5 ms·
No basic income scheme is viable unless the economy that implements it already produces 100% of the basic living consumables required by the populace. It is no
by logfromblammo 12y ago
No basic income scheme is viable unless the economy that implements it already produces 100% of the basic living consumables required by the populace. It is not a wealth redistribution--more like a production capacity redistribution.
Naively attempting to do that using currency manipulation as your only tool seems doomed to failure, in my opinion.
I don't care to argue for or against basic income at the moment, but presuming that it is to be implemented, the task cannot be accomplished with an alternate currency. I think that ultimately, it will be necessary to threaten highly productive owners of capital with the use of force unless they meet some portion of the consumption requirements of non-working individuals.
The producers would be taxed, at a cruelly high rate, such that if they sold a product that is both appealing and affordable for the people on basic income, they would break even on a cashflow basis, only losing some use of their productive capacity. For some made-up, spewed-out numbers, Apple is taxed $1G on the sale of 4 million of its fully-featured iPhones, at $250 cost and $750 retail--effectively taxing 50% of the profits--and recoups $1G in revenue from selling 20 million "Nekhama iPhones" (Nekkhamma is a Buddhist term) that cost $25 to make, and sell at $75. Maybe it's just the same guts as an iPhone 1, using a smaller chip feature size. Or they could just tell that $1G to go piss off, and less prestigious manufacturers pick up the slack in the basic market. Obviously, sales in the basic market could not trigger the onerous taxes, or the scheme wouldn't work.
- nosuchthing 12y agoBasic income could work as a segregated portion of the economy for basic essentials. Food, shelter, transportation, and hygienic items. Some combination of a tax on luxury goods and services, low income housing, and regulation on food production might be one way to offset the resources required to sustain the basic income output. The scenario of thousands of citizens living purely on basic income in free housing projects should also be considered. What is the minimum level of contribution we require from citizens in return for the minimum level of support that the State provides? In some countries, it's required to do a year or so of public service though the equivalent of peace corps. It seems fair to ask for a minimum level of work contributing back to society in exchange for society providing a minimum level of life support.
- yungchin 12y ago> It seems fair to ask for a minimum level of work contributing back to society I think BI proponents argue that specifying what counts as a contribution leads to economic inefficiencies, in the broadest sense. Does taking care of your own children count as a contribution? Or sitting in the pub and making other visitors happy by your presence? What about writing software and putting it on Github? And for the latter, should you get a minimum number of stars to make it count? How long should the list of "useful activities" be, that the Department of Civil Contributions would maintain? And how much money would we spend on civil servants who determine whether your edge case qualifies? The result would be that people end up doing artificially much of what counts as "contributing", and too little of some things that aren't specified as "contributing", but that society actually still benefits from. Would some people just sit on the couch all day, and really contribute nothing, by any standard? Yes, probably. So the premise here is that the number of true freeloaders is small enough, that it would be inefficient to worry about them. I personally don't know any true freeloaders, which leads me to think that that's probably a fair assumption.
- nosuchthing 12y agoI imagine to appease anyone with doubt to the benefits of basic income some sort of "basic work credits" type system would need to be in place for anyone without a normal job to contribute something noteworthy back to society. The matter of what is acceptable as "basic work" may already be in place as court ordered community services, peace corps, or local public works projects. Maybe even a new variation of non-profit organization [1] that has specific structural rules for "basic work" credits? [1] http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/501%28c%29_organization http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/501%28c%29_organization
- saraid216 12y agoIt's a noble attempt at compromise, but at that point, you're not talking about UBI anymore. The entire point of UBI is a rejection of the notion that a person must contribute before they have permission to live. It's a statement that the right to life is inherent to every individual, details on the morality of suicide or abortion aside, and that if we can't simply provide those necessities, then we can at least provide the means to get them through guaranteed income. Basic Income is, by itself, already a compromise. To compromise again is to no longer be a separate concept. At the point you're talking about, it's not actually different from the situation as it stands now: what you're really saying is that the minimum wage needs to be sufficient for living expenses. Nothing more.
- patcon 12y ago> No basic income scheme is viable unless the economy that implements it already produces 100% of the basic living consumables required by the populace. Maybe my thinking is off, but isn't that the sort of capacity the "group fund" could go toward building?