7 ms·
Apple collects tons of user data, and I'm sure they use some of it to provide machine-learning backed services, and I'm sure they'll come out with much nicer pr
by threatofrain 11y ago
Apple collects tons of user data, and I'm sure they use some of it to provide machine-learning backed services, and I'm sure they'll come out with much nicer products to compete with Google in the future, also enhanced by machine learning techniques.
The difference that Tim Cook wants you to believe in is that Apple doesn't directly make money from your data, they just use it to improve their product; alternatively, Google makes money from your data by providing advertises with guided access to your eyeball.
But the danger isn't in the fact that Google lulls you into complacency with free services. The danger isn't in the fact that Google sells guided access to your attention. The danger is just in the collection of data, and the fact that one day the government or somebody could find a way.
There's only one way to be safe. And that's to collect only minimal amounts of data for minimal apps. That means gimped Siri. No Apple competitor to Google Photos. And I don't think Apple will do that. I think they'll continue to amass all the data they use to improve customer experience. The fact that Apple makes money differently off the data doesn't change the fact that it's collection that's inherently dangerous.
- makeitsuckless 11y agoThis is just a another way of saying "business good, government bad". The fact that Google abuses the data and Apple doesn't is already a major difference. Just because government can use its monopoly on violence and imprisonment to go one step beyond doesn't make what businesses do harmless. Yes, the collection is already inherently dangerous, and what Apple does is certainly not harmless. And yes, they will use that data to their advantage. But the unscrupulous abuse of that data, the blatant disregard for privacy, a business model that depends on abuse of that data, and the obvious hunger for social and economic power by Google and co is not a minor difference.
- amirmc 11y ago> "There's only one way to be safe. And that's to collect only minimal amounts of data for minimal apps." No. The only way to be really safe is to go live in a cave, not to have any friends and never go anywhere near any tech ever again. I'm sure you can tell that I don't consider that to be much of an option. It's unhelpful to label 'data collection' as the source of the problem as 'collection' happens everywhere in our interactions with the world. There are valid arguments and discussions to be had about who really owns that data. It may well be about me, but that doesn't necessarily mean that it's mine. I'd say the majority of people are only just beginning to understand that a discussion needs to take place even though technical folks have known this for a long time. One solution to the 'ownership' problem is to make it possible for everyone to run their own infrastructure. i.e. have their own 'backend' that apps/services can be installed into, which their end-devices can then connect to. This is already possible for the technically savvy but a lot of work is needed before I feel we can trust such systems (I'm working on approaches to this [1,2], based on unikernels). In the meantime, I applaud business models that are not built around profiling (which is the crux of the issue cf. advertising). They're the only ones where the incentives have any hope of aligning. [1] http://nymote.org/blog/2013/introducing-nymote/ http://nymote.org/blog/2013/introducing-nymote/ [2] http://amirchaudhry.com/brewing-miso-to-serve-nymote/ http://amirchaudhry.com/brewing-miso-to-serve-nymote/
- higherpurpose 11y agoOr researching fast fully homomorphic encryption so they can one day be able to mine data while preserving strong user privacy.
- hobs 11y agoMy thoughts are basically: + "Run your own infrastructure" is currently a pipe dream for what is 99.9% of people. + Companies selling data when they go bankrupt or M&As changing the nature of what they do with the collection happens regularly. + Discussing ownership is fairly simple as well, "Does the company already have your data?" + Any business not based around profiling has a additional options to make more money by selling their (your) data. Why isnt excess data collection a problem? Is it because its very very hard to solve and if we pass laws bad actors will continue to flaunt them? Is it because we are past the point of no return?
- castell 11y ago> Is it because we are past the point of no return? If you look at the computer history, we already had several cycles from single computer to timesharing to mainframes/supercomputers to PC to thin-clients/mobile to (?). There has always been a time when single powerful computers were in the majority and then there has been times when thin-clients with big server structures were the majority. The Internet supports also the model of more decentral computers and everyone could host their data on their own devices. It's currently just not the right time and there is no business model behind it, so no one push for that solution at the moment.
