8 ms·
Basic income as proposed at the societal scale is essentially a wealth redistribution scheme, which implies that there is some concrete actual value removed fro
by jerf 12y ago
Basic income as proposed at the societal scale is essentially a wealth redistribution scheme, which implies that there is some concrete actual value removed from somebody and given to somebody else. Using a cryptocurrency to provide basic income would manifest simply as the creation of currency, with no actual value being created to correspond to the new currency, so it's just going to be inflationary. I don't see any proposals on the linked page on how to overcome that, links welcome if there are, nor does anything leap to mind to solve this problem in a sensible way.
(This has nothing to do with whether basic income is a good idea or not; the point is that this does not appear to actually be basic income except at an extremely superficial level. Nor is my calling it a "wealth redistribution" scheme intended to be a criticism. I'll admit to being extremely skeptical about basic income, but that is what it is, just like EITC. Whether redistribution is a good idea is a separate discussion I'm not trying to have here.)
- chipsy 12y agoWhat this scheme does is create equitable inflation. That is, I concur, not identical to BI. However, inflation does come with redistributive effects. In most macroeconomic models, the question of "who makes the money" is abstracted into "the banks make it and lend it to everyone." That means that money has to start in the investment sphere - the expected impact on individuals is to experience cheaper debt and higher wages and prices - a sort of "regression to the mean" in their financial status. But in a situation like the post-GFC markets, investment tends to slosh around in financial instruments without reaching Main Street in any meaningful way - the money isn't turned into capex or wages. This is the kind of thing that is smoothed out when the inflation is reformulated as a benefit. Individuals still experience the regression to the mean, but it happens instantaneously, on a predictable schedule.
- jsprogrammer 12y agoMost likely, it's just an impedance mismatch between current models and reality. Institutions and individuals with access to money taps will find ways to divert some of the flows towards their benefit while ignoring all of the downstream effects.
- harperlee 12y agoCould we create a system where inflation would hit harder on the one that had the most money? That way, rich people would be enticed to move their money, and invest in risky plays. Some of them would grow very rich, others would lose a lot of money, but, on the end, they would end up reducing their income...
- ejlo 12y agoThe tool for that is demurrage, http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Demurrage_%28currency%29 http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Demurrage_%28currency%29, which adds devaluation of the currency over time. This complements Basic Income very well, with UBI for money creation and demurrage for money destruction. For physical currency is has some obvious practical problems, which has prevent adoption, but for virtual currencies it is easy to implement.
- harperlee 12y agoWell sorry, I did not explain myself properly: my idea was that, if every coin could be associated with a specific person, rich people's coins might devalue quicker than poor people's coins. It's a weird idea and giving it a little more thought, I don't see how could a state enforce such a system effectively, though.
- tlarkworthy 12y agovariable Sales tax/VAT pegged to credit card and linked to SSN/NI Cash purchases would be problematic. Maybe drawing out cash incurs the variable tax too?
- itistoday2 12y ago> Using a cryptocurrency to provide basic income would manifest simply as the creation of currency, with no actual value being created to correspond to the new currency, so it's just going to be inflationary. CryptoUBIs/group currencies can be deflationary. Have a look at the first item in the FAQ [1]. If the value represented by AcademicCoin is increasing faster than the issuance of tokens, AcademicCoin becomes deflationary. [1] http://groupcurrency.org/#FAQ http://groupcurrency.org/#FAQ Disclaimer: I am a co-author of the document.
- jasode 12y agoYour FAQ says: >Provide others with a token that represents the group's value and potential as human beings. That is already non-zero (researchers are very valuable!). If that's the logic, you can do that today without any cryptocurrency. Take a blank sheet of paper and write, "the bearer of this note acknowledges my value & potential as a human being." Go and take that paper out on the street and see if you can trade it for other pieces of paper such as Euros, US Dollars, or real goods such as hamburgers. If your experiment works, everyone can have "basic income" just by writing affirmations on sheets of paper and trading them. I'm not being flippant with my example. Warren Buffet can take a piece of paper and write, "the bearer of this note is entitled to a 1 hour lunch with me." Someone could take that note and sell it on ebay for over $1000. (A similar type of transaction happens everyday with celebrity autographs.) There's a reason why Warren Buffet's piece of paper (scrip, IOU, whatever) is more valuable than your piece of paper or my piece of paper. Cryptocurrency doesn't solve that. Basic income is also not something that can be solved by cryptocurrency.
- deleted 12y ago[deleted]
- Eliezer 12y agoIf you understand jasode's objection, it is not apparent from this reply.
