4 ms·
"Their findings are one of the main pieces of evidence used by the Intergovernmental Panel on Climate Change, which says global warming is a threat to humanity.
by ars 17y ago
"Their findings are one of the main pieces of evidence used by the Intergovernmental Panel on Climate Change, which says global warming is a threat to humanity."
So basically there is no evidence the earth is warming? Because evidence based on unreleased data is worthless.
If I can't reproduce your work, you are a crackpot (isn't that the definition of junk science?) I can't reproduce their work, so they are crackpots. (Or deliberate frauds.)
Did they even record their methodology on how they adjusted the numbers? Maybe we can undo that methodology?
If they didn't record even that, then they are incompetent. And I see no reason to pay attention to incompetents.
What if someone made a simple arithmetic error? Without the raw data, and the methodology of adjustment how could we ever know?
Their conclusions are worthless, and unless there are others (are there?), then there is no evidence the earth is warming.
- chez17 17y ago"So basically there is no evidence the earth is warming? Because evidence based on unreleased data is worthless." Unfortunately this is true. As someone who has never doubted that global warming was man made (yes, those last leaked emails were private conversations and held no smoking gun whatsoever. People were reading into one term used ten years ago to sex up a graph), this is embarrassing. This, more than any other thing has made me reconsider my views. The problem is that glaciers and polar ice are melting at unprecedented rates, this is unarguable. The earth is getting warming in those areas and it is effecting the sea levels and biodiversity of the planet. How do we tell if it's man made? What can we do to stop it? Remember this doesn't prove that global warming isn't real.
- timr 17y agoNo, it's not even remotely close to true. What happened here? They threw away their copy of the raw data. That data still exists (they gathered it from public repositories), and the methods of the paper describe what they did. You could reconstruct the results. Essentially, the "skeptics" are getting worked up over what amounts to throwing away the lab notebooks for a paper published two decades ago. Even if you assume malfeasance on the part of these authors (an assumption that does not appear to be justified), you'd have to disregard the results of thousands of other papers to leap to the (wild) conclusion that "there is no evidence the earth is warming."
- robotrout 17y agoOut of curiosity, why do you put the word skeptic in quotes? Do you imply that my skepticism is not genuine? Believe me, it's genuine. I'm no "skeptic", I'm a skeptic, proud and true. If what you say is true, that's really good. It's probably not true, judging from the comments in the source code, where the guy laments on his inability to verify the very existence of some of these stations. That's not to say the stations he wanted, didn't, at some point, probably exist, it's just that time passes and the world moves on, people retire, and filing cabinets go to the salvation army.
- timr 17y agoI put the word skeptic in quotes to denote the difference between scientists (who are already quite skeptical), and the people who employ fallacious "skeptical" arguments to advance a political agenda. I don't know to which group you belong (but then, I wasn't referring to you in my comment). Anyone who has spent any time around scientists knows them to be a conservative and naturally skeptical group of people. The "scientific establishment" -- if there is such a thing -- is powerfully opposed to new ideas. The climate change debate was a controversial new idea thirty years ago, but after three decades of research and debate, it's been as close to universally accepted as anything ever is in the world of science. The people who would have you believe that climate change is a conspiracy amongst rogue scientists either do not understand how science works, or are purposefully dissembling to advance their cause.
- robotrout 17y agofallacious "skeptical" arguments You're being a bit kind to yourself, don't you think? You're skeptical, as are those you agree with, but those you don't agree with are "skeptical". The climate change debate was a controversial new idea thirty years ago See, this revisionist stuff drives me crazy. 30 years ago, it was called "global cooling". Now, sophisticated punters call it "climate change", instead of the less sophisticated and more embarrassing flip-flop of "global warming". http://www.denisdutton.com/cooling_world.htm http://www.denisdutton.com/cooling_world.htm Just call it global warming and admit that 30 years ago, climatologists were wrong. Don't try to obfuscate their lack of perfection (nobody expects perfection anyway) with this "climate change" nonsense of "we knew it all along, see, we predicted climate change 30 years ago!"
- robotrout 17y agono evidence the earth is warming. Just a quick comment. The earth is definitely warming. We are exiting an ice-age. There has been a conscious effort, I believe, to equate global warming with man-made global warming. They are not the same thing, even if used interchangeably by the media. The "hockey stick" graph appears to shows that the earth is warming faster now than it was earlier. It's this "steeper slope" that we're debating, and that may have been manipulated. The general public, however, has had the debate obfuscated for them into "is it warming, or isn't it?"
- timr 17y ago"So basically there is no evidence the earth is warming?" If Darwin's original notebooks were lost, there would not cease to be evidence for evolution. There are many thousands of papers on climate change. A loss of the raw data sets for one paper does not change the conclusions drawn by the others.
- krschultz 17y agoNo, this is the set of raw data beneath the corrected data all the papers are based on. It isn't Darwin's notebook, it is the set of species that Darwin studied. If you removed all the fossils and a lot of the species and tried to prove evolution you'd be in the same ball park as what is going on here.
- timr 17y ago"No, this is the set of raw data beneath the corrected data all the papers are based on." No, it's not. First, no reputable journal allows re-publication of the same data set -- after thousands of publications, it's just silly to suggest that it's all based on the same data. Second, even if you don't believe that other scientists would prevent the re-publication of the same data, one only has to peruse the IPCC report to see that there's a lot more than just the "hockey stick" graph and computer models.