- wyldfire 11y ago> + "Run your own infrastructure" is currently a pipe dream for what is 99.9% of people. Or not even a dream, because those 99.9% prefer not to run their own infrastructure even if it's easy and cheap. However, "local apps" (ones which don't require infrastructure) could be appealing if they could achieve parity with the enormous-backend apps.
- un_ 11y ago
- Aissen 11y agoActually, there's another alternative. Provide all these "insights" with offline, data-on-computers-you-own systems. The intelligence can be carried with you, without internet. This is traditional computing. Apple or Microsoft, or even any other competitor could provide that. They just need to sell you this software (oh and also build it first).
- msellout 11y agoNot possible. The insights come from the combination of everyone's data, not the analysis of any individual in isolation.
- collyw 11y agoI am sure there is still value in one users data that could be used that way.
- Aissen 11y agoI'd like to disagree. When Google Now reads my email to track my delivery package number or flight number, it's my data. When it understands that I like sport team X, it's my data. When it knows where I work and live to ask Google servers the weather or how long it would take to go somewhere, still my data used as the request base. When Google(+) Photos auto-tags my photos, still my data, although I'd admit the IA training requires a big amount of photos. Looking at https://www.google.com/landing/now/#cards https://www.google.com/landing/now/#cards ; it's obvious a lot of those need online information. It's not obvious that the data source for requiring those online informations has to be in the cloud, or combined from multiple people's data.
- lbotos 11y agoRight, It's your data because it's the things you care about, but knowing you isn't what google cares about, they want to know where you intersect with everyone else.
- threatofrain 11y agoI think your point is good, and depends on the question of how much can be done on current and future hardware, and what differences might result to product quality in local-only storage and processing.
- pdkl95 11y ago> Apple doesn't directly make money from your data, they just use it to improve their product Apple improves their products for several reasons, but as a for-profit business the main reason they would use some of their limited capital to "improve their product" would be to make money. The details about how a business exploits user data is not that interesting. Arguments about this kind of minutia are a distraction and a waste of time. The problem is, as you say, the fact that they collect data at all. > That means gimped Siri As Dan Geer said regarding the inevitable software-industry complains about liability legislation "Yes, please! That was exactly the idea." Some people may wish to trade their future privacy for whatever clever trinket is being sold. I believe that is usually a bad trade, but they have the right to make that kind of choice. What is not being discussed is how the people that use Siri (and similar live-microphone-with-network-access products, including newer "smart TVs") are making that privacy decision not only for themselves, but they are also imposing their choice on everybody else the microphone can hear. In his recent (highly recommended) talk[1], Aral Balkan suggested a very interesting model, because there is another product that is well-known to adversely impact the people "near" the user as a secondary effect: tobacco. Siri, Amazon's Echo, and most of Google's services are like software "second-hand smoke". Like smoking, I don't care what you do in your own home. What we need - at a minimum - is new social conventions/etiquette where you ask permission or step outside before enabling any of these recording devices. [1] https://projectbullrun.org/surveillance/2015/video-2015.html#balkan https://projectbullrun.org/surveillance/2015/video-2015.html...
- Silhouette 11y agoThe third party surveillance issue is certainly one that needs more attention and consideration. Not on a social networking site? Don't worry, they probably know a significant amount about you anyway, just from friends who have given the social network the entire address book from their phone and a few photos with you in them. Decided not to use Google because you're not sure about how much data they collect these days? Don't worry, they probably have a significant proportion of all the e-mails you ever send from one of the other parties anyway, and you have no reliable way to determine when this is happening or to avoid participating. And of course there are the numerous third party widgets that not only make the modern web a slower, sometimes malware-ridden, often ad-ridden mess, they also follow those not technically skilled enough to protect themselves around. Don't worry, they promise they won't tell your health insurer about the medical conditions you were looking up. No, wait, they didn't. Now we have the kinds of technologies mentioned in the parent post, with smartphones and headsets and home automation systems that have sensors and network connections being placed just about everywhere, and we really are starting to live in a society with permanent surveillance. In many ways, these kinds of issues are much harder to address than the already difficult questions of how to control first party data collection. Most of them by their nature operate in the background where a lot of people will never even know they are there, and even those who do may or may not be able to do much about it.
