17 ms·
Autonomous truck cleared to drive on US roads for the first time
- maxmcd 12y ago"But they are not totally driverless. A human driver still sits behind the wheel, ready to take over in case of a lane change or unexpected hazard." Autonomous with a requirement for a human driver doesn't sound like real progress. Title might be a little misleading.
- chc 12y agoDoes automated factory equipment with a human overseeing its operation and correcting error cases sound like real progress over what came before? If so, why doesn't it sound like progress when we have an automated truck with a human overseeing its operation and correcting error cases?
- MichaelApproved 12y agoThough, I agree this is progress, I don't think your analogy is correct here. The progress you're referring to allows 1 person to oversee machines that do several people's work. 1 person = 10 jobs. With the trucks, you have the same person overseeing his own job, except that it'll be done safer. 1 person = 1 job (safer). Your analogy would make more sense if the trucks were remotely supervised and 1 person could oversee several trucks via remote connection.
- marcosdumay 12y ago> Your analogy would make more sense if the trucks were remotely supervised and 1 person could oversee several trucks via remote connection. How long until they get there? It does not look like a huge change from the person on a wheel. Automatic cars wouldn't be allowed at the roads in one step.
- gtirloni 12y agoIn time, all of that will happen. Right now there is too much (warranted) skepticism that society won't let a driverless truck running around alone. In a few years, after proving that the number of incidents is much less than with human drivers, everybody won't care.
- trimble-alum 12y agoToyota is returning back to artisanal skill as the basis for automation.
- _random_ 12y agoAny bureaucratic approval of a new tech is a real progress.
- seanp2k2 12y agoI think it's progress in the same way aircraft autopilot is; it can make operation safer for everyone and protect against some types of operator error such as falling asleep and drifting into oncoming traffic.
- anigbrowl 12y agoThere's more to progress than getting rid of jobs. I'll happy pay the same price for human truck drivers/supervisors at the cash register as we do now, or a bit more, if the benefit is lower accident rates and more efficient fuel consumption. I won't save anything directly but it will result in a safer and cleaner place to live.
- sschueller 12y agoIf trucks become completely autonomous what will prevent someone from standing in front of one causing it to stop and then robbing it? Unlike with human drivers that may not stop if they believe they are in danger of getting carjacked I assume an autonomous system will be required to avoid hitting a human at all cost.
- superuser2 12y ago- Remote video surveillance - The driving algorithm will need to be capable of causing a 911 call to be made for various reasons, including that - When there is no human driver, a carjacking is not actually that bad. There is insurance for this kind of problem, and it will be up to insurance companies to figure out if it's even worth attempting to mitigate.
- jjoonathan 12y ago> - Remote video surveillance So the robbers wear masks and shoot / paint over / jam the video equipment. They can do this at a distance because there is no risk of hitting a human. > - The driving algorithm will need to be capable of causing a 911 call to be made for various reasons, including that So the robbers choose a section of road far away from the nearest police and otherwise conducive at making them difficult to follow. > - There is insurance for this kind of problem If it gets to be too frequent of a problem, the insurance will become expensive enough that it will be easier just to keep a human around on more dangerous routes.
- Crito 12y ago> "So the robbers wear masks and shoot / paint over / jam the video equipment." Doing any of that would create a very distinct MO. You want to avoid that if you want to avoid being caught. Also, have you seen how small cameras are these days? Maybe you could load up a crop-duster with paint and cover the whole truck, but there is no way you could hope to successfully shoot out every camera an insurance company could stick on a truck. > "So the robbers choose a section of road far away from the nearest police and otherwise conducive at making them difficult to follow." A problem not made any worse by driverless vehicles. If anything, you can program a truck to always follow approved routes while with human drivers you have to account for insubordination.
- ahelwer 12y agoSimilar to a train. An operator is present, waiting to take control if necessary. I bet there'll be a dead man's vigilance device[1], just like in the rail industry. [1] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Dead-man%27s_vigilance_device https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Dead-man%27s_vigilance_device
- tonetheman 12y agowhen AI takes over it will be easier for them to run us down, or cut off supply chains.
- ionwake 12y agoWhich is why I for one, welcome our new robot overlords.
- olivermarks 12y agotruck driving is the most common job in the western states.
