5 ms·
Ambition and willing to take a risk is not a rare thing. Musk is no different from the huge number of people involved in startups except that he is investing m
by threeseed 12y ago
Ambition and willing to take a risk is not a rare thing.
Musk is no different from the huge number of people involved in startups except that he is investing more money. Many of us are investing all of our valuable time and money in risky ventures instead of saving and taking the rational path in life.
And stop acting like Musk is doing this for pure altruism. He stands to make a lot of money and get written into the history books if these companies are wildly successful. And from everything I've read he has enough of an ego to make those goals a pretty significant reason for these companies.
- mozumder 12y agoIt would be different if Musk did something new and innovative, but none of his work is actually novel. I find all his stuff to be completely uninspiring. China and India are also making cheap rockets. So what? Who cares?
- syense 12y agocorrect me if im wrong, but those are governments creating those rockets, while elon is just a private citizen. the space program that he created would be unshackled from the states desires, be they good or bad.
- mozumder 12y agoDoesn't matter. Elon still relies on government funding because he's selling to government. It's no different than when Rockwell/North American built the Space Shuttle. The biggest problem is that his ideas are just so boring and uninspiring. How about a new idea for a change? (Hyperloop isn't more exciting than High-Speed rail) Being known for someone that "did something for slightly cheaper" isn't exactly awe-inspiring. Sucks that millennials are stuck with him for inspiration. I want to see new ideas from our tech innovators. The Mars Curiosity lander is an amazing example.
- dba7dba 12y agoDoesn't matter. It DOES matter. :)
- mozumder 12y agoNot at all.
- deleted 12y ago[deleted]
- patcon 12y agoYou're wrong. :)
- mozumder 12y agoI have yet to see any broad visionary ideas from Musk/Space-X. Everything they're doing, and are planning on doing, has already been done.
- dba7dba 12y agoWhat other nation or private entity has come up with a visionary idea in space industry? Let me remind you he first thought about sending a life capsule to Mars on a former ballistic missile. Isn't that visionary enough ya? And how about Tesla?
- ForHackernews 12y ago> What other nation or private entity has come up with a visionary idea in space industry? How about building inflatable space stations? https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Bigelow_Commercial_Space_Station https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Bigelow_Commercial_Space_Stati... Or mining asteroids? https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Planetary_Resources https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Planetary_Resources For my money, either of those is more "visionary" than "a rocket booster that costs somewhat less than previous rocket boosters". Now granted, they're both a lot less practical, and it's true that making things cheaper is often a crucial first step towards making them better.
- deleted 12y ago[deleted]
- dba7dba 12y agoChina and India are also making cheap rockets. And SpaceX is making cheapER rockets. IN California, one of the most expensive state to do business in.
- ignoramous 12y agoI think that's a weak argument. Apple doesn't make the profits cause it builds iPhones in California. It does so because it chose the Eastern shores for a strategic reason. If your aim is to go cheaper, then to not take advantage of global-trade is really going to set one back by a significant margin. But I understand that Elon Musk is a patriotic South African who wants to create jobs for South Africans, in South Africa... oh, wait, I meant, the United States.
- astrange 12y agoIt's not possible to outsource spacecraft manufacturing because it's considered a weapons technology. You have to optimize at home instead. American satellites aren't even allowed to launch from Chinese rockets.
- levlandau 12y ago"Musk is no different from the huge number of people involved in startups except that he is investing more money. Many of us are investing all of our valuable time and money in risky ventures instead of saving and taking the rational path in life." Seriously? Like Are you actually serious when you write this? You seriously believe that the only difference between Musk and the huge number of people working on startups is that he is investing more money? You do not think that it has something to do with working on hard problems that nobody thinks are worthwhile until later on. You also do not think it has to do with him actually solving said hard problems. You also do not think it has anything to do with him being smart enough to manage multiple fields like a physics, computer science, engineering and design and have in depth discussions about rockets and space explorations at the same level as he can about electric cars and software? You also seriously believe that someone who is motivated by money would go and try to start a private rocket company that can deliver people to Mars and is reusable? Seriously? They wouldn't just go make some web app and "flip it"? This response is atypical for me but it's hard for me to read this sort of response and respond normally.
- tempestn 12y agoNot to mention, risking everything when you have $10k in the bank is a hell of a lot different than risking everything when you have $50M. In the first case, if you fail, oh well, you get a job for a year or two and earn it back. In the second case, the impact is rather... more significant.
- clarky07 12y agoalternately, you could not be a fool, and risk 47 million or so instead of every dime.
- tempestn 12y agoYes, of course, initially. The risking it all period isn't when you're considering spending a few million to buy some rockets. But then the day comes when you're this close to finally succeeding, but you're running out of cash. You need more now to make payroll, and there's nowhere else left to get it. Sure, you could cut your losses and walk away with 3 million, but then a) you probably wouldn't have risked the 47M in the first place, and b) you likely wouldn't end up where Musk is now. This isn't a hypothetical. As the article describes, there was a point when he was begging or borrowing every cent he could. I don't know what his personal financial situation would have been had it failed, but I doubt he held much back.
- dba7dba 12y agoAmbition and willing to take a risk is not a rare thing. Yes, most will agree. But having ambition, taking risk and being successful is a rare, rare thing. Especially after you made your fortune AND having the gut to risk it all. Now THAT is a rare thing.
- ChuckMcM 12y ago"Ambition and willing to take a risk is not a rare thing." It is a bit more nuanced than that. When a 3 lb terrier starts barking and growling at you, you have one reaction, when a 175 lb rottweiler does the same you have a different reaction. Those situations are, on their surface, exactly the same. You are being threatened by a dog. But the realities of the two situations are very different because what is at stake. The terrier can be kicked across the room, the rottweiler will likely kill you. It is really impossible to know how you are going to respond until you're actually in the situation. Perhaps not surprisingly, for a lot of people there are things worse than dying. And for many of the people I've known letting down people who are depending on them ranks pretty high on that list. Musk is very different from "most" people. We know this because he has been in the fire and we've seen the result. Look at the stories of the fall of the twin towers on 9/11. Most people paniced and froze, a small number of people took action and evacuated. At the critical stress level, when your limbic system cannot take it any more, it takes over. Some people become rabbits, some people become tigers, and the really weird thing is that I don't think you can really have any idea which way you'll go until you experience it. You can believe you will do one thing or another, but you don't really know. Scott McNealy shared with me that all you could do as a leader was to put people into really stressful situations, to see where they broke, and then note which side of the coin they fell on. It is why the armed forces put new recruits in to actual life threatening situations, to watch them panic and evaluate their response. I don't know Elon, but if he is as characterized in interviews and by third party accounts, I don't think he altruistic so much as he is driven. The most amazing person I have ever met in person who is truly driven was Dean Kamen at one of the FIRST competitions in San Jose. It seemed like he could live to be 150 and still not get done all of the things he was driven to do before he passes. It isn't about altruism and it isn't about wealth, it is all about getting the important thing done. What ever that is. And someone who is driven AND functional in the face of extreme stress, is, in my experience, a rare individual.
- throwawaymsft 12y agoThis is one of the biggest examples of middlebrow dismissal on HN I've ever seen.