- castell 11y agoIt's more complicated. Apple's position as a hardware company that sells them with very good software is certainly the better position in comparison to Google, Microsoft & co. Siri (as well as several other similar products) is based on Nuance technologies (speech recognition, text-to-speech, etc). It was recently in the news that Nuance outsourced their voice technology quality control (US based human workers listen to your voice data and checks the speech recognition quality, some workers mentioned they recognized single persons from reoccurring voice data). So your voice data is being processed by several parties. The two big mobile OS vendors Apple and Google and also smaller players like Microsoft make it incredible hard to not-use their cloud storage&sync offering. Storage space is synthetically limited to low GB, with an high up price for additional storage. An SD-Card slot (= cheap extra storage, as a card is very cheap) is only available in Android devices (third party vendors hardware manufacturers like Samsung, Sony, etc.) but not from Google itself. All the inbuilt sync functionality only works with their own cloud storage, no third party cloud nor a simple sync over Bluetooth, Wifi or USB-cable. They could do better.
- gesman 11y agoAgree 100%. Essentially Tim Cook said: "Apple is a good girl (we do the same things that bad girls do but better)"
- flycaliguy 11y agoIt feels like the same underlining luxery branding of Apple products. Those guys are tacky and cheap, we are HBO. Apple doesn't even own a TV, they go to the art house theater... With the car industry about do become part of the ecosystem it makes sense. Get in a Google Taxi and you'll have to watch targeted ads the whole way there. Get in an Apple Taxi and listen to classical music.
- dmschulman 11y agoOr the latest U2 album (and the doors lock once you enter the taxi)
- minthd 11y agoIt's even worse than that.Not using Apple's products is a good way to increase privacy. How ? If you use Google's products(and who doesn't use Google Search ? ) , Google already knows plenty about you. And even if you don't use Google products, Google knows plenty about you, since it's tracking software is installed in large percentage of sites, etc. And if you add machine learning on top of that , the amount that Google knows about you is great - even if you use Apple's products. In reality, by using Apple's products, you don't gain privacy , you lose privacy - now two companies know a lot about you, instead of one.
- dashoffset 11y agoIsn't it better to have two companies that have partial information about you than one company that knows it all?
- gwu78 11y ago"Apple collects tons of user data..." I gateway all my devices through one computer running a stripped down kernel. Through this host I monitor all attempted network connections. I block ads and of course this means I block Apple. Apple devices are like beacons, attempting to contact a variety of Apple servers from the moment you turn them on and continuing to "phone home" incessantly 24/7 until you turn them off. That is only one example, but to me it is the most egregious. Apple's competititors are no better. Do users really believe that one of these companies is going to protect them? When the owner of a Chromecast plugs it in for the first time it tries to connect to Google to patch itself and prevent the owner from jailbreaking. Perhaps my favourite was this patent application from Apple, with the CEO as a listed inventor. http://www.google.com/patents/US20090265214 http://www.google.com/patents/US20090265214 As for "providing advertisers with guided access to your eyeball" I believe that is what the App Store system does; it lets the app developers do the providing by embedding advertising into applications (cf. operating system, as in the above application).
- coned88 11y ago> I gateway all my devices through one computer running a stripped down kernel. Through this host I monitor all network connections. I block ads and of course this means I block Apple. Do you do this always via a vpn or something or was it just to try it out?
- gwu78 11y agos/connections/attempted &/ Yes, I do this always. For me, the ad blocking is most easily done via DNS. djbdns features make it especially easy. I have been using DNS to block ads especially in app ads for several years now. Never expected it to work so well (such heavy reliance on DNS by developers), but it does. There are of course other ways besides DNS to block unwanted connections including ones to Apple and third party ad servers. As for Apple's VPN capabilities, I have experimented with xl2tpd but not as a way to block ads.
- coned88 11y agodon't you waste a lot of battery going through a vpn though on your cell phone? I'd love to hear more about this setup.
- snom320 11y agoIMO, the main difference is that Apples gives you more choice in the matter. I can still choose to not enable iCloud, and only sync my iPhone / iPad to my computer. Also, for some data collection Apple explicitly asks you whether you want to share the data to improve its service (location data and crash report data, for instance)