11 ms·
What I’m Teaching my Son about Money
- lloydde 11y ago> more likely to commit suicide than others who live with a fraction of their privilege. data that supports this?
- bcheung 11y agoI love the fact that you guys are using that spreadsheet.
- defenestration 11y agoGreat article, it gives me some new ideas like the excel bankaccount with monthly interest. I value the curiosity that our son has. He likes to ask about how we make money with our own company, what taxes are and why you have to pay them. He's really happy when he can buy us an ice cream from his own money and have a good time together.
- burritofanatic 11y agoAgreed! This particular quote: "Income is not something that employers or the government ration out to you based on a rigged system. It is a something you generate yourself. It is the byproduct of your hard work, combined with learning and mastering the system itself. Even the system itself is subject to your control if you choose."
- jparishy 11y agoThere's an active subreddit for discussing Financial Independence (FI) that often links to MMM and recommends his blog to people interested in learning about the topic. If you liked the article, you might find the community there interesting: http://www.reddit.com/r/financialindependence http://www.reddit.com/r/financialindependence
- jessedhillon 11y agoSuppose that there are, broadly-speaking, two levers on a person's financial independence function: money brought in, and money spent. The FI subreddit and MMM focus, IMO, almost exclusively on reducing money spent. I subscribed to the FI sub hoping to find a lot of discussion about efforts to bring money in. Instead, I find a lot of people angling for a definition of financial independence that includes wearing the same clothes for seven years, barely ever eating out, and vacations that resemble nothing I'd call travel. Whatever discussion around increasing income does take place is usually centered around picking up another job. For me, as long as the income earned is a linear function of time invested, it's a losing proposition. There's a reason why "work 10 jobs" isn't commonly suggested as a way to get rich. I know this sounds snobby, there's not any way around that. My definition of FI is not having to deliberate, rationalize and bargain with myself when it comes to purchasing something I want. Yes, reducing wants is a major factor in happiness, but finally there will always be something that I want, despite pursuing a life of frugality and parsimony. The FI/MMM approach leans way too far towards ascetism for my tastes. Are there any communities, besides HN, which focus discussion more on strategies for increasing income and less on lifestyle amputation?
- lutorm 11y agoYou kind of made his point there: Yes, reducing wants is a major factor in happiness, but finally there will always be something that I want If there's always something you want, where do you stop? It seems the key to happiness is to learn to live with that want, rather than try to satisfy a desire that can't be satisfied?
- jessedhillon 11y agoTo me, saying "want nothing more" is as naive as someone saying "I want everything". FI means freedom from scarcity, not freedom from ownership. I don't look at people who buy $100,000 homes in the suburb -- and have to consider a 1 hour drive into the city to see friends or a show -- as being independent, even if they are free from wanting a house in the city. I view them as prescribed by their scarcity to a life separated from their mates and a vibrant culture. MMM, and presumably you, might ask if dining with friends and taking in novelties like arts and culture are truly worth spending money on, but to me the answer is obvious.
- Havoc 11y agoWhile I don't have kids myself these types of experiments aimed at pushing kids in a certain beneficial direction. e.g. My dad had a policy that he'd cover the cost of all bookstore purchases. All other entertainment expenses get funded via allowance. I wouldn't be surprised if small nudges like that have far reaching effects much later in life.
- Havoc 11y agowow I really massacred that sentence...sorry guys. It was supposed to read: >these types of experiments aimed at pushing kids in a certain beneficial direction ---interest me---
- dionidium 11y agoI wouldn't be surprised if small nudges like that have far reaching effects much later in life. I suspect that having a nudger around who cares enough to do that kind of nudging is what really matters.
- brc 11y agoEven having a household with books in it is a massive boost in life prospects.
- Havoc 11y ago>I suspect that having a nudger around who cares enough to do that kind of nudging is what really matters. That too. I'm proud to say that my dad was a true class act - he swore both his kids would walk into life with a varsity education and no debt come hell or high water. That being said I still think its the small practical things that count. All those small things accumulate towards one massive social edge that is hard to quantify. Suppose you need to pick an engineer to build a bridge...the one grew up with legos the other grew up without. Who do you pick? Trivial childhood detail?
- defenestration 11y agoI remember the nudge of my dad that he wanted to treat all his sons equally. So the same financial rules and support for all of us. He learned us to value fairness.
