6 ms·
Uber leaves Kansas after lawmakers demand background checks and more insurance
- cantankerous 12y agoUber has been having similar regulatory fights in Kansas City, which recently passed ordinances that Uber claimed would make it prohibitive to do business there (http://goo.gl/cXlhzb http://goo.gl/cXlhzb). Uber made claims that "thousands of jobs" would be lost in the move, despite the fact that its competitors (Lyft, etc.) would abide by the new rules and continue to operate. It seems a little silly to talk about the jobs of your contractors as being "lost" when they can walk over to your competitor and work almost seamlessly. Uber pulling out of Kansas makes half of the KC metro area impossible to work in. I'm curious if this will have a major impact on Uber's future in the entire city.
- iamdave 12y agoUber made claims that "thousands of jobs" would be lost in the move I've got a lot of reservations about calling Uber/Lyft a "job" in the first place; in fact I have a lot of problems with these "sharing economy" apps-calling them jobs when really you're just subcontracting labor on the cheap while the business side collects massive investments and benefits for the full-time employees. It's like when you drive by a Dominos Pizza {substitute with the chain of your choice} and they have signs "make $15/hr"; you'll maybe make $15/hr on an incredibly busy day or a sudden surge in ride requests, but what's the mean? Is $15/hr the mean? If not, you don't get to advertise "make $15/hr". I said it once at the start of all of these talks two years ago: It's becoming increasingly apparent to me that "disruption" in so many startups more recently means less "disruption with the goals of bringing about much needed substantive change to local regulation" and more like "give my company special treatment to operate". And it's a hard pill for cities to wave off when the population centers are all clamoring for an alternative to taxis. okay I'm done ninja editing.
- cantankerous 12y agoI think I agree with you, but I'm hesitant to to slight somebody for how they making an honest living. All "jobs" aren't created equal, especially of many jobs are contracted or low paying without benefits. It's unfortunate that this kind of (presumably it's political in origin) rhetoric has colored our reality as it has.
- hn_user2 12y agoEspecially because they argue that they are not a taxi company because they are doing "ride sharing". Well are you ride sharing or are you a limousine service with jobs on the line?
- FireBeyond 12y agoFunny you mention that, given Uber was forced to roll back its claims that you could easily make $90K a year as an Uber driver... (http://www.huffingtonpost.com/2014/12/04/uber-driver_n_6249608.html http://www.huffingtonpost.com/2014/12/04/uber-driver_n_62496... amongst many others).
- cantankerous 12y agoAlso, here's a video of Kansas City's mayor, Sly James, speaking about the frustration of these negotations from his side of things prior to the vote. https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=fHjJUJW0Jt4 https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=fHjJUJW0Jt4
- halviti 12y agoI hope this has a big impact on Uber even outside of Kansas. I think any customer would prefer background checks for drivers. Being defiant against them is just bad PR. Background checks cost $20, or if you go through a channeler because you want your results in a couple days, you can pay $50.. This is a tiny price to pay for the safety of thousands of passengers, not to mention it wouldn't cost them anything, as they could defer the cost to the drivers as a part of the application process. Trying to skimp out on insurance also goes further to show a wanton disregard for passenger safety.
- deleted 12y ago[deleted]
- tigeba 12y agoKansas City, MO and Uber have worked out their differences. I believe Uber will provide background check info to the city about their drivers, and pay a flat fee to cover all their drivers in the city. http://www.bizjournals.com/kansascity/news/2015/04/23/kansas-city-reaches-compromise-with-uber.html http://www.bizjournals.com/kansascity/news/2015/04/23/kansas...
