3 ms·
We could have technologically guaranteed the energy security of the US for a lot less than the budget cost of the Iraq war (which itself ignores the costs of th
by SilasX 11y ago
We could have technologically guaranteed the energy security of the US for a lot less than the budget cost of the Iraq war (which itself ignores the costs of the lost lives and soured diplomatic relations).
For $1 trillion we could have blanketed the deserts with solar arrays, Manhattan Project'd fusion, and developed synthetic fuel technology that would have let us turn grid energy into liquid fuels.
The amount spent was truly mind-boggling, and the opportunity cost hard to grasp.
- timr 11y agoI think you missed the part where I said that I don't buy it as a justification for our adventures in Iraq.
- SilasX 11y agoNo, I saw that. My point was that, even if you did justify the war by how it provided energy security, there were far cheaper ways to obtain that security.
- timr 11y agoWhich, again, had nothing to do with my point. I said that I don't buy it as an argument for the war. But I'm not trying to justify the war. I'm saying that the comparison made by the OP between the supercollider and the war isn't valid.
- SilasX 11y agoHow is it irrelevant whether research investments would have more efficiently achieved the war's aims? Why would that not validate the comparison between the supercollider and a war for energy security?
- soup10 11y agoMaybe, but it's not like people aren't already working on those things. If they were easy problems they would of been solved already. We do actually spend a ton of money on government funded R&D but it's also terribly inefficient in how it's allocated. Grant system is terribly designed. Maybe it reduces corruption but hard to believe the trade-off of not really knowing the people/teams/companies being funded is worth it.