4 ms·
I would say the psychological riddle is why people feel an urge to treat consciousness as an irreducible quality.
by joe_the_user 12y ago
I would say the psychological riddle is why people feel an urge to treat consciousness as an irreducible quality.
- comex 12y agoRight. The paper also only takes a few seconds to identify as bullshit: rather than having any claims whatsoever about biology or how the human brain in particular depends on quantum behavior, it just takes the Copenhagen-interpretation concept of "observer" over-literally. While others may have more credible claims that the brain's operation depends on quantum behavior, my inclination is to be highly skeptical due to the basic nature of biology combined with the bias you cite.
- s_baby 12y agoI would say the psychological riddle is why people feel an urge to personally invest themselves in this issue. :tips fedora:
- duaneb 12y agoBy all observations it is not a riddle (i.e. there are no unexplainable phenomena) but rather an illusion.
- danbruc 12y agoI don't think it is justified to say that consciousness is not a riddle. There is no evidence that consciousness is more than the product of the complex physical processes happening in our brain but I don't think that makes the issue any less puzzling. How does a collection of particles completely governed by physical laws become conscious? If consciousness is just an emergent property of an incredible complex state machine than any implementation would have to be conscious, the often quoted simulation of a brain inside a computer as well as a gigantic pile of levers, gears and pulleys in the right arrangement. The thought that a collection of gears can become aware of its existence seems, at least to me, pretty outlandish.
- duaneb 12y ago> The thought that a collection of gears can become aware of its existence seems, at least to me, pretty outlandish. I mean, it's less exciting when you break that down into the what it means for a person to be aware of themselves. For me, it breaks down to neurons & symbols, well-known scientific domains. While I may not be right, it's not difficult to come up with plausible explanations for the phenomena humans experience. Most of the mystery comes from it being very difficult for most people to even define consciousness. Much of the syntax we have for it (in the west, at least) is cobbled together from various religions, spiritualities, and extremely, extremely dense philosophers read by few and understood by fewer. You might find Richard Hofstadter's Book "I Am A Strange Loop" illuminating if you find my explanation meager.
- vixen99 12y agoYou mean Douglas Hofstadter.
- duaneb 12y agoThat's what happens when you google a spelling and lazily copy and paste. :)
- s_baby 12y ago>I mean, it's less exciting when you break that down into the what it means for a person to be aware of themselves. For me, it breaks down to neurons & symbols, well-known scientific domains. I'm not aware of "neurons and symbols". I'm aware of feeling, sight, smell, etc.. The fact that consciousness is an experience is what's fundamentally at odds with building a consistent model. Modeling cognition is the easy part.
- duaneb 12y ago> I'm aware of feeling, sight, smell, etc.. a), you can have that thought only because of symbols, and b), people without thought can feel, see, smell, etc. I don't see how your argument holds any weight.
- nemo1618 12y agoBecause our experience of the world is the thing we hold most dear. We associate it with our identity, to the point where the two seem inseparable. The idea that we are "in the world, but not of it" is very deeply ingrained. Our tendency towards introspection alienates us from nature, and leads us to the conclusion that there must be something that sets us apart from the rest of the animal kingdom. Just about everyone has a deep-seated desire to be special, to be destined for a higher purpose -- and that view is not (generally) compatible with the notion that consciousness is an emergent physical phenomenon, rather than evidence of a soul.