7 ms·
Miles per Gallon
- markild 12y agoThe illustration at the bottom of this[0] xkcd "what if?" illustrates this pretty well. [0]: http://what-if.xkcd.com/11/ http://what-if.xkcd.com/11/
- ColinWright 12y agoYes, I've been meaning to add that link at the bottom of the page with a short piece of text for context - I'll do that soon. Thanks. Edit: Done that now. Not sure why this comment got a downvote, though. Extra Edit: Hmm, now been re-upvoted. Bizarre, but thanks for the votes! I know that they're not actually worth anything, but they do indicate that what I've done is appreciated, and considered to be of value.
- markild 12y agoWith or without illustration, really enjoyed the write up. Also fun to think about what would happen if you plot the value that is represented by the "mm^2" over time, and do an integration of the plotted graph. You somehow end up with a volume, or total fuel consumption over the period you integrate over. Unit cancellation is cool stuff.
- ibmthrowaway271 12y agoVote cancellation is weird. I wonder if posts that have no genuine reason to be downvoted (like yours) get more votes if they add a comment to the effect "Not sure why this comment got a downvote" since multiple people will try and correct the erroneous downvote with no idea whether anyone else already has. Edit: Ha! Thanks for the downvote.
- ColinWright 12y agoIt is odd. When there's a strange downvote people might then make more upvotes because they can see it was downvoted, but can't see when it's been corrected, because the scores are no longer visible. But voting is weird anyway. I don't take it personally, and I don't want to complain, but I genuinely get confused when there are downvotes I don't understand, and I want explanations purely so I can decide either that I was right and to hell with it, or I was wrong and I need to reconsider things. With just a downvote I don't get the chance to learn. Still, there we are.
- Svenstaro 12y agoConversely, if people could just upvote outright but to downvote would need to provide a minimum 10 character reason that was made public, would this break of improve the system?
- guelo 12y agoSo each bad comment would require a large comment thread? Seems like the opposite of what you'd want.
- Dylan16807 12y agoIt could be displayed much more compactly, or not displayed at all to third parties.
- ibmthrowaway271 12y agoA way to give feedback to the poster on inconsequential details such as language/spelling/typos/grammar/etc that isn't displayed to anyone else would be useful.
- QuercusMax 12y agoYou're describing something like Slashdot's moderation system, and we all know how well that worked out.
- ZeroGravitas 12y agoIt's very easy to downvote comments by mistake when trying to upvote them on mobile. Shortly after posting just one mistake can make people feel they've done something wrong but it usually sorts itself out over time.
- Khao 12y agoThanks for that! Not being a native English speaker I couldn't really grasp what the author was trying to describe when he started talking about a "trough with a cross-sectional area of 0.1 mm2" and the following paragraph. This image made everything clear!
- unwind 12y agoThis is probably the kind of trough that's meant: http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Watering_trough http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Watering_trough, detailed image: http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Watering_trough#/media/File:Cattle_trough.jpg http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Watering_trough#/media/File:Cat.... If you "think away" the actual trough and keep only the liquid, you get the cuboid that the text is referring to.
- kalleboo 12y agoThe kind of trough imagined in the article is actually precedented - although to replenish water and not fuel http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Track_pan http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Track_pan
- mdellabitta 12y agoOf course, you'd probably do a little better than that, because at no point would your car be carrying all of that gas. But the trough would have to get wider when you went uphill or had to get going at a light.
- DougBTX 12y agoInstead of scooping up the fuel, you could think of it as laying out the fuel in a line behind the car. All the fuel starts off in the fuel tank, and slowly drains out of the car. Fuel efficiency is how large the hole is that the fuel drains out of. In reality, it gets turned into a gas and blows away, but the effect is much the same.
- maxerickson 12y agoThe environmental concerns with having fuel evaporating everywhere would be the first practical problem you would want to solve. (a small working reservoir handily solves the problem of needing more fuel at some moments.)
- brudgers 12y agoNot really, fuel consumption as an input takes carrying or not carrying fuel into account...same as wind resistance of the pickup or the friction of it moving through a trough of liquid or the force of the liquid moving into the void behind the pickup, etc.
- Serow225 12y agoAs a car nut, this actually seems pretty reasonable; if you take that diameter and divide it by (fuel injector duty cycle at cruise rpm, times number of injectors), the resulting diameter should be pretty close to the car's injector outlet effective diameter!
