8 ms·
In Europe, Fake Jobs Can Have Real Benefits
- neil1 11y agoIt seems like it would be a much more productive use of human capital to actually do the work below cost so something is actually being accomplished.
- rsynnott 11y agoAt that point, the state (who is ultimately paying for most of this) would be competing unfairly with private companies (in particular, it would not be paying minimum wage). This is probably not a good idea. In Ireland we have a scheme where an unemployed person can get an extra 50 euro a week on their unemployment benefit, in return for which they do an internship for a private company, which must at least in principle be training-oriented. In practice, this can cause a problem where these 'internships' displace the need to create real jobs.
- detaro 11y agoThis system also likely works without making changes to wage laws etc, and makes clear that it is temporary and to help people get a job and not a source of cheap labor (which quickly would take over "real", normally paid jobs, which would mean more people are unemployed, ...)
- pjc50 11y agoThe UK has a nastier version of this: you can be compelled to do unpaid work or lose your unemployment benefit. Some of this is displacing real jobs in the low-paid retail sector. Some of it results in people standing around in hi-viz jackets doing nothing for 35 hours a week. https://welfaretales.wordpress.com/2015/05/15/workfare-forced-labour-and-the-new-business-and-community-wardens/ https://welfaretales.wordpress.com/2015/05/15/workfare-force... The (rather idealised sounding, by the NYT's description) European version is about keeping people engaged with society by giving them things that feel like work so they have colleagues, a familiarity with working practices, and a feeling of usefulness. The British version seems to regard sitting at home while unemployed as an outrageous privilege; drudgery must be imposed on those people otherwise they're better off than the 'hardworking' people who must suffer commuting and not seeing their family. A previous version was declared illegal, so the government enacted "emergency" legislation to retroactively legalise it. http://www.politics.co.uk/news/2013/03/19/ids-emergency-jobseeker-law-sparks-civil-liberties-outrage http://www.politics.co.uk/news/2013/03/19/ids-emergency-jobs...
- vixen99 11y agoIt's a free lunch for all is it? Someone pays (if not the descendants yet to be conceived who will be making interest payments on current debts) so it's certainly drudgery on the folk who have to pay for those sitting at home.
- pjc50 11y agoI suppose that's how you keep the chain of economic coercion through threat of starvation going. "We are giving you this free lunch, because we're uncomfortable with people starving to death in a first world country, but in order to maintain the strict ranking that citizens are only allowed happiness in proportion to their income, we're going to inflict useless activity on you. Don't have a nice day or it'll come out of your benefits." (Current debt is being issued at 0.5% interest rates, a historic low)
- areyousure 11y agoThough you are correct that interest rates are very low, I believe it is disingenuous to quote the rate of a gilt with a maturity under 10 years. (You have mentioned the 2-year gilt.)
- rsynnott 11y agoYep, Workfare is definitely far worse than Jobbridge (the Irish scheme); in particular Jobbridge is not mandatory (or even particularly common) and the internship has to provide useful experience and training (though there has been abuse of this; a major supermarket chain was advertising shelf-stacking jobs as Jobbridge internships for a while before getting caught).
- jules 11y agoYou could do things that are not in competition with any company (or in minimal competition). For example visiting and having a chat with lonely elderly.
- yummyfajitas 11y agoI don't understand why they don't simply do real work. Are all possible useful services in France already provided? Why not simply have these unemployed people work for the government, instead of hiring overpriced union workers?
- rsynnott 11y agoSo, replace a highly-trained essentially unfireable labour force who'll mostly stick around for life with a labour force which would more or less turn over entirely every year (as noted in the article, people who do these schemes tend to get real jobs afterwards)? This seems like a bad idea.
- Cthulhu_ 11y agoBecause there is no real work? If there was a pet webshop like the one described in the article, these people could go there and work there. There isn't though, else they'd be working. Simple economics, really. As for working for the government, that depends on whether the government has any jobs that suit these people. If you're suggesting they could work for their unemployment benefits... that's a legal problem, because then they'd technically not be unemployed anymore and would cost the government / tax payer more money. Although they'd be tax payers themselves again via income tax. It gets very confusing really. TL;DR: One does not simply create jobs.