- cantankerous 12y agoGood catch! I haven't been back recently and hadn't checked the news. I'm still waiting for the state legislators to prohibit city regulation of ride sharing services. This may roll back the requirements at the city level. See: http://goo.gl/7MIZFP http://goo.gl/7MIZFP
- meritt 12y agoDoes anyone have details on the associated costs involved for Uber and/or the drivers? I can't imagine background checks being very excessive for the drivers, so maybe it's grossly expensive and miscategorized insurance? Uber + Lyft just relaunched here in Portland. Drivers are required to have valid business licenses and pass a background check too. Everyone is very happy with the changes. (except our local taxi commission, of course)
- prostoalex 12y agoSame in many European cities, where even UberX drivers have to have a "private driver" license. The requirements involve documented regular maintenance and insurance coverage that would include passengers, not sure what's the business logic behind opposing them.
- rmc 12y ago> not sure what's the business logic behind opposing them They want to have no costs to doing business, and to reap all the profits.
- prostoalex 12y agoI mean, the cost is already shifted to the drivers (who have to pay for license, submit maintenance paperwork and buy insurance) and taxpayers (who hire government clerks to review all that stuff). But I get what you're saying - at that point the profit opportunity diminishes somewhat. The upfront cost of it also discourages casual drivers who only planned to do some weekend work.
- cantankerous 12y agoGlad to hear they could reach a deal in Portland. The terms your describing is, I think, essentially the terms KC is asking for now. Uber is holding out that the Missouri legislature will override the city ordinance with regards to ride sharing. A likely proposition as Missouri's legislators are so readily influenced by those with money and love overriding home rule in the major cities.
- mahouse 12y agoHow despotic! Lawmakers demanding background checks and insurance from taxi drivers! This is outrageous. Where is muh freedom? I want to be able to hire a taxi with a rapist driver! http://www.houstonchronicle.com/news/transportation/article/Uber-driver-accused-of-rape-not-permitted-by-city-6182503.php http://www.houstonchronicle.com/news/transportation/article/...
- deleted 12y ago[deleted]
- dantheman 12y agoYeah, I mean it's like a background check will protect everyone: http://www.dailymail.co.uk/news/article-2937996/Woman-33-raped-robbed-driver-one-Bloomberg-s-Green-Cabs-designed-New-York-City-s-outer-boroughs.html http://www.dailymail.co.uk/news/article-2937996/Woman-33-rap...
- mahouse 12y agoA background check is obviously not bullet-proof, as it failed with "Esa Alusaimi", but it is so much better than nothing.
- jasonlotito 12y agoThat's like saying driving drunk shouldn't be illegal because you drove home safely that one time.
- istvan__ 12y agoJust wait till an NRA class lobby organization emerges and fixes it for everybody. :)
- Dylan16807 12y agoBackground checks aren't demanded for a thousand other jobs. An evil person could be hiding almost anywhere. What makes cabs special?
- 12y ago
- stegosaurus 12y agoAll of this nonsense about insurance and checks and blah makes me weep for humanity. If I can hitch hike legally, why can't I pay for the same service? Basically it seems to me that regulation has the effect of forcing lifestyles upon people. You can't just sell people things, you have to be a Thing Seller and devote yourself to that regulatory environment and then you can sell some of the people some of the things. Bonkers.
- raldi 12y agoWhen you hitchhike, the driver's insurance is in effect. And when you get out of the car, it's still in effect. With Uber, as soon as you get out of the car, it's possible that the driver suddenly has no insurance in effect, until the next passenger gets in.
- chinathrow 12y agoWell, in some locations you can't hitch legally. So there's that.
- Spooky23 12y agoThe difference is when you hitchhike, there is insurance coverage in effect. So when the driver slams into a tree and you get hurt, your care (which isn't covered by health insurance) is paid for by the auto insurer. When you aren't covered by insurance, society absorbs the costs of the $10,000+ ER visit, $500 ambulance trip, etc. Your family bears the burden of chronic medical issues and work loss, etc. The answer is simple. You pay a little more for commercial/livery coverage and your passengers are covered against perils. The background check thing is even easier. Do you want your wife picked up and driven around by a convicted rapist? For the want of Uber spending the massive sum of like $20?
