2 ms·
I found the initial example to be invalid, especially having worked in "physical" industries (auto parts manufacturing, to be precise). The four choices are pre
by potatolicious 17y ago
I found the initial example to be invalid, especially having worked in "physical" industries (auto parts manufacturing, to be precise). The four choices are presented as if they are mutually exclusive - they are not - and are in fact quite often used together.
Options 1 through 3 are incredibly useful for early prototyping in order to whittle down a large set of potential solutions. Certainly every design process I've ever been a part of has also gone through option 4. To present these choices as if people are blindly walking down paths 1-3 and only them, is IMHO the straw man.
tl;dr version: The article brings up the classic "look what dumb people are doing!" example, but yet I don't see people doing these dumb things that are supposedly being done.
- ThomPete 17y agoSo let me see if I understand. You are taking in users and have them look at drawings of your products? I am not saying you shouldn't do 1-3 I am saying you shouldn't test 1-3 on users. You should test 4
- pbhjpbhj 17y agoSo basically you think hammer manufacturers should do all the design and testing in the dark, then finalise drawings, design and produce production processes and machinery and tool up a factory, forge hammers ... and then show them to the buyer for the first time. Buyer: "we wanted ball-pein hammers not claw hammers perhaps you could show us a product drawing next time"
- ThomPete 17y agoYou are confusing what kind of product the customers want with testing a product you have decided to try and make. In so far as producing the first hammer yes they should do it in dark. That have nothing to do with whether they should research if there is even market for it. But it is not done by asking the users to look at a paper prototype of the hammer.