- ChuckMcM 11y agoI like the idea of a spreadsheet. I suppose its ok to give your kids a 10% ARR, too bad we can't get that on anything as close to secure as "Dad's checkbook" :-). But the key message which I really like is spending is your choice, and if you can't afford something you want to buy it may be because you chose to spend the money to buy it on something else instead. Recognizing that is what you are doing when you "spontaneously" buy that over priced beer at the ball game is a good life skill.
- fsk 11y agoThe stock market will, on average, do better than 10%/year. There will be some -50% years along the way, though. To get 10% with zero volatility, you have to invest with Bernard Madoff.
- ChuckMcM 11y agoWell I've only been really fully diversified since 2001 but over 2001 to 2015 it hasn't done 10% year over year, closer to 7.8% :-) And that included the tight clench in 2007 - 2009 which is why 'security' and 'return' are inversely related. And I see the S&P has done slightly better (8.3% [1]) over 10 years so I should probably kick myself to having anything in a stock or fund other than SPY :-) [1] http://quicktake.morningstar.com/index/IndexCharts.aspx?Symbol=SPX http://quicktake.morningstar.com/index/IndexCharts.aspx?Symb...
- matb33 11y agoWith my 6 (almost 7) year old I've been giving him 2% daily interest on whatever is in his chequing account. He's aware I'll scale it back when it gets out of hand :) But so far he spends enough on nerf equipment that it hasn't posed a problem yet! Now he wants to keep more of his money in the bank to see it grow, and I didn't have to say that specifically, which was the entire point. A rule I did have to institute later though is that if he forgets to ask for his interest that evening, he doesn't get paid. We also have to rely on his last bank receipt to calculate the amount owed because it appears impossible (at least here in Canada) to open an online account for a child his age.
- Kluny 11y agoWhen I was 8, I had a ScotiaBank Getting There savings account. It wasn't online, but then again, that was 20 years ago. Is that still a thing?
- matb33 11y agoI should clarify he does have a bank account (with his own Interac card) but no way to access it online. This is with TD Canada Trust. I don't imagine it's much different across other Canadian banks. Edit: sorry, to actually answer your question, yeah they still have those -- they just call it Youth Account at TD
- developer1 11y agoYou make your kid ask you... every. single. night... to please give him his 2%? You are warping that child's mind with your mind games.
- sokoloff 11y agoDisagree. The point is to get the child to internalize the value of savings and investing. Silent accumulation of wealth (the point of investing as a adult) is useless from an educational point of view (the point the parent is making for their child). It also teaches the value of speaking up for what is due. Hats-off to matb for it, IMO. We give our kids an allowance of sorts for chores above the basics. We also allow them to blow this money on "stupid crap". We once let them split a pack of candy at an ice rink, but they didn't have the money yet (we were traveling). Once everyone agreed that they'd buy it with their allowance, I bought it with them understanding that they needed to pay me back. Later that weekend, it came time to pay their allowance. We could have easily paid them $2 each (the net), but it was far more effective to pay them $3 each and then make them physically pay us back the $1 each, even though it resulted in significant frustration and a more than a few tears now that the candy was gone. That's education, not a mind game.
- hkmurakami 11y agoI agree with the general premise of the article, but there are a few points that struck me as somewhat misleading. > On the other hand, having crossed the threshold of having more than enough money for a good life almost a decade ago, I cannot even imagine my son not earning a plentiful and permanent surplus very early on in his adult life. If I remember correctly, the author's net worth was greatly boosted by the stock and real estate market bull market of the 90's. During that era, making an earnest living and investing aggressively in these two markets would handsomely reward you. To automatically believe that the same is true in the current era or any other future era is a dangerous assumption. In regions with the biggest opportunities from employment, employees are increasingly priced out of the real estate rally and the tax savings home ownership affords you. Similarly, there are no guarantees on how much longer the current 5 year bull market run in the public equities market will last, and how sharp and long lasting an eventual correction will be. While it is possible for informed individuals to navigate times of volatility in the markets, it is a matter easier said than done, particularly for a young professional who has not experienced market turmoil first hand. > And yet consider the stunning case study of the children of the nation’s uber-wealthy enclaves like Palo Alto, California. Despite incredible wealth and some of the best educational institutions money can buy, kids there are more stressed, less happy, and more likely to commit suicide than others who live with a fraction of their privilege. The problem arises when high-achieving parents assume that their kids need to be pushed to achieve more themselves, to beat out the other high achievers and gain access to the most elite schools, in order to compete in this incredibly challenging modern world. It's worth examining "why" these parents behave this way -- what their underlying motivations are. I'm going to simplify the situation and focus on what I believe is the largest slice of the hypercompetitive