8 ms·
Wind Power Without the Mills
- dates 12y agoAlso relevant are these awesome wind kits google is developing: http://www.google.com/makani/ http://www.google.com/makani/
- Super_Jambo 12y agoparent has a typo, it's meant to say 'awesome wind kites'.
- drewm1980 12y agoThe makani team is serious business. They keep building larger and larger prototypes and are nailing their predicted power curve every time. They have internal expertise to build (almost) everything in house, and have already demonstrated autonomous operation. They recently unveiled the wing from their under-construction 600 kW model, which should fly sometime this summer.
- lotsofmangos 12y agoIf they have managed anywhere even close to their claimed cost reductions then this is very cool. Wind is already on par with oil in terms of EROEI.
- ci5er 12y agoIf oil were the primary fuel for electricity generation, you'd have a solid point. Assuming that we were to compare it to natural gas, for which you may have used oil as a proxy, this provides some substantiation to your claim: - http://www.theoildrum.com/node/1863 http://www.theoildrum.com/node/1863 But the calculations here don't reflect that peak power generation doesn't reflect peak demand. So, we've looking at adding in battery's costs too. At the end of the day, if a greedy capitalist can make a bigger buck (with or without government subsidies) with wind than they can with coal or natural gas, they will. Given that the efforts to bring new capacity on-line fluctuate (dramatically!) with the comings and goings of government subsidies, my guess is that they aren't quite the competitive economic wonder, at this point, that they are touted to be. YMMV.
- realcoolguy 12y agoAlways found it odd that wind capture/generation shapes resembled centuries old windmills. Great to see some (expected) innovation in the space. With non-moving parts, no noise, and won't sent people into epileptic shock around sunrise/sunset, it looks like a winner. (if you've never driven past a windfarm in the morning or evening, the flashing is incredibly irritating).
- masklinn 12y agoIt's not really odd, it's a very efficient shape. Which is why propellers and main rotors also use it.
- scblock 12y agoLet me do a quick word substitution. > If you've never driven past trees in the morning or evening, the flashing is incredibly irritating. Shadow flicker is a siting and operations problem. It's based on geometry (sun angles and turbine locations), wind conditions (turbine direction) and weather conditions (cloudiness). If we consider residences, schools, churches, and so on as discrete shadow receptors, flicker can be minimized through careful siting of the machines, and eliminated at those sites through programmatic controls (curtailment).
- mrfusion 12y agoI don't understand how they can have no moving parts?
- millisecond 12y agoSounds like a magnetic coupling to the motor rather than gears, not no moving parts at all. Imagine it saves wear-and-tear and is easier to disengage on winds that are too strong.
- masklinn 12y agoIt has moving parts, just not moving parts in contact with one another. From what I understand the outer segment is flexible and oscillates because of vortex shedding, and a magnetic coupling between the flexible outer segment and the fixed inner one generates power. So the outer segment is mobile, but it never touches the inner segment.
- lotsofmangos 12y agoIt does have moving parts, the article says 'no moving parts that come into contact with each other'. The tower waggles and is made of piezoelectric materials, so the electricity comes from the deformation of the tower. Edit - I got sideswiped by marketing. The current one is electromagnetic, the future ones are proposed to use piezoelectrics, but they do not have the materials available to do this.
- kitd 12y agoIt uses a similar effect to this: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=ptYrbQGk6DQ https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=ptYrbQGk6DQ ie vortex shedding. There are moving parts, but the movement is much smaller and more confined.
- bkardell 12y agoI remember hearing about something similar in '08 https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=AMojRXK14jU https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=AMojRXK14jU which became http://www.humdingerwind.com/ http://www.humdingerwind.com/ - I wonder if they are related? Seems like a really interesting idea.
- phloxicon 12y agoAre there any numbers on how much it generates compared to a traditional design? I imagine it generates less electricity but it costs less so there's a trade-off.
- Htsthbjig 12y agoOne of the great things about wind turbines today is that they capture power over the entire disk of wind the blades touch. I suppose using this system means blocking the wind with something akin to a forest, with a small space between "artificial trees".
