3 ms·
There's a difference between a 5 min leisure drive and a rush to a hot spot or surge location (such as a sports game that's about to end) to pick up a passenger
by prostoalex 12y ago
There's a difference between a 5 min leisure drive and a rush to a hot spot or surge location (such as a sports game that's about to end) to pick up a passenger, because of the driver incentives. Insurance companies are very aware of this, and this causes the price premium between personal and commercial insurance.
As somebody above pointed out, such accident already happened http://m.sfgate.com/news/article/Family-of-SF-girl-killed-by-Uber-driver-backs-5579980.php http://m.sfgate.com/news/article/Family-of-SF-girl-killed-by... although I don't know if it carries any statistical significance when you count all the Uber rides in SF.
- Dylan16807 12y agoIf you're rushing to pick up a passenger you have insurance from Uber. (I looked that up to make sure after making the above comment.) Rushing to a hot spot seems like a flawed argument, you can do that while totally off the grid. App closed, phone off. That's probably going to get you more money, too. You could have four of these apps open at once, do you need quadruple insurance? The app requires no interaction, and you perform no actions for the app until it notifies you about a pickup and Uber's insurance kicks in.
- prostoalex 12y agoIf the purpose of rushing is to engage in commercial activity, I could see how insurance companies would claim that it constitutes commercial activity by itself. It just seems like a higher risk profile. > Rushing to a hot spot seems like a flawed argument, you can do that while totally off the grid. Maybe my original example was misleading, but Uber app points an idle driver towards the areas of increased demand (and surge pricing) by color-coding them http://disinfo.s3.amazonaws.com/wp-content/uploads/2014/12/surge_pricing_lead.jpg http://disinfo.s3.amazonaws.com/wp-content/uploads/2014/12/s... > App closed, phone off. This part I agree with, if the driver has arrived at a pick up point due to inside knowledge of relevant details, and was not guided there by the app, it's a personal ride. I think any time the app is open, though, you can make a reasonable argument that the driver is guided where to go. However, in the US it only matters what the judge/jury says if/when such case hits the court.