11 ms·
Section 215 Expires For Now
- cinquemb 11y agoHa… "All of this political drama neglects a reality which has been pointed out by an earlier CounterPunch essay.[0] The majority of the NSA’s mass interception is sanctioned by other laws. To be precise Section 702 of the FISA Amendments Act of 2008 and Executive Order 12333. It’s likely that congress is fixated on Section 215 because politicians view it as an “easy win” that both panders to voters and winks at spies. Flanked by a blitz of press coverage lawmakers can brag to voters about fighting Big Brother without really altering the surveillance apparatus itself."[1] [0] http://www.counterpunch.org/2015/05/05/the-usa-freedom-act-doesnt-end-bulk-data-collection/print http://www.counterpunch.org/2015/05/05/the-usa-freedom-act-d... [1] http://www.counterpunch.org/2015/05/08/will-appeals-court-ruling-really-stop-nsa-bulk-phone-data-collection/print http://www.counterpunch.org/2015/05/08/will-appeals-court-ru...
- fweespeech 11y agoYeah, and even by some miracle it vanished completely, the rubber stamp NSL process provides the same level of access on a [very short] delay. The fact is, the government is going to do what it wants and throw out the occasional figleaf to pretend it cares for political reasons.
- gizmo686 11y agoAnother way of viewing it is that they went after an easier target as a sort of test case, to demonstrate and build the political backbone for surveillance reform. This will hopefully make future attempts at more serious reforms easier.
- deleted 11y ago[deleted]
- solipsism 11y agoOur elected representatives are finally waking up and growing a pair? Putting aside the sexist expression, are you really under the impression that they all of a sudden have found some courage they didn't have before? You don't think they're just swaying in the political wind of the time?
- unethical_ban 11y ago"On The Media" did a special on the PATRIOT Act, with some history, analysis, and predictions. They do mention the same thing: That many of the things we don't like are authorized by other measures. One part of me is similarly cynical, and that if it was allowed to expire, they "let" it expire. But the hopeful part of me realizes that change happens in increments. Maybe reforms will continue to come, because there will NEVER be a "fix all civil liberties violations" bill. http://www.onthemedia.org/story/on-the-media-2015-05-29/ http://www.onthemedia.org/story/on-the-media-2015-05-29/
- dragonwriter 11y ago> The majority of the NSA’s mass interception is sanctioned by other laws That's far from clear (its far from clear that the mass interception is authorized at all). It may be that there is more that the government would claim is authorized by other laws than 215, but then its worth keeping in mind that with the metadata collection they've claimed is authorized by 215, the 2nd Circuit Court of Appeals has found that it was not authorized by 215.
- bradleyjg 11y agoAt least section 702 is set to eventually sunset, in 2017. Section 214 was made permanent. http://www.ratical.org/ratville/CAH/Section213.html#214 http://www.ratical.org/ratville/CAH/Section213.html#214 https://w2.eff.org/patriot/sunset/214.php https://w2.eff.org/patriot/sunset/214.php http://www.lawfareblog.com/2015/05/without-the-usa-freedom-act-nsa-could-resume-bulk-collection-even-if-patriot-act-provisions-expire/ http://www.lawfareblog.com/2015/05/without-the-usa-freedom-a... "The section 215 phone records program was modeled on an earlier, Internet metadata bulk collection program that began after September 11. The FISC approved the Internet metadata program under the pen register/trap and trace (PR/TT) provisions of FISA – as amended by section 214 of the Patriot Act. The Internet metadata program – known as the PR/TT program – had serious compliance problems because it was difficult for the NSA reliably to segregate Internet metadata from Internet content. Still, the FISC continued to approve the PR/TT program, with modifications, until the NSA itself chose to end the program in 2011. As a result, the FISC’s orders approving bulk metadata collection remain a viable interpretation of the PR/TT provisions of FISA and would have precedential value in any effort to resume bulk collection, whether of Internet or telephony metadata. The PR/TT provisions of FISA are not limited to Internet metadata. If anything, they apply more naturally to traditional telephony metadata, as they cover “dialing, routing, addressing, or signaling” information. Section 214, unlike section 215, is not going to expire tomorrow – it was made permanent in 2005."
- late2part 11y agoWe should work to sunset these earlier.