- nhaehnle 11y agoBecause there is no real work? Really? I suspect that our eyes are merely blinded to positive things that can be done but that currently nobody is willing to pay for. In ageing societies, think about services for the elderly. The elderly benefit, and if the job is designed humanely (i.e. not with the aim of extracting as much profit as possible at any cost), it could also benefit the one who does it. What about making the cities we live in more beautiful by creating new municipal gardens and tending to them? These are just two examples. Once you look outside the usual economic spheres you can certainly find more. Somehow, I have the feeling that it would be more valuable to society if the people working fake jobs as described in the article actually did something useful instead. That could still provide training as a side effect.
- RyanZAG 11y agoWould it be legal for these people to start a real business in that office? Even if it's something like knitting a jersey and then spending the next week trying to sell it for 10 bucks, at least they'd be 10 bucks richer than spending all that effort doing nothing. It's not like they don't have time or resources to run a business - they're running a fake one.
- fab13n 11y agoIt wouldn't be training anymore, so they'd lose their unemployment benefits. There should be a gentler ramp-up from unemployment benefits to sustainable business, but there isn't so as of today the practical answer to your question is "no, it's not legal".
- k-mcgrady 11y ago>> "There should be a gentler ramp-up from unemployment benefits to sustainable business" There is. In the UK you can work up to 16 hours per week while on unemployment benefits. If self-employed you also don't have to pay national insurance until your profit exceeds a certain level.
- deepnet 11y agoIn theory yes. In practice the UK poverty trap is very real and crushing to the entrepreneurship of the economically disenfranchised.
- dllthomas 11y agoI've been wondering if it wouldn't make sense to help businesses with a portion of the salary of people who have been out of work for a long stretch of time, to offset the cost of retraining.
- weddpros 11y agoI'm ashamed I'm french... How can one think "let's start a fake company" instead of asking real companies to train these people for real? and for free... How is it OK to work for a fake company, but it's bad to work for free for a real company and gain some real experience... How come?
- thadd 11y agoThis article makes me feel like Yossarian
- sakri 11y agoHow they had it wrong. Instead of robotics liberating mankind from bullshit jobs, we create imaginary bullshit jobs for those who aren't suffering from one. Amazing. Pretty soon people will pay for these oppportunities.
- kokey 11y agoThey will also have to borrow money to pay for these, and these loans will add up.
- redblacktree 11y agoWe'll call it "University!"
- rwmj 11y agoYou wrote what I was going to say, but better. If there is a good thing about all this, it's that the nakedness of the emperor is fully exposed here.
- pjc50 11y agoPeople have already been known to pay for internships.
- stephengillie 11y agoYour perception is that a job is somewhere you go to be productive, work, and get things done. For a lot of people, a job is - in Starbucks' marketing phrasing, a "second space" - a different physical space to occupy, and different people to interact with. A way to occupy their day. I've said it before: a large part of the reason I'm in IT, and not automotive mechanics or environmental conservationism, is because I can spend my days in temperature-controlled office buildings, instead of on the cold and muddy ground or cold and damp forests. Some people grudgingly leave their warm beds to stay in an office building in exchange for currency they can use for food and shelter. I feel as though this is a type of modern autarky, and it gets shamed by those of us whose dreams and ambitions involve building useful or cool things with available technology.
- garagemc2 11y agoWow it's like a whole another world. I really like the idea - much more effective form of training than traditional types. Everyone knows about the scarring effects of long term unemployment (if not http://bit.ly/1Qf8ue3 http://bit.ly/1Qf8ue3). This is a good way to combat that scarring.
- benoitg 11y agoSeconded, there's a discouraging element to being unemployed. Besides the training angle, this helps people to stay confident and even improve their skills. I'm wondering how this could be translated to software development. Setting up an IT department in these virtual companies would be a very good idea. Going further, you could even sell the software and kickstart real software businesses in the B2B space, this could be a tremendous opportunity to help software developers to learn about marketing, sales, accounting, etc.
