3 ms·
Your response, colored for me by the downvote I received roughly when you posted it, consists largely of hand waving. Maybe my perception of PL research papers
by plsceptic 11y ago
Your response, colored for me by the downvote I received roughly when you posted it, consists largely of hand waving. Maybe my perception of PL research papers is horribly skewed, but the ones I've read are as I described: conjecture unsupported by evidence. The fact that some researchers are trying to do better is laudable, but it doesn't redeem the field of PL research as a whole.
This bit in particular struck be as absurd:
>Trust me, there is no glory to be had in this game
Humans naturally crave fame, and programmers are no exception. Look at all the developers with Github and Twitter profiles and blogs; are you telling me these people don't want attention?
Inventing a programming languages is one of the few ways that's been shown, on occasion, to make a programmer famous. We all know who Larry Wall, Matz, and Guido are. Frameworks, both front-end and back-end, are another (and I suspect that's part of the reason why we're up to our neck in JS frameworks). Look at DHH, for example. He's a programmer of modest ability who got so famous through Rails that Alan Kay quotes are mis-attributed to him, meanwhile I doubt you know who Daniel Veillard is, despite him being the principal author of LibXML2, one of the most heavily-used pieces of software in the world.
- seanmcdirmid 11y ago> Maybe my perception of PL research papers is horribly skewed, but the ones I've read are as I described: conjecture unsupported by evidence. The fact that some researchers are trying to do better is laudable, but it doesn't redeem the field of PL research as a whole. I have the totally opposite opinion: the PL academic community has shifted very much in the science direction so much so that innovative and inventive design work no longer really has a place in their conferences (contrast to the 90s, when this work dominated). Science doesn't take you very far in a design discipline, so as a result we have seen the shifts in focus that the article discusses (away from PL design, toward PL-related science topics). > Humans naturally crave fame, and programmers are no exception. Look at all the developers with Github and Twitter profiles and blogs; are you telling me these people don't want attention? Is anyone who does anything and puts it out there craving attention? Maybe they just want to, I don't know, share. There aren't a lot of PL groupies worshiping Roberto Ierusalimschy, for example (who is quite a modest guy in real life). I hang around these people, they don't have particularly large egos. > We all know who Larry Wall, Matz, and Guido are. But did you know who Roberto was? Would you be able to pick out Gilad Bracha in a grocery store? I also know who Paris Hilton is, yet she (probably) isn't a PL designer.
- plsceptic 11y ago>Is anyone who does anything and puts it out there craving attention? Maybe they just want to, I don't know, share. I never said everyone was motivated purely by vanity, just that it is a major motivator and possible explanation for certain perceived excesses (of languages, frameworks). >did you know who Roberto was? Would you be able to pick out Gilad Bracha in a grocery store? I'm typing these messages on a machine with NewSpeak installed on it.
- seanmcdirmid 11y ago> I never said everyone was motivated purely by vanity, just that it is a major motivator and possible explanation for certain perceived excesses (of languages, frameworks). Correlation isn't causation, and frankly, I'm not seeing much correlation. The proliferation of languages and frameworks has more to do with itch scratching. > I'm typing these messages on a machine with NewSpeak installed on it. Good, then you know that PL designers can be pretty down to earth and in it because they like doing it vs. seeing it as a path to fame and fortune.
- steveklabnik 11y ago> colored for me by the downvote I received roughly when you posted it, I know you're a throwaway for this discussion, but if you reply to someone on HN, you can't downvote them.
- deleted 11y ago[deleted]
- jules 11y agoI think you can, it's the other way around: you can't downvote comments that reply to you. You can't downvote this comment but I can downvote yours.
- seanmcdirmid 11y agoYou can't downvote comments that you reply to. If you downvote a comment and then reply to it, the vote is cancelled, I think.
- jules 11y agoI still see the downvote arrow on steveklabnik's comment though? So you're saying that clicking it won't have any effect? I don't see any downvote arrow on your comment, because it's a reply to mine. Could you downvote my comment that you replied to?