3 ms·
There are many programs which together provide a significant economic baseline. It's not all in the form of direct cash deposits, although much of it is, it's j
by zaroth 12y ago
There are many programs which together provide a significant economic baseline. It's not all in the form of direct cash deposits, although much of it is, it's just that the programs are a disparate and tangled mess. That $40k trucker's salary nets out to only about $5k more than the baseline benefits for an unemployed adult citizen. [1] It's barely better than not working, and you have to spend the whole week on the road! Staying home and fixing up the house [2] while taking the subsidies will always be a better bet.
The only difference between what we have today and "Basic Income" is currently we phase the benefits out as you start to work, obviously to disincentivize working. You could think of "Universal Healthcare", for example, a lot like eliminating the phase-out for Medicaid. ACA already eliminated the asset test, now it's just an income test, so maybe that will go next. (mostly depends who's elected in 2016)
[1] http://www.cbo.gov/sites/default/files/11-15-2012-MarginalTaxRates.pdf http://www.cbo.gov/sites/default/files/11-15-2012-MarginalTa...
[2] http://imgur.com/a/Bnacv http://imgur.com/a/Bnacv
- adventured 12y agoThat's not the only difference. We have a massive bureaucracy to handle all the various aspects of the distribution of those benefits. Most of which is not necessary in a basic income system. The cost savings by eliminating that bureaucracy would be substantial.
- icebraining 12y agoOf course, by "cost savings" you're essentially talking about a whole new lot of jobs lost.
- Programmatic 12y agoIt's cool, they'll get a basic income too. ;P
- ams6110 12y agoAll those eliminated bureaucrats are now on basic income. What have you saved?
- egypturnash 12y agoMaintaining the working environment of all those bureaucrats. Buying them new equipment as the old stuff breaks or becomes obsolete. And it may not show up directly on a balance sheet, but: how many bureaucrats love their job? How much depression and misery do you remove by replacing "go sit in a dimly lit crowded office all day for enough money to pay for your basic needs" with "hey here is enough money to pay your basic needs, go do whatever"?