7 ms·
None of which would have mattered if Putty.exe was codesigned. Unfortunately it is not. Code signing certificates are insanely expensive. The cheapest one I co
by Someone1234 12y ago
None of which would have mattered if Putty.exe was codesigned. Unfortunately it is not.
Code signing certificates are insanely expensive. The cheapest one I could find from a CA was $73/year (3 year minimum). I could go on a long rant now about how much CAs are in collusion and how they're making everyone more insecure though their pricing, but that would be redundant as I think "everyone knows that" by now.
Let's Encrypt are welcome (when they arrive), but they still don't offer Code Signing, Wildcard Certificates, and so on. The whole certificate/CA industry needs change, Let's Encrypt doesn't go nearly far enough. I blame Microsoft, Mozilla, and Apple primarily as they decide who gets to be a CA, and could allow non-profits and other disruptive startups into the space if they wished.
- brians 12y agoThe "browser" half of the CAB forum is happy to accept new CAs that meet their standards. Non-profits and disruptive startups are finding that difficult, as they should—it's hard to run a CA safely. It's not hard like curing cancer is hard, or even like heart surgery is hard. It's hard like avoiding iatrogenic infection is hard: it requires constant and diligent adherence to rules in the presence of no visible threat. LE are a wonderful start, and they are succeeding in part because they're moving slowly. I expect them to go further, but only with full understanding of the obligations they take on by doing so. They're very, very right to be conservative in their operational practice, because they'll be allowed no more slack than anybody else, and maybe less. Could something like LE have started ten years ago? Maybe, but nobody did. CAcert.org was a lovely dream, but didn't (and couldn't) hold to those standards of diligent practice.
- stcredzero 12y agoThe "browser" half of the CAB forum is happy to accept new CAs that meet their standards. Non-profits and disruptive startups are finding that difficult, as they should—it's hard to run a CA safely. This is something that Google should do.
- ceejayoz 12y agoIf SSL is free and easy (especially if it's automatable) to generate through Let's Encrypt, the use case for wildcards mostly goes away.
- joshstrange 12y ago> When Let’s Encrypt launches in mid-2015, enabling HTTPS for your site will be as easy as installing a small piece of certificate management software on the server: "When" being the keyword. Also they don't, as of this post, do code signing...
- Phlarp 12y agoExcuse me for being a pedant, but wouldn't Let's Encrypt end up being just another potential attack surface?
- ceejayoz 12y agoNo more than the existing for-pay SSL providers, I'd imagine. What sort of attacks are you proposing?
- j_s 12y agoOpen source developers have a dwindling number of free options: http://stackoverflow.com/questions/1177552/code-signing-certificate-for-open-source-projects http://stackoverflow.com/questions/1177552/code-signing-cert... https://reactos.org/wiki/Driver_Signing https://reactos.org/wiki/Driver_Signing
- Igglyboo 12y ago$73/year is not free but calling it "insanely expensive" is pretty unfair.
- joshstrange 12y agoWhile I fully understand where you are coming from let's try and remember that putty is 100% free and I'd bet money the author puts in more time/energy/money than he gets back from it. That means that ANY money spent is more money in the hole making $73/yr ($219 all at once b/c you have to pay for 3 years) quite a bit of money.
- pdabbadabba 12y agoI suspect that if the Putty dev created a Patreon for code signing, and posted it on HN and Reddit, he'd almost immediately have that $73/yr covered for the foreseeable future.
- Kluny 12y agoAnd then some - I don't see a donate link anywhere on putty.org or the linked sites, but who wouldn't donate 5 bucks to putty, when they use it for free basically every day? I've paid 5 bucks for less useful programs.
- Symbiote 12y agoI remember reading the statement about beer and curry some years ago, so I knew there was a link somewhere: http://www.chiark.greenend.org.uk/~sgtatham/putty/faq.html#faq-donations http://www.chiark.greenend.org.uk/~sgtatham/putty/faq.html#f...
- cat9 12y agoOr "paid version is signed, free version is not."
- joshstrange 12y agoNo doubt but we all need to remember that sometimes accepting money is more trouble than it's worth. I know that sounds crazy but people taking donations have to declare that on their taxes and some people don't want to deal with that. Also while crowdfunding platforms have gotten really easy they still take effort and sometimes some sort of verification process. It's obvious the putty dev is not a designer (I don't say that to be mean) so I'm sure there would be people here on HN that would be all like "Ugh, this guy is asking for money and he can't take 2 minutes to make his funding site look halfway decent???" (Those people would be clarified as douches but that wouldn't stop them from making the comment nor the dev potentially reading them). Lastly let's say he gets the money and takes care of the taxes and all of that. Now he has to get a code signing cert (not a fast or easy process I would assume) and add that to the list of things he needs to do for each release. We are talking about a non-trivial amount of work over a month or more all so that people will stop bitching about the FREE and OPEN SOURCE product he is producing... If you find code signing/HTTPS to be so important I suggest you do it yourself, the code is freely available and since it's under an MIT licence you can even SELL access to your code-signed and https-protected putty version. I'm not saying that either of these things are not important (they both are) but let's not jump down the dev's throat because they aren't giving up even more of their time on something they seen no return on.
- deleted 12y ago[deleted]
- kainsavage 12y agoTIL: $73/year is "insanely expensive". Literally cheaper than sponsoring an African child or paying Sarah McLachlan to stop using commercials to make me cry.
- byuu 12y agoWould you mind paying for a code signing and two wildcard certificates for me then, please? Yearly, of course. I would cover the costs out of my profits, but the $0.00/yr I am pulling in from my open source projects doesn't quite cover it, let alone the $200/yr for the VPS and domain registration.
- w8rbt 12y ago"None of which would have mattered if Putty.exe was codesigned. Unfortunately it is not." You mean Autenticode on Windows? I once had an Authenticode code signing cert that I used to sign Windows executables. Mostly, I signed hobby projects with it. I wrote a proof of concept keystroke logger for Windows, then Authenticode signed it and made it available along with source code for others to experiment with and review. Several years later, some customers of Zemena and Comodo complained that the keystroke detection/security software (that they had paid money for) did not detect my keystroke logging software. This caused a big fuss. Even though my software had been available for years, was code signed, came with full source code and was clearly labeled for educational purposes only, the security companies sent takedown notices to my ISP, placed my domain on DNS blacklists and 'fixed' the issue by declaring any exe signed by my Authenticode cert as malicious. Their customers were then happy and felt safer as it was now 'detected'. The real issue was that the security software trusted any code that was Authenticode signed and let it run no matter what. There was a check-box somewhere to disable that, but long story short, I would not say that Authenitcode code signing is a big security benefit today. It may help some, but not much. Maybe in the future. I still have the Keystroke logger source code: https://github.com/w8rbt/keycap https://github.com/w8rbt/keycap Someone with an Authenticode cert should compile it and then sign it and see if it still gets by the security vendors.
- drzaiusapelord 12y agoSigning verifies identity, nothing more. That keylogger was yours. In this case, signing putty tells us that it comes from the putty maintainer. The content, what it actually does, whether its not malware inside, etc doesn't matter. Putty should be signed, imo.
- Someone1234 12y agoI was merely suggesting it as a way to verify who created that binary of Putty. Nothing more, nothing less. If you ignore who signed the binary completely, yes, it could be open to abuse.
- jpalomaki 12y agoWith code signing there remains the problem that how do I figure out who to trust. I don't remember the exact details for the author of PuTTY.