7 ms·
On the one hand, this would have serious implications for compatible FOSS reimplementations of proprietary APIs, such as Wine, libc, emulators, etc. On the oth
by JoshTriplett 11y ago
On the one hand, this would have serious implications for compatible FOSS reimplementations of proprietary APIs, such as Wine, libc, emulators, etc.
On the other hand, this would make it far easier to enforce copyleft licenses like the GPL.
I'm one of the people who provided text and examples filed in the EFF's amicus brief against, and on balance I'm not a fan of stricter copyright like this, but it's interesting to consider how this ruling could be used positively.
- codecamper 11y agoBut how often are laws used positively?
- wmeredith 11y agoThis is an overly cynical view. The vast majority of laws are used positively. The are the foundation of this country. When they are abused it makes headlines (sometimes). When everyone gets to work and back safely and can afford to pay the mortgage and buy a big screen, it's just business as usual.
- codecamper 11y agoI'm asking that based on what I've heard from a friend who runs a VC backed company. He said he needed VC largely because an incumbent in his category decided to sue him rather than compete. The lawsuit was rather frivolous, but when you get a bunch of people with a dim view of computer programming involved, then you need lawyers. And lawyers are EXPENSIVE. They are much much much more expensive than computer programmers. And then it becomes not so fun to run a company. It was about writing great software. Now it's about defending yourself in court. Total nightmare.
- wmeredith 11y agoThat's a pretty nightmarish scenario, and I sympathize with your friend. However, it does nothing to convince me that most laws are used for evil.
- fapjacks 11y agoI firmly believe that laws provide psychological boundaries for most people (in that I believe most people are neutral good, lawful good or neutral evil), and provide tools for some to abuse others (the lawful evil). Given a perfect distribution, or even a bell curve, I think yes, most uses of law are not used for evil purposes. But there is a significant segment of the spectrum that does. Of course, in my purely anecdotal system based on Dungeons and Dragons. :P
- notdanariely 11y agoDan Ariely's recent book titled "Dishonesty" presents a lot of research that supports this. His thesis (in part) is that people tend to cheat / lie right up until the point they can no longer internally think of themselves as decent people. In this interpretation, the legal system is a reasonably objective proxy to inform people how far they are across the line. This suggests that even unenforced laws can help establish an acceptable norm, so people have an external comparison.
- JoshTriplett 11y agoIn my opinion, far too many people are lawful neutral, and far too few are neutral good.
- AnthonyMouse 11y ago> The vast majority of laws are used positively. I find that a sensible way to look at it is that laws that are used are bad laws. Because almost everyone follows sensible laws so they only need to be litigated in rare outlier cases. By contrast, bad laws end up in the courts continuously because they're susceptible to abuse by dishonest parties. So the vast majority of laws are used negatively, because good laws don't have to be used.
- deleted 11y ago[deleted]
- billsix 11y agoI'd be curious to hear RMS's stance on the issue, but I'm guessing he would agree with Oracle. http://clisp.cvs.sourceforge.net/viewvc/clisp/clisp/doc/Why-CLISP-is-under-GPL http://clisp.cvs.sourceforge.net/viewvc/clisp/clisp/doc/Why-...
- nickysielicki 11y agoVery interesting link, thanks for sharing. From reading that, you can be near certain that RMS would agree.
- JoshTriplett 11y agoOr that he would have in 1992. The landscape has changed quite a bit since then. And the terminology has improved greatly since then; for instance, nowadays the requirement would be described as making CLISP "GPL-compatible", rather than putting it under the GPL.
- pornel 11y agoI'm not sure. His main argument in this case was that distribution of a non-GPL program with intention of letting user link with a GPL library was a "subterfuge". Google's case is different. They didn't write Android so users can choose between a dummy libDoesNotRunAnything or wink, wink unlicensed Oracle JVM.
- marcosdumay 11y agoThat's not the same issue. He's talking about distributing code that is not functional unless linked with a GPL library. Not about distributing code that replaces such GPL library. Oracle is basically saying that you can not write a compatible implementation of Java.
- sounds 11y agoI assume RMS would say that Java is non-free, and that the best move here would be to create a free compiler and runtime -- i.e. a new language. This stands to reason, as one of the first things RMS did in his efforts to advance Free Software was create a free compiler (gcc) and a free editor (emacs). He might note that gcc is not meant to replace all other languages. It is just an example of a well-made and libre compiler.
- higherpurpose 11y agoSo it will be used 99% negatively and 1% positively. That doesn't sound like a great outcome to me. Also, killing FOSS reimplementations of proprietary APIs is exactly why Microsoft filed a briefing in favor of Oracle the last time Oracle won at the CAFC. That and also the fact that Microsoft hates Google much more than Google hates Microsoft behind the scenes, which is why it keeps extorting Android OEMs and wants Oracle to win in this case.
- laumars 11y agoEmulators are a tricky one because they often require a BIOS file which does break copyright.
- JoshTriplett 11y agoNo more so than the games, and some emulators have reimplemented BIOSes.
- laumars 11y ago> No more so than the games It goes without saying that copying games is illegal. Well, bar a few caveats which seldom apply to people who run emulators. > some emulators have reimplemented BIOSes I'm sure some do but many don't - hence my point.
- JoshTriplett 11y ago> It goes without saying that copying games is illegal. Well, bar a few caveats which seldom apply to people who run emulators. Obtaining ROMs for games you own may or may not be, depending on your jurisdiction; in any case, it seems entirely ethical to have ROMs for games you own. Likewise for BIOSes.
- stinkytaco 11y agoI'm just going to play devil's advocate here, just for the sake of discussion, not because I believe it or not, but I think you could argue that obtaining ROMs for games you own is not ethical. The "phase shifting" argument is never one that held much water legally and certainly the industry would argue that if you want to use the content in a different form (i.e. an emulator), that you should pay for that additional right. It is a copy, after all. In the same way that the music industry would argue you can't upgrade all your vinyl records to mp3 without paying again. For example, should I be able to get Photoshop for all available platforms just because I happen to own one copy? This, of course, brings us into the thorny world of whether copyright even makes sense in the software business. Copying seems to be an essential part of using a computer (copying runtimes into memory, caching web pages to your computer, etc.) so it may be an outmoded way of thinking about protecting IP.