14 ms·
> "Privacy, above all other things, including safety and freedom from terrorism, is not where we want to go," Steinbach said. It's where I want to go. Also you
by joshstrange 11y ago
> "Privacy, above all other things, including safety and freedom from terrorism, is not where we want to go," Steinbach said.
It's where I want to go. Also you have YET to show ANY evidence that we are more safe or more free from terrorism by surrounding our rights to privacy.
>He also disputed the "back door" term used by experts to describe such built-in access points. "We're not looking at going through a back door or being nefarious," he argued, saying that the agency wants to be able to access content after going through a judicial process.
You mean "Rubber Stamp Judicial Process"? Even if you didn't the mere fact that these backdoors (you can rename it all your want it's a BACKDOOR) exist make the whole system LESS secure. What a clown and this is the AD of the FBI's Counterterrorism Division??? Fuck....
- zamalek 11y ago>show ANY evidence that we are more safe or more free from terrorism by surrounding our rights to privacy Wasn't FBI surveillance a thing during the Boston bombing? Since 9/11 have any attacks been prevented? If surveillance was a tool to prevent these attacks, why wasn't the surveillance authority (FBI) held directly responsible for the attacks? Anyone who would advocate surveillance would first need to be criminally prosecuted for the Boston bombing because at the time they had the information and ignored it. With-holding information from the law about crime or potential crimes is illegal.
- themeek 11y agoSurveillance was used, however, to identify and track the Boston Bombers, leading to death and capture, and parallel construction was used to create an unstoppable court case, leading to imprisonment and death sentencing. But you are right - these tools are not used merely to detect and stop terrorist activity. It is also used to track and stop ideas, to give leads and to give extremely powerful intelligence to the FBI, CIA, DIA, NCTC, etc whenever it is needed for some purpose. To those in power these capabilities are extremely powerful. The existence of these powers does not mean that they will be abused on a systematic level - though of course the potential is always there. One danger is that America's fight to remain relevant in a world that may be moving past it, it may turn ever more Fascistic. In this case, these are powers that would be extremely dangerous for the government to have. But take a step back to think about this. As citizens we are worried about the use of these capabilities to thwart the public. They are so powerful and so complete that we fear being subjects of its application - viscerally. To the extent that the good will and checks and balances have worked to keep the brunt of these capabilities aimed outside US borders there are people who do fear, and deserve to fear, the wrath of the US government - even those who might otherwise be innocents, bystanders, or casualties of the struggle for power. My heart goes out to these people stuck in the middle and it beats faster at the thought of being one myself.
- harshreality 11y ago"Surveillance", if you count confiscated video footage from the crime scenes, may have been used to identify, but not to track. Tamerlan died in a shootout after a police officer in Watertown noticed the stolen SUV and called it in. [edit: note there was some tracking of the hijacked SUV due to the owner's cooperation, but that's targeted tracking with cooperation, and not of the brothers themselves] Tsarnaev was apprehended after an ordinary citizen noticed someone hiding on his boat and called it in. The massive manhunt, whatever the intelligence apparatus contributed, the shutting down of Boston and suburbs... all accomplished pretty much nothing, other than conditioning people to get used to martial law, and an excuse to point guns at people[1] to cow them into submission. And what evidence at trial was unlikely to have been available except by parallel construction? The defense strategy was to admit the acts but argue he was brainwashed by his brother and shouldn't receive a death sentence. [1] https://ajmacdonaldjr.files.wordpress.com/2013/04/martial-law-boston.jpg https://ajmacdonaldjr.files.wordpress.com/2013/04/martial-la...
- themeek 11y agoDid they not track the brothers with their cell phones?
- harshreality 11y agoThe hijacked ML350 was tracked, allegedly, but not with broad surveillance powers. They were able to track it after the driver escaped, because he cooperated, had left his iphone in the vehicle, and the vehicle had satellite navigation.
- dragonwriter 11y ago> Since 9/11 have any attacks been prevented? Lots of attacks have been claimed to have been prevented, though in many cases when the details for several of them came out they were attacks that may have been discussed but weren't particularly likely to have been executed, and/or plots that were largely driven by government agents.
- dguaraglia 11y agoWell, there's plenty of people who have been goaded by the FBI into a mock attack who have been stopped from carrying out those mock attacks. I know, that doesn't count and if anything it's basically entrapment, but hey... we have to justify the budget somehow.
- naveen99 11y agoActually, I like this strategy and it probably works. It's a good strategy against pirated software too. If 90% of terrorist suppliers are really cia entrappers, terrorists are going to have a hard time coordinating anything that requires resources beyond 1 person. Entrapment requires lying. And if you have ready decided to lie to your own people, may as well use its full evil power on the adversary.
