9 ms·
Data furnaces arrive in Europe: Free heating, if you have fibre Internet
- dmritard96 11y agoWhat happens in summer?
- glibgil 11y agoIt still heats of course. It's free heat.
- Carrok 11y agoif you "turn off" the eRadiator, the servers don't actually turn off; the heat is just pushed outside Same as in a data center, the heat gets pushed outside.
- jessaustin 11y agoTFA: To be eligible for the eRadiator, your home has to have... "an external wall" ... and the external wall is needed for venting (if you "turn off" the eRadiator, the servers don't actually turn off; the heat is just pushed outside). Admittedly, without active refrigeration this is unlikely to work too well when the temperature outside is over 35 C. EDIT: they don't mention separate electric supplies, so presumably the unit has a way of tracking its power usage and reimbursing the homeowner. Otherwise this is just a scam, because far more efficient electrical [EDIT: thanks 'votingprawn!] heat pumps are available for less initial cost. However, the non-scam scenario seems only to make sense as a business in cold locations.
- nine_k 11y agoMakes complete sense in Scandinavia, Iceland, Alaska, etc.
- jessaustin 11y agoIs this a correction? A clarification? Was it insensitive to describe those places as "cold"?
- nine_k 11y agoA clarification. For instance, there's plenty of cold in Antarctica, but no fiber and not enought dwellings. In Scandinavia, high fixed broadband penetration is actually combined with cold most of the year. (JFYI, Finnish official definition of summer is temperatures above +10°C for entire 24 hours.)
- votingprawn 11y ago> because far more efficient electrical heaters How are you defining efficiency here? Efficiency is usually defined as (useful power out)/(power in), and basically all the power that goes into a computer comes out again as heat, which in this case is considered useful. Not really convinced you could buy a heater that was measurably more efficient. ETA: heat pump would do it, didn't spring to mind when I read heater though!
- tinkerdol 11y ago> seems only to make sense as a business in cold locations. I'd change that to read "in cold or temperate locations." There are plenty of locations in Europe for example that rarely have days over 30 C yet don't often get below freezing in the winter. Doesn't make sense to describe these places as particularly "cold."
- jloughry 11y agoCloud computing users don't care---modulo network latency and, to some extent, national laws regarding data privacy and seizure of servers---where their servers are physically located. When it's summer in the northern hemisphere, it's winter in the southern; I'm sure they're looking at South America too.
- wmf 11y agoSure, but I don't think the provider can afford to buy servers and only run them for half the year.
- dzhiurgis 11y agoInternational speeds on a consumer grade line are usually crap, around 10% of declared speed. This could be a supplement for existing systems, perhaps even a backup or to serve some use spikes. But definitely not a replacement.
- toomuchtodo 11y agoThis is best suited for async workloads (think EC2 spot instances or cpu intensive distributed computing tasks) where network performance isn't critical.
- blacksmith_tb 11y agoWe just need to roll our own clusters of RPi-s driven off Peltier junctions arctic-silvered to the side, and we can run our own parasitic cloud provider off the waste heat. It's turtles all the way down...
- dzhiurgis 11y agoI assume next versions will have AC? There are only few days a year when it gets over 30 in Scandinavia & Baltics.
- arethuza 11y agoProbably more like a few days a decade when it even approaches that here in Scotland!
- michaelleland 11y agoWhat about the electricity costs to run the machines?
- ihsw 11y agoIt's a cost-sharing agreement, so electricity costs are split between the data-furnace provider and the home-owner.
- jsprogrammer 11y agoAccording to the efficiency of the device?
- caf 11y agoThe heating efficiency has to be 100%, because the electricity isn't being converted into any other energy form. (That's still worse than an electric heat pump though, though - those have > 100% heating efficiency in terms of electricity input).
- jsprogrammer 11y agoEverything above 0K will emit photons, no?
