4 ms·
Amazon drops gendered categories for toys
- taurath 12y agoIts still amazing how much we sort boys and girls based on gender and not interests.
- pauleastlund 12y agoPersonally I'm of a like mind and I consider this progress. I have a bunch of (smart, curious) daughters and I feel a real struggle against gender role orthodoxy when I'm trying to nurture their interests in legos and science and Tolkien and their friends are into American Girl dolls and Disney princesses. With that said, you can see why retailers would be slow to drop gender categorization. For people who aren't particularly progressive on this issue, Amazon just made shopping harder. For the average adult shopping for kids' toys, I bet the single most valuable bit of information to predicting their purchase is the gender of the recipient.
- voltagex_ 12y agoRetailers might be making more money selling gender-targeted products - particularly rebadged versions of the same products. https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=3JDmb_f3E2c https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=3JDmb_f3E2c
- xupybd 12y agoAlso if you are shopping for someone else's kids. If you don't know the kids interests it's a lot easier to look for toys of around that age and for the gender of the child. Sometimes its all the info you have.
- dragonwriter 12y ago> Also if you are shopping for someone else's kids. If you don't know the kids interests it's a lot easier to look for toys of around that age and for the gender of the child. If you are shopping for someone else's kids, how hard is it to talk (/text/email/etc.) to the parents about the kids interests?
- kps 12y ago> If you are shopping for someone else's kids, how hard is it to talk > (/text/email/etc.) to the parents about the kids interests? Or even talk to the kids about the kids' interests (with written permission from the parents and social services and in the presence of at least three independent board-certified chaperons, of course).
- pbhjpbhj 12y agoHow? There are kids in my child's class at school I've never met; I don't know their parents and in some cases there are never occasions where we share geographical location (their kids are picked up by carers). Schools don't give out the parents information; relaying contact details through children under about 8yo is impossible. Then what? Arrange to meet them at their home to talk to their child for 30s about what they want for their birthday (that's in my price range) - the whole process is costing more than the present at this point. Am I right in thinking you're not a parent? Asking a parent you know for ideas for a party present for a kid is quite reasonable, asking the child won't help unless it's a child you're close to and you're spending a considerable sum and I'd warrant know the child's personality pretty well.
- redorb 12y agoa bit harder than just having the filters.
- dragonwriter 12y ago> a bit harder than just having the filters. But, given that kids that don't conform to gender stereotypes of interests exist, probably infinitely more useful. Heck, even for kids that conform to gender stereotypes to the extent that all of their interests are within the scope expected for their gender, its still vastly more useful to get direct information from them or their parents about their interests, because its very rare that any kid's interests will be cover all of what is within the gender stereotype even if it is contained within the gender stereotype.
- craigvn 12y agoYou must be the worst shopper. It is not that hard.
- aikah 12y ago> You must be the worst shopper. You must really be an arse hole to feel the need to belittle people just because they disagree with you.
- mcv 12y agoBlindly relying on gender can lead to terrible presents. Plenty of girls do not like pink princesses, and plenty of boys do not like aggressive-looking action figures. Ask about their interests, or get something generic enough that it's going to be fun for everybody.
- JoeAltmaier 12y agoA ball, or a game, or a puzzle - all safe
- trose 12y agoMaybe we need to have girl-branded thought-provoking toys in the meantime to deal with parents that force these stereotypes on their children. Princess model rockets and Frozen science kits.
- jebblue 12y agoI doubt most parents force anything on kids these days least likely gender specific stuff. It's human nature, girls generally like girly stuff and boys like guy stuff and that's human nature and it is not ever going to change over the course of human history.
- deirdres 12y agoForcing adults who would automatically think "trucks for boys, dolls for girls" to think about their choices is, in itself, valuable. As a child I was given dolls because I was a girl. I had absolutely no interest in dolls. Nor in trucks. I wanted building toys, animals, and dinosaurs.
- mhuffman 12y agoI don't think anyone is suggesting that educational toys should be in a specific gender category. On the other hand, the number of tween-age boys into American Girl dolls has to low. I don't think "forcing" your customer to do anything is a good idea. I don't see the problem with the gender filters for those who want them and find them useful. It isn't a toy can ONLY be in one category or the other. I believe they are doing this just to pander to a small group of activists.
- endtime 12y agoSometimes you don't know a kid's interests, and their gender is the best heuristic available (and a pretty good one at that). Obviously if it's e.g. my daughter and I know she likes trains she's going to get trains, but not everyone buying a toy for a kid has that much information.
- jebblue 12y agoA lot of interests are tied to gender, probably more so than not. I'm more amazed that you're amazed that it should be the other way around. Even more amazing if the story is true that Amazon would try to change the core of human nature with a web site.
- Yakimoto 12y agoIt's still amazing how much we determine maturity by numerical age and not maturity or experience. Point being, pretending to be off put by a reasonable and logical thing doesn't make you correct.
- mahouse 12y agoTowards a more robotic future.
- mkr-hn 12y agoI must be misunderstanding you, because it looks like you're saying refusing to conform to gender roles makes us more robotic. Which would be ridiculous, so you probably don't mean that.
- mahouse 12y agoYou are understanding me well. I think gender roles are a very important part of what makes us human. (Or animalic.)
- FLGMwt 12y agoGender identity and agency are a different than prescribed gender roles.
- JoshTriplett 12y agoAll of which is separate from "what kind of toys do you like to play with".
- pauleastlund 12y agoI get what you're saying, but there is a vast gulf between: - gender is not just a social construct, men and women in aggregate don't have the exact same strengths, and that diversity is beautiful rather than something we need to suppress and - boys should play football and girls should play with dolls and wear frilly dresses I think people who agree with the former, but not the latter, should overall feel good about Amazon not gratuitously dividing all sorts of categories of toys into "his" and "hers."
