8 ms·
I'm a liberal professor, and my liberal students terrify me
- istvan__ 11y agoVery sad indeed.
- cjbprime 11y agoUnimpressive; the worst he has is that someone made a groundless complaint that was handled perfectly well in 2009, and he worries that someone will make another one one day (though it seems kind of telling that they haven't..?) and it will go differently. Why not get someone who's actually been harmed by this change in culture to write about that?
- eli_gottlieb 11y agoUncynical answer: because finding someone who's actually been harmed is difficult. Cynical answer: because anyone actually harmed will be told to check their privilege. Suspicious, realistic answer: because authority figures are always more scared of disruptions to their power than is warranted by actual conditions.
- dragonwriter 11y ago> Unimpressive; the worst he has is that someone made a groundless complaint that was handled perfectly well in 2009 > the worst he has is that someone made a groundless complaint that was handled perfectly well in 2009, and he worries that someone will make another one one day On top of that, also, the groundless complaint that went nowhere in 2009 was from a student accusing the professor of "communistical sympathies" for not validating right-wing talking points on the housing crisis, and the result is that the professor is especially scared of his liberal students.
- ksenzee 11y agoThe important point here is that he's changing his curriculum to avoid provocative works, so he doesn't get in trouble. If that becomes a widespread practice, we'll have a serious problem in higher education.
- dragonwriter 11y ago> The important point here is that he's changing his curriculum to avoid provocative works, so he doesn't get in trouble. I think that the rather spurious grounds that he identifies for the fear motivating those changes is also important, particularly, it is important in identifying the source of the problem -- which is not, contrary to the headline, his liberal students, or even his students more generally.
- michaelbuddy 11y agoNo they are the other liberal students that got his colleagues in trouble. He's trying to avoid that so he can continue his career. But unfortunately he's stifled by a bunch of cry baby children who wish to take things away from everyone because feelingz.
- bamboo_7 11y agoI think the deeper point isn't just that it will go differently now, but that he has had to adjust his material and teaching style in fear of that bad reaction ruining his career. He points to a few examples of professors who were fired because of a single student's complaint and where universities have removed activities in deference to this outspoken social justice. The shame is that the discussions which should challenge and enrich a student's mind are now being silenced and therein lies to the harm.
- BlackAura 11y agoSo the university being paranoid about being sued is the students' fault? > being silenced Nobody is being silenced by the students. What the students want is for professors to stop being assholes towards anyone that's not just like them, and are (correctly) pointing out various kinds of systemic bias, subjective opinions masquerading as objectivity, and instances where you have material that is disturbing or emotionally difficult for absolutely no good reason other than "it doesn't bother me, so it shouldn't bother you either". When confronted with that, this professor's response is basically denial, writing off these complaints as irrelevant, trivial, or "pandering" (ignorant of how much society in general panders to his own perspective). So, given that bringing this up directly will result in either being ignored, or being belittled or insulted, and the conversation shut down immediately... students don't actually have any choice but to complain. At that point, the university overreacts because they're paranoid about being sued. Which is part of a larger cultural issue that has nothing at all to do with the students. Funny that student activism that happened decades ago is considered a good thing (now), but activism by today's students is considered to be some kind of scary monster that threatens the whole of society...
- michaelbuddy 11y agoIf anyone wants to get inside a liberal's mind, you got one right here, BlackAura I'd bet money you are. Weasel words are present and everything. The young liberal-speak of concepts of 'systemic bias' and 'societal pandering' and of course the students as victims who 'have no choice' but to complain Everyone is going to have an example of some bad professor. But if you're in college seeing a systemic bias, you've gone into it thinking that ahead of time, or somebody planted the idea and no surprise young students are impressionable as all get-out. You'll find a good deal of variation among educators. The only systemic bias you'll find across a whole campus (or more with the administration) is an almost shocking and unrealistic unnecessary drive towards what might be called 'diversity' but really isn't. But if these SJWs / Liberals / feminists go in expecting some sort of bias, they are definitely going to find it. Just like once you buy a car, you see it everywhere on the road. > "ignored, belittled, insulted" More weasel words. Nothing that can be checked up on specifically, no particular victim or perpetrator. Just a thing that we're supposed to believe is ever present, rampant etc. >material that is disturbing or emotionally difficult for absolutely no good reason other than "it doesn't bother me, so it shouldn't bother you either" You've got the SJW bug for sure. You need a dose of realism. The obvious symptom is making wild assumptions about somebody else's frame of mind or purposely narrowing their intent and stating it on their behalf in order to justify any and all reaction over them. Add on to that getting mad that others aren't on your side. The reason society might be considering a lot of SJWs as scary is that they are young impressionable and have a lot of ignorant followers on twitter and will do anything and everything to weasel through a situation because their form of social justice must prevail. that includes, as we've seen in St. Louis and Baltimore, justifying illegal behavior for so-called systemic racism. the other scary thing about SJWs is they attack in many ways our most important right, freedom of speech. Like here you insist it's not being attacked but it is. It's playing the victim card and projecting somebody's intent knowing full well that your feelings hurt don't justify somebody getting a write up or being forced out of a position because of the way you claim to have suffered. The sad thing about all of it is it really doesn't get anyone anywhere. SJWs might get a statue taken down or a tradition removed, a speech cancelled, but they never really fix anything they just destroy things because they don't like them, so nobody else should either.