- dm2 11y ago"permit authorities to target "lone wolf" suspects with no connection to specific terrorist groups, and make it easier to seize personal and business records of suspects and their associates" If I search lots of technology and military related topics, or do any system-admin work, or use any privacy-enabling services (VPN / TOR), then my friends/family/associates and myself would likely fall under those categories. My concern is there should be a data-retention policy due to constantly changing laws. If 20 years from now I want to run for president, then all it would take is to search for records in one of the many caches of NSA collected data that other agency, state, local, and even foreign law-enforcement have collected over the years. That would allow a large number of people to have the power to easily find something that would distract me enough to pull me out of the race, such as inappropriate text-messages/emails that a cheating spouse sent in the past.
- deleted 11y ago[deleted]
- pvg 11y agoEven when the president was an outright crook and used some of the machinery of state (and some other outright crooks) to dig for dirt on his opponents, he wasn't able to accomplish this through the national security services. Oh and he got caught and forced to resign. There are many good reasons to be concerned about surveillance, privacy, data gathering, etc. Your future presidential campaign is almost certainly not among them.
- hackinthebochs 11y agoYou're kidding right? Are you actually implying the scale of information gathered in the Nixon era is anywhere comparable to what is possible now?
- pvg 11y agoAre you actually implying that information gathered by security services has been used to derail someone's presidential campaign, even in the era of the worst of such abuses? Because that's what the OP is worried about, ostensibly. And it's silly.
- mercurialshark 11y agoSection 215 concerns both foreign and domestic signals, allowing for the collection of metadata. Section 702 focuses on the content of foreign intelligence. While 215 is debatable, 702 serves a distinctly different purpose. IF your concern is domestic surveillance, particularly sharing metadata that originates in the US with law enforcement, than this can be considered a win. IF you think collection of foreign intelligence should be limited, which of course is in the US's interest, then you are out of luck. Considering the majority of people say faulty intelligence is to blame for the Iraq war, it's difficult for me to encourage less intelligence surrounding foreign intelligence gathering. But I'm partial, as an American who prefers to know who and what and why we are actually fighting. It's not like we can take everyone's word for it.
- zanny 11y ago> faulty intelligence is to blame for the Iraq war, it's difficult for me to encourage less intelligence surrounding foreign intelligence gathering How about - how would you rather spend your money, spying on foreigners living in destitution, or fixing our roads? The international spy network the US maintains is probably a paltry drop in the bucket of the preposterous defense budget in this country, but honestly anything to curtail that black hole of taxpayer dollars is a win in my book. If we weren't destroying the lives of millions around the globe with our imperialism, we wouldn't have enemies to suicide bomb us with planes to require massive spy networks to try to catch American dissenters planning to commit jihad against us. The military industrial complex only exists insofar as the American people are complacent to being global police forcing their will upon anyone who does not fall in line with what the US wants. And that is after we already have trade sanctions that can decimate countries overnight. This isn't 1970 anymore. We don't need to have a dick waving contest with the next largest nuclear arsenal trying to ruin the lives of billions of people in a juvenile game to show who is the coolest kid, whose god is the best, or whose economic model should rule the world. Maybe its time to just back the fuck off and take our tendrils out of every nation on Earth for once and maybe try to be good to our fellow man.
- dragontamer 11y agoSo we stop spying on people? Let me ask you: do you think it is better or worse that we _know_ about ISIS? Mind you, Obama knows enough about ISIS that he is confident to keep troops out of the Middle East. Would he have that confidence if it weren't for the spy network? Or would it be closer to a George Bush ordeal with Iraq War. George Bush was working off of a CIA that was cut by 20% to 30% by Clinton. He was practically flying blind. (Yes, when you lose 25% of your _workers_ between 1990 and 2000, the CIA will begin to make some pretty crappy decisions) Here's another question. Do you think Israel would have continued to stand down against Iran if it weren't for the intelligence sharing programs between US and Israel? Intelligence stops wars. Intelligence tempers decisions. When leaders fly blind, they instead make hasty decisions and over-react to threats. Lets say the US stops spying on Iran... what do you think Israel will do without any information? Hell, there's a reason why the US spies on Israel, and Israel spies on us. Even allies spy on each other: its the most reliable source of information. Even _with_ information sharing agreements, countries will spy on each other behind each other's backs. https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Jonathan_Pollard https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Jonathan_Pollard Frankly, I'd want to know what Israel's plans are if we stopped giving them information. Don't you? I mean, yeah, we support them and all... but lets hope they're not gonna do anything crazy (like... use their nukes, or something). Or do you think Israel will actually tell us these details, even if they are our Allies? Nah man, the only way you make decisions as a leader is to spy on other leaders, figure out what they're thinking, and then make plans based on that.