student population: the children of successful immigrants (this classification is very representative of the Palo Alto and Cupertino school districts). The immigrant parents who are sending their children to High School now overwhelmingly came from modest means and worked their way to financial and social well being and stability. As immigrants, their situation was highly volatile, both with respect to employment and residence status. As the author himself notes, parents want their children to have it better than them. The worst part about being an immigrant? The fear of not knowing what will happen to you tomorrow. The fear of losing your job and getting deported was a very real possibility. What they want for their children is first and foremost, stability. More than pure financial EV, they wish to maximize the predictability and stability of their children's employment prospects. Status and financial returns are secondary. Anecdotally, even self made millionaire behave this way. Read "The Millionaire Next Door," (a book primarily about small business owners with prudent spending habits who saved their way to 7 figures) and you will find that most of these self made entrepreneurs want their children to become doctors and lawyers so that they won't have to endure the volatility that the parents suffered. How do you maximize professional stability? The narrative of "go to the best school and study a technical, skill based discipline" is actually not misguided. The problem if any is that you quickly hit precipitously decreasing marginal returns on any additional academic competitive effort. But from the parents' perspective, even "poor marginal returns" looks like a no brainer. After all, they would have loved to have that opportunity to increase their employment stability before being subjected to the economic forces themselves. The stress in children is a result of wildly differing perspectives and experiences between the immigrant parents and the child born to safety and prosperity. The parents truly want the best for their children, informed by their own experiences and difficulties. Sadly, even "the correct decision" for any person is hardly ever the correct decision for another.
- dcre 11y agoThis line stands out to me: > Income is not something that employers or the government ration out to you based on a rigged system. It is a something you generate yourself. It is the byproduct of your hard work, combined with learning and mastering the system itself. Even the system itself is subject to your control if you choose. It's easy to interpret this as a positive statement about the way things simply are, but I don't think the author quite intends it that way. When pressed, he might say it is a positive statement, but the clearly intended ethical significance of the statement—the fact that it has deep consequences for the way his son should act—suggests we can look deeper. Specifically, it's important to understand the normative dimension of the statement: that when "income is not something that employers or the government ration out to you based on a rigged system", that is a good thing. And most importantly, it's possible for things not to be that way—whether because the laws or government of your country are not set up the right way, or because you yourself have the wrong attitude about your work. The attitude interpretation is probably what the piece is focusing on (and what most readers will take away), because obviously the author can't teach his son to solve problems outside of his control. But the author is thinking about systems too. When he says "the system itself is subject to your control if you choose" it's clear that there are plenty of systems where this is not the case, where the system is so huge or arbitary or irrational that "learning and mastering" it is not possible. Examples might include oppressive dictatorships, bloated bureaucracies, or sweatshops (especially to a child). ------------ The point I'm trying to make is that we have a responsibility not just for our own attitudes and actions, but also to shape our world in such a way that it is possible for the right attitude to pay off. Edit: the author's point about how the son's savings account enables him to be generous is a great example of this. This is called "moral luck" by philosophers--the idea that certain conditions need to obtain before a person can be virtuous. The idea goes back all the way to Aristotle.
- CADBOT 11y agoI'm glad to see MMM here on hacker news!
- MichaelCrawford 11y agoIf your kid asks for something, don't just tell them it's too expensive. If you don't want them to have it find some good reason, but not always "it's too expensive". The kid will get a distorted idea of the value of things. A few years ago I finally figured out that the reason my mother always says things are too expensive is that her father committed suicide when she was just seven years old.
- pbhjpbhj 11y ago>The kid will get a distorted idea of the value of things. // Are you equating price with value here? Just because something is expensive doesn't mean it is valuable.
- Domenic_S 11y agoNot to speak for OP, but my mother used to do that too, used 'too expensive' as a reason when she didn't want me to have something. That video game rental was 'too expensive' or those hideous velcro shoes were 'too expensive' and what have you. It was really confusing to hear that McDonalds was 'too expensive' and then have delicious grilled steaks for dinner that night.
- MichaelCrawford 11y agoI myself eventually learned to save up then purchase what I regard as being of the most lasting value. I figured that out on my own - no one else taught me. Yes I agree, I wear very modest close for example. Denim jeans because the cloth is comfortable and durable.
