4 ms·
This is spot on. There isn't anything inherently difficult about what entry-level professionals (as defined in the article) get up to. You'll be doing powerpoin
by lordnacho 12y ago
This is spot on. There isn't anything inherently difficult about what entry-level professionals (as defined in the article) get up to. You'll be doing powerpoint slides or reading documents until you fall asleep, but it's a skill that many, many more people have than are needed. Basically anyone can bone up on a few accounting ratios (what is xyz technical term?), read a book about brainteasers (100 people on an island...ugh), and read the general news (tell me something interesting?).
So who do you pick? You have all these well-educated, similar people. So of course you go for the ones you like. You ask them stupid brainteasers and stock questions (what's your greatest weakness? Where do you see yourself in 5 years?) and just see who will say something you like. They are just as capable as the ones you don't like. This is also the reason you need to have gone to a top uni: why bother looking for a skill that everyone has? Nobody ever got fired for hiring IBM.
Oh, one exception: the children of the powerful. A buddy of mine worked in investment banking and there were a number of kids whose parents were CEOs of known firms, or other important people. Those kids are going to be able to do the job at hand as well as the future job of getting business. It does tighten the pyramid for the other capable kids, but they know the game.
Contrast that with a job where the skill is roughly as available as the demand. Where it is possible that the random guy off the street cannot do it (eg iOS developer). What do you do then? Well, now you can't just show up to the interview unprepared. You need to spend time asking real, discriminating questions (How do optionals work in Swift?). You also might need to balance your opinion about the person's character with your need to have that skill in house.
- Falcon9 12y agoNice Halt and Catch Fire reference. Why does it make any sense that these jobs with ridiculous numbers of qualified candidates would "get to be" the 1%, as opposed to those others you mention (iOS developer)? Not asking you specifically, lordnacho. Just a question to the universe that's probably as useful as asking "why me?" whenever anything at all happens. Still though.
- lordnacho 12y agoiOS dev guy does not tie his self image to his net worth. You can buy his services with an interesting job. He also is not a hard bargainer, and just giving him enough to be comfortable will work. Finance guy has been told his whole life to work hard. He goes into finance because he can't think of anything better to do (why don't interesting companies go to recruitment fairs? WTF?), but he does have this one trump card which is he went to Harvard. Having no particular interest, he goes for the highest paying job.
- rayiner 12y agoThat doesn't actually make any sense. If 100 people can do the job, why pick the people you like the most instead of the ones who are willing to work for the least? Why filter it down to 10 people based on pointless criteria and then pay them all a bunch of money? You're essentially assuming that professional services firms are irrational. The reason these firms don't screen for knowledge is that they don't care what you know, they care what you can be taught. These are fields where you can't learn the job without actually doing the job, and where relative skill often matters more than absolute skill.
- exelius 12y agoBecause they hire for likability for a reason. If the client likes your people, and your people are good at talking to people, the client will be more likely to hire them. Professional services margins are already so huge (think 200-500%) that what you pay your employees is almost irrelevant to the bottom line. Thus, these careers are highly lucrative and usually pay 10-20% more than the exact same job in industry.
- lordnacho 12y ago1) Signalling. Look at my fantastic management consultancy. All my people have Ivy League degrees. 2) These people are (In Thiel's words) indefinite optimists. They don't know what they want. They could do anything. There's plenty of other boring jobs they could do. You have to pay up. By contrast, iOS dev guy needs an app company. 3) A lot of these firms run pseudo-monopolies. It costs a LOT of money to get a bank license. There's only 4 big 4 firms left, and you can't have Mickey Mouse as your auditor. The magic circle is not getting bigger. Monopoly profits means you can pay over the odds. You can have a hiring strategy that is basically just a burnout factory. More hamsters will come.
- exelius 12y agoFor entry-level positions, you're absolutely right. But the authors fail to mention that these firms have turnover approaching 50% per year for new employees. As a new employee fresh out of college, they work you like a dog and wait for those who can't hack it to quit. The first two years are screening for work ethic (though by "work ethic", they mean how much of your life you're willing to sacrifice to the job). And likability is the core criteria because not only are these professional jobs, they are professional service jobs. As in you work directly with clients. So it's a huge asset to the firm if you're a likable person because you'll have better client relationships that lead to you selling more work. I've worked in management consulting for a while and that's just the game. Executives at large companies almost invariably have consulting backgrounds themselves, so they know how it works.
- dicroce 12y agoI know what a consultant is, and I know what a manager is... But I'm not sure I know what a "management consultant" is.. You sound like a contractor who shows up and tells managers better ways to do their jobs? If that is true, why don't they ask you why they should trust your opinion over their own?
- rayiner 12y agoSay you're a successful startup founder. You're technical, good at raising money, and good at getting your team to deliver a high-quality product on time. Fast-forward 10 years, and now you're a pretty big company. You want to start manufacturing your product yourself instead of sending that work out to someone else. Do you know anything about managing a manufacturing operation? Say you want to acquire a company. Do you know anything about integrating it?
- hessenwolf 12y agoDo the 20-something-year-old MBAs know either? Gosh, no. But they can whip up a MECE and crunch some numbers in their heads which look totally plausible. I think it provides some value, but I am not a huge fan. In my experience, the devil is in the details and the failures come during the implementation, and the management consultancies in the Marvin Bower tradition explicitly side-step implementation.
- shostack 12y agoYour investment banker scenario is pretty interesting. Given what a single large deal can mean to the firm, hiring the kid of a CEO at a big company you hope to work with one can could almost be seen as a form of lead-generation or a business development cost. The high salaries paid to a junior iBanker are nothing compared to the revenue from a successful deal, plus that new hire is hopefully competent and contributing to the firm's success (and one day sourcing their own deals).
- tomp 12y ago> Given what a single large deal can mean to the firm, hiring the kid of a CEO at a big company you hope to work with one can could almost be seen as a form of lead-generation or a business development cost. It's actually seen as bribery and is illegal. From [1]: > U.S. authorities are examining whether JPMorgan violated anti-bribery laws by hiring the children and other relatives of well-connected politicians and clients in China in exchange for having business steered to the firm, [1] http://www.bloomberg.com/news/articles/2013-12-08/jpmorgan-china-hiring-probe-spreads-to-five-more-banks-nyt-says http://www.bloomberg.com/news/articles/2013-12-08/jpmorgan-c...