5 ms·
South Koreans triumph in US robot challenge
- MCRed 11y agoThis is just the beginning, both for robots and for asian dominance. Culture plays a huge role, and in our culture we're happy to watch Reality TV and let government babysit our kids. Government doesn't care about robot competitions. I assume in Korea but believe in general in asia, the parents are more on top of their kids, so that even if they have a "lower quality" government (Which is always debatable) in China, for instance, eventually we're going to be less and less the source of these kinds of technical advances over time. Hell, even if the chinese culture doesn't inspire creativity and achievement, just by demographics they should produce three times as many innovations as us, since if the innovative people are %0.1 of the population, they have three times the population.
- melling 11y ago"Government doesn't care about robot competitions." That was a DARPA competition they won.
- noobermin 11y agoWhich confuses me. I wasn't aware DARPA opened it's competitions to non-USA teams.
- nether 11y agoWell, now you're aware.
- noobermin 11y agoUnfortunately, it seems my comment was taken with an assumed connotation. I simply wasn't aware that DARPA opened it to any one outside of the US since, well, it's DARPA. It probably wasn't the most insightful comment in the world, but, yes--now I am aware.
- munin 11y agowhy wouldn't they?
- gdy 11y agoD is for Defense
- melling 11y agoNot a big deal. Do a little research instead of making assumptions. I found a German entry in the 2007 Grand Challenge: http://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/DARPA_Grand_Challenge_(2007)#National_Qualification_Event http://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/DARPA_Grand_Challenge_(2007)#...
- sho_hn 11y agoYes, parents do push kids quite hard in South Korea, because studying hard and getting into good schools are seen as plain necessary for success in life. But that doesn't necessarily mean the quality of education is fantastic -- a lot of the after-school classes kids get worked to death in are snake oil levels bad, and the teaching methods applied in the primary schools are often sub-par as well. Meanwhile many students suffer a great deal in that highly competitive pressure cooker, and it contributes to an unusually high teenage suicide rate for the country. Education and parenting are complex. Education is not as simple as quantity-does-the-trick, and parenting isn't as simple as applying pressure.
- adventured 11y agoYour entire premise is wrong. Japan has proven how easily an Asian giant can fall (just as easily as any other), how quickly they can lose their edge and stagnate. Demographics and the size of the population has absolutely no correlation to production in any regard. Pakistan has 182 million people; Nigeria has 173 million people. By your incorrect premise, Pakistan should produce ~55% as many innovations as the US, and Nigeria ~52%. Whoops, turns out it's a lot more complicated than having a lot of people.
- spb 11y agoWhenever I read Western diatribes about China now, I can only think of http://www.washingtonpost.com/opinions/for-american-pundits-china-isnt-a-country-its-a-fantasyland/2015/05/29/24ba60e0-0431-11e5-a428-c984eb077d4e_story.html http://www.washingtonpost.com/opinions/for-american-pundits-...
- digitalzombie 11y agoYour comment is just speculation. Currently the most nobel prize won and research papers published is USA. There are many areas that one can dominate, I'm unsure that Robotic is Asia as a whole continent and also when you mention Asia... Middle East and Russia can be consider Asia too. I'm not sure what you are comparing this to probably USA or Western countries but I don't think this comparison is useful at all cause of the generality. But this is just glass ball looking. Good job for Korea and I think it's good for the whole world if more and more countries gets better at things.
- x0054 11y agoWhy is it that after looking at this rather cool competition, and looking at all the cool technology that is coming out of it, you reduce it to "South Korea > USA?"
- Animats 11y agoThat was a big change in the standings since yesterday. IHMC and KAIST weren't even in the top 3 as of 5 PM yesterday. I thought Tartan Rescue had won.
- Animats 11y agoI get the feeling that nobody responding here watched the competition. Is there a forum where anyone is discussing this subject? Notes: - Everybody using the Atlas robot had stability problems. Nobody seemed to be outside of static stability (base of support under CG) let alone outside of ZMP stability (base of support under CG modified to account for momentum.) Any loss of balance meant a fall. They're probably using the basic DLL that Boston Dynamics provided to get teams going. (One team admitted this.) That has functions "walk slowly", and "stand maintaining balance using only joints from the hip and below", plus direct control of joints. Boston Dynamics has demonstrated much better locomotion control than that, but the teams didn't have access to it. (Boston Dynamics supplied the Atlas robots and thus could not compete.) IHMC was working on balance recovery [4] but didn't have it working in time. - This is the new Atlas robot, unveiled in January 2015. It's still mostly hydraulic, but it's now self-powered, with a big battery backpack. I think there's also a hydraulic accumulator in there, so they can recover some energy when running, but nobody at the event went fast enough to gain from that. Mechanically, that machine is far more capable than it appeared to be in the competition. It's quite capable of picking up objects from the ground, and getting up if it falls. Nobody did either in the competition. The teams only got these new robots around February, so they really haven't had the time to develop software to use them effectively. Right now, the hardware is much better than the software. - Everybody was doing their manipulation by almost pure teleoperation. As soon as DARPA introduced delays into the data links (which they do to penalize teleoperation), the robots spent most of their time stopped. The operators were stuck waiting for enough data to get through to update their screens. Not much autonomous operation here. Here's the winning team video, sped up about 30x.[2] Note that although it's capable of walking, it was run in kneeling wheel mode almost all the time. Only for the stair climbing did it walk. - Nobody had combined manipulation and locomotion working at all. That's why getting out of the vehicle was so hard - it takes coordinated leg and arm movements. - The CMU team had a partially tracked base, and the NASA/JPL team had a "monkey" robot with rollers at knees and elbows. They both did reasonably well. If you're going to teleoperate, a dumber, statically stable robot is easier to deal with. Of the top 3 finishers, only one used an non-wheeled robot, an Atlas. Here's their first run, with two falls.[3] Again, this is a 30x speedup. The penalty for a fall or a need for repair was only a 10 minute penalty, not disqualification. - The tasks were dumbed down twice during the project. The original specs called for the robots to have to replace a pump. The final competition only required turning a valve and cutting a hole in very soft material with a power drill. Basically, the tasks were reduced to the point that they were hard, but not so hard as to lead to total fail. - Schaft did better in the first round back in 2013, but after Google bought them, they were pulled from the competition. Google, remember, now owns Schaft, Boston Dynamics, and several other robotics companies. I look forward to the next competition. If work continues, in a year or two the results should be far better. [1] https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=27HkxMo6qK0 https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=27HkxMo6qK0 [2] https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=q_yfvlplJe0 https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=q_yfvlplJe0 [3] https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=vDXnlgNkRl4 https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=vDXnlgNkRl4 [4] https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=soPM7LddLY8 https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=soPM7LddLY8
- ckozlowski 11y agoTo the South Korean team: Congrats!
- fblp 11y agoFast motion video of the winning robot: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=q_yfvlplJe0 https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=q_yfvlplJe0 1min trailer of the winning robot: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=L4B5BhDoS9o https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=L4B5BhDoS9o