- task_queue 11y agoIf you're justifying your program by spending its resources trying to goad people with mental handicaps and other lowest common denominator people into committing terrorism, what have you accomplished? Any organization with a degree of security, one a nation would consider an adversary, is aware of the dangers agents pose with infiltration. http://www.democracynow.org/2015/3/19/how_the_fbi_created_a_terrorist http://www.democracynow.org/2015/3/19/how_the_fbi_created_a_... http://www.npr.org/sections/thetwo-way/2013/12/08/249610501/report-details-atfs-use-of-mentally-disabled-in-gun-stings http://www.npr.org/sections/thetwo-way/2013/12/08/249610501/...
- michaelvkpdx 11y agoSounds like this dude works for Her Majesty's Secret Service, not the USA. He should be fired for this.
- amyjess 11y agoNah. He's just nostalgic for the pre-Internet days when the FBI could listen on anyone's communications because phone companies were legally required to make their lines tappable.
- bradleyjg 11y agoThey make going dark seem like some terrible unprecedented thing but electronic communication hasn't even been ubiquitous for that long. Before that there were no wire taps because there were no wires. The human race somehow managed to survive.
- swsieber 11y agoIt's important to note that part of the reason they "need" technology to track terrorism is that technology enables terrorism. To say that we got along fine before technology and mass surveillance means we don't need mass surveillance is a flawed argument; it misses the fact that technology brings with it a big bag troubles and benefits. But personally, I still think window of abuse for back doors is too large to be rationally allowed.
- TeMPOraL 11y agoI wonder how we'll deal with this as technology progresses even further. In 10-20 years, it probably won't take much for a random nutjob to make an extremely deadly virus. And that are only baby steps in nanotechnology. Do we really want total privacy and anonymity in a world where a single person can easily wield such destructive powers?
- ionised 11y ago
- fweespeech 11y ago> It's where I want to go. Also you have YET to show ANY evidence that we are more safe or more free from terrorism by surrounding our rights to privacy. If they could show that, credible evidence would have presented by now. ;) But in all seriousness, the 1st & 4th amendment protections are the most vital freedoms we have and they should not be abridged outside of a direct link to harm. [e.g. Things like child porn, words designed to incite violent harm, violent prisoners shouldn't have privacy ] So you have to be rational about it but yeah, mass surveillance and reducing self-defense tools to protect ourselves against criminals isn't "rational" behavior. Criminals are going to do illegal things and we have the right to protect ourselves. If it inconvenience the government? So be it. I'm not going to bend over for any criminal who wants access to my financial data "because Terrorism". Similarly, banning tools of self-defense [e.g. encryption for financial data, access keys] are simply guaranteeing the criminals will be the only ones to possess them. I'm aware alot of people will be like "what about the 2nd"?? Yeah, that provides no protection against the government since they'll always have the ability to drop bombs on you. When you can afford a F-16 and the ability to pilot it for "self defense" purposes, let me know.
- meatysnapper 11y agoYou cannot fight against an evil government with the 2nd amendment, but you can definitely resist it. An unarmed population is totally helpless, meanwhile.
- c22 11y agoWhat's the difference between fighting against an evil government and resisting it with arms?
- meatysnapper 11y agoActually trying to take on the military, vs resistance (sabotage and only fighting if absolutely necessary). Guns are still helpful for the latter.
- 11y ago
- higherpurpose 11y agoPrivacy, in the context of the government, also means freedom to be left alone. I think that's quite an important freedom to have. We really need to make stronger arguments for privacy. Too many people conflate real privacy (which I believe virtually nobody actually wants to give away, if they truly understand what giving it away means) with "sharing stuff on Facebook and Instagram". One is an obvious choice, and the other (the government, or even companies through non-transparent trackers, knowing everything about you) is not, but is forced upon you.
- chrismarlow9 11y agoTheyre tired of having to break laws to do their job. They want to spy on us and they want us to not only accept it but appreciate and like it. If you make it socially acceptable it will never be challenged again.
- rdudek 11y agoThey'll chisel away at the protection laws piece by piece until they get what they want. I sometimes feel that we're screwed no matter how hard we try to fight.
- TeMPOraL 11y agoMaybe not. If there is a force as strong as parts of government, it's other parts of government. Intelligence community is its own kingdom, with its own goals, but other areas of government run on a four year cycle and depend on public support. So if people will want restrictions in surveillance badly enough, politicians' pathetic pandering to public opinion could create a very powerful counter force.
