3 ms·
OK, I have looked at the ESR link again. it says in the code "; Apply a VERY ARTIFICAL correction for decline!!" Folks, please!!! So it is known (from the oth
by Tichy 17y ago
OK, I have looked at the ESR link again. it says in the code
"; Apply a VERY ARTIFICAL correction for decline!!"
Folks, please!!! So it is known (from the other emails about tree-ring data not corresponding with thermometer readings after the 1960s or something) that some correction is needed. So it seems plausible that a researcher starts with some crude correction to test things out, before they take the time to find the proper adjustments. This is probably just some throwaway code (like approximating pi = 3,14 before you take the time to make an algorithm for calculating Pi to higher precision). I don't think it ended up in a chart that was presented to Obama in person.
The whole case looks very, very weak, and to be honest, I just lost a whole lot of respect for ESR. Climate change be true or not, I don't like brainless mob behavior.
I think the problem again is with the wording, "artificial" can mean different things - again take your pick depending on what you want to believe.
In the end, I don't see how "artifical charts" like that could end up in scientific papers. Surely if you present a chart, you also have to present the way you derived it, at which point any fakery should become evident. If no such process is included, it simply is a weak paper.
- patio11 17y agoI'm sorry, I majored in engineering rather than Real Science (TM) so I might have missed this lecture, but when I'm doing stats I don't start with a data set, a faked version of The Right Answer (TM), and a list of adjustments to try prior to finding the proper one (i.e. the one which results in The Right Answer). Though now that you mention it, that seems like it would save a heck of a lot of work. Surely if you present a chart, you also have to present the way you derived it, at which point any fakery should become evident. If nothing else, this scandal is exposing the difference between the dogmatic version of science we all learned in the Scientific Method lecture back in 6th grade, and science as it is actually practiced in the real world. The Scientific Method lecture says that all results must be reproduced by experts. In the real world, the computer programs involved are outrageous hacks, the data are practically never seen after publication (and go missing with disturbing regularity), and the peer review concentrates mostly on making sure you cite the right people and scratch the right backs. Nobody is ever going to try to actually duplicate the math it took to transform your raw data into your massaged data -- that is hard work and have you ever met an engineer who would reliably leave detailed instructions to exactly reproduce 6 months of labor, in a form where they would be instantly comprehensible to anyone in the field? I would be astounded if scientists routinely actually committed to paper an exhaustive list of all the software installed on the computer they did the math on. (What version of which library, etc etc. So you can reproduce bugs.) Then there is the "Frustrate anyone who opposes us at any turn, destroy data in response to FOI requests, get our nemeses expelled from their institutions, and ruin journals which publish competing work" angle, which takes it from "science as it is practiced in the real world" to just farce.
- Tichy 17y agoI don't want to defend the scientific system, I am pretty sure it has a lot of flaws. However, the papers you mention that only depend on back scratching in my opinion are simply very weak. I am not even interested in discussing such papers. If anything, the blame should then go to the state departments responsible for funding the research. If they are being blinded by such crap, it is a problem. That said, I think succeeding in academia requires good skills in politics, I have a lot of respect for some people who manage to do well both in research and in pulling the right strings.
- jimbokun 17y ago"I would be astounded if scientists routinely actually committed to paper an exhaustive list of all the software installed on the computer they did the math on. (What version of which library, etc etc. So you can reproduce bugs.)" This shouldn't be necessary, of course. The raw data and a description of the algorithms (with sufficient latex-y equations) should suffice. If not, I don't think the paper is worth much. I think, though, this is what you meant by: "Nobody is ever going to try to actually duplicate the math it took to transform your raw data into your massaged data -- that is hard work" But that is exactly what must happen for anyone to claim they have reproduced the original results. If you just get a VMWare instance of the original author's computer, run his program and get the same results you still are no closer to knowing whether he made a mistake or not.
- danbmil99 17y agoHear hear. Finally someone who sounds rational. The degree to which everyone in the sci/tech community has rallied around these sloppy, untrustworthy miscreants is really boggling me. Defending bad science because you agree with its conclusions is not a good idea. I'm sure there's good climate science out there, and I suspect it can show a connection between human endeavors and the actual climate. But if it turns out the evidence just isn't there yet, at least with this bunch at the wheel, well then let's suck it up and accept that, rather than circle the wagons and defend "science" when it's clear the scientists in question have not acted in accord with their professed principles.
- tezza 17y agoRight, I'm going to wade in here. Tichy I completely agree with you, the evidence exposed by these leaks is very, very weak. Basically there is already existent a lot of evidence that many scientists disagree strongly about Climate Change. People who have doubts should not need to lower their arguments to a shrill 'Aha I see a smoking-gun'. This morsel of evidence is tiny by comparison to more eminent disagreement. --- For more weighty disagreements see amongst many more: S McIntyre and R McKitrick 'Corrections to the Mann et a. (1998) proxy data base and northern hemishpere average temperature series' [1] as Nigel Lawson[2] says: 'it turned out ... that crucial data for the period before 1421 was based on.. one single pine tree' ----- [1] http://www.uoguelph.ca/~rmckitri/research/trc.html http://www.uoguelph.ca/~rmckitri/research/trc.html [2] p126 note 39 of A Call to Reason: A Cool Look at Global Warming by Nigel Lawson. The 2009 release has lots of up to date information in a foreword
- Retric 17y ago"many scientists disagree strongly about Climate Change." I think many misrepresents the level of conflict. There are plenty of people that think man made impact on Climate is negligible. However, most people with a strong and relevant scientific background acknowledge, the heat island effect around city's and or desertification which are less controversial man made impacts on local Climate. CO2's absorption spectrum is different than other atmospheric gasses and it's low over all percentage in the atmosphere magnifies it's importance. And there is little debate over the quantity of CO2 released by human activity's. But, quantifying the effect of CO2's impact on global climate with high precision is hard, so there is debate about the magnitude of it's impact.
- Tichy 17y agoFrankly I am a bit surprised at seeing the hockey stick again. I thought that had been written off years ago. Which wouldn't mean that there is no warming going on. In any case, it might once again be nitpicking about unimportant details.
- tezza 17y agoThis email trail disection involves data from around the Hockey Stick time, so I felt okay to list the historical disagreement. Time does not age the fact that shoddy practices were used as recently as 2001. The book mentioned has quite up-to-date info.