- probably_wrong 12y agoPrecisely, because you don't pay the guy that gives you a lift when you hitchhike, but you do pay to an Uber driver. Once there's money involved, we are no longer talking about an agreement between gentlemen, but about a commercial transaction, and those require regulations because the incentives are different, and money does weird things to people. A driver maximizing profits has no incentive in, say, checking his brakes regularly (money spent + car immobilized for some time), while a random driver does ("yeah, I'll take a cab for a couple days, no biggie").
- GFK_of_xmaspast 12y agoGood riddance.
- discardorama 12y agoIf my recent experience is anything, Uber needs some serious regulation. I live in SF, and was flying out of OAK. I had used Uber only once before, a long time ago; but this time, I suggested to the wife that we use Uber again. We had to leave SF at 7:15AM - 7:30AM or so. Around 7:15 I pulled up the app, and saw that there were several cars around (as they usually are). I requested an UberX; punched in the destination. A driver quickly accepted, and Uber said he'd be there in < 5 minutes. A couple of minutes later, I get the notification that the driver cancelled. OK, I tried again. Same thing again: driver accepts, and then a minute or two later, cancels. This went on for 4-5 times. Now, time is getting tighter, and I have a large suitcase; and cabs don't come around in my alley. I tried Uber again, and this time Uber says: "Surge pricing in effect! Rates are 1.5X". I knew what was going on; but I had to accept out of desperation. What do you know? A driver quickly came over and we were on our way. The driver did say that some drivers may not have wanted to go to OAK because traffic back would have been bad. But here's the thing: a licensed cab cannot refuse to take you to your destination! Uber seems to be set up to take advantage of riders with their "surge pricing" scam. This experience left a bitter taste in my mouth, and I made sure I installed Lyft for the ride back.
- ardit33 12y agoIf you live in NYC, cabs always refuse people to go to Brooklyn/Queens/Unwanted destination, eve though it is illegal to do so. The usual excuse: I am going out of my shift, and can't go that way. (this can be legit, but often it is not). Next time don't enter your destination address, so the driver doesn't know where you go, and once you are in the car it is much harder for them to refuse you.
- tjdetwiler 12y agoLyft (as far as I know) won't show the driver your destination until the ride is started. It's intended to save time in allowing the driver to bring up directions and not as a decision point for them to decide if they want to take the ride or not.
- gecko 12y agoI have been living in NYC for ten years. I use cabs constantly. This has happened to be exactly one time. I'm not saying it doesn't happen, but I think the idea that this is common for NYC cabbies to do is really outdated.
- sagarm 12y agoThe point of contention here seems to be insurance: Uber already provides insurance that covers the driver while they are carrying passengers, but Kansas wants them to have commercial insurance that covers drivers 24/7.
- cozzyd 12y agoBusiness models that rely on skirting regulations affecting competitors are probably not sustainable.
- bsbechtel 12y agoTo me, this seems to speak volumes about the viability of Uber's business model in the long run. If they can't compete because additional background checks and insurance are needed, is it really a $40B company?
- ddingus 12y agoMy thought exactly. Or, they are mixing an agenda (low to no regulation) with business, choosing to leave a market rather than operate in it's rules.
- amyjess 12y agoIf this is the case, Uber is being either colossally stupid or both colossally stupid and colossally evil here. You see, big businesses actually love regulation. It raises the barrier to entry and prices smaller competitors out of the market. The only companies who don't like regulation are a) small businesses who risk being priced out of the market and b) monopolists or near-monopolists, who have no competitors left to price out of the market. For Uber to throw their hands up and walk out of a market over regulation means that either they think like a small player or they think like a monopolist. If it's the former... well, they're a $40B company, and they should start acting like one; it's a sign of terrible incompetence that a $40B company is acting like a "poor, oppressed mom-and-pop". If it's the latter, then they're just plain evil, and they should be stopped before they actually become a monopoly. They're also being stupid, too, because they're not a monopoly yet, and Lyft is now going to eat up the Kansas market.
- bsbechtel 12y agoYou make some great points, however I question how big the Kansas market really is. I'm from a 150,000 person city in the Midwest, and there might be 5 taxis operating in town. Kansas has a few bigger cities, but the demand for personal drivers in the Midwest isn't like it is on the coasts.