- 12y ago
- zkhalique 12y agoWhat's wrong with wealth redistribution? Money is essentially a man-made concept anyway. We want to keep people alive, so this constraint is very well captured by giving a basic income to everyone, a social safety net. Libertarian free market economics don't capture these constraints.
- bduerst 12y agoHypothetically, some form of wealth redistribution is necessary in a democratic society, otherwise the poor will vote to take the wealth for themselves.
- mod 12y agoI would say that hypothetically, no form is needed because the poor won't vote to take from others. In reality, though, it seems the poor will vote as much of it for themselves as they reasonably can. It's happening piecemeal here (in America).
- Sir_Substance 12y agoThey're doing an incredibly shitty job of it then. It would be more accurate to say the rich are voting just enough to the poor to prevent widespread active looting.
- bduerst 12y agoIn reality, the exact opposite is happening. In the U.S., wealth concentration is growing with the top 0.1%.
- r00fus 12y agoThat, or as we're seeing today, the wealthy and corporations coopt all the discussion and essentially buy votes with "campaign financing".
- Frondo 12y agoTo put it bluntly, no, the poor don't vote to redistribute--that's why they're still poor. It's the rich who've made it a practice and habit to grab whatever they can, whenever they can; excepting those who were merely born rich, that's why the rich are rich.
- logfromblammo 12y agoNo basic income scheme is viable unless the economy that implements it already produces 100% of the basic living consumables required by the populace. It is not a wealth redistribution--more like a production capacity redistribution. Naively attempting to do that using currency manipulation as your only tool seems doomed to failure, in my opinion. I don't care to argue for or against basic income at the moment, but presuming that it is to be implemented, the task cannot be accomplished with an alternate currency. I think that ultimately, it will be necessary to threaten highly productive owners of capital with the use of force unless they meet some portion of the consumption requirements of non-working individuals. The producers would be taxed, at a cruelly high rate, such that if they sold a product that is both appealing and affordable for the people on basic income, they would break even on a cashflow basis, only losing some use of their productive capacity. For some made-up, spewed-out numbers, Apple is taxed $1G on the sale of 4 million of its fully-featured iPhones, at $250 cost and $750 retail--effectively taxing 50% of the profits--and recoups $1G in revenue from selling 20 million "Nekhama iPhones" (Nekkhamma is a Buddhist term) that cost $25 to make, and sell at $75. Maybe it's just the same guts as an iPhone 1, using a smaller chip feature size. Or they could just tell that $1G to go piss off, and less prestigious manufacturers pick up the slack in the basic market. Obviously, sales in the basic market could not trigger the onerous taxes, or the scheme wouldn't work.
- nosuchthing 12y agoBasic income could work as a segregated portion of the economy for basic essentials. Food, shelter, transportation, and hygienic items. Some combination of a tax on luxury goods and services, low income housing, and regulation on food production might be one way to offset the resources required to sustain the basic income output. The scenario of thousands of citizens living purely on basic income in free housing projects should also be considered. What is the minimum level of contribution we require from citizens in return for the minimum level of support that the State provides? In some countries, it's required to do a year or so of public service though the equivalent of peace corps. It seems fair to ask for a minimum level of work contributing back to society in exchange for society providing a minimum level of life support.
- jsprogrammer 12y agoWhere does the 'redistribution' come from? From what I can tell the currency is created at an agreed on rate proportional to the pre-existing arbitrary community that is participating in the currency. There is no 'previous wealth' that you can bring into the scheme, so there is no redistribution going on. The real fallacy is believing that wealth is a concrete entity.
- olalonde 12y agoI'm a bit late to the topic but it seems to me that equitable inflation does result in some sort of "wealth redistribution". I know it's a little bit extreme but let's assume there are 3 people in the economy who respectively own 1, 1 and 100 units of currency. The person with 100 units is 50 times richer than the other two combined. However, if the inflation is set at 1000 units, after one cycle of inflation, the amounts are 1001, 1001 and 1100. The person who started out with 100 units is now poorer than the other two combined and only slightly richer than them individually.
- madawan 12y agoInflation is usually a percentage though.
- olalonde 12y agoI don't think this contradicts the point I was making though. If inflation was set at 50%, the total amount to redistribute would be (100+1+1 * 0.5) 51 units and each person would get and additional (51 * 1/3) 17 units. So the amounts after the first inflation cycle would be 18, 18, 117. The richest person, who was 100 times richer than the poorest before inflation, is now only 6.5 times richer. Do this a couple of times and the relative difference between the amounts become smaller and smaller.