6 ms·
I don't disagree with Snowden's sentiment, and I know it's possible he didn't write the headline...but "The World Says No to Surveillance" is simplistic and ina
by danso 11y ago
I don't disagree with Snowden's sentiment, and I know it's possible he didn't write the headline...but "The World Says No to Surveillance" is simplistic and inaccurate.
The obvious rebuttal is "But China"...but beyond that, among the Western powers: France and Britain, among others. And Snowden acknowledges this (which is why I don't assume he wrote the headline, necessarily):
> Spymasters in Australia, Canada and France have exploited recent tragedies to seek intrusive new powers despite evidence such programs would not have prevented attacks. Prime Minister David Cameron of Britain recently mused, “Do we want to allow a means of communication between people which we cannot read?” He soon found his answer, proclaiming that “for too long, we have been a passively tolerant society, saying to our citizens: As long as you obey the law, we will leave you alone.”
Again, it's not that Snowden is wrong in his opinion about surveillance. But it's wrong to think that the world, or any kind of non-U.S.-status quo, is anti-surveillance. The battle is much more uphill than that and those who want to fight it have to keep that in mind.
- tanderson92 11y agoThe world's response is more than the aggregate will of the governments. To take your case of China, I would be wary of claiming that the people of that country are content with the surveillance state in which they live. Rather, they are an oppressed people, and the surveillance state does them no favor in this regard. Ed Snowden's larger point was about the public reaction to learning they were being surveilled; obviously, governments already knew whether they themselves were spying. In this sense I think the world has indeed said no to surveillance, it's just that in some cases the government doesn't wish to listen (well, not to that, just everything else!).
- tmalsburg2 11y agoA few years back, I visited China for a couple of weeks and I was pretty surprised by the people's opinion about the government and government actions that we in the west perceive as abhorrent. Short version: For most of the 20th century, China was in deep shit and bullied by almost anyone who felt like it. In the eyes of many Chinese people, the economic success and regained self-esteem justify almost any measure the government deems necessary. Even if that leads people to be ok with things that we might find horrible, I kind of see where they are coming from. Bottom line: as westerners we have no idea what the world looks like from the Chinese perspective. For many or most Chinese people, the current system doesn't stand for oppression but for the liberation from oppression. I'm sure my story is grossly oversimplified; Chinese readers, please correct me.
- wisty 11y agoNot Chinese, but I've lived there. A lot of people hate the government, but only in the same way many Americans hate the government. And you're right that they see the CCP as being reasonably good, compared to the alternatives they've had. In many ways, the central government is much better liked than the local / provincial governments, as they are the ones who clean up corruption when people complain. No-one likes internet filters (except for the "think of the children" crowd - the filters also block porn). But anyone who really cares can get a VPN, and most people just use puns or images to say things that would normally be filtered. Yes, you can be hauled to the police for a "tea chat" (literally a cup of tea, and a chat) if you're a popular blogger who is stepping on the wrong toes. But it's not like they're shooting people for dissent - the process is roughly: deleting posts, threats, contacting family / employers, eventually maybe house arrest, fines, prison, etc. Black arrests are typically internal party matters (e.g. corrupt officials), people protesting in person, organisers, and people going to a capital to petition a higher level of government (some local leader with gang-connections might try to keep people from petitioning his boss). What annoys the Chinese isn't free speech, per say. It's corruption, pollution, unsafe products, abuse of eminent domain, etc. And things like jobs, education, healthcare, and house prices - they've got a lot of problems, and free speech isn't the biggest one. Revolutions are expensive. It's a crap-shot whether you get real reforms, or a new strong-man (think Putin). Mostly, they want gradual reform, and that's what they tend to get.
- fineman 11y ago> But it's not like they're shooting people for dissent - the process is roughly: deleting posts, threats, contacting family / employers, eventually maybe house arrest, fines, prison, etc. Wow. Also, they do shoot people for dissent. Those who aren't cowed or jailed. > they've got a lot of problems, and free speech isn't the biggest one. Not the biggest, but one of the most central. You can't agitate for anything you need if speaking out is forbidden, and you can't organize if you're being monitored. > Revolutions are expensive. It's a crap-shot whether you get real reforms, or a new strong-man (think Putin). Very true.
