3 ms·
But there is some process by which you can prove the money is yours and you are entitled for it to be returned? For example, petitioning to be involved in the c
by zaroth 12y ago
But there is some process by which you can prove the money is yours and you are entitled for it to be returned? For example, petitioning to be involved in the case, can it be denied? Is it just a procedural nightmare? Then what? I'd just be interested in the deeper story about actually trying to get the money back. If you show the paper trail of exactly where the dollars came from, are the judges still ruling against it and keeping the money? That's sounds like an entirely seprate layer of corruption which is going unreported.
I've seen it written many times that it often costs more to get the asset back than they're worth. That cost to the lawyer is also cost to the state and judicial system, and typically the justices don't take kindly to anyone wasting their time. I'm not reading about the massive backlog of forfeiture cases, mostly it seems like people don't even try.
On the one hand I hear that JDs are dropping like flies because there's no work, and on the other hand I hear there's tens of billions of dollars in money sitting in a big pot waiting for lawyers to try to get some of that back on contingency?
I found one blog after a bit of searching which has an interesting summary (criminal and civil forfeiture considered) I'm guessing that most people targeted, as usual, simply don't know their rights, and don't bother fighting for them, even when there's thousands of dollars on the line. [1]
The narrative that you can't get the money back I think is damaging to the cause of clamping down on forfeiture abuse. In fact you can get the money back [2], and particularly in cases like TFA, when the prosecutors office starts having to allocate a larger part of their workweek defending this bile they will start pushing back on it as well.
[1] - http://brendagrantland.com/truthjustice/how-to-defend-5th-amendment-privilege/ http://brendagrantland.com/truthjustice/how-to-defend-5th-am...
[2] - http://fear.org http://fear.org
- fencepost 12y agoThe problem is that you're paying for legal representation. Even if you get the money back by the time you pay legal bills there may not be much of it left.
- gmac 12y agoSo this 'civil forfeiture' is appalling and Orwellian enough in its own right, but it's also one of those cases where the apparent inability to award costs in US courts seems truly insane. If this happened under the English legal system, you can be pretty sure the courts would make the DEA pay both sides' legal costs for meritless seizures like this one. So if you were prepared to take the risk of going to court you'd at least stand a good chance of getting all your money back. (IANAL, But My Wife Is).
- learnstats2 12y agoIn my opinion the English courts don't even go far enough. There are plenty of cases where it's worthwhile for a malicious actor to antagonize someone, safe in the knowledge that the most they can lose is the legal costs. That is, if the victim is able to offer the significant effort and cash enough to seek legal recourse.
- tsotha 12y ago>I'm not reading about the massive backlog of forfeiture cases, mostly it seems like people don't even try. For two reasons. One, you can't afford a lawyer because the government took your money. And two, there's not a lot of point in spending $300k to get $12.5k back from the government. The DEA is using tax dollars - they can stretch out the proceedings until you run out of money.
- pbhjpbhj 12y ago>And two, there's not a lot of point in spending $300k to get $12.5k back from the government. // Don't injured parties receive costs from the perpetrators in USA courts? The risk may not be worth it but provided you have reasonable legal costs they get paid, surely? Also if the action is without due process or is malicious then you'd get punitive damages as well wouldn't you [which would have to be high to discourage the behaviour in the future]? At least in a democracy you'd have these things ...
- wmil 12y agoIn general, not unless the judge rules the claim was made in bad faith. There are some specific exceptions. http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Attorney%27s_fee#Who_pays http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Attorney%27s_fee#Who_pays
- zaroth 12y agoThe Civil Asset Forfeiture Reform Act (CAFRA) ammended the law specifically in civil forfeiture cases so that you should be awarded attorney fees if you "substantially prevail". Unfortunately, the courts have decided to interpret this as meaning something mystical other than simply winning the case on the merits. https://www.law.cornell.edu/uscode/text/28/2465 https://www.law.cornell.edu/uscode/text/28/2465 -- See (b)(1)
- pbhjpbhj 12y ago... and attorneys that do win seem to find it hard to get their money, http://brendagrantland.com/truthjustice/tag/english-rule/ http://brendagrantland.com/truthjustice/tag/english-rule/. Personally I think the American Rule is terrible in general, now I understand more why USA has [an appearance of having] so much litigation.