- Domenic_S 11y agoI never say "too expensive" to anyone, even myself, ever. If it's too expensive in the sense that I think it's a bad deal (e.g. that 1br/1ba 400sqft house is too expensive at $700k), then I express that. Everything else though, I say "you have to save for it". A Model S isn't too expensive, I just have to save for it. My wife wanted a couch that I thought was a little unreasonably priced, but I said if we save for it, sure. Savings is separate from retirement and so forth so knock yourself out. Interesting thing about this is it forces you to choose -- you can't save for 10 really expensive things all at once, unless you're prepared to wait 15 years for the money to accumulate. So this method forces you to choose priorities. Works great for a kid I think -- you're saving for this $10 book, but you want a $3 candy bar... what is that going to do to your book savings? You can have anything you want if you save for it.
- the_economist 11y agoMr. Money Mustache really helped me with life as I ran my startups, because he taught me that I could live a great life with almost no money. Therefore, even if I failed, life could be great. This simple bit of wisdom massively reduced my anxiety, once I internalized it.
- BjoernKW 11y agoI love his blog because he not just tries to educate people about personal finance or money as an end to itself but about money with a purpose. An attitude like his can almost be considered subversive today. If it wasn't for 'keeping up with the Joneses' the world could be a much better place and more people could live the lives they actually want to live.
- cushychicken 11y agoMoney (and it's alternate form, stuff) too often ends up being read like a scorecard, when it's really a means to an end. I love MMM for the exact same reason as you do - he gets that money is what lets you do things that you find enjoyable or rewarding, not something you flout around as a status symbol. Thank god MMM is a subversive, because his is one of the only revolutions I could see myself subscribing to.
- dataker 11y agoGreat article! It's funny to think how our kids are overwhelmed by useless subjects and have no background on personal finance. On the long-term, it's fundamental for building wealth and a future for oneself.
- euphoria83 11y agoI am one of those people who followed the path (and was told to) of "study hard, get a good job, work hard till retirement, spend wisely, ...". A few years back, I realized that one important thing nobody taught me during my childhood is that a very important part of everyone's life is to provide value to others in exchange for money that you live by. At that time, I decided to teach my children about this. One of the ways I have thought of doing this is to ask my children to start earning a small amount of money early in life by providing value to others in ethical ways. I am glad to read that the author, who can be considered an expert at managing personal money, is being successful at a similar experiment.
- antisuji 11y agoThis connection—between earning money and providing value to others—is something that sounds obvious, but I only really internalized it recently, after reading Kevin Simler's Congolese Trading Window thought experiment[1]. It would be easy to take this line of reasoning into dangerous territory and suppose that earning money is equivalent to being morally virtuous, but this neglects externalities and the sometimes fundamental difficulty of accurately pricing certain kinds of goods (subjective wellbeing, community, a sense of meaning, etc.). Money is, at best, a very rough proxy measure for human value. [1] http://www.meltingasphalt.com/wealth-the-toxic-byproduct/ http://www.meltingasphalt.com/wealth-the-toxic-byproduct/
- sukilot 11y agoThat's a good article. It has a long introduction that resembles libertarian twaddle, but then Section V brings it home to tie the knot in a way most econ 101 libertarians ignore.
- formulaT 11y agoActually the article is completely wrong. If you make money "squarely" as described in I-IV, then you have created some value. Cashing out in section V is simply consuming that value. All we can say (given the assumptions in I-IV) is that the person was a net positive (or zero) for the Congolese economy. The technical mistake that the author makes is not realizing that adding value to the Congolese economy means increasing the total amount of physical wealth in the economy. When the person cashes out their yacht, they are simply exchanging cash for the physical wealth they helped create. I don't think you can logically say that I-IV are "libertarian twaddle" and that V "brings it home", because V is predicated on I-IV being true. If you're interested in the theoretical basis behind "econ 101" I suggest you look into general equilibrium theory.
- formulaT 11y agoI really liked the compassion and care that MMM shows for his kid. In too many articles like this, it's clear that the author cares more that the child adopts the parent's ideology than that the child is actually happy. The goals and methods were moderate: earning one's own money (at an appropriate age), learning to control one's own life (I would add "to the extent possible") and not over or undervaluing wealth. My only reservation was the artificial 10% interest rate. The current interest rate is 0%. Over the last 100 years interest rates averaged 5%. This is a concern to me because people on the Right tend to fetishize compound interest rates, while MMM seems to focus on true fundamentals.
- brc 11y agoMr money mustache needs to spend some of that dosh on a properly scalable server, I think.
- tempestn 11y agoCan I please deposit some money in the Bank of MMM?
- tempestn 11y agoI liked this line: > To me, raising kids to feel pressure and fear so they can be COMPETITORS is bullshit. Life is not a competition. It’s a gigantic collaboration, and the world welcomes and rewards people who see it that way. Life is not a competition; it's a collaboration.