- scblock 12y agoAgain? AGAIN? Another "no blades! save the birds!" technology that's little more than a concept. There are constantly amazing technologies just around the corner that will definitely totally be awesomely better than existing 3 bladed horizontal axis wind turbine technology. And they'll always be less expensive than current technology somehow. Trust me, getting the cost right at this stage of the technology curve is almost impossible, and founders and technology developers are notoriously optimistic. Yet they are always a few kW (this one is 4 kW) rather than 2 or 3 MW (a factor of 1000), and are always "just a few years away". And will never be a commercially successful product outside, perhaps, small scale demonstration and greenwashing projects. We didn't get to the standard model of wind turbine by accident. It took decades of engineering and refinement. And yes, we still have a lot to learn. And yes the current technology has problems.
- bpodgursky 12y agoDecades? I would say it took centuries at least. The basic design hasn't changed since the middle ages.
- ifdefdebug 12y agoWell maybe changing the basic design of wind turbines would be somewhat like changing the basic design of wheels but still today's wheels are better than medieval ones.
- scblock 12y agoTruth. To clarify, I was specifically referring to wind turbines that generate electricity.
- posnet 12y agoAnother example of interesting developments. But this one at least seems to be scalable to 1MW. http://www.thinkerstools.net/powerpack.htm http://www.thinkerstools.net/powerpack.htm
- olau 12y agoI think you have to separate joy of the tech from practical matters here. Regarding the practical matters, it looks like they are three orders of magnitude from being on par with the three-blade vertical design. So while this idea may be worthwhile in some niches like mentioned in the article, it's currently not a replacement for the giant, towering, 3 MW and up turbines erected these days. And just like other wind-turbine replacement ideas (like kites or vertical-axis designs, but there are many more, just check Wikipedia), they probably never will. As I understand it, part of the beauty of the three-blade design is that by scaling the blade length linearly, you get a quadratic gain (pi r^2 area swept) in energy harvested.
- samatman 12y agoGetting kites to work has proved challenging, yes. But the beauty of the design is that they have in principle better scaling properties than a wind turbine. Don't count them out yet. As for the parent design, could be interesting. I cannot imagine a possible justification for not building it out given the urgency of renewable power to our present needs.
- mark-r 12y agoThe problem with these things is always in the scaling up. Either things don't scale linearly, or you run into some fundamental limit where the tech doesn't yet exist to solve it. Even if the bigger systems don't pan out, it's still cool and useful. I wonder what's the size of their prototype? Hard to tell from the picture.
- startupfounder 12y agoI have repelled (using Industrial Rope Access) off hundreds of multi-megawatt Wind Turbines on $1B+ wind farms around the world to inspect and repair the 13+ ton fiberglass blades and wanted to give my 2 cents. [A clarification: Wind Turbines generate electricity, Wind Mills mill flour. It's a small but important detail.] Operation & Maintenance expense is my biggest issue with new technology. I have met many design engineers that have never been inside of a nacelle or even visited a wind farm. In the real world generators and blades break, hurricanes, lightning, shit happens. Cranes are extremely expensive and a 2MW "mast" that can compete with today's technology is going to be crazy tall. How to repair a lightning cable? Cranes are over $10k per day and cables take a few days to fix. Today there is a 26 story ladder in the interior of the support tower that people climb up to fix hardware in the nacelle. To inspect the blades we then rig our anchors to the generator, pop out the top hatch and repel over the nose cone and down onto a blade in the "down" position. The only specialized hardware needed is anchors, carabiners, ropes, harness and helmet. Vortex Bladeless would be impossible to inspect and repair using this method, yes drones are great for inspection, but what about repairing a stress crack on the tip? You would need a crazy tall crane that is even more expensive and with cranes the wind speeds need to be a fraction that of Industrial Rope Access. This means your available repair days are even less and the turbine has to be shut down for longer for the fix to occur. I am all for new technology and crowd financing, but there are many practical obstacles this team needs to overcome in the design phase to build a product that can actually scale in the real world. Also, feel free to AMA if you have specific wind turbine questions.
- sliverstorm 12y agoI try not to be pedantic, but I was really confused for a minute- I believe you mean "rappel". (Or if you want to sound fancy, "abseil")
- startupfounder 12y agoYou are correct! My right hand pinky finger doesn't have the dexterity it used to. I can crank out words with one "P" in them, but when I have to do the double tap of the "P" it becomes a real issue.
- JulianMorrison 12y agoWind engineers: why isn't "save the birds" as simple as a ring-enclosed sandwich of mesh screen, blades, mesh screen?
