4 ms·
Not Buying a Home Could Cost You $65,000 A Year
- quasse 11y ago>The chart below comes from data published today by realtor.com An unbiased source for this article I'm sure.
- Apreche 11y agoGive me enough money for a down payment, and I'll buy. Until then, gotta live somewhere.
- johnbaboozlld 11y agoWhy should we pay for your house down payment?
- ZanyProgrammer 11y agoBecause buying a house is very expensive?
- mfisher87 11y agoThe point was probably that coming up with the money for a down payment is significantly more difficult (or less likely) today than it was in the past. Given how many graduates are burdened with loan debt.
- shanemhansen 11y agoIt is much easier in the US than other countries. 3-5% down for FHA loans is not uncommon. I own 2 houses (one that's probably worth 400k) and I definitely didn't put 20% down.
- jtreminio 11y agoFHA loans require very low down payments.
- usaar333 11y agoUnfortunately, for those of us in San Francisco, the FHA loan maximum is nearly $400k shy of the median priced home.
- arielweisberg 11y agoThis xkcd comes to mind https://xkcd.com/605/ https://xkcd.com/605/ Also boo market timing.
- digi_owl 11y agoSadly applicable to all manner of topics... And there truly is a XKCD for everything.
- e28eta 11y agoThose numbers assume you're planning on keeping it for 30 years, which skews the numbers well in favor of buying. I have coworkers in their early 30's who are already on their second house in the last 5 years. I haven't asked if they timed the market well and came out ahead, or if they regret the first house. Edit: http://www.nytimes.com/interactive/2014/upshot/buy-rent-calculator.html http://www.nytimes.com/interactive/2014/upshot/buy-rent-calc...
- nandemo 11y agoImpossible to say for sure without seeing the exact methodology and the data, but there are probably many other issues with this "study". * taking data for the past year (or for a few recent years) and extrapolating it to 30 years, instead of actually getting the data for the last 30 years * hindsight bias: 30 years ago you didn't know whether it would be better to buy a house in San Francisco or Detroit. * comparing returns on a risky, leveraged investment (buying a house) with returns on a low risk investment ("interest earned on any money renters saved").
- craftkiller 11y agoRenters tend to pay less per month than owners so if you can take that monthly difference and invest it wisely you might be able to beat the owners while keeping your freedom of location.
- RealGeek 11y agoMost renters pay more than than the owners. A typical breakdown of the rent looks like this: Rent = Mortgage payment + HOA + Property Tax + Maintenance + Land lord's profit
- muzz 11y agoIn areas where price/rent ratio is high, the "land lord's profit" portion is a large negative number
- barake 11y agoThat depends on where you live. The house a few doors down rents for $1100/month. My mortgage, insurance, and utilities for a similar home is under $850/month. Of course, I'm in Kentucky where property is dirt cheap.
- usaar333 11y agoThis is only true when price-to-rent ratios are abnormally low. It shouldn't be true most of the time: why would anyone own? On a per-month basis, renting should be more expensive than owning, especially when taking into account tax deductions that favor owning. The upside of renting is that you didn't have to unload a down payment and can in turn invest that money in something that gives higher rate of returns than property. Generally, renters pay more per month before opportunity costs are taken into account and less so (possibly even strictly less) when opportunity costs are taken into account.
- stegosaurus 11y agoThe figures themselves are a bit boring. Basic premise of owning vs renting is enough alone really. Unless you plan to move around often it should be blindingly obvious that buying is cheaper. Someone else owns a home and is renting it to you with a profit margin.
- ForHackernews 11y ago> is renting it to you with a profit margin. Not necessarily. Landlords can only charge what the market will bear. If you happen to live in a not in-demand rental market, the landlord will be renting it for whatever they can get.
- UweSchmidt 11y agoFrom what I have observed it seems that in less desirable areas renting could be more expensive than buying as everyone has _some_ money for rent (especially if there is some social security that helps) but no one wants to buy in a bad area. On the other hand there is an upper limit on rent as wages only go so high, and landlords often enjoy the high income and don't see a need to sell. People who have plenty of money and really want a nice place are willing to pay extra, so for high quality real estate buying can be more expensive than renting. Most importantly though there are ways to buy real estate cheap, and if you "buy retail" or believe the numbers you read in listings you may be the sucker in the biggest deal of your life. Chances are everyone you're dealing with in a real estate deal is super professional and extremely experienced. Price is "var", not "CONST".
