14 ms·
Your cyberpunk games are dangerous
- pyre 12y agoI've read a couple of previous write-ups regarding the raid on Steve Jackson Games, but this one provided a number of details I don't remember the others having (though I could have just failed to remember them).
- waterlesscloud 12y agoSci-fi author Bruce Sterling's non-fiction book _The Hacker Crackdown_ covers the era pretty well, and is freely available. Sterling, after all, coined the very phrase "Information wants to be free." http://www.mit.edu/hacker/hacker.html http://www.mit.edu/hacker/hacker.html
- escap 12y agoper http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Information_wants_to_be_free http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Information_wants_to_be_free the phrase is attributed to Stewart Brand "On the one hand information wants to be expensive, because it's so valuable. The right information in the right place just changes your life. On the other hand, information wants to be free, because the cost of getting it out is getting lower and lower all the time. So you have these two fighting against each other."
- waterlesscloud 12y agoHuh. Looks like I've wrongly attributed that phrase for pretty much its entire lifetime!
- lkrubner 12y agoI am not sure which is more dangerous, the era in which the government did not understand the Internet, and accidentally lashed out in hysterical fear against non-threats, or the era in which the government does understand the Internet, and deliberately lashes out in hysterical fear against non-threats.
- wtbob 12y agoOr the era in which the government does understand the Internet, and deliberately attacks actual threats…getting caught in the crossfire is never fun, no matter how legitimate the battle. How many people died in the Battle of Britain from shells, shrapnel and planes falling on them? But of course, many more would have died had the RAF not fought the Luftwaffe. Likewise, how many will suffer today in the crossfire between criminal gangs, extremist organisations and legitimate governments? How many would suffer if legitimate governments didn't fight?
- nitrogen 12y ago"Cyberwarfare" cannot be analogized to traditional war. There is no analog to mutually assured destruction. There are no open battlefields; every system attacked has a private or government owner. Every dollar spent on attacks instead of patching vulnerabilities leaves everyone else vulnerable to those attacks. Instead of analogies and aphorisms, let's talk about actual consequences to actual tactics.
- tptacek 12y agoSoftware vulnerabilities are now the most important vector for signals intelligence, so really the argument here is whether there's a purpose to conducting signals intelligence, and whether it outweighs the harm done by postponing fixes for bugs that NSA could otherwise report.
- bediger4000 12y agoI'll admit up front that I don't have a clearance of any sort, and I don't work in intelligence. But as a citizen of the USA, that particular argument is really quite irrelevant. I don't want my systems used by IDF Unit 8200, The Equation Group (or whatever the NSA calls themselves) or PLA Unit 61398. The "important vector" is a wide open hole I want patched. All the NSA arguments are pretty irrelevant, except for signs for the rest of us to regard the NSA as a rogue agency. On some authority, you're asking me to put myself in the position of an NSA leader. I'm not an NSA leader. Postponing the bug fixes hurts me, and the rest of the people like me. Fix them.
- nearengine 12y ago"Our cyberspace today has its share of problems, but it is no dystopia" Really? What changed? The government at least got more proficient at using the Internet, I guess.
- deltaprotocol 12y agoI had just copied this to paste here. That someone is able to write such an article and at the very end wrap it up like this, today, after everything that the whole world knows for a fact, this scares me more than anything in the article.
- increment 12y agoYeah, ultimately I think the Internet today is a lot more open and a lot more beneficial to liberal society than any network was in 1990. I understand why you gag at that, but, I can imagine much, much worse outcomes than we got.
- ploxiln 12y ago"Role-playing games were dangerous: they warped fragile young minds, breaking down the barriers between the real and the imaginary. The irony is that it was the authorities, not the players, who couldn’t tell a game from reality." ... well said.
- digi_owl 12y agoWhat is the quote again? "Do not expect a man to grasp it, when his continued employment depends on him not doing so".