- aselzer 11y agoFake jobs might be necessary but there is a danger of making them half fake jobs that get things done slowly and end up as a cost to society and the people supporting the workers. An example of that I've observed are construction workers maintaining railway infrastructure. There are probably a few times as many people working there as needed. When walking by you'll see them standing around talking, or maybe one of them is sitting in an excavator and four are staring at him. Meanwhile people have to take the replacement buses for two months. Most of the work only gets done in the first and last week, largely using machines, while everyone relying on the train connection is at risk of delays or has to spend extra time on the journey.
- mattmanser 11y agoThis is so incredibly ignorant and judgemental I don't know where to start. http://www.quora.com/Why-does-it-always-look-like-construction-workers-are-standing-around-doing-nothing http://www.quora.com/Why-does-it-always-look-like-constructi...
- themartorana 11y agoYes and no. While there is legitimate "standing around" as your link makes clear, and safety should be paramount, most building projects from where I am - Philadelphia - take twice as long as the Empire State Building at 1/4 the size. We have labor unions that contribute to the problem, but you can't imagine how slowly work goes around here. I'm aware that OSHA rules are different, and we have a higher standard of safety now than we did, but so too have materials and tools and building methods improved.
- saalweachter 11y agoThe Empire State Building was completed in one year and 45 days ... with 7 million man-hours of labor. Given 2000 man-hours in a work-year, that is 3100 people employed full time building the Empire State Building. I would be surprised if the buildings you're thinking of in Philadelphia are employing even a tenth of that full time, continuously.
- 11y ago
- dataker 11y agoI wonder if rate of governments barricading SMBs is a good metric for tyranny.
- aluhut 11y agoThis is horrible and scary. I could imagine it would be possible to establish such a business without telling the people that it's fake... Why not simply give the people the money and use the space to help them creating new ideas? Or hell....get another child and raise it properly. Or...I don't know there is a whole universe of better solutions then this. This is the nightmare version of the 60s/70s dream of less work through robots.
- rsynnott 11y ago> I could imagine it would be possible to establish such a business without telling the people that it's fake... I think they might notice that they weren't being paid... Bear in mind, this is not actually a fake job, despite the title; it's a rather contrived training scheme (and a reasonably successful one; as noted in the article most people who do this do get a proper job after).
- maratd 11y agoThe frightening part really is that no actual profitable business wants their labor for free. So they must provide their labor for free to a fake business. That's insane. That means in all probability, their labor is a negative for any employer even if it comes at no cost. My guess is that this is a result of idiotic labor laws and tax practices.
- jqm 11y agoSounds like an interesting simulation. I would suggest they throw in some politically backstabbing co-workers, 20 hours a week of useless meetings and a psychopathic self serving boss to make it more lifelike.
- kokey 11y agoI think this is a bit extreme on the fake side, but I have found somewhere between that and a real job that works quite well, while not being fake. There are agencies that will make you come in like a 9-5 job, help you write your CV, help you communicate with recruitment agencies and give you interview training, will effectively teach you about the recruitment industry and the sales industry since you will be selling yourself. You will do this with other people in an office who are either looking for work like you are, or who are between temporary or contract jobs, so it also offers an opportunity to network.
- jarek 11y ago> There are agencies that will make you come in like a 9-5 job, help you write your CV, help you communicate with recruitment agencies and give you interview training, will effectively teach you about the recruitment industry and the sales industry since you will be selling yourself. This is an extension - teaches you what to do once you actually get the job. As far as training for skills required in modern office goes, it sounds pretty good actually. We don't need superheroes to answer email.
- dllthomas 11y ago"I have found somewhere between that and a real job that works quite well, while not being fake." You have found that in a rigorous scientific study, a methodical comparison between approaches, personal experience, or second-hand experience?
- dazmcg 11y agoWasn't this the plot of the matrix or something?
