6 ms·
> companies might want to skip around accessibility issues when they're first getting started So, if it's inconvenient, you get to pretend it doesn't exist bec
by stephenr 11y ago
> companies might want to skip around accessibility issues when they're first getting started
So, if it's inconvenient, you get to pretend it doesn't exist because you're a "startup"?
That kind of mindset is what's wrong with the startup community. "Disrupt" isn't a synonym for "break any laws you don't like" and "startup" isn't a synonym for "I am above the law!"
- a3n 11y agoAnd "the law" is not the only measure of what's right. Just because it may end up being legal for Uber to discriminate against disabled doesn't mean they aren't major dicks. There's a fundamental rule for living in the world: Don't be a dick. Uber is breaking that rule, through sociopathic sophistry.
- oldmanjay 11y agothere are many related fundamental rules, like "everyone is considered a dick by someone" and "you're a dick if you blame a group for the actions of a few." mainly, though, none of these are actually rules because your subjective notion of what being a dick means isn't transferable outside of your head, even if it really, really feels like your opinions are right.
- a3n 11y agoBut by saying it, I hope to convince others. Because I really, really want "defending a corporation's right to condone and tolerate disabled discrimination" to be seen as being a dick.
- maxlybbert 11y agoIn New York, there are thousands of wheelchair accessible taxis ( http://www.nyc.gov/html/tlc/html/passenger/accessible.shtml http://www.nyc.gov/html/tlc/html/passenger/accessible.shtml ), but there are also thousands of taxis that aren't wheelchair accessible. The ones that aren't accessible aren't breaking the ADA (then again, the ADA requires "reasonable accomodation," so the ones that aren't wheelchair accessible probably still have to make an effort to put a wheelchair in the trunk, if requested).
- lkiernan 11y agoBlack cabs are more accessible by default, but I'd assume if I called ahead for any taxi I'd need to let them know of any special needs, the same as if I needed to let them know I wanted a taxi for 7 people? Shouldn't there be an area for adding special requests such as accessibility? You filter to the vehicles that are able and willing to take this passenger's money. I can only assume that, as contracted drivers, they have to worry about scratches that may be caused by loading and unloading wheelchairs? Am I overlooking some kind of personal discrimination expecting people to be better?
- deleted 11y ago[deleted]
- giltleaf 11y agoThe special request feature wouldn't be hard to implement, but I'm not sure that it benefits drivers to respond to it unless there was also a system to incentivize them.
- lkiernan 11y agoSuch as being paid for accepting the business?
- maxlybbert 11y agoI'm sure I'm not the only person seeing ads from Uber to use my own car for extra income. For the record, I haven't signed up. My own car is not wheelchair accessible. It is spacious, and could fit a collapsed wheelchair. But I don't have a lift. Even if I were to sign up as an Uber driver, I can't say that I'm a kind enough soul to add a wheelchair lift or other equipment to make my car wheelchair accessible. I might be willing to do so for the right incentive. If Uber were to get me a discount on the modification, or promise to buy my car from me when I no longer want it, or give me a higher percentage of the fare when I pick somebody up, etc. But I, personally, wouldn't foot the bill for purely altruistic reasons.
- 11y ago
- devcpp 11y agoBut going the other way hinders progress in the name of very few people (if any) who may benefit from this kind of measures in very early stages. When the company gets a broad audience, then it becomes a concern. And since the founders have growth in mind anyway, they'll be sure to make it possible to implement the measures later on (or they'll pay the price in court, either way all is well).
- lkiernan 11y agoBecause you're catering to much smaller markets? I think the view above is something like a food delivery service not offering gluten-free or vegetarian options?
- goatforce5 11y agoIf i'm building an MVP I might not even fully support all of the popular browsers, let alone the correct standards for screen readers, and my page layout will probably break if you increase the font size. Similarly my website is probably only in one language. (I'm not sure what my point is... I'm just thinking out loud.)