- late2part 11y agoHoooray! Now, the real fight begins!
- ScottBurson 11y agoThank you, Edward Snowden.
- deleted 11y ago[deleted]
- wyclif 11y agoThank you, Edward Snowden and Rand Paul. FTFY.
- chx 11y agoThe EFF felt it needed to mention it's fighting this since 2006 but they left out the name of one Edward Snowden. I feel this is a dick move.
- aburan28 11y agoWhy do people think that surveillance is going to thwart real terrorist attacks? Terrorists are not stupid. Bin Laden stopped using his satellite phone in 1999 and the NSA did not intercept a single piece of audio intercept data from Bin Laden ever again. The 9/11 hijackers were mostly engineers and barely even touched technology. HUMINT is the only way to catch real terrorists IMO.
- sliverstorm 11y agoHypothetically speaking enough surveillance plus really advanced compute could find criminals indirectly. As a totally fictional example for illustrative purposes, recall Batman's "cell phone sonar" device. You don't have to touch technology to leave a footprint. Your footprints are just harder to find. Edit: I'm not saying it's a good idea, I'm just saying "you can't track terrorists who don't use technology" is false.
- flycaliguy 11y agoIt also indirectly enables criminality by eliminating people's ability to be anonymous sources to police or the press. Along the same lines, it grants anybody with privileged (or unauthorized) access to surveillance data the opportunity for any number of truly maniacal illegal acts.
- pearjuice 11y agoBut that is because 9/11 didn'really happen.
- reddytowns 11y agoHow so?
- deleted 11y ago[deleted]
- 0xCMP 11y agoDon't forget why it happened either. Rand Paul fought to make sure it didn't pass.
- wyclif 11y agoNot a single mention of Rand Paul by EFF. Is EFF stingy with credit, or do they just whitewash any mention of Paul out of Patriot Act subversion stories because he's not a Democrat? EDIT: No, really. Serious question.
- schoen 11y agoHe's mentioned (and quoted) a ton on the @EFFLive Twitter feed from today (operated by EFF staff to provide live coverage of events). https://twitter.com/EFFLive https://twitter.com/EFFLive Also mentioned and quoted repeatedly by @EFF Twitter feed during last week's Senate debate prior to the recess. https://twitter.com/EFF https://twitter.com/EFF
- briandear 11y agoStill a Twitter mention is hardly the same as mentioning it prominently in the announcement. If it were Rand Paul fighting the EFF, it's almost certain that he would be mentioned above the fold. I am also interested in why Hillary's pro-NSA position hasn't been discussed more by EFF. Have they ever criticized a prominent Democrat? Hillary has been a big NSA supporter as well as a customer during her time as Secretary of State. Obama is obviously a huge NSA advocate given he signed Patriot Act extensions.. Not a single word from the Hillary campaign about privacy. Of course, privacy and transparency aren't exactly Clintonian. What's sad is that large numbers of the tech community are still going to raise money and vote for her, regardless of the issues.
- qq66 11y agoRand Paul is a declared candidate for President, and the EFF does not make political endorsements, so they're probably trying to avoid discussing Rand Paul too much.
- drawkbox 11y agoIt is all theatre. We've moved from bulk collection to bulk receiving that collection. Think about it, it won't ever end. It is like a regular person going back to before Google/search engines. The way we think now includes that path. So in the intelligence agencies, it has been a way of life for 15 years. The have an internal "google" if you will, that has all of our information at any time. It has become the way they work and 'investigate'. It is forever part of their path. In another 5 years, which the USA Freedom Act extends section 215 to 2019[1], the intel agencies will forget how to investigate in real, old school judicial warrant driven surveillance with oversight. Judges have been worked out of the system and it is too easy to investigate with these tools for it to end. This is also not for terrorism, nearly 99% of all inquires for Patriot Act sneak and peeks have been used for domestic crime [2]. I am sure 215 is being abused in ways we won't know for years because there is lack of oversight and NSA directors openly lied to Congress before for national security. This is a domestic crime tool, not only for terrorism. It would be nice if people in power were just honest about this but they shroud it in terrorism, 'Patriot' Acts, bills called 'USA Freedom' and more disrespectful ways to the US brand. We should require all bills be named by number or by what they are, these would be 'Domestic & Foreign Surveillance Act I and II' or SB/HB 2015[some number]. That way we can debate on merit not some doublespeak name. These tools will eventually be used for corporate espionage and market manipulation, it is too useful not to. Local police will be able to get all your records, maybe even connected businessmen and bankers. If you want change, politics is not the way, it is cooked. The country runs on money and markets. If you want to change something, come up with a market solution that can get to the point where it is big enough to cause change. [1] https://www.govtrack.us/congress/bills/114/hr2048/text/ih#link=VII_705_a_~T1&nearest=H3970213DCD8B4A7C9D2AC368B1ADFDCA https://www.govtrack.us/congress/bills/114/hr2048/text/ih#li... [2] https://www.eff.org/deeplinks/2014/10/peekaboo-i-see-you-government-uses-authority-meant-terrorism-other-uses https://www.eff.org/deeplinks/2014/10/peekaboo-i-see-you-gov...
