5 ms·
Note how this would all go away if the empty buses could pass the full buses. Which they usually can, since even on single-lane roads, the bus stop is out of th
by derefr 12y ago
Note how this would all go away if the empty buses could pass the full buses. Which they usually can, since even on single-lane roads, the bus stop is out of the way of traffic.
But then there are trolleybuses. When the busses are all hooked to a single overhead cable run, as is common in places like Vancouver, the driver of one trolleybus would have to de-latch and then re-latch their "rabbit ears" (i.e. get out of the bus twice) in order to pass another trolleybus. Needless to say, this is uncommon. (Someone on HN: please, come up with a trolley pole design that can hot-pass another trolley pole pair while remaining on the line, and sell it to cities.)
- seanmcdirmid 12y agoTrolley buses are common on hilly routes where electricity provides torque needed to navigate steep grades. Very common in the pacific northwest (Seattle) and much of the alps (e.g. Lausanne). Buses tend to bunch in Beijing also, bad traffic prevents them from passing very well.
- seanp2k2 12y agoAnd San Francisco.
- seanmcdirmid 12y agoThey also have real trolleys just for this purpose. Unfortunately, those have become tourist attractions.
- jakejake 12y agoIn Chicago on very rare occasions when the train is running late they will have an impromptu "express" train where they skip the next 4 or 5 stops. They announce it so you know not to get on the train if your stop is being skipped. It seems like such a huge deal for them to do this - it's very rare. It must be a giant pain, even though it makes a lot of sense. Not only does it get the train back on schedule, but it reduces the riders on that train, which further speeds it up. If there was an easy, intelligent way to allow the bus to go into "express" mode and alert the riders then the busses could avoid getting bunched up.
- minimax 12y agoI'm not sure how often you're on the CTA but I've found trains running express during rush hour to be a pretty common occurrence.
- ams6110 12y agoThere are scheduled express trains during rush hours.
- dredmorbius 12y agoGiven that trains share track, switching, and a whole mess of other stuff, I'm really surprised they do this at all. I suspect it's only possible with significantly automated / computerized controls, or by having a secondary switching and traffic control pattern that they can run.
- learnstats2 12y ago>Note how this would all go away if the empty buses could pass the full buses. It's more complicated than that and has to be managed carefully. Here's what happens in the unmanaged case: - The empty bus passes the full bus - There are passengers waiting at the next stop - The empty bus stops to pick them up - There are no passengers waiting - The full bus typically doesn't have to stop - The full bus passes the empty bus Now these buses are irrevocably bunched. P.S. This site doesn't work for me at all.
- lotharbot 12y agoA fairly full bus will still stop at many stops (maybe not all) even if nobody is waiting to get on, because there will be people waiting to get off.
- derefr 12y agoOne frequent problem is with lines that run between two places (e.g. the downtown core and a stadium during a game), where virtually everybody will get on at the first stop and ride until the last stop. This plays havoc on the needs of regular commuters who live between the two stops. Usually, express runs are created that only go between the two stops, to siphon off some of that traffic—but if the regular bus arrives before the express bus, people will get on it in order to go to the terminal stop nevertheless. Really, almost all transit problems could be solved with etiquette about not (always) getting on the first bus to arrive at your stop.
- JadeNB 12y ago> Really, almost all transit problems could be solved with etiquette about not (always) getting on the first bus to arrive at your stop. I think that not etiquette but rules is the solution here. If I make up my own standards of politeness for which bus I should board, then it's likely that I will inadvertently conflict with the transit system's standards, making things worse for others or for myself than the greedy approach. To be blunt, I'm not going nobly to sacrifice my bus based on my guess of what's efficient. If, however, the transit system clearly indicated what was appropriate—via its rules—then I would be much more motivated to obey them, based on the idea that the rules would have been set up to maximise throughput. (Live status monitors, which not all cities have, also help a lot here.)
- barrkel 12y agoI don't quite note how it would all go away with less full buses passing more full buses. For one thing, it would be incorrect for an empty bus to pass a full bus - a full bus can't take any more passengers, and the people who don't fit on the full bus would have to wait even longer, for the next bus again. Secondly, people get off at stops, not just get on. The bus that overtakes won't get a big lead, because it probably has to stop anyway. It can only leave when it looks like the front bus is going to fit all the passengers. Thirdly, the bunching that has already occurred (to make it possible for one bus to overtake another) means that the bus stops ahead have far more people at them. Instead of merely bunching together, one full bus followed by one empty bus, you'd have two fairly full buses leap-frogging one another. The only way get back to a situation where the buses are on opposite sides again, minimizing variance in bus wait time, is to have a bus pause when it gets too far ahead of schedule.
- derefr 12y agoNote that bunching isn't actually the problem—in fact, bus runs are frequently planned in bunches, with two shorter busses arriving in series simulating a the arrival of a single double-length bus. The problem, in practice, is people cramming into the nearly-full first bus of a bunch (and delaying the bus further as people slowly fight their way off and on), with another nearly-empty bus following along with nobody getting on it. This problem would go away if people could be trained to wait for the second bus in the "bunch", rather than getting on the lead one. But, since that change-of-perspective is unlikely to happen, "two fairly full busses leap-frogging one-another" is actually a good solution. It's load-balancing, basically.
- JadeNB 12y agoFor bus stops with live status displays, this is reasonable. In cities where there's no indication of when the next bus is, there's no live-monitoring facility available on the phone, and the driver's response to "when is the next bus?" is "dunno"—you can bet I'll cram on that bus.
- dredmorbius 12y ago
- SomeStupidPoint 12y agoThe passing technique for trolleybuses is actually for the lead bus to pull their rabbit ears down and reraise them once the other bus has passed (when I've seen it done, such as the case where one bus has mechanical trouble and is being replaced by another). When well executed, it's actually a pretty smooth maneuver that takes just a moment of cooperation, but I agree with your (main) point that it's not efficient enough to do in live traffic as a routine thing.
- koenigdavidmj 12y agoThe trolleybuses that Seattle is in the process of ordering are capable of driving off-wire on battery power for quite a ways (enough to bypass a construction detour), and can also detach and reattach themselves without the operator directly manipulating the wires.