3 ms·
This project is pretty awesome... though I'm not clear on what happens after you are setup. Does mail-in-a-box then provide the scripts to perform regular soft
by tracker1 11y ago
This project is pretty awesome... though I'm not clear on what happens after you are setup.
Does mail-in-a-box then provide the scripts to perform regular software updates and any configuration migrations between versions? There's more to running software than the initial setup... A complete Mail solution in a Unix-like environment consists of a lot of disconnected programs with their own configurations that are difficult to get running, and even more difficult to maintain without a full time systems administrator in place.
I mentioned in another discussion recently how much I would love to see something akin to SmarterMail available as a simple package install Cross-Platform (one of the best mail server softwares out there imho, from a setup/upgrade POV) but commercial and tied to Windows for deployments... If I didn't have to work for a living, I'd probably start something like this. Mail services are usually made far more complicated than they should be, and I understand there are a lot of desired features... but I do feel that having a good module/plugin system that one could be developed that isn't the pain that current solutions are.
To me a current mail solution should provide, SMTP, POP3, IMAP, WebMail, and WebAdmin at a minimum... Value adds would be easy multi-domain support, easy to configure AV/Spam plugins, Calendars + Sharing and Group Contact Sharing. Honestly, the only solutions with a relatively easy setup for this are for Windows... All the nix solutions are cobbled together bits that are very hard to upgrade and maintain versions and require a lot more breadth of knowledge than a single product. I've tried many of the systems for nix and they mostly suck in practice.. some more than others.
- joshdata 11y ago> Does mail-in-a-box then provide the scripts to perform regular software updates and any configuration migrations between versions? Yes it does.
- tracker1 11y agoThanks... I ran my own mail server for a number of years, but with only a handful of accounts, it finally became far easier to just outsource... I've been thinking of doing something like mail-in-a-box on a cloud/vps host, but the time/frustration in maintaining such a thing has kept me away.
- _cbdev 11y ago> Mail services are usually made far more complicated than they should be, and I understand there are a lot of desired features... That was my impression of the whole thing, too. I've long had an exim configuration I could decorate my walls with, without understanding what most of it did or if it was secure. Recently, I got so fed up I began writing my own mail server suite. It's still pretty basic and in development, but it does have some of the features you mention, namely > SMTP > POP3 > WebMail (though rudimentary) > WebAdmin > Multi-Domain support In the pipeline, but not yet ready > IMAP > Plugins Some of the goals of the project are to have a mail processing suite with a clear interface between the modules, as well as easy extensibility and configuration. Me and some people I've talked into testing it already run some instances, and so far it has proved pretty stable. Caveat: The backend is an SQLite database, so if your use-case is serving a lot of clients, there might be some lock contention. If you're interested, check out https://github.com/cmail-mta https://github.com/cmail-mta / http://cmail.rocks/ http://cmail.rocks/
- tracker1 11y agoIf you separate each account's folders/inbox into a separate sqlite database, with the accounts/configuration in another, it probably wouldn't be to bad at even moderate scale. But for < 100 users one sqlite db would probably be sufficient. (on a relatively fast drive/ssd)
- _cbdev 11y agoThat's actually exactly what you can already do with cmail ;) Each user can optionally be assigned a "user database", storing only the mails in her own inbox (which also allows users to have direct control over their own mail database). If this is not used, mail is stored in the master database. As you said, most normal deployments should not run into those limits, but its worth keeping them in mind.
- peterwwillis 11y agoWhy not use Maildir, or really any other standard scalable mail storage format? The most annoying thing in the universe is trying to export mail from one client to another with incompatible formats. Well, okay, maybe Vogon poetry is worse, but e-mail is a close second.
- lfowles 11y ago> Does mail-in-a-box then provide the scripts to perform regular software updates and any configuration migrations between versions? There's more to running software than the initial setup... A complete Mail solution in a Unix-like environment consists of a lot of disconnected programs with their own configurations that are difficult to get running, and even more difficult to maintain without a full time systems administrator in place. If so, I'd be extremely tempted to switch over. I already use Postfix/Dovecot/Roundcube, but Roundcube is currently broken because of conf changes between upgrades and Dovecot has been _horribly_ broken (taken a week+ to sort out) by a big configuration change on their side a couple of years ago :\
- Scramblejams 11y agoI'm curious about all these comments about how much time it takes to maintain these systems. I've run a Debian+Courier+Spamassassin+Roundcube setup for over a decade for friends and family, and the maintenance required has been quite minimal. I have a script that emails me when security updates are available, and apt-get upgrade just takes a few seconds. Every couple of years I have to upgrade the Debian version, but that rarely takes more than a couple of hours. Outside of that, it just runs and runs. Having said that, I am comfortable doing all that Linux sysadmin stuff, so maybe that's the difference. And if I were offering email accounts to people I didn't know, that would be an entirely different maintenance challenge.