- tickit 11y agoThe Internet's a bit different, it's more of a virtual wild west... at least it used to be. If your service has a real world presence and you cut corners then you're more likely to bother someone - especially if you want to be ubiquitous.
- gohrt 11y agoThe ADA applies to the Internet.
- Lawtonfogle 11y agoIt does? Last I checked you don't have to make your page screen reader friendly. Some technologies are very inaccessible without modification.
- tedunangst 11y agoWell, some provisions of the law only apply to businesses above a certain size, so yes, a startup literally can be above the law.
- kweinber 11y agoUber is larger than most huge corporations. Their funding is astronomical (5.9 Billion) and their investors include folks like Goldman Sachs. It isn't fair to real startups for giants like Uber to claim startup loopholes.
- ohitsdom 11y agoNo one is claiming Uber has an out due to "startup" status. OP said "(somewhere well before billion dollar valuations)", which sounds like a clear shot at them. Point is, early on it is understandable that Uber would take this kind of stance. Now, it's unconscionable.
- Frondo 11y agoThey're not above the law--it's just that, under a certain size, some law may not apply to them.
- electroly 11y agoYes, you do. Accessibility laws generally include exemptions for small businesses. The Americans with Disabilities Act definitely does. Title III goes out of its way to only require "reasonable accommodation" that is "readily achievable" and not overly burdensome to the small business.
- gamblor956 11y agoA company, like Uber, that has raised several hundreds of millions of dollars in financing, is definitely not a small business and doesn't get to claim that exemption.
- Spivak 11y agoThat was exactly his point.
- electroly 11y agoThe post I replied to was talking about the "startup community," so I was addressing that. A startup isn't breaking the law by not having the same level of accessibility as a large company. Uber has 2000 employees (excluding the drivers); they definitely wouldn't qualify.
- stephenr 11y agoI'd really like to see you try and claim that loading a folded-up wheelchair that the occupant themselves regularly loads into a car on her own, is "overly burdensome". I know the american legal system is pretty much fucked, but surely even you lot would have to accept that putting a folded wheelchair into the boot/trunk of a car is "reasonable accommodation".
- vinceguidry 11y ago> "startup" isn't a synonym for "I am above the law!" It kinda is. Hear me out. Commerce is bound to be political. Offering up a product or service for sale isn't always going to be acceptable to everyone. So we pass laws to tell people what they can and can't do. So far, so good. Except that if this continues, the business landscape changes due to the collective weight of all these laws. Existing organizations that understand the growing burden of the necessary law that has to be complied with are eventually the only entities that can do business. There needs to be some mechanism to operate in the opposite direction, to deprecate laws and allow smaller companies, who don't have the operational capacity to obey every single law that's ever been passed, to do business. Law is an imperfect instrument, it remains imperfect no matter how much social good it does, it never foresees all the different ways that society can evolve. The startup, the small, scrappy player that seeks out market opportunities and creates businesses out of them, has to be willing to break laws, has to be willing to believe in itself and its ability to help society evolve. Small economic actors have always played this role in society, there's nothing magic about Silicon Valley-style startups in this regard.
- gohrt 11y agoHow many hundreds of millions of dollars does it take before you are no longer a "small" actor?
- eatbuckyballs 11y agoI'd even go so far as to argue uber is larger than many taxi companies too. Not to take sides, but the whole small actor argument is bs now.
- vinceguidry 11y agoThat's not the right question to ask. The right question is whether we think Uber is innovative enough to change the laws for. You've got your thinking backwards. It's not us that has to conform to the law, it's the law that has to conform to us. The right thing to do, IMO, is to make Uber conform to disability law, and do away with the other laws that seem to be doing nothing at this point besides protecting rents, like the taxi medallion system. There are also other questions like whether we should consider Uber drivers to be employees or contractors. Any decently innovative startup will raise lots of these questions. Uber does just that. Of course, it would require too much political capital to just do away with the taxi medallion system at this point. So we have to tolerate the grey state of affairs until the legal and political issues are wrangled. Uber deserves to be rightly rich for being pioneers in this space.