- 11y ago
- ekianjo 11y ago> The world's response is more than the aggregate will of the governments. Certainly, but in France people are known to demonstrate and block the country when they are not happy with a particular Law or government plan. For surveillance, I am still waiting to see anyone protesting in the streets in any meaningful measure. That says a lot on how much actual people care.
- tajen 11y agoFrench people here. Agreed. There's always a syndicate for job-related topics or Christian-Homo things. There's no syndicate against surveillance yet. On the other hand, since the vote, it seems that the surveillance law became the top 1 example of how our politics betray us, where we used to quote corruption and lust, so people are well aware of a problem, in many different social classes.
- luckydude 11y agoHe's in marketing mode and that's what he should be doing. The reality is different but he's painting a picture of what should be happening and marketing that as if that is happening. I get it. Hacker news is full of engineers so they'll take issue, which is fine, they are also right. My feeling is Snowden++, he's doing a great job. It's going to be a long battle and he is helping a lot.
- ekianjo 11y agoThe Headline should rather be "A Few People Say No to Surveillance, while the Majority does not care and continues Business as Usual". His view of how much impact he has had is probably heavily biased. Although I think he did the right thing, there's still a LONG way to go.
- fineman 11y agoSure, the same majority who don't vote. The knife cuts both ways. If we say that things which aren't acknowledged by the majority don't count then pretty much every government is out.
- harry8 11y agoPick 10 people at random. "Do you want everything you do and say to be kept in a permanent record to be used by the current and any future government against you at their discretion." See if you can get even 1 who says yes, or "that's ok with me" May not say "no" loudly enough to be working yet. Don't mistake that for yes.
- ekianjo 11y agoYour question would never make it into any actual survey because it's so heavily biased the way you are asking it.
- kirsebaer 11y agoHow is it biased? This is the issue we are talking about.
- ekianjo 11y agoIt's biased if you force the answer on one side vs another.
- harry8 11y agoIf you don't mention that you have to trust all possible future governments, public servants and have absolute faith in their perfect competence your poll is shockingly biased because that is the actual thing we're holding opinions on. And nobody I know does have that level of trust and I'll lay dollars to donuts you don't either.
- harry8 11y agoThe obvious rebuttal is "But China"... This is just plain wrong, it's far from obvious. "But the tiny number of Chinese presently in power." That may be fair but you have zero idea or appreciation of the breadth of opinions or lack thereof of the population of China. Differential empathy. When he says "The world says no" I think he's right. I'm yet to meet someone who is in favour of everything they say to their friends, foes or just out loud taken down and kept in a database forever where it could be used against them at any point in their future or their children after they are gone by not just current, but all possible future powerful entities. After the revolution that your political enemies succeed at by force, they can use it against you. Really, absolutely nobody I have ever met wants that. Not one person. It's a sentiment that crosses politics, cultures, ethnicities, wealth you name it. The world says no.
- tajen 11y agoMy parents. My parents are annoyed that we're letting too many people in without a due visa. They are annoyed we let too many people steal in shops, destroy, menace, deal with mafia, organize children work in subways (preferrably children with malformations trying to play harmonica and beg). They want a clean country where more people respect the law, and they live in France where people are quite flexible with the rules, laws and exceptions. Therefore they would like the police to have more latitude to investigate. They think we should be lenient when police bashes someone, because they think too often people don't comply to police instructions and get away thanks to the law. They're ok with shutting down 3G metworks punctually "to avoid a mob" and prevent pictures from being uploaded in live. And they enjoy that the government can spy on citizen, so we can investigate on illegal networks. Of course they're wrong. But they exist.
- harry8 11y agoAnd they really think the government should have a store of everything they say and do they keep forever? Really?
- tajen 11y agoYes, really. (facepalm) Don't worry, I'm working on them. One argument is usually quite popular: Stories where policemen are caught using such tools to track their ex. Funny enough they're not generally afraid that police might be corrupted.