- NLips 12y agoBecause generally the birds don't really need saving from wind turbines. Numbers from an unverified source: http://science.howstuffworks.com/environmental/green-science/wind-turbine-kill-birds.htm http://science.howstuffworks.com/environmental/green-science... (other sites seems to agree on the cats vs turbine numbers) Alternatively, from a source you might expect to be very biased in favour of birds: http://www.rspb.org.uk/forprofessionals/policy/windfarms/ http://www.rspb.org.uk/forprofessionals/policy/windfarms/
- lambdaelite 12y agoA problem with the estimates in the U.S. is that turbines disproportionately affect legally-protected birds, and so the numbers are suspected to be severely under reported.
- insertnickname 12y agoSo what? If they're too stupid not to fly into a giant blade, then maybe it's ok that they die.
- johnchristopher 12y agoLet me introduce you to a wonderful concept: http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Ecosystem http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Ecosystem Enjoy the next three days of reading.
- lambdaelite 12y agoA selfish reason to care is that apex predators like birds of prey are useful as indicators for the health of an ecosystem. Take the case of DDT as an example. A less selfish reason is that bad things happen to the rest of the ecosystem when you mess around with apex predators.
- frobozz 12y agoThis says 'Because there is no contact between moving parts, there is no friction. Therefore no lubricant is required. No replacement of spare parts either.' However, there are animations that show it wobbling. This implies that it's made of a flexible substance. I'm not being so pedantic as to suggest that the fibres or crystals etc. of the substance are moving parts (though surely there is friction between them), but I do have a query: In my completely anecdotal and limited experience of household bendy objects vs. household hinges; hinges win the longevity battle every time, even without regular application of lubricants. Also, when a bendy object fails, the whole thing needs to be replaced. On the other hand, when a mechanical part fails, I can replace the part and keep the rest of the object. Can these things therefore really be cheaper to maintain than a mechanical wind turbine?
- david-given 12y agoHow to make tall, stiff objects wobble safely is pretty standard technology these days --- all tall buildings do it, and very tall skyscrapers are carefully tuned and damped to wobble in exactly the right way. This is partly because of wind, and partly earthquakes. Here's a terrifying video of a skyscraper farm in Japan swaying gently after an earthquake in 2011. https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=EQaHyY9-Fuw https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=EQaHyY9-Fuw So I'd say it's at least plausible that these generators could be built.
- qbrass 12y agoBuild them out of skyscrapers.
- bengali3 12y agooscillating: https://youtu.be/2_5K4kmnsL4?t=75 https://youtu.be/2_5K4kmnsL4?t=75
- boardwaalk 12y agoThe comments here are amazingly negative -- personally, if I was to live off the grid, the 4kW, 40', 220lb version sounds pretty great to me. At 220lb, you could easily raise/lower the thing as one person with some sort of mechanism for installation/service. I'm really curious how much it'd cost in comparison to solar. Maybe someone can estimate with the "80% less maintenance cost, 53% manufacturing cost" than wind turbines bit.
- ska 12y agoWell to be fair, I thought the article and company blurbs was targeting significant production as much as smaller & off-the-grid use. And these guys are hardly the first to make strong claims before demonstrating at scale. On the other hand, this sort of unit might be interesting for the use you suggest. Even if the manufacturing cost isn't a big win, if the MTBF is enough of an improvement by design, it might have some application in small remote sites where maintenance is a pain.
- toomuchtodo 12y ago> I'm really curious how much it'd cost in comparison to solar. For a 4kW sized solar system, you'd be looking at ~$6K-8K USD before your 30% federal tax credit (plus state incentives, if available). Your solar system would have significantly less maintenance requirements, consisting of rinsing the panels with a hose 1-2/year.
- pietrofmaggi 12y agoHere's another article with a short video that show a prototype working. http://www.renewableenergymagazine.com/article/the-power-of-the-vortex-20150407 http://www.renewableenergymagazine.com/article/the-power-of-...
- frik 12y agoIt's called the "Magnus effect" and is not new at all: http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Magnus_effect http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Magnus_effect There are airplanes and boats that use this technique too: http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Rotor_ship http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Rotor_ship , http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Flettner_airplane http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Flettner_airplane , http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Alcyone_(ship) http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Alcyone_(ship) , http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/E-Ship_1 http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/E-Ship_1 , Wind mills and green energy is great, so go for it - just don't try to patent the "Magnus effect".