- wlesieutre 11y ago
- ville 11y agoThere's a datacenter in Helsinki that pushes its heat to a district heating system. http://www.theguardian.com/environment/2010/jul/20/helsinki-data-centre-heat-homes http://www.theguardian.com/environment/2010/jul/20/helsinki-...
- ersii 11y agoThere's also one in Stockholm, Sweden owned by Bahnhof AB: http://www.opendistrictheating.com/pilots/bahnhof-thule/ http://www.opendistrictheating.com/pilots/bahnhof-thule/ (From the same company that also has the "James Bond Data Center").
- jsingleton 11y agoNice article. It certainly works at scale because of the economies. I think this distributed system has potential but there are some issues. There are also some things they could do to make it better if the trial is a success. Using resistive heating (which is what this is) is not very efficient (even if it's a by-product). A better way to heat your home is to not waste power and use it instead to run an electric heat pump (which are over 100% efficient). There is a good analysis in the "Mythconceptions" section at the end of chapter I.11 of the excellent "Sustainable Energy — without the hot air" [0] on p71 (p84 of the free PDF). That's the downside but there are some interesting applications. They could enable you to host your own personal cloud on the box in your home. So you know where it is. You could vary the operating time of the servers so they only operate (or at least only run at 100%) when heating is needed. This could be based on the season, an external temperature sensor or weather data. Processing could migrate between the hemispheres of the world depending on the season. The load could also be varied based on the local grid demands and power mix. Various real-time data sources are available that report on how green the current energy mix is [1] [2]. You can even just measure the frequency of the electricity to see how well generation is matching consumption. This is known as dynamic demand or demand shaping and you can even be paid by the grid operator for it so it could be a good business model. It would also be nice if they partnered with green power companies that buy their energy from renewable sources. [0] http://www.withouthotair.com/download.html http://www.withouthotair.com/download.html [1] http://www.earth.org.uk/_gridCarbonIntensityGB.html http://www.earth.org.uk/_gridCarbonIntensityGB.html [2] http://www.gridwatch.templar.co.uk/ http://www.gridwatch.templar.co.uk/
- hyperion2010 11y agoI heated my room in college for 4 years using nothing but a Q6600, never turned on the radiator once. Nice solution, but probably will have issues cooling for anywhere that has 90F summer temps.
- dzhiurgis 11y agoHow about the noise?
- hyperion2010 11y agoWell that is a different story because I was using 4800rpm 80mm fans like an idiot back then.
- PebblesHD 11y agoI'm doing basically the same thing at the moment with a rack of xServes and an HP Proliant. Pretty quiet actually, compared to my music and other noise in my area.
- omgtehlion 11y agoIt must be pretty warm where you live. I had a couple of Q6600 upped from 2.4GHz to 3.2GHz, and that wasn’t enough to heat the room. It was in Russia though...
- masklinn 11y ago> It must be pretty warm where you live. Good insulation and small surface also helps. You won't heat up a 2-story house with just a computer, but a well-insulated dorm room is more than feasible.
- anonymousDan 11y agoCloud&Heat are another company doing this in Germany: https://www.cloudandheat.com/en/index.html https://www.cloudandheat.com/en/index.html
- vmarsy 11y agoAnd a French one: http://www.qarnot-computing.com/technology http://www.qarnot-computing.com/technology Qarnot computing
- raverbashing 11y agoA pun on on Nicholas Carnot, the creator of this: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Carnot_cycle https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Carnot_cycle
- Artemis2 11y agoAnother French one: http://www.defab.fr/ http://www.defab.fr/ They're heating water for consumer purposes. I met one of their founders yesterday, they're pretty neat!
- TheLoneWolfling 11y ago...And no data cap, and don't mind a chunk of your bandwidth being used, and don't mind a locked box with an always-on and encrypted connection to who-knows-where in your house. I'd also worry about what happens if/when it breaks down. (For instance, if the power supply fails. Or whatever: there are pretty much always single points of failure on such things.) A neat idea in some ways, but I'd be wary.