- xefer 11y agoThe reminds me of the dryly satiric, darkly comic Magnus Mills novel "The Scheme for Full Employment"[1]. It concerns "UniVan" drivers delivering loads to different UniVan depots around the country. It eventually becomes apparent that the only thing they are delivering are UniVan parts and the only work being done at the depots is maintenance and repair of the UniVans themselves. The entire enterprise had been established to provide busy work. [1] http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/The_Scheme_for_Full_Employment http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/The_Scheme_for_Full_Employment
- bohm 11y agoSelf-Driving cars will obsolete Univan Drivers
- CPLX 11y agoThe HN self-driving car fetish has apparently metastasized out of its usual Uber and Google threads and has started infecting and spawning here in totally unrelated topics apparently.
- moron4hire 11y agoDude, it's on-topic. The conversation is about people losing jobs because of automation. The comment was that even the fake jobs will probably get automated away.
- pjc50 11y agoWorse than that, they eventually go on strike, causing the scheme to collapse.
- gls2ro 11y agoThere might be a solution to do real work and not disrupt other people jobs (or lower the salaries) and this might be to do Volunteering. I'm thinking everybody wins in this case: the worker who is actually doing work and contributing to something, the NGO/non-profit who always needs more labor and (maybe) the society in general.
- gexla 11y agoI'm pretty sure I used to do something like this as a kid. And after the fake job, let's all meet up for a tea party in the back room. If you aren't into tea, then feel free to grab yourself a fake cold one from the fake fridge. If you are going to fake something like this, at least you could be a fake lawyer (you can't handle the truth,) doctor (whoo, that might be scandalous!) or astronaut. Personally, I could come up with a really long list of things to spend my time on that would be helpful to society and potentially land me a job (or make me money.) Just allowing people access to the basics of putting something together (internet connected terminals) might be more worthwhile. Too bad these places can't teach people how to think outside the system in creating roles in society.
- pingou 11y ago"The success rate of the training centers is high. About 60 to 70 percent of those who go through France’s practice firms find jobs, often administrative positions, Mr. Troton said. But in a reflection of the shifting nature of the European workplace, most are low-paying and last for short stints, sometimes just three to six months." Doesn't seem that high a success to me. I'm sure it helps, but we don't know how much it cost, and it doesn't seem really scalable. It would be interesting to know how it compares to other training methods.
- LaurensBER 11y agoIt might not be the most effective way but it also gives people a reason to get up in the morning and some structure and social interaction in their lives. I think that's a very important benefit that's often overlooked. This is as much about making unemployment bearable than it is about training people.
- fab13n 11y agoAs developers obsessed, sometimes unhealthily so, with optimization, this strikes us as an inadmissible waste. However, we need to remember that a lot of what we perceive as "legitimate" jobs are also bullshit jobs. Even if they're not exactly zero-sum games, many jobs are more about diverting money from company A to company B than creating net wealth. Take marketing and advertising departments operating on inelastic markets: every dollar taken to Adidas by a Nike marketing guy is cancelled by a dollar taken to Nike by an Adidas marketing guy. And even if they can convince you to buy more shoes, every additional dollar spent on shoes is one less dollar for your video game budget. We treat salaried work as an intrinsically good thing rather than a necessary evil: that's the fundamental fallacy that makes the mock companies in this article morally justifiable in many people's eyes. To sustain that "work ethics", we pretend that people wouldn't do anything socially useful if they didn't get a salary in exchange, despite overwhelming evidence to the contrary (stay-at-home parents, most retired people in sound health and financial situations, philanthropists... People only work for salary, because they're in a vital need for a salary. And as every decent manager knows, extrinsic motivation kills intrinsic motivation) Central planning won't solve the problem of inefficient exploitation of human workforce, as demonstrated by communist countries. But the situation is very comparable to an arms race, and there already are many multilateral agreements to limit this arms race, some legal (can't hire a hitman to dispatch your competitors' executives), some informal (no-employee-poaching agreements), and some illegal and secret (cartels). If we were to admit that wealth creation, not salaried occupation, is what we should thrive for, multilateral agreements to limit unproductive work could be set up. The net result would be orders of magnitude bigger that thwarting the couple of ridiculous initiatives, such as illustrated here, to conceal unemployment and unemployability. Here are some examples of wealth-creation-promoting reforms, which don't require central planning: punitive taxes on advertizing; mandatory long warranties on product to tackle obsolescence; limiting lottery-like legal actions by banning "no gain=no fee" lawyer hiring, and by making it standard for the loser to pay the winner's fees (that would probably kill patent trolls). A key reason why we focus on preserving jobs rather than maximizing job efficiency is that we use salary both as a way to create wealth through work, and to distribute it through wages. It becomes a poorer and poorer way to generate wealth on average, but as long as we don't set up better complementary ways to distribute wealth, we're doomed to create more and more bullshit, pointless jobs. Capitalism reaches its limits later than communism, but when it does, it also becomes a wildly inefficient converter of human work. Another reason is that the jobs which give power are often those which control and displace wealth flow, rather than those creating net wealth. What's the lawyer/engineer ratio in Senate and Congress? You can't expect those in power to destroy their power tools, if they can help it.
