7 ms·
> It also benefits hugely from urls, which allow users to share what they've found. how about http://some.storage.service.tld/path/to/video.mkv http://some.sto
by the8472 11y ago
> It also benefits hugely from urls, which allow users to share what they've found.
how about http://some.storage.service.tld/path/to/video.mkv http://some.storage.service.tld/path/to/video.mkv or even rtmp://some.streaming.service.tld/path/to/stream ?
For sharing that would be sufficient.
Of course there are some business realities (ads, copyright, paying for storage) that make direct, free access to videos unlikely. But that's basically arguing that the web is a superior platform for monetizing things, not necessarily a superior platform as far as user-experience goes.
> The other key piece is discoverability, and on that front, YouTube is far, far better
I'll give you that one.
But then again there are dedicated media-discovery-sites (imdb, last.fm) that do not have playback as their core functionality, even though they may offer some playback.
- msl09 11y agoI would like to complement that native youtube(the one used on mobile) is far better at playback while keeping nearly every other advantage that it has on the web.
- monsterix 11y ago> that native youtube(the one used on mobile) is far better at playback. No, it is not. Playback would get stuck, sound would go away for no rhyme or reason and what not. Better experience? - no - quite the opposite. I got rid [1] of the native nuisance completely. And the experience of search, comment and history on native was simply terrible. Much lesser control on ad-blocking too, and really the ads on YT are sometimes seriously irritating. [1] Evidence: https://twitter.com/marvindanig/status/598701509963083777 https://twitter.com/marvindanig/status/598701509963083777
- c22 11y agoI haven't tried YouTube on IOS but the native YouTube app for android is better than watching YouTube videos in mobile Chrome for me. Evidence: ^
- briandear 11y agoIf you block the ads, how does the site make money to support your viewing habits?
- mattLummus 11y agoThat is irrelevant. I prefer to not have ads and Google is generally kind of to comply and suggest developers respect ad-blockers as well, even though the vast majority of Google's revenue comes from ads. To suggest going native to provide revenue over UX only benefits the provider, not the user.
- JetSpiegel 11y agoAre you seriously arguing that Google is not making enough money?
- mattLummus 11y agoNot at all, but it is still their main source of revenue.
- wpietri 11y agoThat's certainly not what I want to share. One of the things that good video sites provide is context. E.g.: Who made this? What else have they done? How can I find them? Has this been widely seen? What do people say about it? Raw streaming urls don't get me any of that. URLs aren't just pointers to bytestreams. From a user sharing perspective, they're humans pointing to a unique thing. And what they're pointing to is often much more complex than a single raw file.
- the8472 11y ago> What do people say about it? you want to share youtube comments with people? they are a significant value-add to you?
- snowwrestler 11y agoYoutube comments are great for finding out the name of songs in the background of the video.
- towelguy 11y agoAnd all of them are Darude's Sandstorm.
- 15155 11y agoYou mean 009 Sound System.
- ethbro 11y ago> Youtube comments are great for finding out the name of songs in the background of the video. And here I'd concluded the comments section existed to allow pre-teens to practice their ability to make racist remarks.
- x0x0 11y agoand post-teens
- jamespo 11y agoThe business realities make direct, free, downloadable videos impossible rather than unlikely at scale.
- thatcat 11y ago>business realities make direct, free, downloadable videos impossible at scale And yet it's existed for years using p2p/torrents. So they're more like business fictions
- oldmanjay 11y agoDo you feel you made a point by listing services that exist only by breaking the law to exist as somehow related to business reality? Making your money by trampling the rights of others isn't exactly sustainable. The only way you have a point is to be rampantly intellectually dishonest, or ignorant of reality. Neither option is great, so charitably, it's best to assume you know this stuff and you're just trolling. Also not great. Do you have a 4th option?
- cousin_it 11y agoI think grandparent just wished to say that "direct, free, downloadable videos" are technologically possible at large scale via p2p. Mentioning copyright is a bit off topic. It's possible to create a paid p2p service for video, and have tons of viewers without spending millions on infrastructure. Hence the bit about "business fictions".
- deleted 11y ago[deleted]
- drostie 11y agoThe violation of IP is a similar problem for torrents and YouTube alike. The "4th option" is that you've got the causality completely backwards in your head: it just happens to be the case that the cultures where distributed tooling became important were the ones where it was necessary to promote an "all information is free" mindset, not that it's necessarily a part of distributed tooling that you take that mindset. If we start with a centralized metadata server/peer tracker, a set of "base seeds" to keep videos alive, and a commenting system, we can still revoke access to individual videos (our app will simply not support peer discovery except through our tracker, we take down the seeds, comments, and tracker entry on a revocation) while distributing bandwidth for the viral videos that need it. The point is germane.
- baddox 11y ago> how about http://some.storage.service.tld/path/to/video.mkv http://some.storage.service.tld/path/to/video.mkv or even rtmp://some.streaming.service.tld/path/to/stream ? Well, if I click on the first link, a video doesn't play (that would be the case even if the link were to an actual MKV video). The second URL isn't even a hyperlink on news.ycombinator.com. But if I click on a valid YouTube link, a video plays nearly immediately.