5 ms·
I don't trust anything released by BitTorrent. Sync was a huge let down and frankly I'm not going to waste my time on any more of their software after the ad/to
by joshstrange 12y ago
I don't trust anything released by BitTorrent. Sync was a huge let down and frankly I'm not going to waste my time on any more of their software after the ad/toolbar/bitcoin-mining infested installers they put out for uTorrent...
- solomatov 12y agoCompletely agree with you. If they want it to be focused on privacy, they should at least document their protocol.
- reymus 12y agoI dont understand. Could you explain why?
- solomatov 12y agoI don't trust a product which is closed source and closed protocol. It's ok to be closed source and closed protocol for a product which isn't focused on privacy, but for the product which is it's a showstopper. Also, bittorrent did bait and switch with btsync, and had supplied utorrent with spyware. I just don't trust the company.
- higherpurpose 12y agoCare to elaborate on why Sync is a huge let down?
- black_puppydog 12y agohttps://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=8626931 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=8626931
- Sir_Substance 12y agoThat's as dishonest as btsyncs statement, in it's own way. Because it's closed source, we don't /know/ how secure btsync is. However, we do know that microsoft, google and dropbox will just hand your shit over if the US government asks. Something is better than nothing. The only open source competitors in this space are owncloud, who /still/ won't let me upload to both a work and person cloud at the same time, and syncthing, which I have high hopes for but which currently has a workflow so bad I think I'd rather just use a thumb drive. I've stuck with btsync 1.3.94, the version with the beautiful workflow, just before it went off the rails. It solves my need to avoid google/facebook etc. /Maybe/ it doesn't protect me from the US government, but that's still better than dropbox. I think bleep's gonna struggle, because it requires me to get /other/ people to buy into my disquiet, which turns out to be really hard if my experiments with XMPP over skype tell me anything. You know what I might actually pay for? A gateway to facebook/gtalk/skype. I'd be willing to pay $5 per month for a bleep-to-everything gateway, either from bittorrent or someone else. Half of bleeps value is simply in my not needing another account (e: I could say the same about btsync).
- joepie91_ 12y agoThe problem is that there's no "something". All BitTorrent does is make a promise, and that is worth nothing. Thus, "something is better than nothing" doesn't apply. Now if it were a verifiably half-assed solution, I'd agree with your statement.
- danieldk 12y agoThey did let iSEC partners review their source code. So, it is not nothing. But I agree that it would be far more trustable (and popular) if Bittorrent Sync were open source. And there is still a profit model with an open source BTSync: let people (who need it) get a tracker, relay server, and always-on (read-only encrypted) peer subscription.
- Immortalin 12y agoTry Syncthing
- zaroth 12y agoSync was great until it locked all my folders and demanded $39 to start working again. Their free tier makes it sound like you get 10 shares free but I think it actually turned out to be 10 folders including sub-folders within a share...
- danieldk 12y agoI think it actually turned out to be 10 folders including sub-folders within a share... No. The documentation says it is 10 shares with any number of subfolders and that is also my experience - when the Pro trial expired, I could sync 10 shares with a large number of subfolders without any problems. Of course, changing the number of shares from unlimited to 10 was a bait and switch move, and a scam because their website said that they wouldn't remove any functionality from the free version. Also, it's very weird that they switched to a subscription model. You bring most of the infrastructure (bandwidth & disk space) and they bring mostly software (and some infrastructure). Why not just let people buy the software?!?
- seanp2k2 12y agoBecause then you don't generate recurring revenue. Microsoft also gets this now (finally).
- chanux 12y agoAlso they call it peer-to-peer (IIRC) and now it comes with an annual fee (how about, maybe a one time charge?). Also the software felt pretty complicated with the Pro update. In the beginning it was all amazing. But we all know we can't have nice things.
- joeyspn 12y ago> Sync was a huge let down Same with BitTorrent Live...
- GutenYe 12y agoSyncthing is the way to go.
- guelo 12y agoI totally agree with you that they are total scumbags. At the same time, I am amazed that they've been able to keep that company going for so long, probably close to 10 years. They've somehow stayed afloat and kept producing new products while so many other more worthy startups came and went that I can't help but give them some grudging respect. How do they stay alive?
- hkmurakami 12y agoToolbar installs were responsible for most of their revenues before the ads came to be on their clients. Meebo (remember them?) was also staying afloat with toolbar installs.