- deleted 12y ago[deleted]
- valarauca1 12y agoHi, I actually work in fuel system analysis. The one issue with the blog post that nobody seems to realize or point out. Is that fuel consumption is measured, and calculated internally as kilograms per kilometer. The change to volumetric units is done for the benefit of the population. This comes into play because namely, thermal expansion. Normally even in return less engines fuel is used to cool injector heads, as well as some body block parts (depending on engine design), as hotter fuel more readily reacts, and is already being routed to the warmed parts of the engine.
- raldi 12y agoThat seems like a coincidence, that the relative velocity between the car and the fuel shooting through its injector should be approximately the same as the relative velocity between the car and the road. One could conceivably build a car with half-size injector nozzles that squirt in the same volume of fuel per unit time.
- mark-r 12y agoYou could do even better if the tube were carrying electricity instead of gas. Maybe it would have enough power to carry a whole bunch of people at once? Hey, I think I'm on to something!
- pcarolan 12y agoAgreed, the south shore chicago trains have feelers to harvest electricity as they go. Maybe a Tesla with a whisker on top could go indefinitely on long stretches of highway.
- ableal 12y ago;-) http://commons.wikimedia.org/wiki/File:Wheeler_Dealer_Bumper_Cars.JPG http://commons.wikimedia.org/wiki/File:Wheeler_Dealer_Bumper...
- ableal 12y ago(0.1 mm^2 is half the cross-section of AWG 24, getting close to hair thin.) I don't think you're correct here. For round numbers, let's take a 100 kW engine (134 hp), and suppose we feed 100 V. At full power, we'd be running 1000 Amps down that wire. Even at 1 kV it would take 100 A. Better get a superconductor. Or a much thicker power cable.
- pdx 12y agoHe was using the wire AWG as a way to visualize the size for those of us that are familiar with human hair, but unfamiliar with visualizing things that are fractions of a mm thick. He was not saying anything about replacing the amazing energy density of gasoline with electricity over a copper wire.
- kitd 12y agoHow about a pressure differential? https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Atmospheric_railway https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Atmospheric_railway Cross-section of pipe = available power
- ableal 12y agoUsing liters/100 km, it's a tad easier, we just have to get the orders of magnitude right - liter = (100 mm)^3 = 1e6 mm^3 - 100 km = 1e8 mm So, 10L/100 km is 0.1 mm^2. (Note that we want low values, and this is on the high side for European cars - the usual advertised numbers for sedans are half of that, with reality somewhere in between.)
- rm999 12y agoFor comparison, what would be the radius of a continuous cylindrical battery that powers the Tesla Model S? Assume, perhaps, that the battery has the same energy density as a typical AA battery.
- TheLoneWolfling 12y agoThe Model S has an EPA rating of ~237.5 Wh/km. I also see that the Model S has a volumetric energy density of ~700Wh/l. Cancelling, I get ~0.34 mm^2. Another question would be the mass per unit length. At 250 Wh/kg, that works out to ~0.95g/m. For comparison, the 30mpg car works out to ~0.057g/m.
- samolang 12y agoHow big of a solar panel would you have to stick on top of an electric car to keep it going forever (ignoring the extra weight/wind resistance)?
- QuercusMax 12y agoI suppose it depends on your definition of "car", but they've been doing this for many years in the World Solar Challenge. GM's Sunraycer drove across Australia in 1987 on solar power alone: http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Sunraycer http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Sunraycer.
- samolang 12y agoYeah, I meant more like a Tesla or Chevy Volt.
- maxerickson 12y agoIt becomes important to decide how much it weighs and how fast you want to go (and if it has to work at night in Alaska...).
- Meredith023 12y agoI think 2*4 will do the job just fine but you may want to check with the folks at http://www.onlysolars.com/ http://www.onlysolars.com/ for this.
- userbinator 12y agoIncidentally, the volume of air required to ideally burn a litre of gasoline is also quite large. http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Gasoline#Energy_content http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Gasoline#Energy_content 1 kg of fuel reacts with 3.51 kg of oxygen to produce 3.09 kg of carbon dioxide and 1.42 kg of water Scaling that to the standard density of 0.755kg/L, that means 2.65kg of oxygen for 1L of gasoline. Assuming the typical 20% oxygen content of air at standard temperature and pressure, that is over 9000L of air. So the air consumption of a car with fuel consumption of 0.1mm^2 is 0.0009m^2 or 900mm^2. Edit: 900mm^2, not 900000.