- runamok 11y agoHuh? He gives at least one example as to why he is concerned: > I once saw an adjunct not get his contract renewed after students complained that he exposed them to "offensive" texts written by Edward Said and Mark Twain. His response, that the texts were meant to be a little upsetting, only fueled the students' ire and sealed his fate.
- current_call 11y agoAre we reading the same article? It isn't about him. He's complaining about general trends and he has several specific examples. As Judith Shulevitz wrote in the New York Times, these refusals can shut down discussion in genuinely contentious areas, such as when Oxford canceled an abortion debate. More often, they affect surprisingly minor matters, as when Hamsphire College disinvited an Afrobeat band because their lineup had too many white people in it. He [Chait] cites an anonymous professor who says that "she and her fellow faculty members are terrified of facing accusations of triggering trauma." Consider that tweet I linked to earlier, from critic and artist Zahira Kelly, in which she implies that the whole of scientific inquiry is somehow invalid because it has been conducted mostly by white males. In another instance, two female professors of library science publically outed and shamed a male colleague they accused of being creepy at conferences, going so far as to openly celebrate the prospect of ruining his career. By the way, you seem to be the sort of person that scares him. Rebecca Reilly Cooper, a political philosopher at the University of Warwick, worries about the effectiveness of a politics in which "particular experiences can never legitimately speak for any one other than ourselves, and personal narrative and testimony are elevated to such a degree that there can be no objective standpoint from which to examine their veracity." Why not get someone who's actually been harmed by this change in culture to write about that? -You
- cjbprime 11y ago> Rebecca Reilly Cooper, a political philosopher at the University of Warwick, worries about the effectiveness of a politics in which "particular experiences can never legitimately speak for any one other than ourselves, and personal narrative and testimony are elevated to such a degree that there can be no objective standpoint from which to examine their veracity." I see why you think I would do that, but when I say that I don't think his fears are justified by the evidence presented and we should seek better evidence of a problem (presumably from someone else), I'm doing the opposite of "elevating personal narrative and testimony".
- current_call 11y agoBut that's not what you said. You said someone "who's actually been harmed" should write about it. That would be elevating personal narrative and testimony.
- 6stringmerc 11y agoAs a self-proclaimed renegade, disruptive thinker, and stubbornly practiced argumentative individual with an English Literature degree, I think this write-up hits on several valid points. The framing of discourse is important, and actually quite relevant to notions of technological / software innovation as well. Placating feelings is akin to me like being a drug dealer. Pandering for profit is a real, viable business model. Freemium gaming is one element. Aggregating and slanting news for a specific demographic is another. Giving a voice to ignorance in the case of vaccination discussion is yet another. I could go on and on, because these things are real, visible, and frankly horrible deviations from intellectual and societal progress. This is why trolling has become such a bloodsport and, quite frankly, one of the counter-balances to the trend. In a primal sense, trolling online is akin to purposefully challenging a person's worldview through their feelings, using drastic / hyperbolic / inflammatory rhetoric. People like Mark Twain and Hunter S. Thompson were masters, and I've studied them extensively. For those who think this article might be a non-starter, fine, go bury your head in the sand a little deeper. It will only be a matter of time before a co-worker, an underling, or a family member exhibits this contagious mental rot and throws you for a loop. After all, if you don't feel that it's a problem, then it's not a problem, right?
- cryptop 11y ago>As a self-proclaimed renegade, disruptive thinker, and stubbornly practiced argumentative individual with an English Literature degree You're trolling, right?
- rcxdude 11y ago>In a primal sense, trolling online is akin to purposefully challenging a person's worldview through their feelings, using drastic / hyperbolic / inflammatory rhetoric. No, The definition of trolling is attempting to get a reaction out of people by any means possible. Trolls aren't interested in having an actual conversation, educating, or changing anyone's view, in fact they thrive off of the opposite.
- A_COMPUTER 11y agoIs it trolling if you pick your targets ideologically and say what you mean? We need a new word, because trolling does seem to capture the method and the spirit, but not the goals.