- chrismarlow9 11y agoRoller coaster. Everythings a roller coaster. We will win for a few years, they will win for a few years, then back to us. You'll have long stretches where we win (golden age) and back to them winning for a long period (dark age), but it will always bounce back one way or the other. http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Golden_Age http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Golden_Age is a good article (obviously) covering this philosophy... All you can really do is try to increase the worth of what you leave behind to your future progeny so that in times of dark ages they are high in the council but remain moral, and in the golden ages they use science to create awesome things and ignore hysteria and FUD. Unfortunately too much shift one way or the other in a genealogy tree makes the family lazy or a war mongrel so it's hard to pull off.
- jqm 11y agoThey will try to chisel away at rights (with some success), but if you think about what they are up against, they will always be playing wack-a-mole. No matter how good the surveillance teams are, they will never completely control humanity nor know everything at all times. They simply aren't capable of it. In addition, the wants are limitless but their budgets are constrained by what they can reasonably appropriate. As they make it harder to do business (by introducing security holes or ruining trust) the amount they can appropriate becomes less. In addition, they become buried by an ever increasing amount of information that their inefficiency can't handle. I have no doubt some of the best and brightest in the world work for for secret agencies. But operationally they are still bureaucracies. Thus, they have no shortage of lazy and stupid people... many of whom are in leadership positions. In fact I believe these pleas for unconstitutional shortcut tools are the pleas of lazy and unimaginative people. People who don't want to be found probably have much more reason to worry if the special pleading ever stops. Because at that point there may be truly more competent people running the program.
- psykovsky 11y ago> by surrounding our rights I think you meant surrendering, or did you really meant encircling? Not a native speaker, just trying to get a better grasp of the language.
- catshirt 11y agoi think, if he meant surrounding, he'd have needed to use "with" or "in". "surrounding our rights with privacy" (which is grammatically correct but doesn't really make sense in this context). so yes, surrendering is a safe guess.
- oxide 11y agoI didn't even notice the error, my brain just registered that as 'surrendering.' I'm positive that's what was meant.
- joshstrange 11y agoI meant "surrendering" sorry, I JUST noticed this typo and went looking for the person who would point it out, thanks! Sorry for confusing you on an already confusing/inconsistent language.
- staunch 11y agoThere's nothing in the world that can provide "freedom from terrorism" which makes it even an even uglier lie. Even if it could, I'd still be against it though, because there are many ways to fight terrorism that don't involve sacrificing the freedom our ancestors bought with blood. The FBI needs leadership that understand how to operate within American principles.
- belorn 11y agoFreedom from terrorism is only modern times bogyman. A hundred years ago, it was anarchists! 50 years ago, it was communists. In 50 years into the future, a new fooist will replace terrorists and the same fight will start all over again. I think what society need is some government reforms that require lawmakers to do cost-benefit analyses with tests and proofs. If they want to ban encryption, they should be forced to provide evidence that it actually work, and that the cost to society is less than current methods to fight terrorism. It would also likely get rid of many current inefficient methods, like security theater at airports.
- ericd 11y agoProving a policy change's future effects is generally impossible. Congress does have panels of people who write reports on the possible/likely effects of legislation. Not sure how frequently they use them, though.
- omegaham 11y agoThis. It boggles my mind how scared people are of terrorism, especially domestic terrorism. If you live in Pakistan, where suicide bombings happen all the time, I can understand being scared of terrorism. But in the US? Come on. You know what I'm scared of? I have to drive two hours four days a week. I am much, much more likely to die in my car. Hell, I was more likely to die in my car while I was in the military. Most people know someone who either got injured or died in a car crash. It happens all the time. How many people know someone who died in a terrorist attack? But we're surrendering our freedom for the latter, which is a ridiculous phantom bogeyman, while we vigorously defend our right to die on the roadways.
- beedogs 11y agoI honestly think the qualifications for high-ranking national security folks in the United States includes things like "played with G.I. Joes a lot as a kid." These people are almost caricatures.
- logicallee 11y agowow your second quote is hilarious. "We're not looking at going through a back door! We just want to access the content". it means the speaker was using that metaphor visually, and didn't know that the word backdoor doesn't really have that kind of a physical meaning. (You can tell the speaker has it wrong because they say, "going through a back door" - I just notice even the word 'back door' is written with a space whereas in computing we write it closed (joined) - https://www.google.com/search?q=wikipedia+back+door https://www.google.com/search?q=wikipedia+back+door)
- DavideNL 11y ago> "Privacy, above all other things, including safety and freedom from terrorism, is not where we want to go," Steinbach said. That's called a "Cognitive Distortion": Polarized Thinking (or “Black and White” Thinking). We don't have to choose between either privacy or safety !