- TeMPOraL 11y ago> and don't mind a locked box with an always-on and encrypted connection to who-knows-where in your house Do you fear hidden microphones, cameras and other sensors? If not, then what's the harm?
- kardos 11y agoSince you have no control over it (aside from ripping it out of the wall), you're at the mercy of whoever runs the box to adequately secure it. When it gets hacked, any shady business conducted by the miscreants will be emitted from /your/ IP, so you're exposing yourself to TOR exit node level liability. You might be able to work around that.... but it depends what's running on the box. If it's a backend server for some organisation (database, etc) then you could have some sort of tunnelling router between it and the fibre that routes all packets back to the organisation's datacentre.
- TheLoneWolfling 11y agoI worry about the potential consequences of legitimate sensors being repurposed, yes. Network snooping / spoofing / etc (even if it's on a VPN through an external router it still leaks congestion information!), temperature settings, especially versus actual temperature, power fluctuations, vibration sensors, etc, etc. I don't particularly want random people knowing - and potentially selling - information about when I sleep, when I eat, when I take a shower, when I'm not home, when I'm on vacation, etc, etc.
- estefan 11y agoAnd don't mind someone else accessing the internet through your account. Better hope they aren't running a search engine that stumbles on kiddie porn/extremist material/pirated content, etc...
- abalone 11y agoCan you turn them off? Obviously you don't want to run a heater in the summer. And if so, wouldn't the resulting (massive) underutilization of hardware erase whatever savings the data center would realize from not having to deal with heat? Not to mention the other (massive) costs of remote servicing, like literally rolling trucks to replace a hard drive. And 1000W is not even one standard space heater. I like the general idea but this decentralized in-the-home concept seems about as well thought out as their logo. It would be better suited to a centralized application like the heated swimming pool: year round usage, enough density to achieve economies of scale in servicing and providing site security. Or how about this: locate your next data center near a town with a district heating system, so you can tap into it and pipe waste heat directly into homes. (Sweden has lots of waste-to-energy plants that burn trash to generate electricity and hot water heating distributed through networks of pipes.[1]) In the case of Sweden you wouldn't even have to build out much infrastructure; it's already there. I wonder if anyone has explored this? EDIT: I just saw ville posted about this very idea. Cool. EDIT2: jessaustin notes that they keep the server running constantly and probably use a powered heat pump to vent it outside during the summer. (Which still raises questions for me about the efficiencies.. small scale heat pumps probably aren't as efficient as a large-scale data center implementation.) [1] http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/District_heating http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/District_heating
- URSpider94 11y agoThe article mentions that the furnace vents waste heat outside when you don't want it. So, yes, it's running all the time.
- smegel 11y ago> Or a fuse blows? Or a kid pours his cup of sticky soft drink in the vents (heaters need to have vents right, almost certainly at the top). Anyone who thinks something can be "tamper proof" has never lived with a 4 year old.
- eloisius 11y agoThey surely use redundant, encrypted storage. MaidSafe is a distributed "cloud" storage protocol that does that: http://maidsafe.net/ http://maidsafe.net/
- teekert 11y agoThe reliability issues that are mentioned are no problem with enough redundancies of course. My fiber optic connection is 50/50 even though the line is (the way it is used now) able to do 500/500. They should aim for deals with ISPs for my excess bandwidth.
- fulafel 11y agoIt would be very interesting to hear their security analysis and conclusions. The article's casual use of the term "tamper-proof" doesn't sound credible without details.
- pepijndevos 11y agoThis seems ideal for running TOR exit nodes. Except for the home owners of course. I wonder if their TOS forbids this?
- m-i-l 11y agoSee also "Heating houses with 'nerd power'" from last week at https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=9581588 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=9581588 .
- wtracy 11y agoI always thought of Bitcoin as an implementation of this idea.
- kozak 11y agoWhen it's in the "push heat outside" mode on a hot summer day, there is a significant amount of air to pump, in order to dissipate a kilowatt. I wonder how noisy is the unit in this case.