- ddingus 12y ago
- gambiting 12y ago"Kansas lawmakers want to make sure drivers have insurance that covers the times when a driver has no passengers — and is therefore not covered by business insurance — but is behind the wheel of their work vehicle — and is therefore not covered by personal insurance either." It's outrageous that there could even be a situation where someone is driving on the road but not covered by insurance. Looking at comments under the article, it's like people don't understand the implications of this.
- kaolinite 12y agoIt really is incredible how the opinion of Uber has dropped. I used to love Uber - and still do love the Uber service - but now I can't stand the company. I used to buy in to the whole corrupt taxi industry narrative, but now I feel like a fool for believing it (even if it was true at the beginning). It's a shame that there's no alternative, at least that I'm aware of, to UberEXEC/UberLUX. I feel like Uber could have been a great, albeit smaller, company had they concentrated on their upmarket service. Aiming to be cheaper than taxis is just a race to the bottom - but there are many people who are willing to pay more in exchange for a better experience.
- prostoalex 12y ago> It's a shame that there's no alternative, at least that I'm aware of, to UberEXEC/UberLUX. How about blacklane.com or limos.com? Both are aggregators for existing car services and allow you to specify a general class of cars.
- taco_emoji 12y agoHonestly I think 99% of the reason people use Uber and Lyft are the phone apps. If "real" cab companies had an app, I seriously doubt Uber and Lyft would've made such headway. (At least in most cities - I realize there's occasionally specific, localized issues with existing "real" cab companies.)
- greiskul 12y agoYes, in Brazil we have phone apps for calling regular taxis, and at least in the big cities, it's great. You end up with all the regulation that regular taxis have, plus the apps normally have a rating system, so drivers end up caring much more about the quality of the ride. Uber is having an extra hard time to compete here.
- gnopgnip 12y agoFlywheel has an app for sf.
- jroseattle 12y agoIt seems that government may have found a lever against a well-funded global operation that wants to do business in their jurisdiction. Get ready for updated regulations in many areas where Uber is doing business now.
- moey 12y agoI've got mixed feelings. At one end, I think it's perfectly reasonable for the state to require more insurance coverage for Uber drivers since there will be more risk involved than a regular driver. Background checks required by state? That's Uber's job to decide, and they do it anyway. If Uber doesn't do background checks, and there are incidents (even a small number) it will hurt their business at the end of the day. It's in their best interest to do the background checks in the manner they please. This is a weird situation where Uber doesn't want to "employ" it drivers and pay for w/e is needed for them to do business, but at the same time their drivers require them to provide them with everything to do their job and now their source of income (employer) left the state and them jobless. I wish we were provided with more details like how much this background check/insurance would cost. They already do both (Uber does a background & provides commercial insurance coverage) so honestly this half-written articles do nothing but make people even MORE confused on how Uber REALLY does business.
- edent 12y ago> If Uber doesn't do background checks, and there are incidents (even a small number) it will hurt their business at the end of the day. I really hate this mode of thinking. What's wrong with preventing incidents? A background check isn't going to weed out 100% of muggers, rapists, or Enron Executives - but it will likely reduce the number of muggings, rapings, and fraud. Your argument is basically "There's no need to inspect restaurants - if people die of food poisoning, the business will suffer." Well, yeah - but how about we take some simple precautions to stop people getting hurt?
- Dylan16807 12y ago>What's wrong with preventing incidents? Privacy issues and companies making hiring decisions on non-work-relevant personal life choices. Do you support background checks for all jobs? Nothing you said is specific to Uber. But there's a reason companies can't ask if you have children, etc.
- amyjess 12y ago
- Dirlewanger 12y agoAs if one need any more evidence as to what a shit-pile of a company this is. But the majority of this site's audience doesn't care. They don't need a car anymore! They're disrupting things and have a slick app!!!!
