4 ms·
There's got to be a difference between poaching people from another tech firm and getting them en masse from a non-profit. Sure, they are within their rights t
by lordnacho 11y ago
There's got to be a difference between poaching people from another tech firm and getting them en masse from a non-profit.
Sure, they are within their rights to get these employees, but it's worth considering whether they should think about the consequences for CMU. There's a lot of organization memory that makes a lab special, especially this particular lab.
If I start a medical startup, I'm more than within my rights to hire some doctors. But would I go and hire half the staff of my local teaching hospital? I think I'd think twice.
- jessriedel 11y agoThose researchers aren't getting paid what they are worth, i.e., society would be forgoing value by keeping them at the university. If your point is that society misses out on the positive externality of the knowledge they publish (which they mostly won't do at Uber), then the university or a nonprofit should work out an agreement with Uber to buy that info from them, e.g., by covering a portion of the scientists' salaries.
- lordnacho 11y ago>Those researchers aren't getting paid what they are worth, i.e., society would be forgoing value by keeping them at the university. Of course. This is the economically naive explanation of why people are paid whatever they're paid (marginal product). It works fine for things like soccer players, where it's quite measurable whether some guy is contributing, how many shirts he sells, how much he'd add to a given team, etc. In this situation, it's not that clear. Uber have money, but that doesn't mean those people are suddenly worth more. They may make something useful, they may not. Having more chips doesn't make you right, it just wins you the hand. >If your point is that society misses out on the positive externality of the knowledge they publish (which they mostly won't do at Uber), then the university or a nonprofit should work out an agreement with Uber to buy that info from them, e.g., by covering a portion of the scientist's salaries. Right, and did they do that? It sounds like they just said "meh, let's not bother and just use this pile of cash to get what we want". Maybe it's more complex than that, but it doesn't sound like they care too much.
- jessriedel 11y agoThe for-profit business will strike any kind of deals the university (or other non-profit) wants for the appropriate amount of cash. The business is self-interested, so its behavior is (more or less) predictable. The question is: do the non-profits actually care about societal benefit, or are they really just managed by people interested in building prestige? CMU robotics wouldn't get nearly as much prestige from paying Uber scientists to publish papers.
- chrisbennet 11y agoMost people associate "non-profit" with charitable organizations but it simply means that the organization does not distribute profits/dividends to shareholders. It also enjoys tax benefits not available to other organizations. A quick look at Glass Door shows that C.M. "post doctoral fellows" are being paid $55K/year. I don't know what the robotics guys were getting paid but it's not hard to believe that they would jump at the chance to get paid what a software engineer gets paid. It doesn't seem fair to expect C.M. robotics engineers to work for half their potential pay.
- noelsusman 11y agoEvery Engineering/CS PhD student and post-doc in the country does that. If you look at PhD students then it's more like a quarter of the potential pay. Everybody who is there has chosen to forgo large chunks of salary.
- chrisbennet 11y agoPhd students and post docs are exploited because they can be - they usually don't have any leverage. They may go in knowing that they will be taken advantage of but that's not the same as agreeing that the arrangement is fair. It isn't like going into the priesthood where there is an expectation of sacrifice. The presidents of these institutions are certainly not setting an example of sacrifice (nor am I saying they should). [The president of C.M. gets over $500K a year.]