- jessaustin 11y agoYou're right about professionals and suckers. A successful (i.e. he's done it for many decades) real estate investor I know says that he makes all his profit on the day he buys. In other words, a professional will only buy a property for much less than the normally-quoted "price".
- themartorana 11y agoIn Philadelphia - mentioned in the article - there is a 2% transfer tax, paid by both parties. Add 6% realtor fees, and you typical need to make 10% profit on a house/condo/apartment just to break even - this, of course, not counting the cost of insurance, home maintenance, taxes, etc. Add those costs in, and it typically needs to be 15-20% appreciation (adjusted for inflation, of course, so add a few more points) to see any profit at all. This makes buying worth while only if you're planning to hang around for at least a decade or more. We bought a 900sq ft 1br condo 7 years ago. Between mortgage, taxes, parking, condo fees, etc., our out of pocket was ~$2600. Seven years later, renting a 2br 1200 sq ft. condo in a more desirable neighborhood with garaged parking is ~$350 less per month. The article is so overly simplistic it's ridiculous. Buying is not by default cheaper, even over the long term. Over 25 years it can be forced savings, but even that privilege is paid for with interest. At the same time I could be investing our savings and it will compound in to a nice chunk of change, that I bet might be around the profit margins of buyers, minus all the expense.
- branchless 11y agoThis article is idiotic. If I miss out by 65K a year that means prices are advancing insanely. How can that be sustainable? We've seen what happens when banks printing money through land runs ahead of productivity. You get a huge crash and the govt bailout begins. We badly need a change in the way land wealth is taxed and in the way we issue money. Without this land prices will always rise to soak up all productivity gains. Today is the anniversary of the peasants' revolt in the UK, by the way.
- r00fus 11y agoWhile what you said is likely true, the fact remains that if you're not "profiting" from the problem, everyone else is doing so on your behalf. If everyone else takes a step forward, it's as if you took a step back.
- daenz 11y agoEveryone else isn't taking a step forward though, though this article would like to convince us of that. And even if they were, if the step forward means less job and location mobility, then I don't mind a step "back."
- 7Figures2Commas 11y agoIf your goal is truly to profit, buying a single property is far from ideal. You don't need to buy a house to profit from these markets. You can buy any number of REITs that own single and multi-family properties, mortgage REITs, homebuilder stocks, closed-end funds with exposure to real estate, leveraged products like ETFs and ETNs, etc. Most of these securities produce income. As an extreme example, there's a UBS ETN with the ticker MORL that tracks a global mortgage REIT index. It offers 2x leverage. It currently has a 20%+ yield and distributions are paid monthly. Is there risk? Sure. But unlike a house, you can exit your position with a few keystrokes. The great thing about investing in real estate through securities like this is that when the market slows or changes trend, you can sit on the sidelines or go short.
- usaar333 11y ago
- DenisM 11y agoPSA. Every decade or two we get a flood of these so-called "news stories": - They don't make any more land. - Real estate only goes up. - Stop paying the mortgage of your landlord, pay your own! - Buy now, or be priced out forever! - (Seattle-only) Californians are moving in and buying up all the real estate. The real news here is that the stars are aligning to start priming the pump for a new real estate bubble. This time it will be different!
- beambot 11y agoReminds me of the pg essay about suits: http://www.paulgraham.com/submarine.html http://www.paulgraham.com/submarine.html
- tdicola 11y agoIf you're in the Seattle area the gold rush for real estate is definitely back on. The only thing different between now and 2007 is that I don't see as many sign twirlers on corners. Tower cranes and new constructions are everywhere.
- jessaustin 11y ago(Seattle-only) Californians are moving in and buying up all the real estate. That would work as a scare tactic anywhere in the West. Sometimes it seems like Denver is populated mostly by Californians.
- branchless 11y agoThey are getting desperate as demographics bite.