- deepnet 11y agohttps://www.ted.com/talks/jeremy_howard_the_wonderful_and_terrifying_implications_of_computers_that_can_learn https://www.ted.com/talks/jeremy_howard_the_wonderful_and_te... Jobocalypse
- danbruc 11y agoEvery time a come across the topic of unemployment I wonder what the fundamental thing is that is broken in an economy with a high unemployment rate. I mean unemployed people mean unused workforce and it seems that there should be a strong desire to make use of unused workforce. So what is it? Are the unemployed not needed? Because we reached a level of efficiency and automation so that we no longer need all the available workforce to satisfy all the demand, i.e. is it a work distribution problem? This seems not to be the case because there are not enough teachers, the infrastructure is in bad shape, there are heavily overworked people and so on. Do they have the wrong profession, one where no additional workforce is required? Is it a latency effect, i.e. available workforce in one sector lacks behind needed workforce while it is the opposite in another sector? Are they obsoleted by cheaper labor abroad? Is it some kind of local extremum or vicious cycle in which the economy got stuck, e.g. unemployed would consume stuff if they were employed and earned money but because they are not and they do not there is less demand and in consequence the jobs to employ them are not created? This seems easily solved with loans breaking the cycle by creating the demand first.
- nkassis 11y agoWell there are multiple things going on here that lead to this. I don't think it's a single thing. It's hard to retrain people for new jobs. Productivity has been going up so demand for labor to fulfill the same output goes down. Teachers and infrastructure are government funded things. To increase teachers and infrastructure you need the political side to vote for it which isn't happening right now. There are a lot of other factors.
- slvr77 11y agoHealthy economies will always displace workers through creative destruction. For example, the internal combustion engine decreased demand for horse whip makers but increased demand for oil workers. While few horse whip makers could make the transition to oil workers a healthy economy can usually adjust. Structural problems in economies can also create sub-optimal use of labor. For example, in a debt based economy debt and savings are just call options on future labor (production). In a healthy economy the concept of debt and savings is used as a way for people to buy and sell call options on their labor. For example a student may choose to sell a call option on his labor by taking on debt for an education with the expectation that his labor will be more valuable in the future. Somebody in middle age may chose to buy a call option on the students labor with the expectation that the value of his labor will decline in his old age. However in a pathological economy structural problems can create sub-optimal use of labor. For example, if deflation becomes entrenched then all rational actors may chose to defer consumption into the future where labor will be cheaper. This can create structural unemployment like it did in the 1930's. Other examples where the available call option on future labor is smaller than the demand. For example the demand from Baby Boomers looking at retirement, demand from the 1% to maintain their relative wealth, corporate coffers that can't be repatriated due to tax minimization strategies and sovereign wealth funds may exceed the productive capacity of the future labor pool. In that case the economic system may be 'signaling' to the rising generation to defer their labor but in a way that exceeds their actual capacity to defer the labor creating sub-optimal use of labor.
- liberte82 11y agoWorkfarce
- WordSkill 11y agoEurope is broken.
- WordSkill 11y agoEurope is broken.
- jokoon 11y agoas a french, this cracked me up. I've been unemployed for a long time, and I'd love to try this.