2 ms·
This article claims that truck driver is the most common job in more than half of all states. That's obviously false. There are as many registered nurses as tr
by adventured 12y ago
This article claims that truck driver is the most common job in more than half of all states. That's obviously false.
There are as many registered nurses as truck drivers for example. And there are seven million teachers in the US.
"About 2.8 million workers drive trucks around. That’s a big number, but it pales in comparison to other occupations. More than 21 million people work in office and administrative support, more than 14 million work in sales and more than 11 million work in food services. Nine million work in transportation or material-moving occupations. Heck, there are nearly 9 million production workers who actually make things."
http://www.marketwatch.com/story/no-truck-driver-isnt-the-most-common-job-in-your-state-2015-02-12 http://www.marketwatch.com/story/no-truck-driver-isnt-the-mo...
- ska 12y agoI don't know if the claim is correct or not, but you have not demonstrated that it is false. The occupations you describe (nurses, teachers, office workers) can be expected to correlate with population density in a way that just doesn't seem to be necessary for truck drivers, or at least for many of them. Given that population is very non uniformly distributed amongst the states, it is very plausible to have a high proportion of long distance truck drivers living in low population states, so this claim could be true.
- djrogers 12y agoLook at some of the states in the map that claim truck driver as the highest - CA, TX, MI, IL; these are not low-population states. What's happened here is that the statistics are very poorly represented. Jobs like 'teacher' and nurse are broken down to fine-grained distinctions, while seemingly everyone who touches a truck steering wheel is lumped in as a truck driver. Lies, damned lies, and...
- ska 12y agoThat's plausible, but the parent analysis doesn't hold; I wasn't addressing the article. I could have worded it better.
- gwern 12y agohttps://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Simpson%27s_paradox https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Simpson%27s_paradox