9 ms·
Unless you're being forced to buy a car because of a wreck or something similar, you have to remember that you have 100% of the power. I've had salesman and "sa
by matwood 12y ago
Unless you're being forced to buy a car because of a wreck or something similar, you have to remember that you have 100% of the power. I've had salesman and "sales managers" laugh at my price and then chase me out as I walked out, only to call me a week later offering my price to which I told them was no longer good so it needed to be lower. I've had the finance guy literally not shaking my hand at the end of the deal and telling me never to buy a car there again (I had to correct his mistakes over and over). Buying a car is war, and if you approach it that way it can be quite amusing.
Some other stories, I had a friend when buying one of his cars it was a month long negotiation. I would be in his office, the phone would ring he would pick up say "No" and just hang up on the sales guy. Pretty hilarious actually.
Another friend walked into the dealership, money in hand and told the guy a price and that he had 45 minutes before he had to go back to work. He said it was awesome watching the salesman run all over the lot in the heat, but the deal got done.
If someone does not want to negotiate, CarMax is okay. The prices are not the best, but they are clearly shown online and the buying process is dead simple.
- jfoutz 12y agoYeah. As someone who's not used to negotiating regularly, especially at car level stakes (what else do people buy that's expensive, houses?) buying a car from a dealer was an experience. The war analogy is apt. Burn every bridge. Don't just be ready to walk, walk. It's an all day process, but it can save you literally thousands of dollars. One of my old managers went to the lot, looked around for the least saleable car, and made a standing offer for it. They called back a couple of times with higher prices, he declined. Turns out at the end of the month, they have to make a quota and would take his deal.
- toomuchtodo 12y ago> If someone does not want to negotiate, CarMax is okay. The prices are not the best, but they are clearly shown online and the buying process is dead simple. You should revisit your first three paragraphs to understand why people are okay with Carmax's prices. Buying a car should not be war, it should not be a hassle, and you should not have to wonder the entire time how you're going to get screwed. Disclaimer: I have bought over 11 cars from Carmax for myself and family; never once have I been dissatisfied. Next car is a Model S or X.
- pfraze 12y ago> You should revisit your first three paragraphs to understand why people are okay with Carmax's prices. It's pretty simple, they're willing to pay extra to avoid negotiation > Buying a car should not be war, it should not be a hassle, and you should not have to wonder the entire time how you're going to get screwed. Why not? If you have a business idea ("it shouldnt be a hassle!") then go for it. But if you think negotiating is unfair, well, yeah, of course it's unfair. File that next to "The Spurs lost" and "I'm not married to a supermodel."
- nitrogen 12y agoIt's pretty simple, they're willing to pay extra to avoid negotiation Negotiation costs time and stress. If one has more money than time and stress tolerance, it makes sense to pay to skip the negotiation.
- pfraze 12y agoI dont disagree, legit reason.
- basseq 12y agoYou can very easily save a couple thousand dollars in negotiation. I understand the TVM, and I see the value in two ways: 1. I can sit around a dealer for a couple hours and save a couple thousand bucks: that's $500-$1k/hr. Pretty good (e.g., worth my time). 2. I get to practice my negotiation skills. This has gotten fun. And while I will likely never be in the position of negotiating for large amounts (e.g., sale of a business), in that instance a 10% delta could equate to hundreds of thousands of dollars. I bought a pre-owned car a couple months ago from a high-end, reputable dealer. They pulled the "that guy over there is interested in the same car" trick. I was tempted to go over an introduce myself (should have). Instead I told them the color wasn't my first choice and they should sell to the other guy. I was told the manager came over to "say goodbye" (no he wasn't), so I stood up and put on my coat. We reached a deal. My wife was freaking out. It was fun.
- tokipin 12y ago
- thrownaway2424 12y agoThis is true. The buyer has all the power in a car purchase, especially for a sports car or motorcycle which are nonessential to daily life. I'll tell you two stories of acquaintances. One wanted a Lamborghini, so he researched what he wanted, drew up a letter to the dealer and included a cashier check for the price he was willing to pay, and a return envelope. Initially the dealer responded in the negative, but without returning the check. Six months later his car arrived. I accompanied another friend to a motorcycle dealer. He had previously negotiated the price of the bike and brought cash in that amount. He puts the cash on the counter, and the salesman starts running this game about how the owner really likes that bike and doesn't want to sell it, except at a higher price, and all this. The buyer reaches into the giant stack of cash -- thousands of dollars in $20 bills always seems like a lot of money -- counts out a thousand dollars, and puts it in his pocket. He says the remaining amount of money is the most he's willing to pay after hearing the salesman's story. The salesman disappears, comes back and desperately tries to close the deal at the original price, but eventually has to settle for the money that's literally on the table. There is almost nobody more desperate than a car salesman, so dealing with them is actually pretty easy.
- ccvannorman 12y agoThis has to be the best example of "cash talks" that I've ever heard. Definitely going to keep this one in my back pocket!
- deegles 12y agoAs much as I would like to do this to a shady used car salesman, I'm hoping I will never need purchase a car again. I'm going to use public transport, biking, walking and carsharing until self-driving cars arrive. I'm sure many millennials are in the same boat.
- robbintt 12y agoYep, car free since 2010!