- formulaT 12y agoCare to expand on this? If you mean to imply that this means automating trucking would be a bad thing, I disagree. According to mainstream economics, jobs are not an externality (although they are during a recession). The total amount of money to go around after an efficiency increasing change, will be greater. With taxation, this means that in theory everyone can be made better off. In practice, the truckers will be worse off, but you could at least arrange taxes so that the percentage of people earning less than X decreased, for all X. Then the only argument left is that the change is somehow unfair to truckers. But that viewpoint unfairly privileges the status quo. One thing that is true is that the adjustment period will be hard.
- arrrg 12y agoAnd the adjustment period can be longer than a human lifetime … so those people are just screwed. That’s no way to go about this. Obviously, not increasing efficiency would be bone-headed, but it is centrally important to create a socially acceptable transition for those (and any people) who are affected by this. That is currently not happening and hasn’t been happening in the past. The luddites were right. The changes industrialization brought really did suck for them and for them it really didn’t get any better ever, until they died. From that point of view smashing the machines is entirely rational, even if those same machines created tremendous, unimaginable wealth. Obviously I’m not advocating smashing machines here, but, you know, we do have to find workable solutions for the luddites.
- formulaT 12y agoBut we don't owe it to make sure that no one is ever worse off. There are people who never had jobs in the first place. If a trucker loses is job because of technological change, why is the trucker now entitled to more than the person who never had a job?
- protomyth 12y ago"In the meantime, several issues still need to be addressed. It is not yet clear how insurance companies might cover self-driving vehicles, for instance, or where blame would be attributed in a road accident." Who is responsible is going to be the big make / break for all self-driving vehicles. I get the feeling this is going to be very messy.
- the8472 12y agoWhy not simply agree on a certain accident-rate with the insurance company and they cover anything that stays within that rate as long as there isn't any gross negligence - which would be pretty hard to prove, considering that the software can be audited in advance - or malicious behavior (kill 10 kids every christmas as long as we stay within the agreed rate). I mean smoothing out low-incidence, high-impact events is pretty much their business, no?
- derefr 12y agoBut insurance companies are founded on the assumption that they will only have to pay out in the exceptional case, no? If they can know for a fact that a certain accident rate is guaranteed for a given car, then they will explicitly disclaim liability for accidents within that rate, similar to how all product warranties expire before the far end of the bathtub curve. Otherwise it's like selling flood insurance on a flood plain, or health insurance to cancer patients: something that makes no economic sense and only exists where the government has forced it to.
- anigbrowl 12y agoNo they won't; they'll be happy to cover it because they'll know who to recover from. At bottom insurance is a cash-flow management business. They know very well what the probabilities are and build those into the price.
- the8472 12y ago> But insurance companies are founded on the assumption that they will only have to pay out in the exceptional case, no? "Exceptional case" is still a well-defined rate for them. They calculate risks and adjust insurance premium accordingly. That's pretty much their business. With sufficiently large amount of insured parties those "exceptional events" are actually fairly common. And that's what I was referring to. If the insurance company is in the business of calculating incident rates anyway they might as well cooperate with the autonomous car manufacturer to drive down incidence rates to a covered level. Just like car insurances will offer reduced premiums to experienced, accident-free drivers they can offer reduced fees to vehicle manufacturers who statistically cause fewer accidents.
- legulere 12y agoAutonomous trucks will be there probably earlier than autonomous cars. For cars it would be a feature for people, but for trucks you would be able to save tons of money with it.
- jfoster 12y agoWhere does the saving come from if they still require a driver? From the article, it sounds like the biggest gain is probably in hiring. Possibly also additional savings in fewer accidents. (lower overall fatigue)
- melling 12y agoIncreased safety and reduced insurance. Will automation reduce fuel with more efficient driving?
- millisecond 12y agoOnce these trucks are out there in numbers, the financial incentive to eliminate drivers will be so high (and there will be safety data) that the laws will change to allow true driverless.