- arca_vorago 11y ago"This is a domestic crime tool, not only for terrorism." Indeed, the primary realpolitik answer that you wont hear from anybody in the beltway till theyve had a few and have a cigar in their hand is that technology has so changed the landscape of threats and potential threats that actions that used to require nation state financial, logistal, etc support can now be accomplished by a single non-state actor, hence, we really "need" to collect it all. The reason this scares the intel community so much is because generally, with some exceptions, if a foreign country sends actors over we tend to know about it due to how deep our tendrils are and the fact that we are setting ourselves up as the main repository of data for even foreign govs to access. (The point being we know what they access and look at), but if all of a sudden we feel like it could be anybody then you get an intel community thats in hypervigilante mode and that mode will wear you out fast, its a mentally degraded state for anything other than actual fighting. im guessing some modifications to the way threats are quantitavely measured is in order, but no one really wants to do that these days. Ive heard rumors over the past few years of an increasing trend to get rid of all the salty old greybeards who tell truth to power... What we will end up with is a beltway full of people who are either too naive to know better and just tout the line, or a bunch of kissass mortage-payers who would condone genocide if it made sure their kids go to a ivy league college. Which essentially what William Binneys says happened when they scrapped his lower cost program designed to at least attempt to protect privacy in favor of a billion dollar blank check for another less effective solution. The bottom line is that by attempting to collect it all before they fully understand how to parse the data, they actually weakened American security in all its various forma. I am curious though when you say come up with a market solution. The problem is that markets simply dont work like you were taught in college economics. For example, the market profitted from the weakening of American security because the more expensive program put more dollars into a few VA counties. I would like some sort of example of how the markets will ever be anything other than opposed to actual progress if it makes them less money. Therein lies the problem, weve allowed our own "representative governemnt" to become completely detached from the people due to their attachment to "markets". Does anybody in DC even remember what their oaths were anymore? to protect and defend THE CONSTITUTION OF THE UNITED STATES OF AMERICA from enemies foreign AND DOMESTIC... Id say our real enemies, the ones threatening the Constitution (as opposed to safety) are domestic, and they wear suits and ties and not burkahs, and quantifiably so.
- billions 11y agoThe Nuclear Age is over. When the major powers have strong trade and business agreements, leverage is applied incrementally rather than explosively. That said, welcome to the Software Wars era. When country A can receive significant financial leverage with a small hack of country B's market, they will. The US needs a world class software defense 'army'. However, you don't point that gun at your own people. Neither should spying be done on allies if it threatens existing partnerships. The hacking 'arms race' is just getting started.
- ChuckMcM 11y agoI think it would be great if the threat of nuclear exchanges was gone, however I don't know that I believe that.
- sliverstorm 11y agoWhen the major powers have strong trade and business agreements, leverage is applied incrementally rather than explosively. You do realize Japan attacked Pearl Harbor because we were waging economic war ("leverage") on them? Such as the oil embargo?
- Intermernet 11y agoThe Nuclear Age is far from over. If anything, we've just gone from the "only big players can afford them" to the "we don't really know who has them" stage. There were reports of the Russian Mafia having control over nuclear material. [1] The collapse of the iron curtain caused a wonderful climate for well funded criminal elements to get their hands on all sorts of nasty stuff. This is documented, but not really discussed that much. I've read that many governments are actually a lot less worried about the Russian mafia having this material than they are about North Korea having these weapons, as organised crime doesn't really stand to profit very much from a nuclear stand-off. Apparently Mossad even purchased some of it to "stop it falling into the hands of Islamic and other terror groups" [2] You can't put that genie back in it's bottle. The Nuclear Age won't be over for a while yet, it's just in a quiet phase. [1]: https://www.law.upenn.edu/journals/jil/articles/volume16/issue4/Mirsky16U.Pa.J.Int%27lBus.L.749%281995%29.pdf https://www.law.upenn.edu/journals/jil/articles/volume16/iss... [2]: http://www.rense.com/general44/maf.htm http://www.rense.com/general44/maf.htm
- Animats 11y agoIf you work for a telco, and you are currently cooperating with NSA by providing them data, you probably just lost legal authorization to do so. NSA connections should be disabled unless your corporate general counsel instructs you otherwise in writing and takes responsibility for that act.