- baddox 12y ago> should Amazons categorization probably does not imply a normative belief. I doubt Amazon cares if you order an Iron Man toy for a female.
- mkr-hn 12y agoAs someone who liked all kinds of toys as a kid and is largely indifferent to gender as an adult, this appeals to me.
- xname 12y agoHow could this appeals to you? If you don't like the gender categories, just DO NOT USE THEM! Why the hell would you want the categories to be removed?
- kristopolous 12y agoCan we get some financial theories as to why they did this?
- deleted 12y ago[deleted]
- kristopolous 12y ago(Note: the deleted parent comment was to the Wikipedia page on gender equality) Sure ... but are you saying that this is politically prudent and financially irrelevant? Unisex things like diet soda are engendered (Diet Coke vs Coke Zero) because market differentiation and segmentation works. Were consumers unable to find products because their assumption of a girl's toy was different from the manufacturer's assignment of the toy's gender? Were manufacturers gaming the system by marking toys unisex to increase sales? Was there a lower convergence rate when the consumers filtered by gender? Were consumers offended by the category and complained? Was gender the least used classifier and Amazon was simply tidying up the interface? I don't know the answer. There's many options. Filters are on the left hand and near the top. That means they are important. I think Amazon knew the financial hazards or benefits and then made the decision primarily based on that.
- blacksmith_tb 12y agoIt appears that what's actually been dropped is the filters from nav, since they still have the boys-toys girls-toys categories. This seems like a reasonable compromise for people want to shop that way, versus just choosing a kind of toy they think the child they are shopping for would like.
- rverghes 12y agoI wonder if Amazon actually A/B tested this, or just dropped it because of pressure from activists. If they did A/B test it, and found it increased sales or search efficiency, they should tout the finding. But part of me wonders if they didn't just end up making their website worse for people actually trying to search for a present.
- the_mitsuhiko 12y agoEven for searching for your own kids gender categories are useful thing. Not everybody subscribes to the idea of ungendered toys and cloths.
- dragonwriter 12y ago> Even for searching for your own kids gender categories are useful thing. I dunno, when I've searched for gifts for children I know (and, really, the same thing goes for adults), I've usually had some idea of what I was looking for which was more useful than a gender category.
- the_mitsuhiko 12y agoWhen you search for baby toys you often have no idea what to look for. Gender categories are useful for that.
- deirdres 12y agoIf the child is too young to express a preference, you don't need to choose between (eg) dolls or trucks - baby toys need to be primarily something that can't hurt the baby. If the child is old enough to express a preference, you can ask the child or their parents.
- PopeOfNope 12y agoYou two are talking past each other. The way it was before, you both could do what you wanted: either use the gender filter or not use the gender filter. Now there's no choice.
- cristianpascu 12y agoThere is significant scientific evidence for differences between men and women, both psychologically and physiologically. For one, if I may, mental illness strikes differently in men and women. In other news, it seems that women have been overmadicated for a long time because medical studies have ignored differences, for different reasons, one being the fear of sexism accusations. And while it's silly to be offered only pink dolls, I do think that little girls and little boys have different preferences which are not instilled by their parents, but rather emerge from their own psychology. I find it very hard to believe that all of our passions and preferences have a source in somebody telling us that we should be this or that way. Like me starting to play guitar, mathematics, physics or now being a programmer and entrepreneur. It's things I just happened to like to do. There's been little encourgements. I think there's a danger in fighting an wheel mill by enforcing a culture of uniformity because "girls need to learn about science too". I hate it when the world is accused of pushing pink on girls while everyday, on the streets, girls and women dress nicely in hundreds of colours and variations while men just wear t-shirts. I think that girls and women can manage this, and they're not as easilly to manipulate as some might think.
- xvedejas 12y agoEven if men and women are different, I'm not certain that prescribed gender categories for toys is really aiding that anyway. Isn't it more convenient for both genders to not miss or avoid a toy because someone has labeled it as not belonging to their gender?
- deleted 12y ago[deleted]
- cristianpascu 12y agoI don't know. You can look at it ethically, or statistically. First option is really difficult and you can not please everyone. Second... if consistently boys/girls want a certain kind of toy, parents will look for that type of toy for their girl/boy.
- PopeOfNope 12y ago
- sergiotapia 12y agoSo how do I find toys for my son and toys for my daughter on Amazon now?
- percentcer 12y agoTalk to your children?
- mcv 12y agoBy searching for something they like, rather than merely trusting blindly in labels and their cultural expectations.
- AhrowTway 12y agoI fail to see the wisdom of assuming children are homo economus capable of expressing consumer will, especially since for the first ten (and even twenty) years of their existence they are mindless meme conduits for whatever mass media monster pumps them full of nonsense.
- deleted 12y ago[deleted]
- egwynn 12y agoA lot of sites have moved to non-binary gender representations. Some do it because they see heteronormativity as a close-but-not-quite-close-enough false dichotomy that leaves too many people out in the cold. I’m not sure if that’s why Amazon did this, but they certainly wouldn’t be the first ones to do it. FWIW, I tend to agree with this recent perspective. In the endless debate over nature-vs-nurture, why should we insist on nurturing this dichotomy? We’re no worse off for not reenforcing that which marginalizes/disenfranchises so many. Are we?
- AhrowTway 12y agohttp://i0.kym-cdn.com/photos/images/facebook/000/947/236/9bc.jpg http://i0.kym-cdn.com/photos/images/facebook/000/947/236/9bc...
- deleted 12y ago[deleted]
- xname 12y agoFor narrow minded people here: - existence of the gendered categories does not force you to use the gendered categories - dropping the gender categories does prohibit others to use the gender categories