- NTDF9 11y agoI used to be a liberal. Then I realized that I cannot trust everyone who cries foul. I haven't turned conservative either. But I don't hold liberal views as correct by default anymore. The problem with today's liberals is that they think political correctness is more important than factual data. Any rational argument requires dealing with cold hard facts, however brutal and hurtful they might be. There is no place for emotions in objective observation, exploration, research. For more info on this perspective watch this video: Why So Many Americans Don't Want Social Justice and Don't Trust Scientists https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=b86dzTFJbkc https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=b86dzTFJbkc TL;DR: Political correctness...aka too many pussies in the real world.
- deleted 11y ago[deleted]
- namlem 11y agoIt's crazy how far left liberalism has been pushed these past few years. Just as crazy as how far right conservatism has moved over the past couple decades. This extreme polarization is very worrying. It's not stable, and it's going to lead to serious problems.
- Balgair 11y agoMeh. It's always been there. It's just that the internet has allowed us to see it better. Also, this definition of 'far' left or right (at least here in the states) is not all that far, historically speaking. Far right would be a return to religious law, banning of contraception, a return to a theocracy, etc. There are countries like that, and we view them as nuts and places you dont want to live in. Far left would be a total communist state (I think) and we all know those are equally as bad. Yet, people do live, love, have families, die, fight for, and defend those countries. Something else must be going on, right? Again, there is a trap of viewing politics as a 1-D continuum. Granted this is better than a 1-D binary, but politics has as many dimensions as there are people, if not more. We all have opinions, or have the idea that our ideas are not important. What is most important is that we VOTE. If we think these people are too far right or left, the best way to do something about that is to VOTE and participate in your community. https://www.opencongress.org/people/zipcodelookup https://www.opencongress.org/people/zipcodelookup http://www.civiced.org/resources/curriculum/lesson-plans/456-how-can-citizens-participate http://www.civiced.org/resources/curriculum/lesson-plans/456... https://www.gop.com/get-involved/ https://www.gop.com/get-involved/ https://www.democrats.org/projects https://www.democrats.org/projects and many more.
- yellowapple 11y ago> If we subscribe to the belief that ideas can be judged within a vacuum, uninfluenced by the social weight of their proponents, we perpetuate a system in which arbitrary markers like race and gender influence the perceived correctness of ideas. I don't understand this. If ideas are judged in a vacuum, then by definition, their perceived correctness is not influenced by race and gender. If those ideas are perceived differently based on race or gender, then they're not being judged in a vacuum. Or am I missing something here?
- BlackAura 11y agoThe belief that ideas can be judged in a vacuum is a very different thing than ideas actually being judged in a vacuum. Ideas are not judged in a vacuum - humans are rubbish at doing that. We allow various factors to influence how we evaluate ideas, even when those factors have nothing to do with the idea itself. Race and gender being very obvious ones. Example: In a meeting, a woman comes up with an idea. Everyone ignores her. Thirty seconds later, a man says the exact same thing, and suddenly everyone is in awe about how amazing this idea is. And yes, that does happen. A lot. However, most of us believe that we aren't doing this. We believe that we're evaluating ideas on merit alone, and are therefore completely blind to the fact that we're not. Humans are rubbish at being objective, but very good at fooling ourselves into believing that we are. The only way to approach evaluating ideas on merit is to be aware of one's own biases, one's own point of view, various power imbalances, systemic discrimination, and all that stuff. Once you're aware of what you're actually doing, you can try to factor that into how you evaluate ideas.
- dropit_sphere 11y agoA defense I'm not sure I believe, but one worth being aware of, at least: Could this simply be people exercising Bayesian reasoning? If we postulate that men come up with more out-of-band good ideas (which I don't find hard to believe, as they come up with more out-of-band everything, including bad ideas), then people's priors will change to reflect that. What I am saying is that this may in fact be rational, whatever your (or my) opinions on its rightness.
- k__ 11y agoI always find it interesting, that the US seems to be all about conservatives (republicans) and liberals (democrats). In Germany it seems to be more of a conservatives (CDU) and socialists (SPD) "battle". Interestingly I had the feeling the liberals (FDP) are more on the side of the conservatives (most of the time in german history FDP and CDU worked together). So when I read about US politics it feels like they are only debating on details. Like socialism isn't even an option.
- ttepasse 11y agoKeep in mind that the word liberal has different meanings in the political context on both sides of the atlantic ocean. Although it is always a question of one's own standpoint. Where I (a somewhat social-democratic german) stand, both CDU and SPD look like parties of the right today. :(
- ilaksh 11y agoThe whole don't-hurt-my feelings culture is odd and a problem, but so is the general employment situation and overall structure.
- vannevar 11y agoI suspect that the situations the author describes have more to do with office politics than personal politics, and have little or nothing to do with the students. Academia is a notoriously feudal environment; once someone has made enemies in their department, any transgression, however minor, is used as a tool to strip them of power or, in the extreme, get them fired. It's no different today than it has been historically, it's just that the particular choice of teapot for the tempest has changed through the years.