- ekianjo 12y agoIf you live in any modern city (not sure about the US though since the car culture is prevalent there in most places) you usually don't need a car for daily activities or going to work. But once you want to have 1) kids 2) a bigger place 3) some land instead of just an apartment, you will end up living farther from the city and having to own a car at some point, unless you have a very large income that can accommodate such standards of livings right inside the city.
- bluthru 12y agoWell that's fine, but they're just going to extort a sweet old lady to make up the difference. Everyone paying the same price with no middlemen is my preferred model.
- oconnor663 12y agoI've had good results just emailing a bunch of dealerships, so they can all see each other in the To field.
- cxseven 12y agoMe too, for the most part. I'd always ask for the "out the door" all-cash price, all taxes and fees included. Two dealerships wasted my time by revealing more fees after I'd already driven out, but that was fine because there was another dealership with the same offer, and they stood by it. Buying used, it seems like cars bought directly from the owner can be had for about $3k less. It costs dealerships a lot to inspect, clean, and warehouse cars, plus pay all their high pressure salesmen.
- Istof 12y agoI had a dealer chase me out and then call me back and then offer me to deliver the car and contract to my home but they were so rude earlier that I went somewhere else and ended up getting an even better deal... thanks to http://www.truecar.com http://www.truecar.com. I don't know if they still help you get a good deal, but I was able to use the best deal in my area from truecar.com and bring it to someone else that was closer to me and they beat that price. I'm not sure if I got a really good deal but I ended up paying less then MSRP with taxes and fees included, so I was happy.
- ChuckMcM 12y agoMy old roommate in college used to figure out the price he would pay, get a cashier's check for that amount made out to the dealer, and slowly start ripping it if they didn't give him the price. He ripped it in half at the first dealer and walked out, he got his price at the second dealer. All it cost him was the $20 to have two checks issued.
- ghshephard 12y ago" I've had the finance guy literally not shaking my hand at the end of the deal and telling me never to buy a car there again" That's a very, very common scam. The "Finance Guy" (or the Sales Guy's Manager) - saying never come back again. Sometimes they'll even say how they screwed up, and lost money on this deal. Sometimes they say they may have to sue to get some money back... It's all an absolute complete scam. Car Dealers have been doing this for 50+ years, and they pass down the techniques and drama to new sales teams. They will never, ever do a deal that they aren't completely happy with. And the "mistakes" (also a super common technique) are almost always placed on the deal so that the person buying the car takes away satisfaction at having "fixed" tiny parts of the deal. My cousin was a car dealer, and, while I love her to pieces, when she started talking about her job and their attitudes towards customers ("Buyers are liars"), I absolutely understood how just filling a role can change how you fundamentally behave (see: http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Stanford_prison_experiment http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Stanford_prison_experiment for more details) Your last scenario, btw - is actually the exact way to buy a vehicle from these jerks. Do the research, find the absolute best price, end of month/quarter/year dealer incentives included, and then find a dealer that's rated well for service - and give them a Yes/No offer, all in (including shipping, transfer, paperwork, whatever the hell they want to make up - you don't care, just as long as the bottom line is less than your number) - and a time limit. If they can't do the deal within the time limit, no drama or discussion, just go to dealer #2.
- vidarh 12y agoThere's a good chunk about this in Cialdini's "Influence" for anyone that wants more detail.
- sorbits 12y ago> They will never, ever do a deal that they aren't completely happy with There was an episode of This American Life about car dealerships that everyone here should really listen to [1]. In that episode they did close deals where they were losing money, but hoping it would make them meet their monthly sales goal (set by the supplier), which would result in a bonus that would put them in the black. [1] http://www.thisamericanlife.org/radio-archives/episode/513/129-cars http://www.thisamericanlife.org/radio-archives/episode/513/1...
- madeofpalk 12y ago> Buying a car is war, and if you approach it that way it can be quite amusing. Lol why is buying something a war? I've gotta say, things can seem pretty backwards sometimes in the US.
- watty 12y agoHaggling is a common buying strategy outside of America as well.
- JonnieCache 12y agoOther places might not favor the armed conflict metaphor quite so much though.
- madeofpalk 12y agoHaggling is not war.
- dredmorbius 12y agoWar doesn't equal battle. The best victory is the one in which you do not actually fight.
- dredmorbius 12y agoBoth are conflicts between two (or more) parties in which the ultimate question at hand is how resources be allocated. If one side chooses to play dirty, your options are to: 1. Concede the battle and lose. 2. Walk away. 3. Up your game and win the best possible deal.
- rando289 12y ago> you have to remember that you have 100% of the power It's simply not how humans interact with each other. Every person I ever meet face to face has a significant power over my emotions.
- deleted 12y ago[deleted]
- zwily 12y agoCarMax is also decent if you want to sell a car with little hassle. You'll get less than you would privately, but it's so dang easy it's almost worth it.
- stephengillie 12y agoThe OP described the car buying process as a masochist's dream, with the endless waiting and the characteristic pricing mind games. You take the other end of the spectrum, making it a sort of sadist's paradise, watching salesmen panic and worry. Isn't there a middle-ground? I don't want to abuse or be abused in some social game; I merely want a box with wheels to convey me from work to home and back.