- Dylan16807 12y agoWell that's obnoxious that the insurance companies would play hot potato and not cover the 5 minute pickup windows. But how much is insurance for that period going to cost? Is Uber even going to notice the difference? Or is the problem that a 'work vehicle' is going to have no insurance the entire time it's being driven around? Even when it's not actually being used for Uber? Now that sounds unfair to make Uber pay for.
- prostoalex 12y agoThere's a difference between a 5 min leisure drive and a rush to a hot spot or surge location (such as a sports game that's about to end) to pick up a passenger, because of the driver incentives. Insurance companies are very aware of this, and this causes the price premium between personal and commercial insurance. As somebody above pointed out, such accident already happened http://m.sfgate.com/news/article/Family-of-SF-girl-killed-by-Uber-driver-backs-5579980.php http://m.sfgate.com/news/article/Family-of-SF-girl-killed-by... although I don't know if it carries any statistical significance when you count all the Uber rides in SF.
- Dylan16807 12y agoIf you're rushing to pick up a passenger you have insurance from Uber. (I looked that up to make sure after making the above comment.) Rushing to a hot spot seems like a flawed argument, you can do that while totally off the grid. App closed, phone off. That's probably going to get you more money, too. You could have four of these apps open at once, do you need quadruple insurance? The app requires no interaction, and you perform no actions for the app until it notifies you about a pickup and Uber's insurance kicks in.
- prostoalex 12y agoIf the purpose of rushing is to engage in commercial activity, I could see how insurance companies would claim that it constitutes commercial activity by itself. It just seems like a higher risk profile. > Rushing to a hot spot seems like a flawed argument, you can do that while totally off the grid. Maybe my original example was misleading, but Uber app points an idle driver towards the areas of increased demand (and surge pricing) by color-coding them http://disinfo.s3.amazonaws.com/wp-content/uploads/2014/12/surge_pricing_lead.jpg http://disinfo.s3.amazonaws.com/wp-content/uploads/2014/12/s... > App closed, phone off. This part I agree with, if the driver has arrived at a pick up point due to inside knowledge of relevant details, and was not guided there by the app, it's a personal ride. I think any time the app is open, though, you can make a reasonable argument that the driver is guided where to go. However, in the US it only matters what the judge/jury says if/when such case hits the court.
- Meiscooldude 12y agoI can't really say anything about this situation. But I can definitely attest to my current relationship with Uber, and my previous relationship with Kansas. I grew up in Kansas. Many times, the government attempted to teach me Intelligent Design and I was always given the option of opting out of being taught Evolution. Sodomy is still illegal for any non-strait married couple. While not enforced, it is still a Class C Misdemeanor. Just the to let everyone know the governments feelings on homosexual couples. Only 17 counties are allowed to have liquor stores, and there are 28 counties that are completely dry. (Dry counties have on average more drunk driving crashes compared to wet due to people driving further for a drink) Thanks to the DARE program there, I grew up thinking Marijuana was more dangerous and addictive than Meth or Cocaine. (Meth is a much bigger problem in Kansas) The legal system there is very much Guilty till proven innocent, they bully people into signing plea bargains. I can attest... Kansas is backwards. So, I left too.. to Colorado. Uber on the other hand, has been nothing but a blessing. Its fantastic. My girlfriend and I love it. Its cheaper than a cab here in Denver. Cheaper than driving (due to parking costs). My girlfriend and I have always felt safe. If you disagree with Uber. Go live in Kansas for 22 years and tell me the state isn't backwards.
- protomyth 12y ago"Kansas lawmakers want to make sure drivers have insurance that covers the times when a driver has no passengers — and is therefore not covered by business insurance — but is behind the wheel of their work vehicle — and is therefore not covered by personal insurance either." How is this a bad thing? So, in other states, drivers are not covered when they are driving to make a pickup?
- gnopgnip 12y agoIn San Francisco an uber driver killed a woman while in between rides and ubers insurance is refusing to pay out. http://m.sfgate.com/news/article/Family-of-SF-girl-killed-by-Uber-driver-backs-5579980.php http://m.sfgate.com/news/article/Family-of-SF-girl-killed-by...