7 ms·
> Metal is coming to Mac, paving the way for new levels of realism and detail in games and other apps. I'm guessing this is yet another API like Mantle/Vulkan
by zamalek 11y ago
> Metal is coming to Mac, paving the way for new levels of realism and detail in games and other apps.
I'm guessing this is yet another API like Mantle/Vulkan that is also seated comfortably in the Apple walled garden and increases the development costs: awesome!
- acdha 11y agoYes, but unlike either of those it's in widespread production use (Mantle is still beta, Vulkan was just announced). It shipped last year on iOS 8 – this is just the expected next step of offering it on OS X as well: https://developer.apple.com/metal/ https://developer.apple.com/metal/
- zamalek 11y agoRight, that makes sense. However the desktop dev market is a completely different beast when compared to mobile - it's been a hard enough (and un-won) battle digging DX out. The chances of Apple pulling off what Khronos couldn't are slim - in my opinion. If I were Apple the best I'd hope for is their mobile games porting over to OSX. However, with the added performance of desktop is Metal really needed? If it works on a tablet I'd say there's a fantastic chance it would work on desktop with mere OpenGL.
- cwyers 11y ago> The chances of Apple pulling off what Khronos couldn't are slim - in my opinion. Apple has a large and loyal customer base, and it's typically people who are willing to spend money on apps and games for their devices. Apple doesn't have to try and satisfy a bunch of legacy CAD vendors who don't care about consumer 3D graphics at all. And when Apple announces Metal, they don't mean they have a spec, they have an implementation that is going to have a significant installed base in under a year. They have a lot of advantages Khronos doesn't.
- leoc 11y agoOS X has a lot going for it, but when it comes to the desktop gaming market it's just not the top dog in revenue generation that iOS is for mobile apps. I'd assume (not an expert) that Vulkan's support from Intel, nVidia and AMD on PC could mean more to professional game developers and publishers than Metal's OS X support.
- cwyers 11y agoI don't think there's going to be a major game developer that supports OpenGL/Vulkan on Windows over DirectX, outside of perhaps Bethesda/iD. If Vulkan isn't present on the second-most used desktop OS, and it's not best-of-breed on the operating system used on over 90% of desktops, I don't see where it makes major inroads on the desktop.
- leoc 11y agoValve is certainly interested in Vulkan, partly as a means to target Chinese Dota players running Windows XP. Even a second-place position on PC may amount to more than star status on OS X. (Though OTOH the relatively easy port could draw people looking for some extra income for their iOS game.) (In any case, is it yet certain that Apple won't support Vulkan on OS X? It wouldn't have been ready for El Capitan's launch this Autumn regardless. Maybe Apple will try to deprecate it (in the non-technical sense) as a compatibility option but support it anyway?)
- cwyers 11y agoValve is an oversight, yeah -- I did mention them in another comment here. I don't really think of them as a game developer anymore, but I'm probably being unfair. If Apple supports Vulkan but with worse drivers than Metal, I'm not sure that's any better. OSX has roughly four times the penetration of Linux in the latest Steam hardware and software survey. I'm not sure it's worth it for most developers to deliberately target the second-best choice on OS X in order to pick up the handful of Linux gamers who can't/won't dual-boot Windows.
- acdha 11y agoJust because something works now doesn't mean it wouldn't be preferable to have the performance to fully support a 5K display or consistently run at higher frame rates and/or on a higher quality level. Developers increasingly treat iOS as a must-have platform but OS X hasn't hit that level. In particular, many games are ported but noticeably slower than the same game running on Windows. This seems like an easy way to avoid requiring a bunch of OpenGL-specific tuning which wouldn't be needed for either iOS/Metal or Windows/DirectX and will thus not be a priority for many studios.
- corysama 11y agoFYI: Mantle is probably never going to go widespread public in any meaningful way. AMD is going to focus on DX12 and Vulkan instead. https://community.amd.com/community/gaming/blog/2015/05/12/on-apis-and-the-future-of-mantle https://community.amd.com/community/gaming/blog/2015/05/12/o...
- emsy 11y agoYou probably won't use it yourself. You'll use Unity or UT4 which uses Metal under the hood.
- zamalek 11y ago> You'll use Unity or UT4 which uses Metal under the hood. Why do I have to use those engines?
- pjmlp 11y agoAs anyone in the industry knows, either you make a game engine or a game.
- gambiting 11y agoWell not necessarily. I work in a large games studio for one of the largest publishers in the world, and pretty much all of our games are made using our own engines. No Unity or UT in sight. But working on those engines is a huge part of every project, it wouldn't be possible if we didn't have hundreds of programmers working on it.
- pjmlp 11y ago> But working in those engines is a huge part of every project, it wouldn't be possible if we didn't have hundreds of programmers working on it. Yes, but was my point. I just oversimplified it. Without a big team, resources are soaked up developing the engine, as so many Gamasutra Postmortens testify.