- lmilcin 12y agoIf one needs 9000L of air to burn 1L of fuel, that would be 9000(0.1mm^2) not (90000.1mm)^2. 900mm^2 is much saner don't you think. I doubt the car would be able to scoop 900000mm^2 as it is 0,9m2. Can you imagine that amount of air fed into engine? Me neither.
- userbinator 12y agoYes, you're right - I somehow thought 1L was 1m^3, when it should be 1L = 0.001m^3.
- hso9791 12y agoIt's not a strange assumption to make, given how the prefix system works for true SI units. The litre/liter is defined as a decimeter cubed, or 0,1 m^3. It is a metric unit, but not SI. Still, it is allowed within the SI system...
- perakojotgenije 12y agoI will never understand why Americans keep using miles per gallon instead of liters per 100 km. Miles per gallon is only good if you want to advertise your car ("look, with this car you can travel 50 miles with one gallon whereas with that one you can only travel 40 miles"). But you never do that in real life, you never fill your car with say, two gallons and say "now I'll travel 80 miles". Instead you always know the distance between two points and you want to know how much will that travel cost you. So you think like this: "distance from point A to point B is 250km, my car uses 6 liters per 100 km so I'll use 15 liters, 1 liter price is 2€ so it'll cost me 30€". Easy as pie and you can't do that with miles per gallon.
- sdrothrock 12y ago> So you think like this: "distance from point A to point B is 250 miles, my car gets 25 miles to the gallon, so I'll use 10 gallons, 1 gallon price is $3.00 so it'll cost me $30.00". Easy as pie. That's why. It's exactly the same thing you're talking about.
- obsurveyor 12y agoYeah, it's the same mental arithmetic. These arguments just don't make sense for making some kind of change.
- sukilot 12y agoNice cherrypick for that pie. And if your car gets 18 or 27 mpg, on a 230 mile trip? Multiplication is generally easier than division.
- maxerickson 12y ago270-30 -> 9 gallons. Real answer, 8.52 gallons. 230 / 20 -> 11.5 gallons. Real answer, 12.2 gallons (and I would know to fudge up). So it is still easy to estimate to within $5.
- perakojotgenije 12y agoBecause it's easier for an average person to multiply than to divide.
- logfromblammo 12y agoIf you start with mass per distance (kg/km), and you divide by fuel density (mass per volume, kg/L or g/mL), you get area (ca or m^2). If you start with distance per volume (km/L) and cancel the matching units, you get inverse area (ca^-1 or m^-2). This doesn't make sense until you realize it is the conversion factor between volumetric flow rate and volumetric flux, and is the number you need to associate volumetric fuel consumption rate (volume per time) with speed (distance per time), which is exactly what you're doing when you think of the fuel supply as a continuous trough. This is a simplification. Different vehicle speeds will be more or less efficient. Volumetric flow rate is an integral of the volumetric flux over an area. So the area is the average aperture size. If your vehicle had a mass-ignoring, initially-empty reserve tank of infinite size, scooping up fuel from an infinitely long trough with the specified cross sectional area, it could go an infinite distance. You need the tank because different speeds may require more or less fuel flux. You need to travel at a more efficient speed before you can go to a less efficient speed.
- bariumbitmap 12y agoThis kind of calculation is trivial with GNU units: You have: 30 mpg You want: 1/(mm^2) * 12.754311 / 0.078404861 It does reciprocal conversion automatically (12.75 mm^-2 corresponds to 0.0784 mm^2). Note also that there are approximately 3.785 liters in a gallon, not 4.5461 as stated in the original article.
- ColinWright 12y ago... there are approximately 3.785 liters in a gallon, not 4.5461 as stated in the original article. Not if you're in Europe. Which I am.
- bariumbitmap 12y agoApologies for my US-centric calculations!
- dragonwriter 12y ago> Note also that there are approximately 3.785 liters in a gallon, not 4.5461 as stated in the original article. "gallon" is a unit of volume in several systems of measures, most notably the US Customary system and the Imperial system (these systems are often incorrectly conflated because many of the units are the same, and where the units are different many of the names are still the same.) The size of the gallon is not the same in those systems: 3.785 l/gal(US) 4.5461 l/gal(Imperial)
- bariumbitmap 12y agoThanks, that makes a lot more sense. You have: 30 miles/imperialgallon You want: 1/(mm^2) * 10.620186 / 0.094160312
- deleted 12y ago[deleted]