 11y agoLotteries are sold with images of near magical life transformation, and those who pkay -- and thus win -- are disproportionately people with unrealistic expectations of what lottery winnings will provide, and therefore lotteries select for winners who will blow their winnings. GiveDirectly, and similar cash aid programs, generally do not have that kind of perverse selectivity.
- menssen 11y agoDoes the fact that this article is at the top of the front page say something about our discomfort that the extreme boundaries of our community are still the top 25% of this country's economy? (Upvoted to express how much I care.+) + sad joke
- bane 11y agoI grew up relatively poor, but have managed to work my way out of it. The reasons behind being poor and staying poor are complex. But one of the common themes is basically poor impulse control, and growing up seeing more examples of this than examples of what good impulse control looks like can be profoundly influential. When my wife and I were first married we were among the poorest I've ever been. We had a very small, very spare apartment, and I wanted a couch...bad, because it seemed that we needed one. My wife (who grew up in a fairly wealthy family) simply put her foot down and we simply sat on the floor for the first two years. It kind of sucked, but there was at least one-time where the money we would have spent on a couch ended up keeping a roof over our heads and she was proven correct. The friends I grew up with, who remain poor, struggle to make rent, but have top of the line smart phones with expensive plans, buy new furniture constantly, have apartments full of sports memorabilia or expensive knife and sword collections and so on. Many of them have buried themselves into MMOs, often paying for multiple accounts and multiple computers to use them with. I know people who got into a local college, decided not to pay the tuition so they could instead outfit themselves in head-to-toe suits of armor so they could walk around the local Renaissance festivals, and then lost the entire suit when they couldn't pay the bill on the self-storage place they were storing it all in.