- phn 11y agoThere are plenty of successful studios that have their own in-house engines. Naughty Dog, From Software, ex Kojima Productions... Besides, for simple games, using those engines are a huge overhead and an unnecessary cost. I understand what you're saying, but I don't like how you make it sound a simple, already-made-for-you decision, when reality is much more nuanced. Each case is a case, and no one should turn down their critical sense when making these decisions, there are no rules.
- pjmlp 11y agoMost studios use middleware and there is zero support for OpenGL in game consoles anyway[0]. So it looks like Apple is saying goodbye to OpenGL, given that all their accelerated rendering has been moved over to Metal, at least from the keynote presentation. [0] No sane studio ever bothered with PSGL on the PS3, the only console ever supporting an OpenGL variant.
- sz4kerto 11y agoI think this benefits DirectX 12.
- pjmlp 11y agoThis benefits game engines in general. I fail to see why it would favour only DX 12. Apple saved OpenGL from extinction when it was chosen as the iOS 3D API, as the API never had a foothold on game consoles. Apparently now they are done with it and with no plans on adopting Vulkan.
- wrl 11y agoDo you have a source for "no plans on adopting Vulkan"? Apple is definitely on the Vullkan working group (logo is part of the image at the bottom of https://www.khronos.org/vulkan https://www.khronos.org/vulkan).
- pjmlp 11y agoIt is a gut feeling from an old dog that has seen corporations change their stances in technology too many times. Why adopt Vulkan given their investment in Metal, to the point that they have moved their accelerated 2D stack to Metal. What is the point to rewrite it again for Vulkan? Even if they adopt Vulkan, most likely would be a layer on top of Metal. As for being in the group, Sony is also and they don't use OpenGL on their consoles.
- izacus 11y agoAnd it's 40% faster! .... Of course they forgot to mention that OGL drivers on OS X were about 30% slower than OGL/DX drivers on Windows on the same hardware running same scene. So instead of updating their OpenGL 3D performance they just kept it back and now you're forced to use a proprietary walled garden API for full performance. This kind of behaviour makes me really really sorry to be an Apple customer :/
- rimantas 11y ago> This kind of behaviour makes me really really sorry to be > an Apple customer :/ Well, don't be then. I don't get this cry about walled gardens. Feel free to roam in the jungle if you don't like them.
- izacus 11y agoWell, I already do own a Mac and I actually like using it. Are you telling me I'm not allowed to be annoyed and complain about having 3D performance crippled on the OS X as opposed to Windows? Are you telling me I'm not allowed to be annoyed about having to reboot my machine constantly to get the most of 3D performance? To borrow your words - I don't get why are you criticising me when I express opinion about a one aspect of the product. OS X / Mac combination isn't just 3D - I do like other aspects of the combination that I will not get on other machines. I don't get why would you like to take away my right to express opinion about scummy Apple practices.
- increment_i 11y agoDid they mention how far back the Mac line will support the new Metal api? I'm assuming it only supports relatively recent chips? Can't find any information on this.
- cwyers 11y agoI'm sure Valve is thrilled to see the largest OpenGL desktop OS abandoning OpenGL for their own API right now. Just thrilled to pieces.
- threeseed 11y agoI don't see where Apple said they were abandoning OpenGL. They just moved over to Metal for AppKit operations which naturally would always be faster than a common abstraction layer.
- cwyers 11y agoI'm sure OS X will retain its current support for OpenGL. But I think this means that Metal, not Vulkan, is going to be the equivalent to DX12 for OS X development.
- threeseed 11y agoI'm going to continue to get downvoted but oh well. Apple was always going to support Metal on OSX in order to allow for iOS apps to transition back. It would be stupid not to. That doesn't necessarily mean they are abandoning OpenGL. Just seems a little early to be getting the pitchforks out.
- kllrnohj 11y agoApple more or less abandoned OpenGL years ago. The state of OpenGL on OS X is a trainwreck. It's outdated by about 5 years. Just look at the supported version list: https://support.apple.com/en-us/HT202823 https://support.apple.com/en-us/HT202823 Note that there's a lot of hardware on that list that supports OpenGL 4.5 and indeed has drivers for that on other platforms but on OS X all top out at 4.1. That may not sound like a big deal, but OpenGL 4.3 brought full compatibility with GLES 3.0. That's a biggie if you're, say, an indie game dev that wants to do a cross-platform game that can span from mobile to desktop. And 4.5 brings the robustness support that allows for secure WebGL.
- 11y ago
- frik 11y ago(Metal is already in iOS8) For the first time in history we have OpenGL, OpenES and WebGL on all platforms including iOS8 and IE11. And then all these companies kiss the open APIs good bye by releasing all the proprietary next-gen APIs whereas the successor to OpenGL isn't even ready. So multiplatform will have to stick with OpenGL/OpenES/WebGL or bit the granite and code for several different APIs :( The WWDC announcements are great, don't get me wrong.