- azakai 11y ago> To compile those numbers, realtor.com compared median home prices and the cost of renting a three-bedroom home in 382 local markets, then factored in estimates for transaction costs, price appreciation, future mortgage rates, and interest earned on any money renters saved when it was cheaper to rent. But those aren't the only costs. When you rent you are generally shielded from paying for various things, like fixing damage to the apartment or other serious maintenance. Also, renting saves you from the risk of the house losing value because of some local event like a neighborhood becoming less attractive due to a new source of noise or crime. Finally, these estimates assume home prices will rise according to "historical norms", which is a gamble. Renting also lets you move around to pursue another job in another city, without needing to worry yourself with renting out your current location. The worry might deter you from moving and getting a higher salary, or it might make you spend the time, effort and risk to rent out the place you own, which brings its own costs. It's hard to quantify those things. Some are unlikely events, some affect the variance instead of the mean, and some depend on the individual (how likely you are to find a job in another city - probably fairly high for people reading HN compared to other industries). But I never see them taken into account in articles like this.
- digi_owl 11y ago> Finally, these estimates assume home prices will rise according to "historical norms", which is a gamble. Especially as "historical norms" have been running on a massive Ponzi scheme for decades.
- rehitman 11y agoExactly, this is just an article by realtors to stress out people to buy homes, even if they cannot afford it or doesn't match their life situation. There are lots of cost associated with owning home that people usually ignore. They just see the mortgage, which sometime is less than their current rent. However, in my experience mortgage payment is just around 60% percent of the cost. You have taxes, more expensive insurance, and depending on your house. HOA, landscaping. large maintenance like furnace, water heater, roof, crawl space, and if you want to sell it in 10 years from now, you have to spend around 10-20k at the time to update appliance. I don't want to say it is always a bad investment. My point is it is a lot more complex investment and needs research, and not buying can also be a good option for some people.
- jchrome 11y agoHURRY UP AND BUY!
- rhizome 11y agoYou want to lock in that equity before you're priced out of the market.
- shanemhansen 11y agoI can't tell other people what they should do, but I'm very happy I own my home. I have a 3% interest rate and got a great deal because of the recession. I also own pets and don't have to stress about what some landlord thinks about that. My rent isn't going to go up. People in SF are signing 2 year leases just to get into an apartment. Do they really have more freedom to move? I'm free to do things like build raised bed gardens and rainwater irrigation systems. We just made our house way more energy efficient because we are environmentalists. If a landlord would even allow me to do those things, it would still be pointless because I'd just be making his house nicer, not mine.
- rocky1138 11y ago> My rent isn't going to go up. Do you have to pay property taxes? I'm sure not all states have them, but here in Ontario, we do. If you own a home, you must pay tax on that home every year. This is a form of rent and goes up with changing regimes and adjustments in the value of your home. http://www.mah.gov.on.ca/Page10240.aspx http://www.mah.gov.on.ca/Page10240.aspx
- simoneau 11y agorealtor.com? Realtors think it is ALWAYS a good time to buy. "Never ask a barber if you need a haircut."
- deleted 11y ago[deleted]
- derekp7 11y agoIf you are going to go the home ownership route, by all means avoid the 30-year fixed mortgage -- even with lower interest rates. So lets say you buy a $200K house on a 30-year, 20% down. If you take the monthly payments, plus property tax and insurance, you could pay down a 90 - 100K condo within 5 years. Then sell it and use that as a down payment on a $160k house (so again borrowing only 60K) and pay that off in anther 5 years. By years 11-15 you could live in a $200 house and have it payed off in 5 years, instead of starting off with that house and having only half the mortgage payed down by then. The best part of this, is you are protected from the market going up or down. So say the market tanks, and your initial house loses value after 5 years. The worst thing is that you are living in a paid off house. The best part -- the next house you wanted to move up to is probably cheaper as well, so it balances out. And if the market goes up, well that means that you can sell your initial house for much more, increasing the down payment on the next bigger house.
- tonetheman 11y agorealtor.com spam ignore and move on
- branchless 11y agoI know - why is this rubbish on hacker news of all places?
- Eternalspting22 11y agoHaving a roof over your head costs money! The basic premise of this article is rising cost of real estate in perpetuity. If that were not true there would be no difference to ownership just different timing of cash flows due to different financing! It is atrocious that Bloomberg of all places published such low quality writing simply using appeal to authority and not going deeper into the assumptions!!! In the long run it makes no difference if you factor all costs! There is also a major lifestyle issue besides the costs.