- DCoder 12y ago> J. Eric Townsend reviewed a copy [of GURPS] for the early computer security zine RISKS This looks like the review in question: http://catless.ncl.ac.uk/Risks/10.03.html#subj10.1 http://catless.ncl.ac.uk/Risks/10.03.html#subj10.1
- hellbanner 12y ago" he notes that “now it seems that anybody with any computer knowledge at all is suspect," seems like knowledge is what's being hammered on these days by propaganda. IIRC a kid was arrested for using DOS / a shell on his school computer (can't find the link, sorry)
- smosher_ 12y agoI got yelled at by a teacher for this in the '90s. I used the command line to access things that weren't presented in the login shell's menu. Since the system had permissions which explicitly granted me the right to access other programs I didn't think anything of it... but he thought differently and accused me of hacking.
- grrowl 12y agoWe had a similar outbreak of NETSEND at my high school. A couple of kids were suspended (for sending bad things) but the chorus of kids explaining how easy it was to send anonymous messages to the entire school caused them to actually secure the computers.
- esoteric_wombat 12y agoIt's at the bottom of the article, but I think it's worth noting that Jon Peterson does some impressive work for role playing game historical documentation. His book Playing at the World is a labor of love, giving not only a detailed history of the early days of wargames and tabletop rpgs, but a history of the science fiction and fantasy genres, a history of games in general, and how those lead to the creation of modern rpgs. He then wraps things up with a chapter on how tabletop gaming influenced the star of the video game industry. The scope is huge, the book is giant, and he published it under his own imprint so that no one could tell him to cut things. I found the section on Kriegsspiel particularly interesting. Highly recommended if you're an enthusiast for the subject, otherwise you'd probably get very frustrated.
- aphrax 12y agoHad no idea Legion of Doom were connected to GURPS. Good read.
- loydb 12y agoLOD is even thanked in the book credits.
- zyxley 12y ago> The raid couldn’t have come at a worse time for Steve Jackson Games. Already in debt, the company depended heavily on new releases for cash flow, and the confiscation of the GURPS Cyberpunk manuscript would significantly delay the book’s release. On March 9, the company let go eight people from its staff of seventeen. Since the Secret Service did not immediately return the manuscript, the team frantically reconstructed it from earlier draft materials and hurried it into print. The other moral the story: always keep an off-site backup.
- spacemanmatt 12y agoIt was far more difficult in the early 90s.
- zyxley 12y agoI imagine that even clumsy methods of doing so would have been cheaper than the turmoil that goes with having to fire half your staff.
- spacemanmatt 12y agoHindsight = 20/20, eh?
- loydb 12y agoWe thought three copies in two separate locations was backup enough. All three of the computers (my home system, my work system, and the Illuminati BBS) were seized.
- e12e 12y agoIf the innocent material you have suddenly becomes subject to search-and-seizure by the Secret Service, off-site backup would likely be targeted as well. Keeping a copy might even be a felony even if it turns out the data was innocent (obstructing an investigation/operation etc).
- delinka 12y ago
- njharman 12y agoI remember this from when it happened. The SJG raid and sun devil made me join the eff. At the time it looked like we needed help defending against the war on information.
- marincounty 12y agoThere are degrees of Black hat hacking. Let's not make the laws so serve most Americans don't even think about ways to penetrate a system? While other countries, like Russia, and China--seem to encourage their citizens to become better black hat Hackers? Russian Hackers seem pretty efficient, and we can't touch them. prosecutorial laws should be not so heavy handed. A Prosecuter should not be able to stack charge after charge against a black hat Hacker(like Arron Schwartz)--to the point where he commits suicide. Or, make Black Hat Hackers so angry with their government they turn their backs if asked to help? Crimes--even computer crimes are not black and white; neither should the punishment be one big blow in order to send a message. When other countries become better Hackers than Americans and take over critical infrastructure; I picture some Gsometing government employee scouring Google trying to figure out exactly what the Russians and Chinese have done to our servers? Or worse, hiring some slick security outfit who claims they know how to fix the intrusion? (No wonder Hackers keep Obama up at night? I don't think he was referring to American Hackers either?)