- to3m 12y agoSemi-autonomous road trains, assuming - and I admit this isn't a minor thing ;) - only the lead lorry need be occupied, would let you get more lorry-hours per driver hour. This might not actually improve the driver:lorry ratio, but by spreading one driver over multiple lorries you could operate the lorries in shifts with that same ratio. Say currently one driver can drive 8 hours per day. So if you need to drive for 24 hours, it's going to take 3 days. If you had 3 lorries doing that journey, it would take 3 days. But say you had your semi-autonomous road train. Now you could do the journey in 24 hours. One driver drives for 8 hours, then the next guy, then the next guy. The two lorries behind just tag along. Imagine 3 x 25 hour journeys, where the destinations didn't quite match. Previously this would take 4 days. This time: there's 24 hours of shared journey and an extra unshared hour of travel at the end of the route. Now your drivers have to split up at that point. The guy who was driving the road train last will have to wait 16 hours, so his journey takes 24+17 = 41 hours; the guy who was driving before him will have to wait 8 hours, so his journey takes 24+9 = 33 hours; the other guy can jump in his lorry and go straight away, so his journey takes 25 hours.
- biesnecker 12y agoYet another Simpsons' prediction come true: http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Maximum_Homerdrive http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Maximum_Homerdrive
- patcheudor 12y agoIt's interesting that on the "what could go wrong" discussions on HN, the focus has been on the discussion of insurance and events like truck-jacking. Those are the issues of today. I think there's a far more interesting future at play. These trucks can and will put people out of work. Right now a large majority of the testing of autonomous vehicles is focused on "perfect environments". Yes, Google will say that test driving autonomous cars in San Francisco is far from a perfect environment; however, in a future where people are loosing their livelihoods, ways to hack autonomous vehicles will be explored, and I'm not talking about just hacking a vehicle CAN bus. All of these vehicles rely on technologies like radar, LIDAR, IR vision, etc. None of which are fool-proof and each of which could fall to very specific attacks. I hope that the auto manufacturers are considering this future. After all, we have technologies today like GNU Radio and the HackRF One which have brought what was once the domain of the nation state to the general public.
- elchief 12y ago25% of Americans were farmers 80 years ago. Now it's 1%.
- patcheudor 12y agoFarming is actually a great example. There were farmers who did fight back against farm machinery. Sabotage of tractors and equipment was an actual thing here in the US and abroad. You can even find whole groups of anti-tractor types in the American Amish country. These days it's sabotage against GMO crops. You'll find Monsanto and other companies will place their GMO test fields in regions of the country known to be sympathetic and/or will keep them under armed guard.
- baddox 12y agoThe views of the Amish regarding technology have absolutely nothing to do with employment rates.
- patcheudor 12y ago
- JulianMorrison 12y agoDriving jobs go byebye.
- tokenadult 12y agoThe article reports about this model of truck, "the first to be cleared to drive on US roads," but I think that is a factually incorrect exaggeration, based on other reporting I have read about this same model of truck. A Washington Post report[1] says, "Daimler’s tractor-trailer, called the Inspiration Truck, relies on cameras and radar to guide itself. It does not use LIDAR, a sensor that is being used by other self-driving vehicle makers such as Google. Like all autonomous vehicles today, the Inspiration Truck has some limitations. It can’t drive on its own during heavy rain, snow or crosswinds above 30 or 40 mph. "Daimler developed a training system for its drivers that Nevada’s department of motor vehicles approved. It’s fairly simple, teaching them how to activate and deactivate the autonomous driving system. It says it picked Nevada because of how thorough its rules are for autonomous vehicles." A thorough National Public Radio report[2] also describes this as a one-state, limited program of experiments. [1] http://www.washingtonpost.com/blogs/innovations/wp/2015/05/06/how-self-driving-tractor-trailers-may-reinvent-what-it-means-to-be-a-truck-driver/ http://www.washingtonpost.com/blogs/innovations/wp/2015/05/0... [2] http://www.npr.org/blogs/alltechconsidered/2015/05/10/405598189/coming-soon-to-a-highway-near-you-a-semi-truck-with-a-brain http://www.npr.org/blogs/alltechconsidered/2015/05/10/405598...
- deleted 12y ago[deleted]
- trimble-alum 12y agoThere are a raft of unaddressed safety and licensing issues to verify that autonomous navigation feedback systems can sense danger and perform evasive, ingenious maneuvers sufficiently to preserve life and property. This is one of the reasons why incremental features are less risky than going all in to uncharted waters.