- hias 11y agoI guess now that it ran out something very bad will happen and after that the section or something worse will be active again and will run forever. ("we can't cancel it, remember the time we didnt have it and something bad happenend?")
- krick 11y agoI can understand eff celebrating this entirely symbolical event, but cannot understand celebration in the comments. "Aren't allowed to do (for now)", "cannot do" and "won't do" are different things, and only the last two do matter.
- mrweasel 11y ago>The law that the NSA used to authorize its collection of vast amounts of information about the telephone calls of ordinary Americans is no more. But the US can still snoop on my internet traffic if it happens to parse through the US, because I'm not an American. For the majority of the world the issue was never that the NSA spied on US citizens, but that they pretty spy on everyone else as well. Don't get me wrong, I think it should be illegal for the US, or any other nation, to spy on its citizens, but it still only half the problem.
- cm2187 11y agoIn fact I have seen several articles in major european newspapers claiming that big countries are going around restrictions on spying on their own citizens by letting friendly countries do it, then exploit the data. I don't know if there is any substance in these allegations but they seem plausible.
- venomsnake 11y agoRichard Marchinko stated the same, although in his fiction books. It was in the early nineties. I would not be surprised at all.
- tehwalrus 11y agoIf you have a proper Data Protection Act(s) passed, it should be illegal for people in a country to obtain or use data stolen against the country's laws elsewhere. Not ideal, but it would make illegal the circle of spying you describe. (not that the authorities, particularly here in the UK, give a flying F about whether they're breaking existing laws...)
- DanielBMarkham 11y agoI hate playing devil's advocate on this topic, but here goes. There are _real_ terrorists out there, and also agents of other states. These folks need observation for a free country to be able to do the various things it has to do. (Or, if they don't, it remains to be shown how such a setup would effectively work). I am completely against maintaining files on your own citizens which can then be "mined" to find illegalities or improprieties later on. However -- that doesn't mean that some folks shouldn't be watched. Heck, in a country with 250M people, the odds are that there are a heckuva lot of borderline crazy people who should be monitored. I seriously hope the local constable has a good idea of the top people in his area that he should keep an eye on. I think we make a mistake when we focus on the NSA exclusively and talk as if all data collection is wrong. We need a principle that allows for nuanced collection -- not one-size-fits-all slogans. So sure, I hope the other agencies are collecting info on folks in my country, and I hope they share that information with my own country's security services -- under the right circumstances and with the right protections in place. What I don't want to see happen is the creation of a data pool where crimes can be "discovered" that normally wouldn't matter. (Really hated writing that, but somebody had to do it)
- ck2 11y agoThey will replace it with something far worse when the "news reporters" and the general public aren't paying attention. We know to look for and hate the "patriot act" they will come up with a "puppies and kittens" name that you will look like an idiot to say you hate.
- pforpineapple 11y ago"Senate rules allow a final vote, which only needs a simple majority of 51, to occur early Tuesday morning" I am not certain it'll go through. What do you think ?
- caseysoftware 11y agoLet me say it explicitly: Ending collection does not change anything. So they can't connect? So what? So GCHQ (Britain's NSA) does the collection and then shares it with the NSA. Problem solved. It's the storage of this information which should be stopped.
- mindslight 11y agoThis is like the one brief beautiful moment above the clouds in The Matrix (Revolutions). One political event from the past fourteen years that I can look at and go "something fundamental changed for the better". Finally one representative actually declaring that this system is bullshit and holding firm with spite, instead of the constant compromise and corruption. Finally laws are simply removed instead of augmented with "fixes" that just rearrange deck chairs to make a different group profit even more. Not that I have much hope of it staying this way for long. Even the EFF here is preemptively giving in and saying "USA Freedom" will be passed, because anything else would be too wild against the status quo (there's that corrupromise again!). But at least there's this one brief beautiful moment to enjoy before going back to writing code, the only way for freedom to survive the infopocalypse.