42 ms·
"Text does not communicate tone" is a huge problem. You can solve that by deciding that certain types of communication should be done face to face. Being kind
by btilly 12y ago
"Text does not communicate tone" is a huge problem. You can solve that by deciding that certain types of communication should be done face to face.
Being kind can be more concise. Here is an example that my fiance recently pointed out...
I think the single biggest mistake people make in communication is reminding the other person they are incorrect when that does not change the content.
"As I told you Monday, the reason is X."
"I have not heard from you when I asked for feedback, so I am following up."
"We could have done it the other way, but since you already set it up, let's use this."
It is amazingly tempting, almost everyone does it, and your communication becomes an order of magnitude more benevolent when you edit those clauses out.
For more ideas on how to be concise and kind, I highly recommend the parenting book, _How to Talk so Kids Will Listen, and Listen so Kids Will Talk_. It is not just for parents. What works with 13 year old kids also works with 30 year old kids.
- derefr 12y ago> You can solve that by deciding that certain types of communication should be done face to face. And in the case where your only relationship with these people is online in the first place? (As in this community, but also in quite a few FOSS projects or remote-only companies.)
- btilly 12y agoThat is a tricky case. It never hurts to be aware of the issue. Beyond that, try to stay within community norms. Every approach will have failure modes. Know and accept which ones are likely with what you are doing, and deal with them when they come. In some communities this will mean that you are very straightforward and technical. Don't say anything emotional. Always work from facts. If you are misunderstood, note it, apologize for the misunderstanding, and move on. In other communities it might mean that you actively solicit input from decision makers, and carefully avoid controversial topics. A variety of approaches will work. But following strategy X in a community that is set up for strategy Y is a recipe for disaster.
- roflc0ptic 12y agoBased off of my vague memory, in "How To Win Friends and Influence People", one main point is not to contradict people. In text or in person, never tell someone they're wrong. In general, when I want to correct someone's understanding I frame it as a failure of my own understanding. Like, hey, I'm the asshole here, would you do me a favor by going over this one more time for me? This is great because it allows the other person to graciously concede your point, and to feel like they're the one helping you. It's also great because when it turns out you're wrong, you don't have to backtrack. Additionally I find it useful as an exercise in suspending belief. Sure, I think I'm right, but let's set that belief aside for a moment and explore our understanding. Nothing misleads people more than the conviction that they're right.
- Nadya 12y agoI rather liked that book and want to disagree with many of the points it tries to make, but find myself choosing not to. It is not economically or socially beneficial for me to be as blunt as I am - but my personal morality triumphs over both of those. If someone is wrong, they are wrong and I will let them know they are wrong. It won't win me any friends and it isn't beneficial for me to be as blunt as I am - but I don't treat life like an economist, trying to maximize use out of people and my relationships with them.
- gnaritas 12y agoI feel the same as you, but I'm come to realize most people have a deep seated need to be win friends even at the cost of being right. Your response, like my own, is very Aspie.
- georgemcbay 12y agoI fit into that "aspie" category as well which likely manifested itself in ways similar to you and the person you are responding to earlier in my life. Now at 41 I'm probably indistinguishable in action from the group you've categorized as having a "deep seated need to win friends" not because I do actually have such a need, but because I realized my need to be vocally, publicly "right" was mostly a manifestation of a core lack of confidence, something which has since been mostly alleviated. Also, in retrospect, I was actually wrong about a lot of things I was sure I was right about because I was intelligent but not wise and the two are often divergent.
- DanAndersen 12y agoThank you for pointing this one out in particular. I've noticed myself falling into this trap at times, which is sad because it's something I know is frustrating when I hear it from others. The pattern in the examples you mentioned is the desire, conscious or not, to twist the knife a little and squeeze out a "sorry" from the other person. The desire for someone else to realize an error they've made turns into a desire for guilt, a general "think better next time" that is just specific enough to hurt but vague enough to not actually be helpful. It's like training an animal with a blunt instrument and expecting that to get results anytime fast.
- JoeAltmaier 12y agoMy rule is, don't mention the other person at all in HN comments. Address only the subject. I don't always succeed, but the comments I've made that folks like are always of this sort where I expand on the topic, instead of contradicting. The worst sin is trying to rephrase what was said before e.g. "You said blah blah". That is always unnecessary, and often folks take offence.
- foxylad 12y ago"How to Talk so Kids Will Listen, and Listen so Kids Will Talk" made a bigger difference to my interactions with colleagues than it did with my kids. It should be on every management reading list.